Games Mafia Game 85 - Shingeki no Kyojin Final Arc - END GAME

[Gajeel]

Role List

@Brandish μ as Eren (Bodyguard) (Super Mason)
@Farfalla as Armin (Mafia Mason)
@Seraph as Mikasa (Freeman)
@scav as Connie (Noble) (Super Mason)
@GrySun as Sasha (Bomb Defuser)
@Raven as Jean (Mafia Robber) (Lover)
@Asako as Floch (Kamikaze Bomb) (Explode Night 4)
@James Rye as Levy (Sane Spy)
@Holt as Hange (Time Bomb) (Explode Night 4)
@Shad as Shadis (Mafia Detective)
@Belserion as Annie (Pirate)
@sakura-aneki as Reiner (Prostitute) (Traitor)
@Vandred as Pieck (Naive Detective) (Super Mason)
@Takuan as Porco (Sane Detective)
@Demonspeed as Zeke (Death Miller)
@digitaldude as Magath (Mafia Bomb Defuser)
@MarmaladeSky as Udo (Insane Spy)
@Lambu as Zofia (Mafia Politician)
@Evil3ye as Gabi (Serial Killer) (Lover)
@Copy Panda as Falco (Jesus)
@desin24 as Colt (Sane Detective)
@goodboy_lawlett as Ms. Tybur (Mafia Bomb)
@gnut as Willy (Mason Recruiter)
@BlackTiger as Yelena (Sane Doctor)
@Lady pompom as Onyankopon (Spirit Medium)


Night Actions

Spoiler: Night 1

Titans
digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
Vandred --> Female Titan (1)
Brandish --> Colossal Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
desin24 --> Attack Titan (1)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
Farfalla --> Cart Titan (1)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0

Priority 1
sakura-aneki (Prostitute) (Traitor) --> Block Evil3ye (Success)

Priority 2
desin24 (Sane Detective) --> Investigate GrySun (Innocent / War Hammer Titan)
Takuan (Sane Detective) --> Investigate Lambu (Guilty)
Vandred (Naive Detective) (Super Mason) --> Investigate gnut (Innocent)
James Rye (Sane Spy) --> Investigate Demonspeed (No results)
Shad (Mafia Detective) --> Investigate GrySun (No results / War Hammer Titan)
digitaldude (Mafia Bomb Defuser) --> Defuse Asako (Success)

Priority 3
gnut (Mason Recruiter) --> Recruit Evil3ye (Fail)
goodboy_lawlett (Mafia Bomb) --> Kill gnut (Success)
Evil3ye (Serial Killer) (Lover) --> Kill goodboy_lawlett (Blocked)

Spoiler: Night 2

Titans
digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
!goodboy_lawlett --> Female Titan (2)
Brandish --> Colossal Titan (1)
!scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
desin24 --> Attack Titan (1)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
Farfalla --> Cart Titan (1)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
digitaldude (Armored Titan) --> Use Armored Titan's power
Brandish (Colossal Titan) --> Use Colossal Titan's power

Priority 1
sakura-aneki (Prostitute) (Traitor) --> Block BlackTiger (Success)

Priority 2
desin24 (Sane Detective) --> Investigate Asako (Innocent)
Takuan (Sane Detective) --> Investigate Panda (Innocent)
!MarmaladeSky (Insane Spy) --> Investigate Seraph (No Results)
!Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate gnut (No Results)
!BlackTiger (Sane Doctor) --> Protect Lady pompom (Blocked)
!Belserion (Pirate) --> Steal BlackTiger's role (Success)
Shad (Mafia Detective) --> Investigate Lady pompom (Spirit Medium)

Priority 3
!Lambu (Mafia Politician) --> Kill Takuan (Success)

Spoiler: Night 3

Titans
digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
goodboy_lawlett --> Female Titan (2)
!Demonspeed --> Colossal Titan (2)
scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
desin24 --> Attack Titan (1)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
Farfalla --> Cart Titan (1)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
scav (Founder Titan) --> Use Founder Titan's power on Shad
Farfalla (Cart Titan) --> Use Cart Titan's power on goodboy_lawlett (Blocked)
goodboy_lawlett (Female Titan) --> Kill Seraph with the Female Titan's power (Success)

Priority 1
sakura-aneki (Prostitute) (Traitor) --> Block Farfalla (Success)

Priority 2
desin24 (Sane Detective) --> Investigate Seraph (No Result)
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate Takuan (Night 1; Lambu, Night 2; Copy Panda)
BlackTiger (Town) --> Protect desin24 (Fail, No Role)
Belserion (Sane Doctor) --> Protect Seraph (Fail)
!GrySun (Bomb Defuser) --> Defuse Holt (Success)
Shad (Mafia Detective) --> Investigate sakura-aneki (Prostitute) (Traitor)

Priority 3
!Asako (Kamikaze Bomb) --> Explode on Farfalla (Fail, Defused)

Spoiler: Night 4

Titans
digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
goodboy_lawlett --> Female Titan (2)
!Demonspeed --> Colossal Titan (2)
scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
desin24 --> Attack Titan (1)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
Farfalla --> Cart Titan (1)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
scav (Founder Titan) --> Use Founder Titan's power on goodboy_lawlett
Farfalla (Cart Titan) --> Use Cart Titan's power on Lambu (Blocked)


Priority 1
sakura-aneki (Prostitute) (Traitor) --> Block Farfalla (Success)

Priority 2
desin24 (Sane Detective) --> Investigate Farfalla (Guilty)
MarmaladeSky (Insane Spy) --> Investigate Farfalla (No Results)
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate Vandred (Night 1; gnut)
Belserion (Sane Doctor) --> Protect Lambu (Success)
Shad (Mafia Detective) --> Investigate desin24 (Detective)

Priority 3
!Holt (Time Bomb) --> Explode on desin24 (Fail, Defused)
Asako (Kamikaze Bomb) --> Explode on Farfalla (Fail, Defused)
goodboy_lawlett (Mafia Bomb) --> Kill Belserion (Success)

Spoiler: Night 5

Titans
digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
goodboy_lawlett --> Female Titan (2)
Demonspeed --> Colossal Titan (2)
scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
desin24 --> Attack Titan (1)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
Farfalla --> Cart Titan (1)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
scav (Founder Titan) --> Use Founder Titan's power on Demonspeed (SUCCESS!)
Demonspeed (Colossal Titan) --> Use Colossal Titan's power (NULLIFIED!)

Priority 1
sakura-aneki (Prostitute) (Traitor) --> Block Lady pompom (Success)

Priority 2
desin24 (Sane Detective) --> Investigate BlackTiger (Innocent)
MarmaladeSky (Insane Spy) --> Investigate Shad (Randomized to Farfalla)
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate Belserion (Blocked)
Shad (Mafia Detective) --> Investigate Demonspeed (Town)

Priority 3
Farfalla (Mafia Mason) --> Kill sakura-aneki (Success, Traitor Recruited)

Spoiler: Night 6

digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
goodboy_lawlett --> Female Titan (2)
Demonspeed --> Colossal Titan (2)
scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
desin24 --> Attack Titan (1)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
!BlackTiger --> Cart Titan (2)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
scav (Founder Titan) --> Use Founder Titan's power on GrySun (Success)

Priority 1


Priority 2
desin24 (Sane Detective) --> Investigate MarmaladeSky (Innocent)
MarmaladeSky (Insane Spy) --> Investigate Holt (No Results)
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate Belserion (Night 2; BlackTiger, Night 3; Seraph, Night 4; Lambu)
Shad (Mafia Detective) --> Investigate digitaldude (Mafia Bomb Defuser)

Priority 3
digitaldude (Mafia Bomb Defuser) --> Kill desin24 (Success)

Spoiler: Night 7

digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
Female Titan
Demonspeed --> Colossal Titan (2)
scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
!Lady pompom --> Attack Titan (2)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
BlackTiger --> Cart Titan (2)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
BlackTiger (Cart Titan) --> Use Cart Titan's power on scav (Success)

Priority 1


Priority 2
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate desin24 (Night 1; GrySun, Night 2; Asako, Night 3; Seraph, Night 4; Farfalla, Night 5; BlackTiger, Night 6; MarmaladeSky)

Priority 3
Shad (Mafia Detective) --> Kill Demonspeed (Success)

Spoiler: Night 8

digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
Female Titan
Colossal Titan
scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
Lady pompom --> Attack Titan (2)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
BlackTiger --> Cart Titan (2)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
scav (Founder Titan) --> Use Founder Titan's power on Lady pompom
BlackTiger (Cart Titan) --> Use Cart Titan's power on scav (Success)

Priority 1


Priority 2
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate MarmaladeSky (Night 2; Seraph, Night 4; Farfalla, Night 5; Shad, Night 6; Holt)

Priority 3
digitaldude (Mafia Bomb Defuser) --> Kill Asako (Success)

Spoiler: Night 9

digitaldude -->Armored Titan (1)
Female Titan
Colossal Titan
scav --> Founder Titan (1)
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
Lady pompom --> Attack Titan (2)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
BlackTiger --> Cart Titan (2)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power
scav (Founder Titan) --> Use Founder Titan's power on Lady pompom

Priority 1


Priority 2
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate Asako (Night 3; Farfalla, Night 4; Farfalla)

Priority 3
digitaldude (Mafia Bomb Defuser) --> Kill scav (Success)

Spoiler: Night 10

Armored Titan
Female Titan
Colossal Titan
Founder Titan
sakura-aneki --> Jaw Titan (1)
Lady pompom --> Attack Titan (2)
GrySun --> War Hammer Titan (1)
BlackTiger --> Cart Titan (2)
Copy Panda --> Beast Titan (1)

Priority 0/ Titan Power

Priority 1


Priority 2
Lady pompom (Spirit Medium) --> Investigate James Rye (Night 1; Demonspeed)

Priority 3
sakura-aneki (Mafia Member) --> Kill GrySun (Success)

 

[Brandish μ]

With all these investigators dead you mob could use my penalties to see if someone gets saved later on.

 

[Baka Taichou]

If I try to learn from a mafia or third party I die, so if I don't die, that means that I'm claiming you are not mafia, i could still be tho, doesn't say anything about me.

Then I invite you to check me out tonight bby ♡

 

[Brandish μ]

"Oh I need to lock and go to bed""Using my anon too"
> still lurking an hour or so after locking
> wakes up with 6 hrs left

I like it.

 

[Baka Taichou]

"Oh I need to lock and go to bed""Using my anon too"
> still lurking an hour or so after locking
> wakes up with 6 hrs left

I like it.

Who scav? ))

 

[Brandish μ]

Who scav? ))

Nah me I'm the noble

 

[Baka Taichou]

Nah me I'm the noble

Now see, this is exactly wy i.m voting for you....

 

[desin24]

There is still mafia boss or Godfather out here hasn't been lynched. With more role reveal it should be clear which one. Waiting for Copy Panda and Lambu reveal now.

Belserion is the only one I can trust. I know I'm doctor and hinted it mid D2 and no benefit Belserion lied stealing my ability which confirmed me if she is mafia.

Would be a possibility if both of you are mafia she stole someone else's role but this way both of you are "confirmed" Since the female titan is gone any doctor fail can be excused. Ooooor she lied about stealing your role so you don't use it tonight thinking you don't even have it anymore which would be a badass troll move.

 

[BlackTiger]

I am willing to lynch Seraph or Lambu. I trust Belserion and seeing Seraph pushing Belserion like that doesn't sit well with me. There is also something shakky about his claim. Lambu also voted Raven last and wasn't fazed when Raven hinted someone who voted her last would die and trolled when asked about his role.

 

[GrySun]

You guys are not fun tbh.

Seriously neither are you. Tied with sakura and Tiger for most unfunny.

 

[Brandish μ]

Seraph is definitely a votepile candidate.

 

[Baka Taichou]

Seriously neither are you. Tied with sakura and Tiger for most unfunny.

How am I unfunny?

 

[BlackTiger]

Would be a possibility if both of you are mafia she stole someone else's role but this way both of you are "confirmed" Since the female titan is gone any doctor fail can be excused. Ooooor she lied about stealing your role so you don't use it tonight thinking you don't even have it anymore which would be a badass troll move.

You are trying too hard to paint me as scum. I already hinted Doctor role so there is no shakky about my claim being a Doctor. And she has no reason confirmimg me if she is mafia. No benefit she lied stealing my ability.

 

[GrySun]

How am I unfunny?

You not using your active role is the literal definition of sadness.

 

[desin24]

You are trying too hard to paint me as scum. I already hinted Doctor role so there is no shakky about my claim being a Doctor. And she has no reason confirmimg me if she is mafia. No benefit she lied stealing my ability.

I am not trying hard. If did that I would have voted for you yesterday instead of getting the extension. You said there is no reason to believe either you or Bel are mafia and I said there is a chance you both are given our 2 pirate claims.

 

[Brandish μ]

I don't have a read on Belserion either way.

 

[BlackTiger]

I am not trying hard. If did that I would have voted for you yesterday instead of getting the extension. You said there is no reason to believe either you or Bel are mafia and I said there is a chance you both are given our 2 pirate claims.

If she lied and I get lynched as mafia doctor for example, that would out her immediately as my scum mate. Don't think she would risk like that.

 

[Brandish μ]

BT goes from noob to GOAT too much. He's town.

 

[Copy Panda]

Im still on page 100 sth from backreading, but what the fuck Sera XD

 

[GrySun]

So what we have is this fine mess.

Living players(duplicates first, in order of who revealed first to last):

desin24 as Colt - Plain Townie
Demonspeed as Zeke - Plain Townie
Brandish μ as Eren - Plain Townie

Farfalla as Armin - Pirate, didn't steal anything yet
Belserion as Annie - Pirate, stole Doctor from Tiger

Asako as Floch - Kamikaze Bomb, limit N4
Holt as Hange - Time Bomb, limit N4

digitaldude as Magath - Doctor
BlackTiger as Yelena - Doctor

sakura-aneki as Reiner - Prostitute
scav as Connie - Noble
Seraph as Mikasa - Freeman
GrySun as Sasha - Defuser
Shad as Shadis - Apprentice, not learned anything yet
MarmaladeSky as Udo - Spy
goodboy_lawlett as Ms. Tybur - Jesus
Lady pompom as Onyankopon - Spirit Medium
Lambu as Zofia - X
Copy Panda as Falco - X

Dead players:

Raven as Jean (Mafia Robber) (Lover) became a mindless titan on D1
gnut as Willy (Mason Recruiter) died on N1
Evil3ye as Gabi (Serial Killer) (Lover) committed suicide on N1
James Rye as Levy (Spy) lost the duel against the Beast Titan on D2
Vandred as Pieck (Detective) (Super Mason) faded into the Paths on D2
Takuan as Porco (Detective) died on N2

• The 3 plain townies stick out a lot, if anything there should be 2 of them like many other things. Unfortunately we have to live with the fact Brandish could easily be lying regardless if town or mafia and dies something stupid like a Mortician and that clears up the inconsistency.
• Of the unpaired players, Sakura could either be the sole Escort, or a mafia is an Escort to pair with her. Honestly she'd be lynched in any normal game with how weird her posts and votes very often are, but her not knowing what she's doing is just another thing we have to live with.
• Scav is likely Noble, making a semi-pair with Raven's Robber.
• Me as sole Defuser is a bit strange, so I expect a Mafia Defuser as my pair. Though what is my reason for existing? Defusing a town bomb to prevent any more town misplays? At least Mafia Defuser can get rid of a/the town bomb.
• Marmalade as Spy fits with James having been Spy, + it's a role that really won't get you far if you fake-claim it. Though one of them then is/was certainly a Paranoid Spy, bleh.
• Two dead Detectives as a pair.
• Greg's Mason Recruiter doesn't really have a "pair" as it's a unique role, however they did scatter some Super Masons around to fit with him.
• We don't know Panda and Lambu's roles which could perhaps help us sort things out or not. With how good the mafia team seems, would Lambu really be so lazy to not have a claim prepared when literally everyone else does?
• Pompom's sole SM is weird, best pair for it is a Mortician which someone still could be, and even if not it wouldn't be the only pairless role I suppose. Plus it makes sense to have an SM in a game with plenty active roles.
• Lawl's Jesus is also not pairable with anything much.
• Seraph's Freeman at best with some Burden from mafia but why have both a Freeman and a Burden in the game? The strangest thing he's said imo is "someone else is likely to contest this claim".
• Shad's Apprentice is also very weird, he could have a Mafia Apprentice as his duo even though the roles' biggest similarity is the name only. Or he himself is just a Mafia Apprentice.
• The two town bombs are quite the thing... Asako claimed first immediately which imo a mafia would not do. If one of the 2 is lying it's Holt. Honestly not sure if them having the same night limit makes more sense than being different or not.
• Our 2 Pirates are also pretty interesting. Farf has been feeling stressed since after Raven lynch, though iirc she joined the train early-ish. Bel feels like she resigned herself to "here's my role, bye". I can see her mafia self doing this, but maybe it's too risky for a team that looks like they're very well coordinated?
• The Doctors are both weird, and if we're really just up against 1 big mafia + 1 SK(that's even lover-bound to another player) then why would we need two?

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------​

So what does all this mean? Well it depends on your point of view. There are likely 5 scums left if not more. I don't think it's possible to trust all duplicates or to distrust them all, as then nobody can be mafia.

However I think it's very unlikely if not impossible that both duplicates of a role are mafia. Say Bel and Farf both being mafia, or Tiger and DD both being mafia, should be impossible. Contesting each other, while not knowing if a townie has the role to make it 3 of them, is just not a good move.
It is possible for both in a pair to be town, but imo it's only few of them where I'd trust both.

If we look at the unpaired people, Shad's Apprentice and Seraph's Freeman are the weirdest. Seraph didn't even claim to be Super Mason, so the Recruiter could've just erased his role and possibly ruined the balance hosts add to a game by it having a Freeman.

If we look at the paired people, 3 Plain townies + the 2 Pirates are imo the weirdest.

 

[Brandish μ]

Did anyone feel like Marm came in to save Seraph, or that was natural/coincidence?