Theory Idea on how Elizabeth and Estarossa are connected.

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
Made this answer on the reddit and thought it wouldn't hurt to share my wild idea on how Elizabeth and Estarossa are connected.

Im basically going on a tangent here, so it's going to be long:

I think there's more to the Elizabeth and Estarossa situation than we think. Initially, I thought it would just be the fact that he killed Mael and inherited his memories, which made me think that Mael loved Elizabeth and the whole "did u fight with your brother" was a reference to him and his brother Ludoshel.

But what if Elizabeth was actually talking to Estarossa in that flashback of "did u fight with your brothers?". Think about it. Chapter 260 just revealed to us that Estarossa without a commandment was fearful of killing anything, even bugs and was probably bullied by his brothers because he didn't meet up to their standards. What if he ran away from the demonic realm every time he was bullied and ocassionally made contact with the Goddess Elizabeth? If he was being picked on he would be sad or depressed and Elizabeth would've been nurturing and supportive of him, especially when their characters both coaside with peace and not causing harm.

This could explain why Estarossa wants Elizabeth. She used to nurture him and take care of him and he wants that back. But because he is bat shit crazy now, that desire probably turned more romantic, sexual or even murderous. If he went crazy then it can explain how he doesn't understand his own memories of Elizabeth and wants her regardless.

Maybe this is how Meliodas first made contact with the Goddess Elizabeth without immediately trying to kill her. Or if he tried to, she would have defended herself and Estarossa would have protested leading him to stop his attack and kick start his relationship with Elizabeth. Since Esta would leave the demonic realm frequently to escape bullying and pity he experienced, the DK might have tasked Meliodas with finding him and bringing Esta back. So this frequent visiting to Elizabeth and bringing back Esta lead to Mel eventually spending more time with her and you know.... He somehow becomes good and falls in love with her.

I feel like the DK gave the commandment of love to Estarossa as a means of control. If it made him him crazy then he would've stopped seeing Elizabeth and start being a ruthless demon - leaving more time for Mel and Eliz together... alone ;)

But I'm sure you're thinking. Elizabeth didn't recognise him which is strange. Well it isn't too farfetched that she does know him but only as the pacifist Esta. She did say he feels familiar, and since Esta has changed a lot physically and mentally with his attitude from being a child (which is when he was visiting Eliz and nice) make him appear as a different person.

I believe the commandment has just messed up Estarossa mental health quite badly to the point that he doesn't recognise his own memories, rather than the idea he took Maels memories or somehow took his soul (or something along those lines).

It would be great if this was the case. It would explain how Elizabeth and Meliodas met without him trying to kill her immediately, how their relationship built over time, how Estarossa wants her and has memories of her as a Goddess and finally would provide development for Elizabeth's character: since this would basically mean she had 2 royal demons "under her thumb" (not really) who she influenced greatly.

As for why Esta killed Mael. Maybe he did it because he was close friends with Elizabeth and a "threat" to him for getting Elizabeth for himself. Not to farfetched that Elizabeth had a close relationship with the AA's, she is the princess after all and I would maybe bet the SD arranged a marriage for her (Ludoshel implied he wanted to marry her).

Ideas pls - sorry it's long, I love to rant on theories.

Thanks if you read it all xD
 

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Hmmm interesting maybe that would be the case. But what the unconvincing part is he just said you fought with your brothers didnt you? So basically Ely knows he had a brother. Lets make believe Ely think its Zeldris, just for the benefit of the doubt, she could have told Zeldris about it. So I think this wouldnt be the case although I like the idea how Mel met Ely and Esta to Ely.
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
Hmmm interesting maybe that would be the case. But what the unconvincing part is he just said you fought with your brothers didnt you? So basically Ely knows he had a brother. Lets make believe Ely think its Zeldris, just for the benefit of the doubt, she could have told Zeldris about it. So I think this wouldnt be the case although I like the idea how Mel met Ely and Esta to Ely.
Why would she tell Zeldoris if the demonic realm was bullying Estarossa? Shes probably aware that he has brothers, Meliodas was the most famous demon and Zeldris was known as the executioner and representative to the DK.

Plus if Estarossa kept meeting her like this for support then he would've told her about his brothers and how they are nasty to him.
 

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Why would she tell Zeldoris if the demonic realm was bullying Estarossa? Shes probably aware that he has brothers, Meliodas was the most famous demon and Zeldris was known as the executioner and representative to the DK.

Plus if Estarossa kept meeting her like this for support then he would've told her about his brothers and how they are nasty to him.
No thats not what I meant. You said Ely didnt recognize Estarossa anymore because he changed so much physically and how he convey his attitude. And never Ely mentioned anything to Meliodas where is his brother whom she used to comfort or even said you look familiar are you the little guy who runs away yadi yada. So basically with that the whole thing wouldnt make any sense.
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
No thats not what I meant. You said Ely didnt recognize Estarossa anymore because he changed so much physically and how he convey his attitude. And never Ely mentioned anything to Meliodas where is his brother whom she used to comfort or even said you look familiar are you the little guy who runs away yadi yada. So basically with that the whole thing wouldnt make any sense.
True. Maybe Meliodas told her what happened to Estarossa but she doesn't specifically know who he is now in terms of appearance. So she wouldn't stand there and go "oh is that u?". Meliodas wouldn't comment on it either since he probably didn't care in that specific moment of time.

Nakaba likes to only reveal info if needed or planned so. Zeldoris could've told Esta to not absorb or Try to absorb the commandments because *insert Monspiet explanation* but he didn't. I wouldn't be surprised if Elizabeth turned around later and was like "Oh it was u".
 

Undina

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 31, 2016
Messages
3,811
Reaction score
4,622
Country
Romania
No thats not what I meant. You said Ely didnt recognize Estarossa anymore because he changed so much physically and how he convey his attitude. And never Ely mentioned anything to Meliodas where is his brother whom she used to comfort or even said you look familiar are you the little guy who runs away yadi yada. So basically with that the whole thing wouldnt make any sense.
Tbh, Nakaba made Elizabeth annoyingly unobservant of physical similarities, she had a hard time noticing Zel looks like a dark haired Mel(ergo, he's likely a sibling of her would be lover and was surprised Zel refered to Mel as his brother) and by the time she saw Estarossa again, she'd supposedly recovered all of her memory(que curse countdown) and was supposed to be far too familiar with the now 100% confirmed poster of "adult" Meliodas. Meh, I'll put it on the stress of the past day and the jumble of info she had just recovered and go with the possibility her memory had the flu back then as well and she was confused.
Besides, we didn't see much of the past of the conscious goddess Elizabeth interacting with Mel to be able to discuss whether she ever asked about her derpy buddy from the demon family.
 
Last edited:

Mythoclast

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2018
Messages
488
Reaction score
720
Age
26
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
Just through Mael hopefully.
 
Last edited:

XXGenesis

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 8, 2011
Messages
3,148
Reaction score
1,900
Age
35
Gender
Male
Country
Turkmenistan
Knowing the lil bit of info Monspett has left us with..Estarossa isn’t exactly an elite demon being born without the power of darkness & the power of the Commandement bestowed upon him has driven him mad. So my only guess is that Elizabeth had befriend’d Estarossa more than 3000yrs ago before he received his commandment or went crazy. & is probably in love with her but her love isn’t reciprocated.. & probably another plot twist of why Meliodas beterayes the demon clan & how he first met Elizabeth
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
They don’t know each other

Elizabeth even said it was here first time seeing Estarossa
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
They don’t know each other

Elizabeth even said it was here first time seeing Estarossa
But she said he felt familiar - that means there's a connection between Eliz/Esta because Nakaba wouldn't have put that detail in for nothing.

Like I said, Estarossa before being given the commandment could've been an entirely different person - hence why she doesn't recognise him but instead explains that he feels ''familiar''.
 

Bøjan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2017
Messages
817
Reaction score
1,111
Gender
Male
Country
Macedonia
But she said he felt familiar - that means there's a connection between Eliz/Esta because Nakaba wouldn't have put that detail in for nothing.

Like I said, Estarossa before being given the commandment could've been an entirely different person - hence why she doesn't recognise him but instead explains that he feels ''familiar''.
True, maybe went into his "adult form" after taking the commandment after all.Because he was still a kid similar to Meliodas/Zeldris when Meliodas was the leader of the 10c
 

JOA20

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2018
Messages
469
Reaction score
465
Age
33
Country
Italy
Interesting theory. Estarossa knowing Elizabeth from before the Demon King gave him the Commandment would be a good twist. That wouldn't explain why Elizabeth forgot about him though. She knew he had a older brother. Unless Estarossa somehow kept his identity a secret, I doubt Elizabeth wouldn't have connected the dots.

I still think that it was Mael's memory though. That panel where Elizabeth thinks she's already seen Estarossa might be because she somehow senses Mael in him.
 

titantron91

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
587
Reaction score
1,451
Age
35
Country
Philippines
Personally, I think Mael's soul/consciousness dwells inside Estarossa in secret.

First time Elizabeth saw Estarossa's image during the current timeline was in a dream. During that dream, the Estarossa-like entity has an armor with Goddess clan symbols on it (triskelion).

First time Estarossa saw Elizabeth during the current timeline was also in a dream. In the dream, Estarossa was in a grassy field that doesn't look demonic at all. There, he meets Elizabeth with her look 3000 years ago. Elizabeth in the dream asks him if he "had a fight with his brother" again.

Here are the fun revelations:

1. Estarossa and Elizabeth haven't met each other until recently (when AM Meliodas visited Zel and the demons).
2. Estarossa killed Mael
3. Mael has an older brother: Ludoshel
4. Mael held Elizabeth in high regard, according to Gowther
5. Chapter 262 spoilers shows that
Estarossa indeed remembers meeting, fighting, and killing Mael.
6. Mael has been repeatedly mentioned in different chapters. Each mention reveals something seemingly important. It's as if he'll have a notable role in the near future.

You will start thinking that Mael could be the one that connects Elizabeth and Estarossa, based on the clues.

The whole idea is that Mael's memories are manifesting in Estarossa's mind. Also, Mael's probably reaching out to Elizabeth through dreams (hence the Estarossa with Goddess symbols).

My speculation is that Mael will appear again and Estarossa (and probably Escanor) will be instrumental to this.

Here's what confuses me: Why doesn't Elizabeth remember Sunshine? Does she even remember Mael at all?
 
Top