Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Nav]

wait how could tokyo shinobi squad end, like what

Edited it a while ago. Ryokutya was saying bottom two series were axed, guess he was mistaken.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

They published 11 new series in this publication year (not counting Dr. Stone spin-off), the same with last year. There's no shortage of series. Just shortage of series that's good enough to survive.

Hell, it is the same with 2016 and 2017, 11 new series in one publication year (and 2015 had 12 new series). Stop talking without checking fact first.

I'm saying shortage of series being published at the same time, not total of new series, talk about misunderstanding comments two times in a row lol

 

[Thundercat27]

So what is your point? What is shortage in this case? So you want jump to axed stuff early to publish more than 11 manga this year? Your point is vague as heck. Maybe so you can easily bend and defense it. Axed 2 or manga at the same time is perfectly normal after a bad year for newbies.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 21, 2019, Original Post Date: Nov 21, 2019 ---

The fact that wsj has to axe 2 series in the same issue is constrast with the "shortage of series running at the same time" narrative you are making.
It's mean jump is running out of slot for new series and has to prune new series asap for the next batch.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

[/QUOTE]

So what is your point? What is shortage in this case? So you want jump to axed stuff early to publish more than 11 manga this year? Your point is vague as heck. Maybe so you can easily bend and defense it. Axed 2 or manga at the same time is perfectly normal after a bad year for newbies.

So, third time in a row? Jesus Christ man, i literally answered OtterBrigade talking about Jump publishing only 18 series for a good part of 2019, you only had to read the comments kkkkkk

 

[animeexpert]

Yui kamio and double taisei axed lol, expected since the first chapter

i expected tokyo and beast to first being axed, well they gonna go soon anyway. zipman looks good, the author knows what position hes in so i hope he knows what hes doing.

READY FOR THE JJK GREATNESS LETS GOOO, pls good studio ,,, PLSSS.. lets the next bandwagon of anitwitter begin

 

[Thundercat27]

What is wrong with "just" 18 series? That's already a big number. And you don't even reply to my second post.
If you can provide facts to prove wsj used to publish more than 18 in the past then your argument would be more credible. So far all of your points seem like presonal opinion and grudge against Nak without anything to back them up.

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

So I found a bigger image of Zipman, with also a preview of Agravity Boys, def is to small to tell, tho to me at first glance I thought it was a sports manga (I mean AB btw) lol

Spoiler

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

What is wrong with "just" 18 series? That's already a big number. And you don't even reply to my second post.
If you can provide facts to prove wsj used to publish more than 18 in the past then your argument would be more credible. So far all of your points seem like presonal opinion and grudge against Nak without anything to back them up.

Ehhh everybody here knows that Shonen Jump has a limit of basically 21 series being published at the same time and the standard number is 20 series at same time, i believe you weere already in this thread when members were talking about Jump working with less mangas than usual, and 18 isn't a big number, in fact is a short number compared to all the other magazines specially the shounen ones.

 

[Nemesis]

I honestly don't see any thing different. WSJ always looked like to me with new series that they throw many per year, cancel most of them and only a few is able to survive. Other magazine editorial do the same ofc, but I feel that the most on here, while lately series aren't getting cancelled as early as in the beginning of the 2010s or before.

 

[Heiji]

Edited it a while ago. Ryokutya was saying bottom two series were axed, guess he was mistaken.

Not really. He said that it was 2 series that were very often at the bottom of the rankings. Not the last 2 series of the ranking of the 52nd issue

 

[Thundercat27]

Ehhh everybody here knows that Shonen Jump has a limit of basically 21 series being published at the same time and the standard number is 20 series at same time, i believe you weere already in this thread when members were talking about Jump working with less mangas than usual, and 18 isn't a big number, in fact is a short number compared to all the other magazines specially the shounen ones.

So I just counted the current toc. There is total 20 entries in the list. Then I ran back to a random issue from the past (issue 15, 2017) https://comicvine.gamespot.com/weekly-shonen-jump-2402-no-15-march-27-2017/4000-585795/ , and found out there is only 19 entries in that issue. Unless you could create a spreadsheet list all number of entries in wsj issue. How can I know if you are actually using fact or that your confirmation bias?

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

So I just counted the current toc. There is total 20 entries in the list. Then I ran back to a random issue from the past (issue 15, 2017) https://comicvine.gamespot.com/weekly-shonen-jump-2402-no-15-march-27-2017/4000-585795/ , and found out there is only 19 entries in that issue. Unless you could create a spreadsheet list all number of entries in wsj issue. How can I know if you are actually using fact or that your confirmation bias?

That issue where Gintama was absent (19), Boruto didn't have the monthly chapter (20) and Robot x Laserbeam started in the next issue with nothing ending for a good time (21). 21 series being published, 20 if you don't want to count monthly Boruto

 

[Thores]

So I found a bigger image of Zipman, with also a preview of Agravity Boys, def is to small to tell, tho to me at first glance I thought it was a sports manga lol

Spoiler

That... doesn't look like the robot police one-shot.

I guess Shibata just likes titles that start with the word "Zip"?

 

[Belkac3m]

That... doesn't look like the robot police one-shot.

I guess Shibata just likes titles that start with the word "Zip"?

And he likes to put zippers in uniforms / robots design.

 

[Aipom626]

Toc #52

Jujutsu (Cover, LCP)
Kimetsu
One Piece
Act-age
BnHA
TPN (CP)
Bokuben
Haikyuu
Seiken Yuusha no Goei (Oneshot, CP)
Yozakura (CP)
Chainsaw
BC
Yuragi
Mitama
S8
Beast Children
Kamio Yui (end)
TSS
Taisei (end)
Stone Spinoff

Seeing Taisei's final chapter at the very bottom of the TOC hurts. It really should be where Beast Children is at least. Seeing Double Taisei and Yui Kamio end before Beast Children and TSS is a bummer. Hopefully those 2 will both end in issue 1 or something since neither of the other series in the preview seemed all that interesting to me, so I hope another 2 new series are on the way as well.

Yui Kamio is going to be massively rushed, even more so than these last couple chapters already were. Double Taisei, on the other hand, could easily have an amazingly conclusive ending. Honestly, even last chapter would've been a decent ending for me, even if it did rush a couple things. With one more chapter on the way, hopefully it'll go out on a high note.

 

[savethecat]

So I found a bigger image of Zipman, with also a preview of Agravity Boys, def is to small to tell, tho to me at first glance I thought it was a sports manga (I mean AB btw) lol

Spoiler

Sadly, it doesn’t look like it’s about Mechs anymore

 

[Samael Morningstar]

Now I guess it would be soon time for TSS, beast children and Samurai 8 to get axed

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

Sadly, it doesn’t look like it’s about Mechs anymore

Being a mecha was kinda its main appeal tbh lol, really hope Shibata knows what he's doing

 

[TxxT]

Jujutsu Kaisen VAs announced, Jujutsu Kaisen is also the final Super Stage announced for Jump Festa 2020
(Studio/Staff/etc will be revealed at the Super Stage)

Junya Enoki - Yuji Itadori
Yuuma Uchida - Megumi Fushiguro
Asami Seto - Nobara Kugisaki

Official Anime Website: https://jujutsukaisen.jp/
Official Anime Twitter: https://twitter.com/animejujutsu

 

[lgrmjauffre]

Now I guess it would be soon time for TSS, beast children and Samurai 8 to get axed

I...doubt Samurai 8 is going to get axed. It underperforming based on their expectations is pretty undermined by the fact that nothing else from 2019 sans Chainsaw Man sold even close to what it does.

I would be genuinely surprised if the other two made it out of the 2019 calendar year, though.