Games Mafia Game 80 - FGO - Endgame

[Holt]

Alright game info here:

ROLE LIST & PLAYER STATUS

PLAYER TARGETS

NIGHT ACTIONS

 

[Crescent Jinx]

But they should do their job, we're paying them lots of money after all.

Paying in what? Blood? Sweat? Tears?

 

[GrySun]

Paying in what? Blood? Sweat? Tears?

I will paypal you for a Vigilante shot.

 

[Erinyes]

I had the same reasoning as Farf, besides Bel seemed to be avoiding us tho we were wrong in the end. To your last question, no I dont fully trust anyone yet but there's a whole bunch of people that ring alarms and others that dont.



Its at least 3 posts to avoid penalties, but if you are playing the game you are surely to make a lot more than that.
At least you can't blame people for not trusting you if the only thing you do is read and not talk.

Honestly id didnt find anything suspecious with Bel, i know nothing about fate grand order so was interested in her explanations, thats why i though the killer wanted maybe to get rid of her. and the striking thing, to me is that it sounds as if the killer was stressing and needed to perform his kill quickly, rather than the target i would say, the circunstances are weird, the day phase last 24 hours, why rushing for a day kill without waiting how ill things going on, and what people will say.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Is vandred in this game

 

[GrySun]

and the striking thing, to me is that it sounds as if the killer was stressing and needed to perform his kill quickly, rather than the target i would say, the circunstances are weird, the day phase last 24 hours, why rushing for a day kill without waiting how ill things going on, and what people will say.

I didn't see anyone being under pressure at all today. If it was Beno he'd have daykilled on Day 1, or if it was one of his teammates. So either Beno is town or the Assassin is solo/from the other team.

But, I don't see a problem with the assassin kill itself. Ideally you want to pass Day 1 not using it, then talk to your team and nightkill normally, and from then on you just keep killing at day. However there would be some more smarter ways of going by it, like trying to set someone up with it, or do it near the end of a phase and also saving yourself/a teammate if needed.

 

[SirSamuel016]

Doing my best to catch up and yikes there's a lot to catch up on.

Killing Bel seems like an odd choice given what she had said when there were others they could've gone, so maybe there's outside influence like some suggested? Can't rule it out as some could use any petty grievances they have to pin things on someone.

There's also some pointing fingers at others but those pointing said fingers aren't exactly being very open either which is odd because we should all be on the same level of scrutiny, new, experienced, successful players and whatnot.

Yeah, I would add Juvii, Taku and Lak to that.

Its about time we question @SirSamuel016 and @Raven too, kind of tired of the "letting newbie go" trope already.

Is myself being new the only reason you're bringing me up? I'm all for not giving new players a free pass so let's hear what you think on myself, and Raven. On the point of Raven, while she is posting more now I do wish it was at least actually related to the game and not about how posts were formatted as that's just needless waffle to go through.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Btw idk about others but I said weird picks about gajeel and bel not because they are bad but they were potential witch hunt kills for me you want to get rid off people who controls the herd like gry and farf /james and not afk to win guys

 

[Farfalla]

I'm actually liking how both Rav and Sam play o.o

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 14, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 14, 2020 ---

Is myself being new the only reason you're bringing me up? I'm all for not giving new players a free pass so let's hear what you think on myself, and Raven. On the point of Raven, while she is posting more now I do wish it was at least actually related to the game and not about how posts were formatted as that's just needless waffle to go through.

She's not as vocal as you but when asked her reasoning was nice.

 

[Takuan]

@Farfalla to explain, again, what i meant : i agree that Marma is a good player, Gajeel as well, DD as well, Belserion as well. And i already said that. I just stated that these players wouldn't be the ones i would lynch immediately, because some players are scarier to me. Could be a matter of opinion, some people might think differently, i never pretended to have the absolute unique truth.

 

[GrySun]

I'm actually liking how both Rav and Sam play o.o

Disagree about Raven so far, though she's doing more than previous day so that's good. Agree about Sam, he could be mafia but he plays well and his posts are constructed well.

 

[Takuan]

Btw idk about others but I said weird picks about gajeel and bel not because they are bad but they were potential witch hunt kills for me you want to get rid off people who controls the herd like gry and farf /james and not afk to win guys

Thank you. That's exactly what i meant as well.

 

[Demonspeed]

Is myself being new the only reason you're bringing me up? I'm all for not giving new players a free pass so let's hear what you think on myself, and Raven. On the point of Raven, while she is posting more now I do wish it was at least actually related to the game and not about how posts were formatted as that's just needless waffle to go through.

Why did you feel the need to lock your vote for Seraph D1?

 

[SonOfDaws]

How can son get mafia 3 times in a row...

I imagine the same way Seraph clearly got mafia in this one.

Why does this read like a "I wouldn't mind Beno getting lynched, but I'd prefer making more cases to avoid him getting lynched". You two wouldn't be teammates would you?

What a cruel twist of fate that would be...

No, I'm perfectly fine with Beno dying. The reason I voted James instead was because he just caught my eye more and earlier on, but Beno played the way he did last game for that very reason if not very similar ones... So, I may change to him, but James is just a bit higher on my list at the moment.

I would like to hear more from both James and Beno though, their suspects in particular.

 

[GrySun]

I'm likely wrong on some, it's Day 2 and nothing much to go by, but for now from the alive players I trust: goodboy, Samuel, desin, Zasz, James and Lambu. Not many names. Mainly the way they're playing.

 

[Lady pompom]

I was backreading,

Maybe insane dr

Why insane? It looks like a perfectly healthy 3 parties killing 1 each. And insane seems a bit too much for this game.

Three deaths, two Mafia teams are obvious to me in this game. DD and Marm are more likely to be Mafia kills and I am expecting a TP in game, one is a veteran, the other claimed to have an active role which are popular killing targets N1.

I think they got the attention either because of hints or because they looked iffy on the eyes of the killer. As for DD, maybe an enemy mafia thought he was a mafia?

About Bel, it is likely the assassin thought she is mafia or just killed because they find her threatening as a player in a long term (and she is)

Well the thing is, i agree with the fact that this assassin kill seems to be from someone who's not used to playing with the usual players. It seems weird as fuck that Belserion was targetting, when seasonned agressive players still roam around.
On the other hand, what i don't get is that the assassin must have communicated with his team during the night... So unless the whole team decided on Belserion, which is an odd choice, i just don't get it. Unless the whole team of the assassin is composed of unexperienced players ? The odds are pretty low.

I don’t think it is that strange, considering Bel usually stays quiet until she gets information and then she pins down the mafia (when she is not one) , they were either afraid or thought she was a mafia from another faction. Maybe a veteran would not choose her this early, but that doesn’t mean the mafia couldn’t have veterans. Considering we have 2 mafias, I suppose 4-4 or 3-4 numbers (not counting the 1-2 third parties). More likely 3-4 + thirdies

Why are people so stuck on the targets?

While weider than usual I can see why those targets. For me Gajeel could be considered the weirder one but this kind of talk seems pretty useless.

We should be focusing on the living ones, not wasting time talking about why they target who they target.

Speaking of living ones that I couldn't even remember were playing: @Lady pompom can you join us?

Isn't revealing more about their roles that ended up killing them tho? Mafia looks the very interested in roles type this time.

I am here, I was reading everything. I gave my thoughts and even hinted yesterday, something not everyone did, but oh well, afkers get the free pass.

Vandred, Raven, beno, zasz, shino, many people yet to tell more...

I've been a sole assassin, so that's definitely possible. I thought that it was a one-time thing only, kind of a testing game with the role, but it might just be my ego making me believe i was special and nobody else could be a sole assassin xD

But i don't get why there was no assassin kill on Day 1 though.

Sometimes mafia hides the assassin to surprise people, they also hid janitor once. I am not so sure about a solo assassin, but we can confirm it if there are only 2 kills next night (considering other things too like blocks and all).

How can son get mafia 3 times in a row...

SonOfMafia?

 

[SirSamuel016]

Why did you feel the need to lock your vote for Seraph D1?

Honestly that was due to me being a mong and not clearly understanding that locking had more weight than a regular votekill, and I took the same approach as just confirming a vote like how in a game show you'd say "Lock it in Eddie" for Millionaire Hot Seat in Australia. I had said my vote could change, but I wanted to make sure it was certain that my vote was what I wanted. Now that you (At least I think it was you) clarified it, the lock was unnecessary on my part. Ignorance on my part, but I've reread the rules so I don't make potentially dangerous assumptions like that again.

 

[SonOfDaws]

I agree with most of what you're saying, but i have some reserve about James being Mafia. The "dead meat" alone makes me believe he's not mafia, at least not in the mafia team that killed Marm, because that would be way too much, James is experienced after all. He could still be a scum from a different team, but in that case that sentence doesn't mean much.

Ordinarily, I would say the same, but his behavior last game makes me heavily question that... He's got plenty of experience and brain, but he let's himself get carried away in his own emotion too much for his own good. Still, I'm willing to give him some benefit of the doubt, but he's still lynch-able to me until we start seeing more.

 

[Lambu]

Doing my best to catch up and yikes there's a lot to catch up on.

Killing Bel seems like an odd choice given what she had said when there were others they could've gone, so maybe there's outside influence like some suggested? Can't rule it out as some could use any petty grievances they have to pin things on someone.

There's also some pointing fingers at others but those pointing said fingers aren't exactly being very open either which is odd because we should all be on the same level of scrutiny, new, experienced, successful players and whatnot.

Is myself being new the only reason you're bringing me up? I'm all for not giving new players a free pass so let's hear what you think on myself, and Raven. On the point of Raven, while she is posting more now I do wish it was at least actually related to the game and not about how posts were formatted as that's just needless waffle to go through.

I brought you up on reflex, of the three newcomers at least you are playing the game. It would be a good moment for a hint towards your role tho.

She's not as vocal as you but when asked her reasoning was nice.

What?? Her reasoning was terrible.

 

[Lady pompom]

I will paypal you for a Vigilante shot.

Granted

 

[GrySun]

Granted

What?