Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[TxxT]

Shonen Jump Issue 43 Preview

 

[Leoat12]

>there are new people on this site that have not lived through the entire Fuuka incident when it happened
>they have not witnessed both English and Japanese anime community collective mletdown
>they have not ride out the shitstorm
>they only heard about it

one of the greatest days of my life as a weeb

The episode just proved that people in manga community are not ready for true literature. Man, that was the best plot twist I've ever seen even now. It was magnificent, the apex of Seo Kouji career.

We Never Learn pales in comparison to that. I don't even like to talk about We Never Learn because it frustrates me the fact that it was supposed to substitute my favorite manga (Nisekoi) and doesn't come even close.

 

[Jovan]

Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san Color Page

Spoiler: Color Page, NSFW?

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

We Never Learn pales in comparison to that. I don't even like to talk about We Never Learn because it frustrates me the fact that it was supposed to substitute my favorite manga (Nisekoi) and doesn't come even close.

That's some quality bait

 

[vinceled]

without spoiling Fuuka

"the big plot twist" got leaked online early with weekly shonen magazine raw

it caused huge backlash online

it caused Kodansha to release an apology statement about the chapter even tho it's not out officially yet

the entire thing was a giant shitfest, it was hilarious

years later the scene was cut from the anime adaptation because of fears it would cause another shitfest

Lmao THE scene was cut from the anime? I had no idea. I remember reading the manga weekly up to chapter 75 and seeing it drag on didn’t keep on reading. His new series kinda interests me but I’m afraid it’s gonna be more of the same that happened in Kimi no Iru Machi and Fuuka.

 

[Jovan]

Lmao THE scene was cut from the anime? I had no idea. I remember reading the manga weekly up to chapter 75 and seeing it drag on didn’t keep on reading. His new series kinda interests me but I’m afraid it’s gonna be more of the same that happened in Kimi no Iru Machi and Fuuka.

In fact, the Fuuka anime director said in an interview they wanted to pick up Fuuka after Ch.36 was out to do an alternative story of that. Seo approved that thanks to the fans pushing for it.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Lmao THE scene was cut from the anime? I had no idea. I remember reading the manga weekly up to chapter 75 and seeing it drag on didn’t keep on reading. His new series kinda interests me but I’m afraid it’s gonna be more of the same that happened in Kimi no Iru Machi and Fuuka.

I read the first 10 chapters and thought was pretty nice, of course you can expect the romance and drama but it's basically the "Bakuman" of Shonen Magazine but focused a bit more on the editors side.

 

[101nemesis]

In today's recap episode of "how entitled fans are"

 

[OtterBrigade]

Jump isn't even off this week and there's a convo about a Kodansha series lol

 

[Jovan]

Yozakura has a really, really good MC. Kind of a meh filler chapter, but still a decent read.

 

[Halloween]

I am a little confused here.

Why... are we discussing a series that has nothing to do with WSJ/Jump+/M+?

Let's course correct, please.

 

[Kolbe]

The episode just proved that people in manga community are not ready for true literature. Man, that was the best plot twist I've ever seen even now. It was magnificent, the apex of Seo Kouji career.

We Never Learn pales in comparison to that. I don't even like to talk about We Never Learn because it frustrates me the fact that it was supposed to substitute my favorite manga (Nisekoi) and doesn't come even close.

I'm kinda disappointed with WNL as well but for different reasons.
Idk, I still think its fine but its not as funny or cute as it used to be.

 

[Aeneas]

Wholesome chapter from Taisei.

And more great art.

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

The Plot thickens in Yozakura, really hope it avoids axe-kun in the near future

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

The answers in the BNHA post:


Geekdom trolling twitter guy lmao

 

[ShenGao]

Yozakura ch. 4 was ok. Seeing the results of Taiyo's training was nice, but that teacher was annoying. Let's see where the plot goes in the next chapter.

I dropped Mitama after the first chapter, but wanted to see if it got any better. I can't even describe how irrationally pissed off I'm at the main heroine for always having the same open mouth, wide eyes, shocked expression. In just 3 chapters that same face appears over 40 times. Yes, I counted.

 

[vinceled]

Since we were talking about the controversial choice made in Fuuka, are there any series in WSJ or even in Shueisha where an author made a choice as controversial as this and was bashed online because of it? The only series I can think of is when Ishida decided to end Tokyo Ghoul out of the blue and for 1-2 weeks people didn't know the series would continue.

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

The first thing that comes to mind is Naruto's ending, how much of a shitstorm it was made it so memorable lmao

 

[ShenGao]

Since we were talking about the controversial choice made in Fuuka, are there any series in WSJ or even in Shueisha where an author made a choice as controversial as this and was bashed online because of it? The only series I can think of is when Ishida decided to end Tokyo Ghoul out of the blue and for 1-2 weeks people didn't know the series would continue.

Didn't people burn their copies of Bleach after the last chapter, because they didn't like the pairings?

 

[Jovan]

Since we were talking about the controversial choice made in Fuuka, are there any series in WSJ or even in Shueisha where an author made a choice as controversial as this and was bashed online because of it? The only series I can think of is when Ishida decided to end Tokyo Ghoul out of the blue and for 1-2 weeks people didn't know the series would continue.

Probably not online but Takaya Senbu Gakuen Gekitouden pulled an isekai reboot during the run and it was heavily rejected. It even had the chapter number reset lmao.