Games Mafia Game 58 - Umineko: How to play 13 - END GAME

[Nii]

Answered most of your questions and Already said everything i had to say with the Erinyes thing
On day 1 you chose to not vote Emperor spriggan &voted me instead even though he was way more suspicious than I,& like Grysun said u barely even commented on him possibly being a mafia for some reason
I think the whole "i dont wanna be the last to vote" was just an excuse so you dont have to vote your colleague
And it Seems to me that you won't be convinced im not mafia no matter what i say or maybe you already know that but dont wanna appear to be convinced because im the easiest townie kill right now
huh,mr.mafia?

Ur proving to be pretty suspicious yourself but i wont vote kill u just yet

Well the only thing you said is give a hint about your role... the rest was admitting that you look suspicious and that you already explained your Erinyes vote. Which comes down to a simple gut feeling? Which basically means you just voted for her for the sake of it, what a great reasoning Besides that absolutely nothing wrong from you, besides saying I'm suspicious for whatever reason.

Now that you mention it, that is indeed funny. He called me a wall that made up his mind but so has he about Empty, seeing it as his savior this day.

The difference is that I actually argued with you, while EmptySoul has yet to say anything to defend her behaviour. How am I supposed to change my opinion if she only agrees that her behaviour looks suspicious, and besides that she's posting nothing? You sure are turning into a try-hard more and more

Of course Empty could be Mafia, but as you said, if there's a Townie with the note, he or she should write Empty's name in the note and pass it to someone he or she deems trustable.
Anyway, I'll wait for Erin's summary then!

So basically Gry says Empty is suspicious but the person holding the note should simply kill her next night, when it's not even certain a townie has the note? That's a statement depending on a big IF, you can't count on that at all. The sole reason he wants to lynch me is because he saw something suspicious in one post, something that no one else saw, but a bunch of people agree on EmptySoul being suspicious. Now what's the most reasonable thing to actually do, listen to one person's gut feeling or what multiple people said, with a clearly suspicious behaviour from her along with it? Yes, this is a rhetoric question

 

[Vandred]

Ignored it because I'm in an OW game right now, gimme more time. That contradiction was a lot more important. And I think you're reaching here, since your reason for letting niichan live makes little sense.

Does it? You mean my reason for letting him live not any longer than tonight and letting Dets confirm their their sanity with no better alternative for doing that at the moment?

I think you have a little less than 13 hours, so no rush

 

[gnut]

Well...didnt i say van and niichan had to be behind demons death.
Van,why in the world would you want to keep obvious mafia around to take a shot at someone they are incriminating lol.

I been watching niichan since early day 1....his post made the hair on my neck stand up....the "work together" thing.

Anyways....votekill niichan




As for the deathnote....i took it that a townie's actions become killing actions.
Where a bad guy "in a group" their power is diminished....i figured they would maybe have less successful chance of killing...idk.

But my point is....a bad guy "in a group"....?
So we possibly dont have 2 mafias but 1 mafia and 3rd party(s)

 

[Kato756]

I have to say I have my reasons for being a bit less active this game

 

[xnut]

I feel incriminated

 

[Erinyes]

the note's mechanism is still not clear to me, so either as gnut suggest there's a possibility theres a 3 party
Ill cast a vote before going to bed in case, may consider changing it depending on further revelations.
Im going for now for Xnut.


Votekill xnut

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 15, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 15, 2017 ---

I have to say I have my reasons for being a bit less active this game

Ah yeah your gf birthday ?
could it be a hidden hint

 

[gnut]

the note's mechanism is still not clear to me, so either as gnut suggest there's a possibility theres a 3 party
Ill cast a vote before going to bed in case, may consider changing it depending on further revelations.
Im going for now for Xnut.


Votekill xnut

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 15, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 15, 2017 ---

Ah yeah your gf birthday ?
could it be a hidden hint

Just read the OP....it says bad guy in a group....why even say that part?

 

[Zasz]

So basically Gry says Empty is suspicious but the person holding the note should simply kill her next night, when it's not even certain a townie has the note? That's a statement depending on a big IF, you can't count on that at all. The sole reason he wants to lynch me is because he saw something suspicious in one post, something that no one else saw, but a bunch of people agree on EmptySoul being suspicious. Now what's the most reasonable thing to actually do, listen to one person's gut feeling or what multiple people said, with a clearly suspicious behaviour from her along with it? Yes, this is a rhetoric question

That if might not that big though, if you know what I mean.
Call it gut feeling or however you want, but I'm sure a Townie has the note right now.
Either way, I really wouldn't want you to be votekilled like this nii.
For the time being, you don't seem to be that suspicious to me after all.

 

[gnut]

That if might not that big though, if you know what I mean.
Call it gut feeling or however you want, but I'm sure a Townie has the note right now.
Either way, I really wouldn't want you to be votekilled like this nii.
For the time being, you don't seem to be that suspicious to me after all.

You know this is a game where personal feelings get shattered....

 

[Erinyes]

Just read the OP....it says bad guy in a group....why even say that part?

sorry didn't finish my sentence as i was going to refer to the lovers thing. but couldnt edit the post
iwas wondering if the bad guy thing was tha bad guy in the lovers (threesome party)

 

[Zasz]

You know this is a game where personal feelings get shattered....

I still want to believe.

 

[Erinyes]

* by bad guy i mean the mafia or 3rd party partner

 

[gnut]

sorry didn't finish my sentence as i was going to refer to the lovers thing. but couldnt edit the post
iwas wondering if the bad guy thing was tha bad guy in the lovers (threesome party)

Lovers cant target anyone unless they have the deathnote.
They do fall in 3rd party...so does santa xD
But im more worried about a SK....what happen if theres one and they acquire the note?

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 15, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 15, 2017 ---

But we definitely agree there is 3rd party

 

[Zasz]

* by bad guy i mean the mafia or 3rd party partner

Hmm, lovers?
Did I miss some important hints somewhere?

 

[gnut]

We may also have masons...
If so lets hope DiMaria isnt recruiter x/

 

[Erinyes]

Lovers cant target anyone unless they have the deathnote.
They do fall in 3rd party...so does santa xD
But im more worried about a SK....what happen if theres one and they acquire the note?

True .
also im not sure are lovers allowed to communicate in day time or night time or both ?

 

[gnut]

True .
also im not sure are lovers allowed to communicate in day time or night time or both ?

Never had a lover

 

[Erinyes]

no zazs just mere speculation based on settings and the theme, knowing our lovely hosts im sure they ll do anything to make things spicy

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 15, 2017, Original Post Date: Nov 15, 2017 ---

Never had a lover

oh should i be sorry or happy for you

 

[gnut]

 

[Erinyes]

just checked on the rules, they can talk only in night phases.