I agree, maybe Tanjiro's death would have been more dramatic, but as everything was resolved it was also good for me.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
when will the popularity survey be?
Yeah I always thought that there was a reason why they did that , but I was convinced that Demon Tanjiro was gonna die soLoving the allusions in this chapter.
On ch. 200 we get a color page showing the fates of each protagonist, with those on the left coming out alive while those on the right have passed on. Notice how Tanjiro, while standing on the dying side, is still facing Nezuko, while Nezuko is also facing him. This looked to be an implicit farewell to me at the time, but it seems I was wrong.
Now on ch. 203 you can see those same dead people from ch. 200 pushing Tanjiro to go back to his sister.
In the end the color page was more of a reference to Tanjiro's oath to Tamayo and Yushiro when he said that his bonds with Nezuko will never be severed. Now we realize that in the end not even death managed to part them. It was not a farewell, but a way of telling that the siblings won't be separated. Brilliant writing right there.
I love this manga to death but I wouldn't call the final fight/part brilliant writing. I don't hate it as much as some people do but there were definitely a couple issues with it. Honestly I am just so happy that all the Kimetsu-part-2 peeps got proven wrong as taking this manga any further would have made any issues we have now even worse.Loving the allusions in this chapter.
On ch. 200 we get a color page showing the fates of each protagonist, with those on the left coming out alive while those on the right have passed on. Notice how Tanjiro, while standing on the dying side, is still facing Nezuko, while Nezuko is also facing him. This looked to be an implicit farewell to me at the time, but it seems I was wrong.
Now on ch. 203 you can see those same dead people from ch. 200 pushing Tanjiro to go back to his sister.
In the end the color page was more of a reference to Tanjiro's oath to Tamayo and Yushiro when he said that his bonds with Nezuko will never be severed. Now we realize that in the end not even death managed to part them. ch 200 was not a farewell, but a way of telling that the siblings won't be separated. Brilliant writing right there.
In fairness a lot more people died in KnY than the norm for WSJ so maybe that's why they got their hopes up - but a protag is a protag after all lol.
weekly shounen jump never kill main characters except Deathnote that because protagonist is evil bastard
1.That’s the reason why I wanted him to die so it can be different and memorable 2. Shonen isn’t a genre it’s a demographic there are plenty of grim dark shonen like devilman, attack on titan, jigoraku, beastars, and akame ga kill ( a story where the main character died) 3. This isn’t the fist shonen story where the Mac dies with ashita no joe and akame ga kill
Compare to hundreds of weekly shounen jump out there jojo and Deathnote is only one. Its not realistic expectation 70 percent chance of main characters living and main characters dieng. It low percentage
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
You guys are looking at wrong genre in My opinion. Plus expecting way too much despite other weekly shounen jump hardly ever cross boundaries of killing main characters. Not even SNK has cross lines as main characters are still alive.
I agree with you most of it to Expected Tanjiro to die not even SNK even pull that off from final scene of the manga doesn t seem like it. Plus it very rare for weekly shounen jump to kill Main characters percentage is very low only handful done it.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Makes no sense why they died lol last we seen they were lively and talking to eachother we didn’t get any afterlife scene and now there dead?! The medics didn’t even try to help them? We seen them tending to everyone’s wounds besides Obanai and mitsuri, that makes noooo sense. How the hell did Obanai die when all he did was lose his eyes
Look like Obanai and Mitsuri are dead.
that isn’t life threatening at all! And mitsuri just got cut on her face and cheek. I know everyone was saying she lost her arms, but that was never confirmed and we never actually seen her lose them so I don’t believe it, it’s all speculation... so why are they dead 
like wtf
I mean they both said that they were close to death and they didn’t even feel pain so it means that there were exhausted and lost too much blood . They also said they were gonna reincarniate and all that staff soooMakes no sense why they died lol last we seen they were lively and talking to eachother we didn’t get any afterlife scene and now there dead?! The medics didn’t even try to help them? We seen them tending to everyone’s wounds besides Obanai and mitsuri, that makes noooo sense. How the hell did Obanai die when all he did was lose his eyes
Lol they said “IF we get reborn again as humans” kanroji legit said “i GUESS I’m dying” that isn’t very solid at all
the way they were talking 100% seemed like they could be saved. Obanai only lost his eyes and mitsuri got cut how are those life threatening at alllllllll so wack haha I’m annoyed they died and seeing them in one panel is the only confirmation we got... every single other character you seen them die as soon as it happened, with them they were hugging eachother and talking and next we know they’re dead.... makes no sense to me :/
He visited the Muzan's jaws, literally. Not to consider that it is fatal, it's like thinking that sharks are harmless fish.