Discussion Best Waifu - Finished

[Valhalla]

 

[Demon Hunter]

Seeing Mira and Lucy make 1 and 2.

The two best waifus in FT.

now all we need is Jellal to be 1. in husbando

 

[Jko]

now all we need is Jellal to be 1. in husbando

If you want a husbando who's never there and cheats on you with his fiance then that's you.

 

[Demon Hunter]

If you want a husbando who's never there and cheats on you with his fiance then that's you.

you're not really a nice person, aren't you

 

[grey matter]

Ufufu, no way. Lucy >> Erza all day every day. Lucy is the most developed character within the series and she doesn't get bs power ups to win fights.

Let's not go into character development in fairy tail lol, it's not really the forte of the series.

Erza is pretty damn developed as well, by fairy tail standards. She actually has one of the biggest character development in the series. She learned to shed her secluded fake tough persona in TOH arc, and be more true to herself - and it was done in a way that had natural flow (i.e wasn't forced). There are few characters who had their persona so drastically changed from the beginning of the series.
Lucy's main development came in Phantom arc, and from the she's been pretty stagnant as a character. Even in Phantom lord arc, her character really didn't 'develop' that much - what about her fundamentally changed? Not much. I though Tartarus would change her, but nothing about her changed since that arc either.

I'm not considering fights for top waifu status, she's actually in my top 10 hated characters of the series based on her fights alone, but remove that and she's a really wholesome (albeit a bit retarded) person,

 

[Demon Hunter]

Let's not go into character development in fairy tail lol, it's not really the forte of the series.

Erza is pretty damn developed as well, by fairy tail standards. She actually has one of the biggest character development in the series. She learned to shed her secluded fake tough persona in TOH arc, and be more true to herself - and it was done in a way that had natural flow (i.e wasn't forced). There are few characters who had their persona so drastically changed from the beginning of the series.
Lucy's main development came in Phantom arc, and from the she's been pretty stagnant as a character. Even in Phantom lord arc, her character really didn't 'develop' that much - what about her fundamentally changed? Not much. I though Tartarus would change her, but nothing about her changed since that arc either.

I'm not considering fights for top waifu status, she's actually in my top 10 hated characters of the series based on her fights alone, but remove that and she's a really wholesome (albeit a bit retarded) person,

don't judge people based on fights

I hated Natsu because he became one punch man after Tartaros and that awful FH Zeref fight but then I saw the light

now he is in my top 5 favorite characters

not husbando material though sorry @Axiomus

 

[grey matter]

now all we need is Jellal to be 1. in husbando

@Jko leaves the chat then, lul

don't judge people based on fights

I hated Natsu because he became one punch man after Tartaros and that awful FH Zeref fight but then I saw the light

now he is in my top 5 favorite characters

not husbando material though sorry @Axiomus

I try not to, but Erza's and Natsu's cases are too much to give a pass .
Erza and Jellal are kinda polar opposies for me lol. I don't like Jellal on my panel, except when he's fighting. I like Erza on my panel, except when she's fighting. Kinda fitting for their ship lmao

I don't particularly like Natsu, even if his fights are ignored lol. The guy got zero character development in the series - he's the typical dummy shounen main character who fools around like a retard (it's entertaining at times, I'll give it that), just without any character development. Outside his fight........... I don't really dislike the guy,nor do I like him. Sometimes I find the guy funny, that's about it.

 

[Star Frost]

I’m satisfied with the results. Lucy and Mirajane are both waifu material and deserve their high placements

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 12, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 12, 2020 ---

If you want a husbando who's never there and cheats on you with his fiance then that's you.

No you didn’t Your hate for him is real

 

[Jko]

you're not really a nice person, aren't you

I'm a realist.

Let's not go into character development in fairy tail lol, it's not really the forte of the series.

Erza is pretty damn developed as well, by fairy tail standards. She actually has one of the biggest character development in the series. She learned to shed her secluded fake tough persona in TOH arc, and be more true to herself - and it was done in a way that had natural flow (i.e wasn't forced). There are few characters who had their persona so drastically changed from the beginning of the series.
Lucy's main development came in Phantom arc, and from the she's been pretty stagnant as a character. Even in Phantom lord arc, her character really didn't 'develop' that much - what about her fundamentally changed? Not much. I though Tartarus would change her, but nothing about her changed since that arc either.

I'm not considering fights for top waifu status, she's actually in my top 10 hated characters of the series based on her fights alone, but remove that and she's a really wholesome (albeit a bit retarded) person,

And then she regresses all those traits from ToH later on lmao.

Lucy however has never been stagnant. She continously grows and grows throughout every arc. PH is far the only arc either as there is the OS arc, Edolas arc, Tenrou arc, GMG arc, Tartarus arc, and Alvarez arc. Even the current 100YQ is still developing her.

Let's turn back and see where Lucy develops each arc. PH arc is where she learns the true value of family and the lengths they will go for you. ToH Lucy forges a new bond with Juvia and showing Juvia that she is family. Loke arc was another mini arc where Lucy stood up to the King of Celestials who can stop freaking time. She puts herself on the line to show the CSK that his rules were indeed wrong and there needs to be rules to protect Celestials from horrible owners. Edolas is where Lucy is put in the seat of the protag and must protect those she loves. It's really where her mental apptitude shines as she beats a main baddy without the use of CS magic. Tenrou is where Lucy and Cana forge a bond of trust and respect. This where Lucy finds out out abput Gild being Cana father and connects to Cana bcs she knows what it feels like to be neglected by her parent. If Lucy wasn't there for Cana and helped guide her as friend then Cana wouldn't of had the guts to tell Gild that he was her father. We then see in her fight with Kainen that Lucy is also ready to sacrifice everything for Natsu and Happy. She could easy run and leave Natsu, but she stands her ground despite the beating she takes.

Spoiler

Let's run over to the GMG where Lucy could easily have taken Yukino keys, but doesn't bcs she realize they have a bond and she forgoes her dream of getting all the CS keys due to the bond they have with Yukino.

Spoiler

Tartarus is where Lucy is the man standing to face off against Tartarus. Does she waver no? Instead she fights back against the overwhelming odds and is forced to separate from her longest friend, Aquarius.

Spoiler

She sacrifices her bond to save the entire guild from being killed. Lucy as continously learned throughout this manga as learned sacrifice and family in many different forms. Lucy from the beginning to Alvarez is a modified character. She goes from a scared run away to a season veteran ready to lay her life on the line for everyone but herself. In Alvarez we notice this as she shows off her amazing analysis skills to deduce the best outcome for each situation. She doesn't let her thoughts and insecurities effect the mission in front of her. This is highlighted when she puts the reconstruction of the guild over her negative feelings towards Natsu for abondoning her. It is further highlighted in her fights with Brandish and Jacob where she goes 1v1 against S12 with no hesitation or fear. She knows what needs to be done and will do it by any means necessary. In the fight with Jacob she easily deduces counters the enemies strongest attack with the enemies own allies special move. Lucy witt and determination is why the guild wasn't merked by Jacob. Lucy is not the offensive powerhouse, but she makes up the difference by being a strategical powerhouse. This Lucy and the one from the beginning are vastly different characters. The only thing they have in common is the core elements of Lucy's character. Even while she is strapped to a chair with magic sealing cuffs on and has knife two inches away from her eye, she stares down a woman who manipulates time. Her determination and courage never wavers in the face of adversity.

Spoiler

Unlike Erza, Lucy never regresses as a character, she only ever moves forwards. She never faces the same damn thing. Look in the current chapter! Erza being cocky af when facing off against freaking Laxus. Has this girl not learned one thing? In Alvarez she easily sides with Natsu to go off and face Zeref which her stupid ass blind faith in Natsu almost gets him killed. Who looks after him when he comes back f-ed up? It's Lucy. She also hyped up Natsu like he can solo Acno.... Lmfao this chick right here is arrogant of herself and Natsu's power.

Lucy is by the far the most developed character and Erza who's only development is ToH which is meh at this point.

You don't have to count fights, but that's where characters flaws and traits are highlighted and we either see them overcome them logically or with bs.

 

[Axiomus]

don't judge people based on fights

I hated Natsu because he became one punch man after Tartaros and that awful FH Zeref fight but then I saw the light

now he is in my top 5 favorite characters

not husbando material though sorry @Axiomus

It's all good. Even if Natsu is subpar as a husbando, Lucy is enough of a top tier waifu to compensate.

Speaking of which, I probably won't be voting in the husbando rounds. I don't think I can summon the same energy as I did here. Too much of a sausage party.

 

[Demon Hunter]

I'm a realist.

Be loved by the Seven Stars
one day, you'll see the greatness of Jellal Fernandes

 

[Jko]

Be loved by the Seven Stars
one day, you'll see the greatness of Jellal Fernandes

When that happens, we'll finally meet Jellal's fiance.

 

[Axiomus]

Jellal has more game than every guy in the series. One day @Jko will see the truth. If he can look past his well of rage against Jellal.

 

[Demon Hunter]

Jellal has more game than every guy in the series. One day @Jko will see the truth. If he can look past his well of rage against Jellal.

first he'll prove that he is a top tier in fighting

he forced Acnologia to go dragon form after all

then he'll show that he is a MAN that all girls love

they'll all Be loved by the Seven Stars

 

[Kouichi]

first he'll prove that he is a top tier in fighting

he forced Acnologia to go dragon form after all

then he'll show that he is a MAN that all girls love

they'll all Be loved by the Seven Stars

I might wonder how big his "bind snake" is because it got immobilized Erza.

 

[M3J]

I am extremely, but pleasantly, surprised Mira won and not Lucy. I guess you losers do have taste after all.

Mirajane <3 best waifu ever

At least most of you know who's the superior waifu. Wish most of you knew who the superior ship was as well.

 

[Ebony Maw]

JellalTear >>> Jerza. Them together co-parenting Meredy gave off top tier FT family vibes

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 12, 2020, Original Post Date: Jan 12, 2020 ---

CS family trio >>>

We don't often agree on much but this isn't really opinion, this... this is fact.

Rank #1 (Score: 214)




214 out of a possible 310 points!!!

Mirajane Strauss

Those who didn't rate Mira: @Axiomus @Brandish @Ebony Maw @Gryffindor
​

​

Well lads, where are we fleeing to? Pretty sure we're going to get hunted down like vermin after this...

All done, thanks for participating!! These FT ladies deserve our love and respect, don't you ever betray your waifu. Like ever.

Did you find the list satisfactory?

Thanks so much for running this @Kiki and @Brandish!

It was fun as always, even though parts of it are objectively wrong.

 

[Jko]

Jellal has more game than every guy in the series. One day @Jko will see the truth. If he can look past his well of rage against Jellal.

What game? He only has one woman pining after him and he's lucky for that lol. Poor Erza got the Sakura treatment

My man Laxus on the other hand is a true ladies man. But, we all know who will capture his heart in the end

Spoiler

 

[Jko]

We don't often agree on much but this isn't really opinion, this... this is fact.

If only he didn't cop out and shaft Ultear.... He should made Erza and Jellal realize they are better off as friends instead of lovers and had Jellal get with Ultear bcs that's the woman he spent the most time with lol.

 

[Kouichi]

Well lads, where are we fleeing to? Pretty sure we're going to get hunted down like vermin after this...

I think it was to shown the results weren't rigged on the contest. But I believe the organizers of this event \o/

No worries I'll hunt you down especially Jellal comes into panel! Our boi needs love though