- Joined
- Nov 26, 2018
- Messages
- 6,815
- Reaction score
- 11,877
- Age
- 42
- Country
-
It is undeniable what SIU wanted was Mas to take Jinsung ALIVE as bait rather than allow him to be killed. Her motives are quite clear; I'm not sure how you think that's open to interpretation on my end. The importance of her arrival was primarily to preserve Jinsung for the overall story. If there's a secondary reason - supposedly to muddy the water over who would have won - then SIU as an author waited a bit too long if he wanted to show how the battered, tired, broken, neutered Jinsung was on equal grounds with Kallavan.That's an interesting interpretation.
Again, if Jinsung screaming instead of countering was thought by him to be his best option when he JUST saw how an ultimate level attack wasn't enough in of itself and the person he's fighting has the ability to literally crush the life out of him then perhaps everyone is overestimating Jinsung's fighting prowess and abilities. It's not like Jinsung didn't know he had to stop Kallavan. He didn't free himself from Kallavan's grip. He didn't counter his damage by damaging Kallavan. All he had left in him was to scream. The danger was already at a fever pitch by both parties. It had nowhere further to escalate. Jinsung was fighting with what he thought was a fatal attack. Kallavan knew he had to neuter Jinsung just in case. Both had already telegraphed their intentions before Jinsung starting screaming because that's all that was left to do. If someone had a gun to my head I could scream too but that doesn't mean by merely screaming I have the ability to stop my execution. It would be different if he was able to push loose and damage Kallavan and THEN start screaming. But he screamed while his useless arms were STILL held by his opponent.So what hindered Siu to make it clear? Kallavan defeats Jinsung, Jinsung loses conciousness, kallavan wants to deliver the final blow and Maschenny steps in to save him. They could also have a talk that makes it clear that Maschenny "betrayed" Jinsung. But that is not what has happened. Jinsung looked like a wounded beast that you pushed into a corner - that's a very dangerous kind of situation.
Jinsung had ALREADY been pushed into a corner. When the cig was knocked from his mouth he knew he had to pull out all the stops to stop Kallavan and he SAYS this. He uses what he thought would be a high-tier fatal attack. Jinsung was not withholding.
Here you are conflating 'being able to attack to the fullest' with 'losing your arms' function not being anywhere near fatal'. I didn't say it wasn't important from an attack standpoint. I said it really didn't matter that Jinsung had broken arms as that wasn't what did him in. It was Mas' spear attack to his torso. And Kallavan PROVED he was able to go on and use high-level attacks and defense after a more-damaging gut punch-out. Jinsung couldn't continue with attacks or defense after a less-damaging torso attack. So while he was able to throw a last-ditched (ultimately useless) move out there that doesn't mean he was qualified to give Kallavan another fatal blow. While not an absolute impossibility, it is a bit of a stretch.And taking his arms is serious,yes. But imagine taking Yuri's arms. She still could use something like the rose shower. That Jinsung could still play tricks was shown as well (reverse flow control).
Broken arms wasn't what did him in as a fighter. It was having the shit kicked out of him and then taking a spear to the gut. Punches and blows and assaults that Kallavan shows he could have tanked (he tanked actually worse) and kept on fighting. Alternatively, Jinsung could not continue.
You don't believe Jinsung to be able to follow up, Jinsung didn't believe that kallavan could do that after his transcendent skill. He was wrong. Maybe you are as well, maybe i am. We don't know, because the situation is not clear, because that's what Siu wanted.
The panel(s) actually is(are) pretty clear. Here's the context:
- Jinsung was bleeding all over - including out of his mouth (Kallavan was not) - not a great sign if you think all things are relatively equal lol. Oh, well I will concede Jinsung was able to break Kallavan's nose. Which had zero effect on him lol. *sign of disproportionate abilities*
- Jinsung was huffing and puffing prior to pulling out all the stops and specifically after his transcendent attack (Kallavan was not) - please see the panels. Kallavan never showed signs of exhaustion (even after big bomber or atomic attack transcendent skills and then going on to fight others) and Jinsung had been showing them for several panels so far. *sign of disproportionate abilities*
- Jinsung's right arm was "a complete mess" and just dangling there from merely taking strikes (Kallavan was just fine) - his arm(s) BEFORE being 'taken' were already approaching their limits by Jinsung's own admission. *sign of disproportionate abilities*
- Jinsung spent an inordinate amount of energy, already being visibly winded, to deliver a blow that he THOUGHT would be sufficient and fatal. *sign of disproportionate gauging of abilities*
With that context in mind (none of which I believe you could argue against as it is all explicitly shown) Kallavan was able to immediately tank an attack that would be fatal to most anyone, probably even Jinsung himself, and overpower Jinsung in raw strength point-blank (not to mention Jinsung didn't have enough energy or speed to avoid being clasped as a 'superior tactician'). Jinsung didn't have much left to give and was in poor fighting shape, and that's before Jinsung's arms being attacked - but certainly afterwards. That is why he even had a momentary thought of teaching Baam an ultimate attack. Jinsung waxes about the importance of the attack because he thinks when pushed to the limits where he ADMITS he has to do everything he can to stop Jinsung that the attack is sufficient. If he held back then that doesn't fit the narrative. If he held back then he's not the best judge of strength and a so-called 'superior martial artist' without situational awareness is a bit oxymoronic.
It's impossible for me to say he absolute had no way of attacking further, but the fact is he quite simply didn't. And he WAS very visibly winded, and very visibly and effectively injured (unlike Kallavan - the scope of Kallavan's injuries didn't matter as it had no effect on him). Too winded and too injured and too slow and too weak (and too surprised) to avoid or stop Kallavan's next attack. So much for being a "tactician" in that regards. Base Jinsung was simply outclassed by Kallavan and balls-out Jinsung was outclassed by Kallavan as well. There was literally no sign that Jinsung was capable of countering simple attacks and the only card he had would be IF he could multi-spam his trump attack (and that's a big if considering). Which he either didn't and/or couldn't. We know he didn't, and I suspect he didn't because he couldn't. Why? Because the context of the entire fight and the condition he was in. None of which is unimportant, but seems to be glossed over.
SIU did not make it unclear who was in superior control in that fight. He did not make it unclear who was sustaining more effectual damage. He did not make it unclear who ended up more winded. He did not make it unclear who was or wasn't able to continue fighting after taking a blow to the same spot on the torso. He did not make it unclear who had the harder flesh.
The only thing that was unclear is IF Jinsung had enough gas in him for another high-level attack and IF he could even land one or perform one in the shape he was in. And to reiterate the shape he was in - pretty damn bad. (prior to Mas showing up). Because it was CLEAR all but the strongest attacks wouldn't stop Kallavan. And it was CLEAR that Kallavan DID posses the strength and power and defense to continue to wreck Jinsung. Jinsung is questionable, Kallavan is a given.
And in the totality of the context of the performance of each individual and the condition they were in (factoring in damage that had any effect, tiredness, speed of assault, use of appendages, etc - all 'wins' on Kallavan's score card) I personally think it extremely unlikely that Jinsung could have pulled it out all things considered. I'll stop short of saying it's an impossibility, because you are right we don't know.
But what isn't up to debate is that Kallavan had superior defense and ability to take damage. BOTH took hits to their abdomen. On Jinsung you have almost the same location with what can only either be a pin-hole sized hole or no hole at all (lightning damage without a hole at all) - it's difficult to tell. When Mas approached a down Jinsung he had no gaping wound like Kallavan did. Either way, Kallavan undoubtedly took more damage to the equally vital area. And with less damage Jinsung was KO'd. With more damage Kallavan went on to take on EVK head-on. That's not unimportant.
So, Kallavan had the upper hand in base attacks, damage tanking, defense, and flesh hardness/density. The only upper hand Jinsung COULD have had would be if he were what is essentially a 'glass cannon'. Now, no one would call Jinsung a glass cannon compared to anyone else but Kallavan. If Jinsung could have landed a strong attack while avoiding more damage to his comparatively weak body he might have irked it out. Meanwhile, Kallavan is a cast-iron cannon - having both strong offense and defense compared to Jinsung. He also had more gas. Jinsung would have to land a lucky blow, overcome the disparity in tiredness, avoid any further damage, and utilize only the strongest of attacks that require time to setup and the gas to do so. On top of that, his 'cannon' was cracked and lacked the mechanism to attack - his hands. All that while relying on Kallavan to sit back and take it as a relatively stationary target now knowing how strong the tiger/dragon attack was.
The likelihood that Jinsung could have overcome all that is slim to none. But if you want to believe he had a chance who am I to say otherwise.
Particularly when considering -
===================================
I can't deny that SIU likes to sometimes play coy in his blogs (see the 'prince of Zahard' blog ffs...). I could point out that 'difficult to predict' =/= impossible to ascertain, but that's a bit over-specific with the semantics. SIU has shown several times that he likes to pretend to not know, that's all well and good. But what is shown in his panels doesn't seem to match up with his noncommittal approach in his blog. He gives us, knowingly or unknowingly, enough data to come to a reasonable conclusion.ya’ll realized that SIU mentioned in his blog if Maschenny didn’t appear, the fight between Kallavan and Jinsung could have gone either way, right?
from SIU’s blog post.
Jinsung could be the superior martial artist as far as skill all day long. OK, so what if he is? If he's too tired and broken and the target is too difficult to overcome short of spamming hail mary's then that doesn't exactly make it seem very likely. And that is how SIU portrayed the condition of Jinsung and the difficulty of his opponent. Relying on hail mary's results in a POSSIBLE win, but not a PROBABLE win.
I mean a 4yo could have more martial arts skills than me. The little shit could go from the best reproduction of a stance transitioned into a perfect kata and end with an on-point striking technique to almost any part of my body. But, realistically, I'd laugh as it would have little to no effect and I'd proceed to front-kick his baby teeth in. It's like Indiana Jones with a gun facing the sword-swinging Arab. I'm sure the later's style was flawless...
Saying that Jinsung is the 'better martial artist' if he can't overcome his opponent is essentially meaningless.
This is an assumption. You're assuming a temp freeze/fast-skip with no setup and no lasting effects is equatable to the bigger, flashier, longer-to-set-up, and more damaging (by 100% lol) ultimate/transcendent attack. It's like when Baam fast-skipped Tall that is in no way equivalent to Baam pulling out a thorn or BM and attacking him. While they COULD be equatable, that isn't likely considering.also another plus, Jinsung was able to freeze Kallavan and Maschenny at the same time, he has it in him to deal another fatal attack to Kallavan.
SIU's doing the 'on this hand... but on that hand... but on another hand yet...' shtick (and having fun at our expense - 'hehe'). He's purposefully noncommittal. Probably for the fan-base of each. Yet, what does he SHOW in the actual fight?plus with SIu mentioning how Kallavan was younger (add in the fact that we know Jinsung said he grows stronger with age, not weaker) SIU could maybe been leaning towards Jinsung
we agree here... (and this is what we SEE and is thus arguably more important as it has the most results in the fight)in straight up physical stats, Kallavan is undoubtably stronger than Jinsung
...but not here - this simply isn't shown to be the case. How do you figure?but Jinsung’s techniques more than bridges that difference.
So, he's incompetent is your argument?You can say Kallavan was beating the life out of Jinsung in the first half, but the fight could also gone differently if Jinsung freeze Kallavan first instead of fighting him physically where he obviously isn’t Kallavan’s match in that field while he could also mercilessly throw attacks at him one after another once he froze him. In this fight specifically, Jinsung kinda looked down upon the younger Kallavan and paid for it. In a rematch, Jinsung is obviously not going to take his attacks head on so easily.
All the more reason to think it would be an extremely slim chance for Jinsung to defeat him. If Jinsung wasn't tired, winded, bleeding, broken, and still had his arms then MAYBE he could do two (or more) transcendent skills back-to-back - with no time to 'reload' in between. Unlikely, but maybe. But considering the shape he was in the likelihood rapidly approaches zero - with some slim chance remaining because we simply didn't get to see a resolution and SIU taunts us about this...also, to ya saying how Kallavan could kept going after a supposed fatal attack, it his attribute. The dude is a literal crystal so fatal dmg to a normal being with fresh and blood wouldn’t apply to him.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
@Jammin or any admin - could you make a new 'who won the fight - Kallavan vs Jinsung' thread?
