Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[tirakai]

I don't know about this year for HZ anymore, assuming the current match goes the expected way there's still the tie-breaker matches to do next before the tournament can end (I don't know how many exactly but if there's 4 people in it I guess either 3 or 6).

And then there's epilogue wrap up afterwards too, even if there's no timeskip to one final yokozuna-deciding match or something I imagine there'll still be at least 5-6 chapters after the tournament. If it does end this year I expect it'll be very late, November or December.

 

[RafGL]

Wow, I never expected seeing Haikyu below Soma.

 

[Ctkk]

It's Yonko so I assume it's real, but this ToC is all over the place. Although looking at it closely, it's just the new series and monthly stuff messing the placements a little. The only super weird thing is really just Haikyuu being so low.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Damn, Haikyuu being this low out of nowhere is really weird, is even under Souma lol

 

[Stivie]

I think we can say that haikyuu is starting to lose its place in the Big 3, seeing from its recent position.

I believe samurai8 will stay in his place.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

When was last time Yonkou posted a ToC? 2017?

Haikyuu has already lived too long. The surprising thing is that it still looks isn't going to end soon.

 

[Jovan]

Act-Age ranking at #5 (OP being on LCP, Dr.Stone CP and the unranked newbies not included), yes! Terrible week for Haikyuu, wonder what happened there. The rest is mostly the usual as always (Jujutsu is also lower than usual).

Kamio Yui and Saiyuuki are dead, dead, dead.

 

[SharkBait]

Guess the western world disliking the league of villains isnt exclusiving to the west. Poor heroAca.

Fortunately BLack Clover gets as prominent as position as ever in one of the best written arcs in the magazine since the Choice Arc.

 

[Stivie]

Damn, Haikyuu being this low out of nowhere is really weird, is even under Souma lol

the jump is the samba of the crazy creole, there were 9 manga that debuted in the first semester and only one that went "well."

sam8 is not going to be canceled, but it's still a somewhat overstated amount

 

[RafGL]

When was last time Yonkou posted a ToC? 2017?

Haikyuu has already lived too long. The surprising thing is that it still looks isn't going to end soon.

And... it shouldn't, since if I remember correctly, there's at least 3 more matches left for Karasuno (guessing they will end up winning all of them until finals, also win finals and that would be it) before National Arc ends. It would be surprising if it ends before Summer 2020.

 

[Jovan]

Surprisingly, it wasn't posted till now, but Shoseki Day 1 rankings.

#1 The Promised Neverland Volume 14
#2 Haikyuu Vol 38
#4 Shokugeki no Soma Vol 35
#5 Boruto Vol 8
#6 We Never Learn Vol 12
#9 Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san Vol 16

#46 Gokutei Higuma Vol 2

#124 Shinshunki Renaissance David-kun Vol 3
#162 Ne0lation Vol 2
#193 Jimoto ga Japan Vol 3

 

[Scruffy8642]

I don't know about this year for HZ anymore, assuming the current match goes the expected way there's still the tie-breaker matches to do next before the tournament can end (I don't know how many exactly but if there's 4 people in it I guess either 3 or 6).

And then there's epilogue wrap up afterwards too, even if there's no timeskip to one final yokozuna-deciding match or something I imagine there'll still be at least 5-6 chapters after the tournament. If it does end this year I expect it'll be very late, November or December.

Assuming it becomes a 4 way tie, it should be 3 matches I believe. Everyone picks lots (East 1 & 2, West 1 & 2). E1 Vs W1, E2 Vs W2, and the winners of each fight for the final, elimination tournament style.

So probably Onimaru Vs Saenoyama & Okanehira Vs Jinou, with Onimaru Vs Jinou to finish it.

 

[TxxT]

And... it shouldn't, since if I remember correctly, there's at least 3 more matches left for Karasuno (guessing they will end up winning all of them until finals, also win finals and that would be it) before National Arc ends. It would be surprising if it ends before Summer 2020.

I dont see it ending in 2020 either, especially if they do advance to the semis considering both the semis and final round are a best of 5 sets unlike the current matches which are 3, and knowing Furudate after the current match we're going back to covering Bokuto

 

[RafGL]

Assuming it becomes a 4 way tie, it should be 3 matches I believe. Everyone picks lots (East 1 & 2, West 1 & 2). E1 Vs W1, E2 Vs W2, and the winners of each fight for the final, elimination tournament style.

So probably Onimaru Vs Saenoyama & Okanehira Vs Jinou, with Onimaru Vs Jinou to finish it.

It can perfectly last until September/October if we think about 5 chapters per fight, but it will probably be a bit less. The early September bet could still be the most fitting imo.

--- Double Post Merged, Jun 5, 2019, Original Post Date: Jun 5, 2019 ---

I dont see it ending in 2020 either, especially if they do advance to the semis considering both the semis and final round are a best of 5 sets unlike the current matches which are 3, and knowing Furudate after the current match we're going back to covering Bokuto

Also there's no way we are going the 'losing-the-tournament-and-going-back-to-grinding' way at this point. Not gonna be overextended, but neither will end early.

 

[Jovan]

Jump+ Shoseki rankings. Bolding the newbie, Lycopene because it was serialized in WSJ, and the MangaPlus serializations.

#8 Jigokuraku Vol 6
#10 Oyakusoku no Neverland
#17 Mone-san no Majime Sugiru Tsukiaikata Vol 6
#19 Bokuyaku Battery Vol 4
#22 Tomatoypoo no Lycopene Vol 3
#33 Touken Ranbu Vol 5
#38 Hidarikiki no Eren Vol 8
#59 Muto and Sato Vol 1 (NEW)
#73 Rocking You! Vol 4
#99 DEMON TUNE Vol 4
#100 Psycho Against Vol 3
#190 Curtain's Up, I'm Off Vol 2
#271 Moon Land Vol 2

Absent: Land Lock Vol 4

 

[savethecat]

I think we can say that haikyuu is starting to lose its place in the Big 3, seeing from its recent position.

I believe samurai8 will stay in his place.

A huge series being low on the TOC basically means nothing

 

[CuriousReborn]

21307 *542232 僕
12454 *262652 鬼
10162 *330488 鬼3
*9893 *323095 鬼4
-
*9737 *317503 鬼5
*9731 *291678 鬼11
*9698 *286547 鬼12
*9684 *269826 鬼14
*9621 *283646 鬼13
*9608 *311804 鬼6
*9465 *296326 鬼7
*9391 *350394 鬼1
*9287 *337744 鬼2
*9263 *294313 鬼8
*9205 *288994 鬼10
*9202 *288615 鬼9
*7975 1932181 Ｏ
*7867 *160129 呪
*6892 *108125 ア

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Strange position of Haikyuu, but not the first time this happens.
Probably Samurai 8 will have many good positions in the coming weeks.
Certainly Shueisha will make this happen to promote the series.

 

[SharkBait]

Jump+ Shoseki rankings. Bolding the newbie, Lycopene because it was serialized in WSJ, and the MangaPlus serializations.

#8 Jigokuraku Vol 6
#10 Oyakusoku no Neverland
#17 Mone-san no Majime Sugiru Tsukiaikata Vol 6
#19 Bokuyaku Battery Vol 4
#22 Tomatoypoo no Lycopene Vol 3
#33 Touken Ranbu Vol 5
#38 Hidarikiki no Eren Vol 8
#59 Muto and Sato Vol 1 (NEW)
#73 Rocking You! Vol 4
#99 DEMON TUNE Vol 4
#100 Psycho Against Vol 3
#190 Curtain's Up, I'm Off Vol 2
#271 Moon Land Vol 2

Absent: Land Lock Vol 4

curtains up Im off charted!!

 

[Ctkk]

21307 *542232 僕
12454 *262652 鬼
10162 *330488 鬼3
*9893 *323095 鬼4
-
*9737 *317503 鬼5
*9731 *291678 鬼11
*9698 *286547 鬼12
*9684 *269826 鬼14
*9621 *283646 鬼13
*9608 *311804 鬼6
*9465 *296326 鬼7
*9391 *350394 鬼1
*9287 *337744 鬼2
*9263 *294313 鬼8
*9205 *288994 鬼10
*9202 *288615 鬼9
*7975 1932181 Ｏ
*7867 *160129 呪
*6892 *108125 ア

Well, MHA couldn't reach 550K in five weeks. Let's see how it goes for HQ and TPN.