Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Neala897]

1/3 of lineup is practically dead... We have interesting times ahead

 

[calimike]

huh?

 

[Neala897]

huh?

If I remember correctly this how its said when all mc are on the cover

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Wondering if SpyxTrue will share this time the color pics of Jujutsu, CSM or Act-age. Oh wait, he discriminates the post-2017 Jump titles except Samurai 8

One Piece again surprises me since it has had this week issue AND last week issue

 

[revo68]

huh?

If I remember correctly this how its said when all mc are on the cover

One Piece would be the Lead Colour Page. The Cover should be all the Main Characters.

 

[SharkBait]

Act Age and HeroAca may find themselves ending in 2020 if they cant pick things up fast.

 

[OtterBrigade]

Act Age and HeroAca may find themselves ending in 2020 if they cant pick things up fast.

I think that 6 spot cushion will probably save them

 

[Jovan]

And as I expected, Tokyo Shinobi Squad continues it's fall to the bottom.

More surprised that Taisei managed to come out on top of the other 4 newbies, interesting.

Beast Children is dead.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

-Shokugeki has ended last month
-Hinmaru has ended this month
-We already have 5 corpses

I'm thinking seriously we are going to get a new serialization round of 5-6 titles, with maybe 1 or even 2 veterans coming back (if that happens, I'm betting on Shimabukuro or Matsui).

 

[Jovan]

Act Age and HeroAca may find themselves ending in 2020 if they cant pick things up fast.

MHA would live for years on the bottom a la Bleach.

-Shokugeki has ended last month
-Hinmaru has ended this month
-We already have 5 corpses

I'm thinking seriously we are going to get a new serialization round of 5-6 titles, with maybe 1 or even 2 veterans coming back (if that happens, I'm betting on Shimabukuro or Matsui).

I doubt 5 or 6 round will happen here. They will leave at least 2 non Samurai 8 newbies (currently that will likely be Kamio Yui and one of Taisei or TSS or even both) and hope for the best.

 

[Stivie]

-Shokugeki has ended last month
-Hinmaru has ended this month
-We already have 5 corpses

I'm thinking seriously we are going to get a new serialization round of 5-6 titles, with maybe 1 or even 2 veterans coming back (if that happens, I'm betting on Shimabukuro or Matsui).

That would be a shot in the foot itself, because you're not sure that 5 or 6 would have any success, even with veterans in the middle.
I think it's safer to have 2 or 3 new manga and hold some corpses to see if they can make a living.
Double Taisei is at least fighting to stay alive.

 

[Jovan]

I am actually curious if Shueisha will axe Beast after what, 11-12 chapters? Seems they may be finally tempted to not keep a flop around 20 chapters like Higuma, ne0, or Saiyuki (and Yui? maybe it's going regardless of it's recent upswing thanks to even bigger bombs)

 

[Ctkk]

I think the only one that they'll be axing in the near future is is Sayuuki. GFC usually starts around issue #40, so I figure they might start a couple series between that and the double issue to replace Soma and Sumo.

 

[Stivie]

I am actually curious if Shueisha will axe Beast after what, 11-12 chapters? Seems they may be finally tempted to not keep a flop around 20 chapters like Higuma, ne0, or Saiyuki (and Yui? maybe it's going regardless of it's recent upswing thanks to even bigger bombs)

you mean saiyuki, neo and yui.
Higuma sold more than newcomers in the botton.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 24, 2019, Original Post Date: Jul 24, 2019 ---

I think the only one that they'll be axing in the near future is is Sayuuki. GFC usually starts around issue #40, so I figure they might start a couple series between that and the double issue to replace Soma and Sumo.

And there's HxH that hasn't appeared this year yet.

 

[PluemBNK48]

We will have a big round of new series for sure!!!
But will Hunter X Hunter come back this time or not???

 

[Ottes]

The last two chapters of Taisei (10 and 9) were the best since the first chapter (Good panels and finally established the first main goal). I hope that Fukuda don't mess up the pacing (again) and the series survival...

 

[Jovan]

you mean saiyuki, neo and yui.
Higuma sold more than newcomers in the botton.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 24, 2019, Original Post Date: Jul 24, 2019 ---

And there's HxH that hasn't appeared this year yet.

Higuma is still a flop for WSJ standards. Just like Yui is.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 24, 2019 ---

I think the only one that they'll be axing in the near future is is Sayuuki. GFC usually starts around issue #40, so I figure they might start a couple series between that and the double issue to replace Soma and Sumo.

Soma is already replaced by oneshots (GFC will just overtake that), so that would leave 2 series up (Saiyuki and Hinomaru's spots), which I think could actually happen.

Imo HXH will return when they inevitably do a bloodbath with newbies (so in 2 rounds).

 

[OtterBrigade]

I think the only one that they'll be axing in the near future is is Sayuuki. GFC usually starts around issue #40, so I figure they might start a couple series between that and the double issue to replace Soma and Sumo.

or it will be like last year and start new series in the middle of the GFC

 

[Jovan]

or it will be like last year and start new series in the middle of the GFC

Or they may not axe anything, start 1 series before GFC to replace Hinomaru (a gag or whatever), and roll with it until post GFC. Countless possibilities here.

 

[Neala897]

That would be a shot in the foot itself, because you're not sure that 5 or 6 would have any success, even with veterans in the middle.
I think it's safer to have 2 or 3 new manga and hold some corpses to see if they can make a living.
Double Taisei is at least fighting to stay alive.

Personally I doubt WSJ has the lack of fodder potential serializations. Its better give chance to other authors than keeping stillborns just for the sake of keeping them

We will have a big round of new series for sure!!!
But will Hunter X Hunter come back this time or not???

It might and what about that? Its not like HxH really part of lineaup. Its sorta special that come and go as Togashi wishes.