Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Kharthas]

They are 6 oneshot (total 33 pages). And Tsukuda and Niso Isin oneshot its just 5p.

Tsukuda and Niso Isin. A bit overkill for merely 5 pages, no?

 

[101nemesis]

Sakura Wars is getting a new TV anime.

Everyone, let's troll the Bleach fans with this news.

I'm a HUGE Bleach fan. Have a tattoo and everything.
But not gonna lie, trolling overreacting fans does sound super fun.

 

[Newkerzy]

Who're the other five by? I'd be flabbergasted if Komi wasn't among them.

I'm not sure if Komi wants to go back to RomCom again. I feel like he wants to go back to adventuring a la Double Arts. I mean, Estelle the heroine got 9th place in Nisekoi's last popularity poll I think.

 

[Jovan]

I'm not sure if Komi wants to go back to RomCom again. I feel like he wants to go back to adventuring a la Double Arts. I mean, Estelle the heroine got 9th place in Nisekoi's last popularity poll I think.

In before, a Double Arts sequel/continuation on Jump+. That was one of my biggest wishes manga wise. Never gonna happen, but I can dream.

 

[Leoat12]

I'm not sure if Komi wants to go back to RomCom again. I feel like he wants to go back to adventuring a la Double Arts. I mean, Estelle the heroine got 9th place in Nisekoi's last popularity poll I think.

Man, his oneshot on Jump Giga right after Nisekoi ended was spectacular. I bought the magazine just to read it as soon as possible. Shame on me, but I forgot the name. I think he should go back to romance. Double Arts was romance by the way.

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 13, 2019, Original Post Date: Sep 13, 2019 ---

I wouldn't be worried about him because he didn't participate in this festival by the way. If it is a 5 pages oneshot then we didn't lose much. It can be a signal that he is concentrating a new series.

 

[Mammo]

Double Art is the poor man's Pochi Kuro

for the second time today

go read Pochi Kuro

 

[Brizzi]

After Spy x Family I'm more willing to read Jump+ series, before I didn't have much enthusiasm. So, what do you guys recommend? I prefer if it is on Manga Plus, but not necessarily, it is just that my japanese readings backlog is immense.

Blue Flag.

 

[vinceled]

Blue Flag.

Blue Flag seems like an awesome series. I'm so glad Kaito managed to get serialised again in Shueisha after Cross Manage didn't do well in WSJ. He's got a really good sense for making slice of life series.

 

[MangAniMY]

Man, his oneshot on Jump Giga right after Nisekoi ended was spectacular. I bought the magazine just to read it as soon as possible. Shame on me, but I forgot the name. I think he should go back to romance. Double Arts was romance by the way.

toki doki?

 

[animeexpert]

Double Art is the poor man's Pochi Kuro

for the second time today

go read Pochi Kuro

The mc with blond hair looks like a class from dofus/wakfu, the enirispa class

 

[Jovan]

toki doki?

Kind of a shame Tokidoki never got a serialization. Very simple but wide concept for a romcom. Guess it could have been too depressing to maybe attract wider audience unless retooled.

 

[LuckyJim]

Kind of a shame Tokidoki never got a serialization. Very simple but wide concept for a romcom. Guess it could have been too depressing to maybe attract wider audience unless retooled.

I don't think Tokidoki has a concept that could work for a long term serialization, maybe a short series at most, but a full serialization in Shonen Jump would be way too long to stretch it out. It works best as a one shot.

 

[Jovan]

I don't think Tokidoki has a concept that could work for a long term serialization, maybe a short series at most, but a full serialization in Shonen Jump would be way too long to stretch it out. It works best as a one shot.

Yeah. E no Genten oneshot of his works much better as full serialization, but I really hated that one. Even the MC designs were straight Raku and Onodera ripoffs!

 

[Leoat12]

toki doki?

Yes, this one. Magnificent.

Kind of a shame Tokidoki never got a serialization. Very simple but wide concept for a romcom. Guess it could have been too depressing to maybe attract wider audience unless retooled.

I, on the other hand, think that after Nisekoi Komi Naoshi could make a romance, not a romcom, with more drama and a more serious aspect. Nisekoi serious arcs were very good.

I don't think Tokidoki has a concept that could work for a long term serialization, maybe a short series at most, but a full serialization in Shonen Jump would be way too long to stretch it out. It works best as a one shot.

I think so, too. A short series at best.

 

[Newkerzy]

In before, a Double Arts sequel/continuation on Jump+. That was one of my biggest wishes manga wise. Never gonna happen, but I can dream.

You and me both, buddy

 

[Jovan]

Eyeroll at We Never Learn's new forced drama arc, yay! If only it would have balls to go through that like Fuuka did (some may like or hate that manga, but that moment was one of the bigger plot twists I have seen).

Yes, this one. Magnificent.

I, on the other hand, think that after Nisekoi Komi Naoshi could make a romance, not a romcom, with more drama and a more serious aspect. Nisekoi serious arcs were very good.

Nisekoi had a really great Chitoge's Mother arc. Shame it kinda drifted too much into the filler comedy territory literally after that ended.

 

[4Eyes]

Eyeroll at We Never Learn's new forced drama arc, yay! If only it would have balls to go through that like Fuuka did (some may like or hate that manga, but that moment was one of the bigger plot twists I have seen).

Ugh, don't remind me of Fuuka, that plot twist was the shove I needed to rage drop the manga.

 

[Mammo]

>there are new people on this site that have not lived through the entire Fuuka incident when it happened
>they have not witnessed both English and Japanese anime community collective mletdown
>they have not ride out the shitstorm
>they only heard about it

one of the greatest days of my life as a weeb

 

[Ctkk]

>there are new people on this site that have not lived through the entire Fuuka incident when it happened
>they have not witnessed both English and Japanese anime community collective mletdown
>they have not ride out the shitstorm
>they only heard about it

one of the greatest days of my life as a weeb

Please tell us this story, senpai.

 

[Mammo]

Please tell us this story, senpai.

without spoiling Fuuka

"the big plot twist" got leaked online early with weekly shonen magazine raw

it caused huge backlash online

it caused Kodansha to release an apology statement about the chapter even tho it's not out officially yet

the entire thing was a giant shitfest, it was hilarious

years later the scene was cut from the anime adaptation because of fears it would cause another shitfest