Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2021] - Discussion and ToC Talk

[Bodoro]

Would this technically make Jojo one of the few WSJ series with a complete anime adaptation? Part 7 did briefly run in WSJ but it was officially considered a new series back then (and I think is still categorised that way on Japanese sites). I think the current full list of series with complete anime is

Kinnikuman (the original series)
Dr Slump
Captain Tsubasa
Stop! Hibari-kun (unsure about this)
Cat's Eye (also unsure)
Kimagure Orange Road (also unsure)
Dragon Ball
Saint Seiya
Ninku
DNA2
Level E
Yugioh
Naruto
Prince of Tennis
Busou Renkin
Death Note
Hatsukou Limited
Bakuman
Ass Class
Food Wars

Less than 20 total from a quick check (unless I missed some old stuff which is very possible) and even then 6 of those series are less than 100 chapters so only 15 or so full length manga. There is some more that'll join the list in the next few years however, like Bleach, Dragon Quest, Shaman King, and maybe even Muhyo and Roji since they teased s3 and it'd only need 4 seasons total.

Saiki is a full adaption too right?

 

[Minsel]

Will TOC come Wednesday more or less. Is One piece on break this week or something? I'm surprised there's no early leaks

 

[Franz]

Is One piece on break this week or something?

It shouldn't be

 

[DreamcastDazia]

Would this technically make Jojo one of the few WSJ series with a complete anime adaptation? Part 7 did briefly run in WSJ but it was officially considered a new series back then (and I think is still categorised that way on Japanese sites). I think the current full list of series with complete anime is

Kinnikuman (the original series)
Dr Slump
Captain Tsubasa
Stop! Hibari-kun (unsure about this)
Cat's Eye (also unsure)
Kimagure Orange Road (also unsure)
Dragon Ball
Saint Seiya
Ninku
DNA2
Level E
Yugioh
Naruto
Prince of Tennis
Busou Renkin
Death Note
Hatsukou Limited
Bakuman
Ass Class
Food Wars

Less than 20 total from a quick check (unless I missed some old stuff which is very possible) and even then 6 of those series are less than 100 chapters so only 15 or so full length manga. There is some more that'll join the list in the next few years however, like Bleach, Dragon Quest, Shaman King, and maybe even Muhyo and Roji since they teased s3 and it'd only need 4 seasons total.

You missed Yu Yu Hakusho and Gintama and saiki and kuroko and I guess you can add Slam Dunk now

 

[tirakai]

I forgot about Kuroko, but Gintama I think still has some net animation upcoming so it's not quite done yet (but will be soon), Saiki I thought had skipped ahead 100 chapters to do the finale, and I've heard Yu yu Hakusho didn't adapt the final arc of the manga or something (never watched it myself).

 

[DreamcastDazia]

I forgot about Kuroko, but Gintama I think still has some net animation upcoming so it's not quite done yet (but will be soon), Saiki I thought had skipped ahead 100 chapters to do the finale, and I've heard Yu yu Hakusho didn't adapt the final arc of the manga or something (never watched it myself).

It did adapt the final arc. I think it skipped some small mini arcs in the manga but its still pretty much complete.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Is only the last 5/6 chapters after the tournament that was skipped but is a whole adaptation of the series (and better than the manga in my opinion...)

Also there was Hoshin Engi, it was a full adaptation right? i know that was criticized, that was rushed AF and etc but still a full adaptation. To Love-ru anime is also a complete adaptation of the manga (of course skipping some chapters)

 

[Lil meen]

So when do spoilers come back out. Also I wonder when the next batch comes, must be around the corner with all of the series ending. Hope the next batch has some incredible manga with all of the massive series that have ended.

 

[TyVip]

Is only the last 5/6 chapters after the tournament that was skipped but is a whole adaptation of the series (and better than the manga in my opinion...)

Also there was Hoshin Engi, it was a full adaptation right? i know that was criticized, that was rushed AF and etc but still a full adaptation. To Love-ru anime is also a complete adaptation of the manga (of course skipping some chapters)

No even with the rushes it is still not a complete adaption

Episode 23 is somewhere around chapter 140~148. Then the final episode starts at chapter 170~174
There is a transitional arc from 150 to 160 that set up to what comes after 174 to 204 (final chapter)

 

[Minsel]

So when do spoilers come back out. Also I wonder when the next batch comes, must be around the corner with all of the series ending. Hope the next batch has some incredible manga with all of the massive series that have ended.

next should be UU and MASHLE's Covers So not till Issue #10

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 12, 2021, Original Post Date: Jan 12, 2021 ---

Coming of age week Q & A I think
All of them are 20 year olds

 

[Mammo]

Saiki I thought had skipped ahead 100 chapters to do the finale

they did another season (Netflix only) after the last arc to cover the arcs they skipped
i think they only skipped a couple of chapters and replace some outta of date stuff (the J-Stars victory VS game tie-in and Jump Festa 2014 stuff) by anime original stuff but overall they didn't skip anything significant
they even did the GIGA epilogue

 

[Minsel]

Shoseki 1/10

My Hero Academia #2
Chainsaw Man #6
Dr. Stone #9
Black Clover #12
JJK #18
MASHLE #43
Yozakura #106

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Full week completed, Agravity Boys and Magu-chan both left the top 500 and Yozakura hold it amazing, keeping in the exact same position, now we wait for the weekly estimations!

Yozakura Family

Vol.1: #40 > #60 > #69 > #114 > #125 > #140 > #251
Vol.2: #47 > #63 > #145 > #57 > #109 > #214 > #260
Vol.3: #41 > #69 > #67 > #86 > #151 > #234 > #234
Vol.4: #16 > #52 > #71 > #114 > #114 > #120 > #149
Vol.5: #43 > #69 > #73 > #83 > #74 > #140 > #249
Vol.6: #22 > #37 > #40 > #75 > #103 > #106 > #106


Agravity Boys

Vol.1: #45 > #82 > #224 > #68 > #153 > #199 > #261
Vol.2: #60 > #92 > #246 > #255 > #138 > #244 > #292
Vol.3: #67 > #104 > #187 > #95 > #142 > #199 > #151
Vol.4: #53 > #94 > #125 > #216 > #360 > #389 > #Out


Magu-chan

Vol.1: #40 > #89 > #96 > #194 > #238 > #209 > #362
Vol.2: #50 > #70 > #140 > #202 > #349 > #473 > #Out


Bokura no Ketsumei

Vol.1: #107 > #161 > #218 > #292 > #Out > #Out > #Out

 

[Thundercat27]

Shoseki 1/10

My Hero Academia #2
Chainsaw Man #6
Dr. Stone #9
Black Clover #12
JJK #18
MASHLE #43
Yozakura #106

Damn, CSM continue to outperform DS and BC. Imagine how big it will become when the anime air?
I guess JJK still have stock issue.

 

[Mammo]

someone scanlated Sand Storm Boarders oneshot if you guys are still interested

MangaDex

Read comics and manga online at MangaDex, with high quality images and support creators and translators!

mangadex.org

 

[Minsel]

someone scanlated Sand Storm Boarders oneshot if you guys are still interested

MangaDex

Read comics and manga online at MangaDex, with high quality images and support creators and translators!

mangadex.org

This guy made Monkey Punch right? I like this oneshot

 

[Mammo]

yup, he made Moneky Punk and Doragagaga

 

[Minsel]

yup, he made Moneky Punk and Doragagaga

He's sure practicing a lot at least. Hope to see him maybe mid-late 2021

 

[perroloco]

Is only the last 5/6 chapters after the tournament that was skipped but is a whole adaptation of the series (and better than the manga in my opinion...)

Also there was Hoshin Engi, it was a full adaptation right? i know that was criticized, that was rushed AF and etc but still a full adaptation. To Love-ru anime is also a complete adaptation of the manga (of course skipping some chapters)

About Hoshin Engi.. No, it's a very weird adaptation, the first episode covers stuff from the entire first volume. Then from episodes like 2-12 they cover volumes 2-11ish (basically where the first anime finished, though the first anime had an original ending and only covered volumes 1-8).

Then they skip like one or two volumes worth of content and arrive to one of the most beloved arcs in the story (basically their plan was to get here fast) episodes 12-24 iirc were good paced, they covered volumes 13-16 or something like that.

But the manga is 23 volumes long and they only covered up to volume 16ish. it's weird because they showed us some of the stuff from the later volumes (when an episode started they you scenes from future chapters, and when I say future chapters I mean future chapters, like no kidding the first episode's first scene is the final battle the anime covers! And then it cuts to the actual first chapter...)

And they did for every episode, I guess they just wanted to show fan favorite scenes that wouldn't get animated (a lot of the scenes they showed in the first couple of seconds of the episodes were scenes of chapters so far ahead that they didn't even get to that part of the story in the anime).

The animation quality was actually quite nice, but the damage had already been done... Imo they should have just started from where the original anime had finished if they were going to do this weird stuff. As one of my favorite manga it hurts.

As for other completed Jump anime:

Also Saint Seiya's anime was cancelled and then, a decade later finished animating its WSJ run via OVAs.

Sexy commando and Ninku should have been completely animated, no? Both were pretty short and had animes.

Shaman king and Dragon Quest Dai no Daiboken (and BLEACH) should be fully adapted now (if not.. what was the point lol)

Captain tsubasa's original wsj run was adapted (it's pretty much the thing hat has been remade to death... 3 times of remaking the same content now instead of actually animating new arcs..)

Hokuto no Ken? Idk? Sounds like something that should have been fully adapted..

Death Note and Bakuman (though iirc they skipped an arc or two... nothing major)

Yu-Gi-Oh! was completed, too.

Prince of Tennis I would actually consider it a complete adaptation too, though it was kind of weird. Some of the matches in the later part of the story were different from the ones in the manga, this was due to the anime catching up to the manga. There was one match in the manga that was not shown, like the team wasn't even shown. I'm pretty sure this was at the request of the anime studio because there was a filler match in the anime for that team (This match doesn't happen at all in the manga).
Then iirc some of the later matches were completely changed because they could not wait for the manga, they even continued the anime for a long time, the merchandise must have been selling great I guess.
Then years later they started adaptating the last parts of the WSJ run in OVAs (IIRC there were like 30), actually Prince of Tennis is probably one of the franchises that has the most OVAs ever, it probably has like 50 by now.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Oh, JJK got 1st place in the total week