It means that our hosts decided to go with a mix of insane and sane dets which seems to much of a hassle. I think everyone was insane in night 0 expect the mafias so Marmy should have gotten a innocent verdict like I did. But I think Marmy saw a chance to hide Zasz away in the mass of guilty verdicts after Demon already stood out as the sole innocent verdict and did not expect somebody else to actually have investigated Zasz in night 0 which ofc contradicted his guilty claim on Zasz,
Think of this: What is more devastating right now? Getting a guilty on you or an innocent? And would a mafia rather use a guilty lie to hide a mafia bro among townies or would a mafia risk death by using a innocent lie on a townie and be the most suspsect one if said target turns out townie after other innocent ones turned out to be mafia? Which one feels more realistic to you?
I'm not criticizing the quality of your scenario. It's a scenario that makes sense, but a scenario. Just saying it's not proof that Marmy lied. Not saying I don't think she didn't either. We could follow your thinking, since even Lambu getting not guilty on you doesn't mean much (knowing we also have a not guilty result on Demon, and none of those are conflicting with other results so far), it is better than nothing. But I think it's even better to wait for people to reveal their actions and try to be more certain on a pattern. And after they do, we might still be lost about how the logic behind the results works (yeah, I also don't think it's random, and I also think that "townies being insane and mafia being sane" is too simplistic). Anyway, I always believed that being hasty when we have over many hours ahead (around 15?) is retarded as well lmao.
It's basically lynching 2 mafias or one and bombing the second (the choice of words in "kill" makes me think the latter option is viable, which means I would be Jesus or sth). I have until night 5, plenty of time.
I'm actually curious about what roles Erin, Marmy and Lambu have, since they hold the odd results so far. But since it seems like half of the people in here claimed either time bomb or defuser, and the rest remained quiet, I wouldn't be surprised if they have nothing to say yet as well... It's kinda weird tho that the ones that usually pressure the rest to drop hints are lenient this time, even if it's due to not knowing their final forms. We could also draw patterns from the roles, and as usual, limit the mafia people before they talk (even if they jump on the time bomb/defuser role, that could become obvious eventually... since they didn't know about their own roles before D1, should be safe to assume they couldn't talk on N0).
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Well, now add Holt to that list, lmao (didn't get your hint, sry Holtie).
Oh look at that an other weird contradicting result @James Rye
With me targeting crescent and getting guilty and now holt targeting crescent and getting innocent
Btw holt what do u mean you're the missing balance in the defuser/bomb?
Oh look at that an other weird contradicting result @James Rye
With me targeting crescent and getting guilty and now holt targeting crescent and getting innocent
Btw holt what do u mean you're the missing balance in the defuser/bomb?
Not sure if it's the best time to reveal I got Guilty on Demon, but I got Guilty on Demon.
And for now I'll just say my temporary role and unlock condition felt pretty exotic before all the Time Bomb/Defuser stuff came out... But I get it now
Not sure if it's the best time to reveal I got Guilty on Demon, but I got Guilty on Demon.
And for now I'll just say my temporary role and unlock condition felt pretty exotic before all the Time Bomb/Defuser stuff came out... But I get it now
This game should be called the defuser and time bomb party hang out
Anyways so far all those who targeted 2 people one got innocent and the other got guilty with the expectation with DD and pompom targeting me and both getting guilty
With the extra innocents I‘m not so sure anymore whether my theory is correct. But the only other good explanation would be that some players get sane, some the insane results. Which is totally useless to us, since we can‘t do any more investigating after N0.
And for now I'll just say my temporary role and unlock condition felt pretty exotic before all the Time Bomb/Defuser stuff came out... But I get it now
This game should be called the decider and time bomb party hang out
Anyways so far all those who targeted 2 people one got innocent and the other got guilty with the expectation with DD and pompom targeting me and both getting guilty
Can you confirm if you're either TB or Defuser? Since you were surprised to hear we had two Defusers, I'd think you're either something else or pretending.
With the extra innocents I‘m not so sure anymore whether my theory is correct. But the only other good explanation would be that some players get sane, some the insane results. Which is totally useless to us, since we can‘t do any more investigating after N0.
Might start to become relevant soon enough. As cynical as it sounds, lynching one of the people investigated two or more times might just be a good idea to get somewhere with it.
Im among the 1st who shared my results, i wouldnt have shared this as earlier if i was not the greenest elf ever
i m currently doing a recap not sure if its relevant or not i suspect a lot might have not say the truth. there must be a pattern in the sanity things but with potential fake roles/investigations it might be hard to figure out easily.
, was about to give the same hint as last game.
Clearly not noticing the color I highlighted the name in. Disappointed in you.