According to this Arc flashback, Ciel's twin is dead and Sebby took his soul as offer, right? However as we also are aware that in the present time we have seen the dead twin, right? What I thought is perhaps this is some troll Undertaker doing and maybe there is a possiblity that his twin, Ciel, has turned into a shinigami hence why he is alive because a dead person can't suddenly come back to life and this was kinda the only logic I could make out of it atm since we have seen that he was killed in front of his Ciel's eyes. That's the speculation I currently have for it. What do you think?