Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[ChocoBar9]

Editors' mind game.

Don't laugh. WNL and Yuuna did poorly this week too.

 

[cody]

Those chapters of Jujutsu and Act Age were nothing special. Looks like our new PUSH age has come

So if any new manga are successful they are being pushed?

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

*Checks Jujutsu chapter 13* Oh, the movie appreciation chapter. I liked that. A totally new way of training.

If this chapter has ended 1st, I can't wait to see what place will chapter 15 get aka

Spoiler

Sensei shows his face and pwns that volcano demon

 

[Doughboy]

how long does it take harem anime to see a boost in sales? They're really gonna do a Dagashi on Yuuna, like that? Smh

 

[LuckyJim]

I'm no expert, but I'm pretty sure the rankings don't exactly correspond to whatever chapter happened to take place 8 issues ago, so I really don't think the current rankings of Jujutsu and Act-Age are due to one specific chapter. It probably has to due with growing popularity, and the fact that their recent volumes needed a reprint.

 

[Caiops]

I remember RobotxLaserbeam getting a first place...

Yeah, never trust EiC mind games/Sharkbait.

 

[OfficialHxH]

Why ? They are always a possibility Yonkou use tocs of 5ch (this tocs was published 30min before Yonkou).

True there's always a possibility but I think he already has the info.

 

[ChocoBar9]

So if any new manga are successful they are being pushed?

Don't play that game. Act Age had a subpar debut and Jujutsu is only getting traction now due to its first volume sales. Them shooting up to the top 5 is suspicious unless you can't shed your own bias for them.

 

[iceemperor]

how long does it take harem anime to see a boost in sales? They're really gonna do a Dagashi on Yuuna, like that? Smh

If you mean manga sales, then harem manga barely see any increase in sales. Yuuna will probably grow about 20-30k at best, if it does at all. The main thing there is merchandising of the girls. There are rare cases like Nisekoi but was huge, like 160k, before the anime. It peaked at 350k after the anime. Yuuna is nowhere near there and the times were also different back then.

 

[ChocoBar9]

I'm no expert, but I'm pretty sure the rankings don't exactly correspond to whatever chapter happened to take place 8 issues ago, so I really don't think the current rankings of Jujutsu and Act-Age are due to one specific chapter. It probably has to due with growing popularity, and the fact that their recent volumes needed a reprint.

Its not by popularity either or else they wouldn't leave the bottom 5.

 

[Heiji]

In fact, in #34 preview picture, no write anywhere they will have big news in this issue XD.
http://www.shonenjump.com/j/weeklyshonenjump/#nextWJ

 

[shoyoboyo]

Remember when y'all were asking why people make fake TOCs? Now you know lol

 

[cody]

Don't play that game. Act Age had a subpar debut and Jujutsu is only getting traction now due to its first volume sales. Them shooting up to the top 5 is suspicious unless you can't shed your own bias for them.

Is every new successful manga from now on going to be considered pushed? Just wondering. What criteria does something have to meet so it isn't considered as "pushed"?

 

[OtterBrigade]

Remember when y'all were asking why people make fake TOCs? Now you know lol

I got that it was to fool people but was the 20 minutes really worth it?

 

[MangAniMY]

In fact, in #34 preview picture, no write anywhere they will have big news in this issue XD.
http://www.shonenjump.com/j/weeklyshonenjump/#nextWJ

the big news hype is most probably from the editor livestream some time ago...

I said this in my local thread a lot, but here is a good chance to say it here...

Damn You Naito!!!

 

[Heiji]

Yonkou Tweet about one piece new movie was delayed

 

[ChocoBar9]

Remember when y'all were asking why people make fake TOCs? Now you know lol

Ironically enough the fake TOC made a lot more sense thsn the real one.

 

[Heiji]

the big news hype is most probably from the editor livestream some time ago...

I said this in my local thread a lot, but here is a good chance to say it here...

Damn You Naito!!!

In fact, its from Saikyô Jump out in june. Inside said they will have big news. But still, normally, will have a big news annonced this sunday officialy (that its from #33).

 

[Doughboy]

Oh no, Yuuna was supposed to be the chosen one...

Give Tokiaku Cawaii 24 episodes Xebec. It's the future of the romance genre.

I got that it was to fool people but was the 20 minutes really worth it?

bro it's for internet clout. All for likes to feel good about theirselves only to sulk back into the reality that they haven't talked to a girl or had good hygiene in years.

 

[Tanzo]

how long does it take harem anime to see a boost in sales? They're really gonna do a Dagashi on Yuuna, like that? Smh

It's a bit too early to say how well the anime will do for the series.
BDs are ranking pretty well right now though.