Decent positions, color page in the middle, this is basically "doing fine" so far, if will sell good or keep for the long running it's another story
The same thing happened with Moriking and bone collection, it is easier for a manga to start well and get worse over time than the other way around.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Bone Collection isn't really a example to use in this case, it had only two good positions and dropped dead in the rankings, Cop and Dolphin is clearly doing better overall with more consistent rankings instead of just 2 good and dropping like a bomb.
No matter the genre, if it sells cancels, unfortunately that's how it works.
It actually do matter, since it's about expectations and gag series are natural low sellers, Mitama Security survived for a year selling the same/less, Spring Weapon from the same author survived for over a year with low sales too, the magazine also do matter since the same thing who is considered as a flop on Jump is considered as well received in many others, so isn't really as much about the world being capitalist but the place where a series is being published and their expectations but i don't know why you're saying all of this when isn't even the point of the comment but that a typical gag series expectations are naturally different than a series like Cop and Dolphin, sometimes you let your problem with comedy series take too much control over your opinions Stivie.
I would say basically your list, but I think Phantom Seer, Cop and Dolphin and Yozakura will still be alive by that issue next year. Idk about Our Blood Oath, but it doesn't seem that popular and has pretty low views on its PV (It has 13k, I know it isn't completely accurate but it shows that it doesn't have that much attention when HS Family has 40k views, and Phantom Seer has 227K views) so you are probably right about that.
I have no problem with the series, as I have repeated it several times, I have no problem with the series as long as it sells well.
Hmm, I think Cop and Dolphin is currently doing well, and is currently being well received. In the future when vol sales are released and it does bad, you should say its doing badly, but right now I don't think you should be too pessimistic with it because everything seems good for the series.
Ehh you're mixing personal opinion about content with things like sales, i don't care about sales when enjoying a series, it don't change my enjoyment, S8 being one case, but never tried to act like the series wasn't selling poorly, but you do let your problem with gag/comedy series take control sometimes in your opinions, which makes it sound very negative/pessimist
I'm realistic, I just want to wait for the sales of the volumes to be sure.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Who is mixing personal opinion is you, I'm just trying to be cautious with the jump series.
One Piece
I think Yozakura Family can reach 100 chapters. I see him as a type of Hinomaru zumou, sells enough to survive and any manga that sells less than Yozakura is canceled.
And High school family and Bokura no Ketsumei?
It's true. Though her new manga is going to be on Jump+ she is not coming back to WSJ if that is what you are talking about.
One Piece
This'll be a fun month!