Games Mafia Game 68 - World of Warcraft: End Game - Missing Night Actions

[digitaldude]

@goodboy_lawlett where is the old vote count from day 1.

 

[Copy Panda]

@goodboy_lawlett where is the old vote count from day 1.

If you go to the OP and click on the 'end of day 1' thing I believe it should be there

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

@goodboy_lawlett where is the old vote count from day 1.

Down here

 

[digitaldude]

btw did anyone get penalty votes? @goodboy_lawlett @Copy Panda

 

[Purity of Magi]

Down here

Lol

 

[Farfalla]

Ever occur to you he could lie?
Are you willing to put your neck on the line because you got his hint on day 1?
Confirmed...i think not.
Not saying he's guilty...but your thoughts on him doesn't make him innocent either.

Sure, it occured to me. He still could be lying. But I was leaning toward him playing more like he was a townie anyway before his claim. A preliminary assumption only based on today’s performance. The fact that he used me for his confirming buddy as oppose to Gry or Van, to me spoke a lot. As normally he is quietly contributing on D1 or sucks to certain players when he’s mafia. Those two carry more weight in this game then me. So there would be more value in hinting to them. Also he doesn’t ever antagonize every active player in the game to begin with as a mafia, he flies more under the radar. Using a hint only a person or a select few would know might seem more suspicious to some, but for me it’s a better hint then some of the general claims we have already. At the very least, he’s more innocent for this day phase to not merit a lynch or a bandwagon..... as people wanted to do earlier.

What makes even less sense is she sees Sprigz as suspicious but doesnt want to press him cause they are friends...
Really Cres...this is MG?

If it wasn't D1, yea but he barely has been around to play. And I know he is capable of more. Plus ES is always shady. He's gotten into a bad habit of lurking more. Yet he has not made an error like in ace attorney to make it super obvious that he is indeed scum. I always say if he survives past 2 days without being lynched, he's probably town.

Here. Greg was the one that started to question her often, about Lambu and Emp.

 

[Purity of Magi]

Hey @gnut =3=/

 

[digitaldude]

hmmm well its absolute no doubt that crescent jinx was protecting lambu heavily, but was he that stupid and careless to protect his mafia friend? hmmm.

 

[Purity of Magi]

Here. Greg was the one that started to question her often, about Lambu and Emp.

Now that you mention it... I dunno in which gane it was but when I also pressured Crescent with questions, her team back then wanted to kill me but failed miserable lol. XD It wouldnt be surprising if mafia decided to kill Gnut just for that.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018, Original Post Date: Oct 23, 2018 ---

Oh well, anyway gotta go off now. Will be back later.

 

[xi0]

Going to votekill Van because it's something I want to do. And I just don't know. I wish I had thought of wanting to do it earlier.

^What I was referring to @Farfalla

 

[Farfalla]

Yeah later we could check Van's post as well cause why not, they had more interactions. Gotta go to work now ç.ç

 

[GrySun]

3 deaths? In 21 player game, after we killed a third party? And of course Dets/Docs dying early, as almost always. At least Cres died as mafia, though a bit sad she died early in a Panda game again.
Maybe Greg killed one of them as an insane doctor, or some other town role like PGO, but this is still a bit much.

And why those 3? Greg was his usual self, Marmalade was a suspect from the previous day(albeit due to randomness) and Crescent seemed her usual self too. I'd have expected them to go for either me or Farf, or DD/Evil since they were pretty active.

Think Crescent was mainly talking with Greg, Spriggan and Lambu iirc, but gotta check back.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018, Original Post Date: Oct 23, 2018 ---

Alright. 3 deaths in one night. Ten bucks they really put in the serial killer. Who said again that they are not the SK? <.<

I think Demon in one post said he didn't get SK, when he made his role hint about getting a role he always wanted.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018 ---

There's no reason for us to discard the possibility of more than one third party around (which is likely, even more considering that Santa isn't a killing role).

I'd go with SK, mafia and doctor... There is still a chance there are two mafia teams however.

The main thing that bothers me is how a Santa was supposed to survive 5 nights with 3 killing parties in the game. At least one of those must be from a townie 1-shot or rng or else the Santa inclusion is too silly.

HMMMMMMMM MAFIA jerking each other very interesting.

@Lambu here's the double-downside of your "hint to one person only" strat, Cres both died and can't confirm your hint anymore and was mafia all along.

 

[Evil3ye]

I think there are two mafia teams, and contrary to what digital said I am sure the mafia team knows if there is a second mafia by doing simple math. Just wonder why marmalade was targeted by the mafia, as she was in the top to get lynched and didn't do much to build the trust. Maybe they found out her tole by checking.

 

[Hardy]

I think there are two mafia teams, and contrary to what digital said I am sure the mafia team knows if there is a second mafia by doing simple math. Just wonder why marmalade was targeted by the mafia, as she was in the top to get lynched and didn't do much to build the trust. Maybe they found out her tole by checking.

Well, we have to think why mafia/ third party would want any of the 3 dead, then relate that to people. I'm not sure about crescent or gnut, but on top of my head marmalade dying as a townie would make grysun and desin look like nice guys for not pulling the trigger on her during the day phase.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018, Original Post Date: Oct 23, 2018 ---

Also, yeah, if your mafia team has 3 or 4 people and you were supposed to have 6, it's easy to think there are two mafia teams.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018 ---

However, they wouldn't be able to check on her role and kill her the same night, that's kind of nonesense coming from you, lol.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018 ---

Not grysun, but lambu and then vandred (grysun actually voted for marma). Edit: NOT LAMBU, GARY, OMG.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018 ---

Nothing to summarize. People voted randomly, ended up with 4 people tied with 2 votes each. For some reason desin and Marm were singled out, xi0 voted desin to get lynched, lambu countered with marm, vand voted desin and then I voted marm. Neither desin nor Marm tried to save themselves by voting for the other person in the tie. Phase got extended, people are still confused but going for Spirit who placed his vote on desin because he was inactive, while himself having posted 3 times only at the time.

That's about it.

.

 

[Asako]

Weird that there's three death well the only thing I think of is an insane doc, as a third party is already out, but what's more weird why did marma die ? I mean I don't see a doc tagging her as she was suspected or a mafia for the same reason ?
@Crescent Jinx you may be the new demonspeed, all the time you're almost a mafia.

 

[digitaldude]

TFW evil forgets the basics of mafia game...

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018, Original Post Date: Oct 23, 2018 ---

Also the hosts never announced who got penalty votes im pretty sure 3 people didnt vote.

 

[Asako]

I think there are two mafia teams, and contrary to what digital said I am sure the mafia team knows if there is a second mafia by doing simple math. Just wonder why marmalade was targeted by the mafia, as she was in the top to get lynched and didn't do much to build the trust. Maybe they found out her tole by checking.

The mafias must be amazing to know who the other mafias are..

 

[digitaldude]

I am almost certain there isnt a mentor in the game cause he needs to recruit his mentee at night 1......unless he started with a mentee. maybe one mafia and one pair of mentor/mentee guys.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018, Original Post Date: Oct 23, 2018 ---

The mafias must be amazing to know who the other mafias are..

WHAT IS YOUR ROLE?

 

[Asako]

@GrySun yea now that I see I did a stupid mistake but that was my reason for doing it, I know u won't trust me but whatever I got used to it.
And I though I was appearing in the user list viewing this thread

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018, Original Post Date: Oct 23, 2018 ---

WHAT IS YOUR ROLE?

Meh ? Do u want me to reveal in d2 ?
U can already take the list of what roles I can have and it's a small one.

 

[digitaldude]

my bad i ve been doing the recap while reading, just saw pompom's recap, thats so stupid of me, would have seen it wouldnt have started a new one will still post it though cause i spent a lot of time on it, but sorry again @Lady pompom i should have read 1st the whole pages before starting.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 22, 2018, Original Post Date: Oct 22, 2018 ---

here the recap, please feel free to tell me if i missed any hint, ill fix it Asap

1. Farfalla as Yrel ->Got an old role that she didn't have in a long while.
   
2. Crescent Jinx As Vereesa -> passive and feels somehow meh about it
   
3. Erinyes as Sylvanas -> 1st time got it.
   
4. Demonspeed as Lothraxion -> never got the role before.
   
5. GrySun as Thrall -> like his role but not that hyped
   
6. MarmaladeSky as Tyrande -> active role
   
7. Emperor Spriggan as Vol'Jin -> 1st time he has it, said its a pretty good role.
   
8. WithYouInSpirit as Varian -> never had the orle, but used it a game he hosted, can be funny or boring depending on his game play.
   
9. James Rye as Illidan - has a role that is similar to a certain mafia one.
   
10. Takuan as Lor'Themar -> passive role
    
11. Asako as Maiev -> her role is either hated or loved ( but usually hated )
    
12. gnut as Velen -> old constant role
    
13. Vandred as Anduin -> passive role , less bad than the previous ones.
    
14. Lady pompom as lady Liadrin -> never had the role before.
    
15. desin24 as Medivh -> said he s happy with his role since he can actually do something (as in active role) and affect the game in a positive way.
    
16. EmptySoul as Khadgar-> active role, never had it before
    
17. Hardy as Malfurion -> active role that can be useless depending on how he plays
    
18. digitaldude as Magni
19. Evil3ye as High Tinker Mekkatorque -> active role
    
20. Holt as Baine
21. xi0 as Greymane
22. Purity of Magi as Elisande -> never had the role before (or maybe not )
    
23. Lambu as Alleria -> said he's disppointed with his role, buit still think it's useful .said sis role is inactive with no intentions of talking.

So these are peoples role hints alright gnut and marmaladesky check out. Crescent the lying mafia said passive and feels meh about it...

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 23, 2018 ---

vandread also claimed passive and made a comment on how he feels about it similar to crescent.