Discussion How Oden and the Scabbards cut Kaido

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
Luffy learned how to inflict internal damage with Haki in order to hurt Kaido.

However, Oden actually cut through Kaido's skin (or scales) which should be impenetrable.



As stated by Hiyori, Oden's blade was the only one who ever cut Kaido, despite we knowing that he fought with the likes of Roger, Shanks, etc.

However, the Scabbards also managed the same feat. So apparently cutting his skin may not just be a matter of sheer strength or advanced Haki.

During the fight against Kaido and Big Mom, a lot of emphasis was put on Zoro's sword.

So perhaps the Scabbards also have unusual swords? That would be fitting for their title.
 
Last edited:

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
Luffy learned how to inflict internal damage with Haki in order to hurt Kaido.

However, Oden actually cut through Kaido's skin (or scales) which should be impenetrable.



As stated by Hiyori, Oden's blade was the only one who ever cut Kaido, despite we knowing that he fought with the likes of Roger, Shanks, etc.

However, the Scabbards also managed the same feat. So apparently cutting his skin may not just be a matter of sheer strength or advanced Haki.

During the fight against Kaido and Big Mom, a lot of emphasis was put on Zoro's sword.

So perhaps the Scabbards also have unusual swords? That would be fitting for their title.
But no emphasis was put on their swords.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
There is zero emphasis placed on the scabbard's swords. Ad to that the sheer improbability of all 9 of them having special swords. Specially considering that most of them use 2 swords. by sheer math most of them could at most aspire blades among the 50... Even out of the 12 great swords zoro hogs at least 2 and then you have shusui, nidai and habakiri being unavailable for plot reasons. The most likely scenario is that the scabbards have decent quality blades and... that's it.

Given how enma has been presented I would still make the point that haki is the actual key to cutting kaido rather than blade chikanery. If it was only the blade then any jackass with enma would be able to cut kaido. Add to that by all appearances zoro is learning an advanced form of haki from the blade. AND based on the flashback both enma and habakiri cut kaido.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
But no emphasis was put on their swords.
No it wasn't.

But it has been made somewhat of a mystery how the Scabbards did it:





Kaido asked if they have "Oden's Ryou". At first I thought he was talking about advanced Haki, but that doesn't explain how Zoro can also cut Kaido.
 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
No it wasn't.

But it has been made somewhat of a mystery how the Scabbards did it:





Kaido asked if they have "Oden's Ryou". At first I thought he was talking about advanced Haki, but that seems unlikely since Zoro can also cut Kaido.
I have a theory about how Enma could be helping Zoro use advanced haki through it. I'll just repost it later from the current chapter thread.

If it's not advanced haki, as kkck said, I don't think that many swords can be that special.

I don't really like how Enma has been handled anyway.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Kaido doesn't seem like a reliable source, he simply doesn't understand why someone can or not cut him. Add to that, it makes zero sense that a person would have another person's haki. The most likely scenario is that the scabbard's have a haki skill which enables them to cut kaido... And zoro learned that haki skill, and more, by using enma.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
I have a theory about how Enma could be helping Zoro use advanced haki through it. I'll just repost it later from the current chapter thread.
Kaido doesn't seem like a reliable source, he simply doesn't understand why someone can or not cut him. Add to that, it makes zero sense that a person would have another person's haki. The most likely scenario is that the scabbard's have a haki skill which enables them to cut kaido... And zoro learned that haki skill, and more, by using enma.
But look at my picture explaining why Oden and the others cutting Zoro's skin is fundamentally different from advanced Haki

The latest chapter seems to support that it's something completely different:



After Kaido was hurt so many times, why would this be a surprise?

It's a surprise even for Killer, who also have an ability to inflict internal damage.
 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
But look at my picture explaining why Oden and the others cutting Zoro's skin is fundamentally different from advanced Haki

The latest chapter seems to support that it's something completely different:



After Kaido was hurt so many times, why would this be a surprise?

It's a surprise even for Killer, who also have an ability to inflict internal damage.
Internal damage is one thing and cutting through his scales is another thing, that much we can all agree on.

However, even if it's not internal destruction haki, why can't it just be strong enough advanced haki? Probably emission haki at that. There was this very small flashback when the scabbards were facing Kaido in which they remembered Oden telling them of the imporance of ryou and pressing them to train seriously, which suggests the secret behind cutting Kaido like they did really is just haki.

When Hyogoro explained advanced (emission) haki to Luffy as a way to become stronger, he really talked about it as an art of the samurai.


Of course, everyone's blades must be good to cut through Kaido, but Zoro appears the only one who needs one to improve his haki, turning it into a weird aura, instead of producing it himself normally. I believe that when he masters advanced haki Enma will stop being more special than any other good sword in his hands.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
Internal damage is one thing and cutting through his scales is another thing, that much we can all agree on.

However, even if it's not internal destruction haki, why can't it just be strong enough advanced haki? Probably emission haki at that. There was this very small flashback when the scabbards were facing Kaido in which they remembered Oden telling them of the imporance of ryou and pressing them to train seriously, which suggests the secret behind cutting Kaido like they did really is just haki.

When Hyogoro explained advanced (emission) haki to Luffy as a way to become stronger, he really talked about it as an art of the samurai.


Of course, everyone's blades must be good to cut through Kaido, but Zoro appears the only one who needs one to improve his haki, turning it into a weird aura, instead of producing it himself normally. I believe that when he masters advanced haki Enma will stop being more special than any other good sword in his hands.
But Kaido asked repeatedly how the Scabbards did it. Wouldn't Kaido himself be quite experience in Haki?

And according to Hiyori, only his sword(s) cut Kaido since then, despite him fighting Roger, Whitebeard and others in the past, who should have mastered Haki.

Kaido even said the Scabbards are nothing compared to Oden, yet they could cut him too.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Kaido doesn't seem like a reliable source, he simply doesn't understand why someone can or not cut him. Add to that, it makes zero sense that a person would have another person's haki. The most likely scenario is that the scabbard's have a haki skill which enables them to cut kaido... And zoro learned that haki skill, and more, by using enma.
Zoro seemed to not know advanced Haki when the battle started:



And he attacked Kaido with 3 swords, but there was only a single cut:



Add to that Kaido and Big Mom mentioned his sword several times, it appear to me that it's all about Enma.
 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
Here's a post from the other thread. I'll answer your post right after the "---------------------------------------------------------".

It is true that Zoro should definitely be using more haki on Enma than on the others (unwillingly), and that will probably keep happening until he masters Enma and, afterwards, advanced haki, but Enma draining more haki than intended is not the reason the other blades aren't performing as well as it is.

Wado and Sandai are working as intended: both very strong, but still not enough to cut Kaido despite one of them having the same grade as Enma. Enma doesn't appear like the only blade that can cut Kaido: it is, for now. Zoro has a strong haki with the potential of reaching (and, given the plot, eventually surpass) Oden's, but he does not know how to perform the advanced haki that Oden used on Kaido. Zoro only knows how to use the usual black armament yet, so how is he hurting Kaido and why is Enma reminiscing him of Oden's haki when Zoro channels his haki through it?

The only thing that canonically Enma has been said to do is sucking Zoro's haki and using up more of it than intended in every slash, which makes it hard to control (and Zoro still has not had enough time to master it). That alone would make it a handicap, but it does help Zoro in two ways:

1- If Zoro wants to make an all out attack and sacrifice his "haki pool" for a devastating attack, it's easier to do with Enma. It's close to what he did on chapter 1002.

2- Most importantly, it drains Zoro's haki subconsciously. Zoro has to worry about restraining it rather than focusing on moving his haki to the sword. This means he doesn't accidentaly waste haki anywhere else other than on the sword. That's the basis of Hyogoro's explanation for learning advanced CoA, accodring to what he taught Luffy. Luffy had to learn how to not waste any haki and focus it on a single point before he attacks. Enma is doing that for Zoro by draining it all when Zoro "opens" Enma, thus helping him use advanced haki without him even know he's doing that.

Enma is a powerful tool, yet still serves the purpose of a training tool that will likely shortcut Zoro in the future to get the gist on what is advanced haki and to master it from experience, but he's far from learning it yet. Zoro still has trouble managing the haki output he uses through Enma, and he should tame the sword before learning anything from it, so I really doubt he will become able to use advanced haki on his own in this fight.

Of course, if Zoro uses santouryu right now, Enma is expected to perform better than the other two swords for the reasons I've stated, otherwise my theory falls apart and he'd just be more OP than expected.
My theory is basically that Enma makes Zoro use advanced haki without him still even realizing what exactly is he doing.

---------------------------------------------------------

But Kaido asked repeatedly how the Scabbards did it. Wouldn't Kaido himself be quite experience in Haki?
We assume as much but he may just be "a natural" at using haki. Like some sort of genius that doesn't even understand how it works because he didn't have to work for it.

This if course is just an hypothesis.

And according to Hiyori, only his sword(s) cut Kaido since then, despite him fighting Roger, Whitebeard and others in the past, who should have mastered Haki.
However, Kaido never fought Roger nor Whitebeard again after arriving on Wano. Roger was dead and Whitebeard never dared attack. Even if they damaged him on God Valley and/or before the incident, Hiyori wouldn't know about it, and it was also before he ate the dragon fruit. Oden, and perhaps Shanks, are the only people who may have wounded him after the incident, and he certainly has only one scar currently.

Kaido even said the Scabbards are nothing compared to Oden, yet they could cut him too.
This appears to be just a matter of "haki strength", if that's a thing.

Like, the scabbards know enough about advanced haki to injure him but their injuries appear to be superficial and they don't even seem to be there anymore after a chapter. Oden was just stronger than them. I guess it's like two people using black armament but one of the two breaking the other man's weapon. In this example, both use the same kind of haki level but one of the two is just stronger.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
But look at my picture explaining why Oden and the others cutting Zoro's skin is fundamentally different from advanced Haki

The latest chapter seems to support that it's something completely different:



After Kaido was hurt so many times, why would this be a surprise?

It's a surprise even for Killer, who also have an ability to inflict internal damage.
There could be more versions of advanced haki. It's not necessarily the case that swordsmen and brawlers use internal damage techniques. Add to that, internal damage techniques wouldn't allow zoro to cut kaido. He'd be doing the same as luffy at this point.

Dunno why it is a surprise for kaido after having being cut so many times. But the vast majority of the times he has been cut it definitely wasn't with enma.

Of course, because killer can't cut kaido. He relies on shenanigans to do damage.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

But Kaido asked repeatedly how the Scabbards did it. Wouldn't Kaido himself be quite experience in Haki?

And according to Hiyori, only his sword(s) cut Kaido since then, despite him fighting Roger, Whitebeard and others in the past, who should have mastered Haki.

Kaido even said the Scabbards are nothing compared to Oden, yet they could cut him too.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


Zoro seemed to not know advanced Haki when the battle started:



And he attacked Kaido with 3 swords, but there was only a single cut:



Add to that Kaido and Big Mom mentioned his sword several times, it appear to me that it's all about Enma.
My guess would be that kaido is indeed experienced in haki but there is a good chance he knows less about it than what we'd guess. If he was just a monster from the get go, like big mom was... It's possible he doesn't know all that much about haki and he just uses it instinctively.

Zoro attacked kaido with a tornado worth of cuts and there was only one cut... You'd think if one third of the cuts in the tornado are from enma then there would be more damage to kaido.

It's the haki in the blade that keeps getting mentioned. And still, the scabbards prove beyond reasonable doubt that non enma swords can cut kaido. And the implication in the series is that oden taught the scabbards how to do this.
 

Pirate Queen

Registered User
九千以上だ! / Kyuusen Ijou Da! / It's Over 9000!
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
9,701
Reaction score
17,780
Country
United States
What would One Piece prefer?

Enma is giving Zoro Advanced Haki without training for it?

Or

Residual of Oden's haki or Oden's Imprint was left on the blade assisting in Kaido getting cut?

Either way Wano ends with making whatever is happening with Enma his own power. He'd basically be Mihawk level at that point. There wouldn't be anything left for him to learn besides ways to increase his haki pool
 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
What would One Piece prefer?

Enma is giving Zoro Advanced Haki without training for it?

Or

Residual of Oden's haki or Oden's Imprint was left on the blade assisting in Kaido getting cut?

Either way Wano ends with making whatever is happening with Enma his own power. He'd basically be Mihawk level at that point. There wouldn't be anything left for him to learn besides ways to increase his haki pool
If he masters the power before the arc is over, that isn't clear. Just how much the slash from 1002 tired him is bad news for his current level. Mihawk should be at a level to make slashes like Oden's leisurely and that's still not where Zoro is at, who still hasn't made a slash like that, leisurely or not.
 

Pirate Queen

Registered User
九千以上だ! / Kyuusen Ijou Da! / It's Over 9000!
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
9,701
Reaction score
17,780
Country
United States
If he masters the power before the arc is over, that isn't clear. Just how much the slash from 1002 tired him is bad news for his current level. Mihawk should be at a level to make slashes like Oden's leisurely and that's still not where Zoro is at, who still hasn't made a slash like that, leisurely or not.
I don't think Oda would make Zoro go through an entire arc with a power up and not have him master it after a battle against 2 Yonko.

I don't think its bad news at all that he was put of breath because more than likely he will do it again and this time hit its mark. Even being tired it didn't seem to affect him this chapter. He dodged Big Mom fairly easily so at least his speed was unaffected, and that was with carrying Luffy
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
I don't think its necessarily the case that zoro will have every skill he needs to take on mihawk when he learns this cutting technique from enma. Its a big step but what if mihawk has haki foresight? Or if he has this haki technique AND internal destruction with his blade? There is still plenty of room for zoro to grow.
 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
I don't think Oda would make Zoro go through an entire arc with a power up and not have him master it after a battle against 2 Yonko.

I don't think its bad news at all that he was put of breath because more than likely he will do it again and this time hit its mark. Even being tired it didn't seem to affect him this chapter. He dodged Big Mom fairly easily so at least his speed was unaffected, and that was with carrying Luffy
I don't think neither him or Luffy are "Yonko-level" at all yet. Just the fact that they're outnumbering the two yonkous at that I can't picture any of them beating Kaido in a 1vs1 is enough for me.

We will see how much they grow in the remaining fight but for now I don't think they'll grow enough to change my mind. Damaging a Yonko or making the first steps in that territory is not enough. It's impressive, but not enough.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
It's fairly clear no one there is yonko level. Luffy did manage a barrage but just to kaido's dragon form... Which by all appearances is what kaido uses when he is not really threatened. We have seen since the doflamingo arc that battles of sufficiently high level end up being battles of attrition... And kaido has been presented as absurdly durable even in his base form and has a particularly, perhaps exceptionally, powerful mythical zoan. We know for a fact that zoans are particularly effective for physical combat.. given how the boosts they give the user work. Optimistically luffy at this point is a baby yonko.

Something I've been wondering though... perhaps kaido is taking more damage than he realizes from luffy? The punches definitely hurt but the key thing about them is that they cause internal damage. So... does that mean kaido has been unknowingly accumulating internal damage? I really don't get the impression that kaido, or even big mom, really get the nuances of haki... Kaido has health bars for days but if his lack of understanding of haki is actually a thing then he might have his own rude awakening in regards to having let luffy punch him like that. Luffy would have been chipping away at kaido's health bars far beyond kaido's imagination. Of course, this only works if kaido from the get go was a big mom like monster who simply was THAT much a natural at combat. And thus never picked up the nuances of haki combat. Someone like luffy who picked up on the nuances of haki from numerous teachers, sweat and blood would be more aware of the perils of haki and perhaps at how to counter them. Say, luffy potentially defending from internal damage haki via projecting his own haki at attacks.
 

slavkovski

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
852
Reaction score
523
Gender
Male
Country
Indonesia
But Kaido asked repeatedly how the Scabbards did it. Wouldn't Kaido himself be quite experience in Haki?

And according to Hiyori, only his sword(s) cut Kaido since then, despite him fighting Roger, Whitebeard and others in the past, who should have mastered Haki.

Kaido even said the Scabbards are nothing compared to Oden, yet they could cut him too.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


Zoro seemed to not know advanced Haki when the battle started:



And he attacked Kaido with 3 swords, but there was only a single cut:



Add to that Kaido and Big Mom mentioned his sword several times, it appear to me that it's all about Enma.
About the 3 swords technique that zoro used, does it ever shown that whenever he uses the technique the scar that resulted from that attack are always in 3 places?
Does killer have 3 big scar right now after he fought zorro??
I mean.. I can't really remember and never actually notice about it, but maybe zorro although using 3 swords but he only focusing his attack in one point so the end result are always only in one slash??
 

XXGenesis

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 8, 2011
Messages
3,148
Reaction score
1,900
Age
35
Gender
Male
Country
Turkmenistan
I think cutting or hurting Kaido is about the Lv of Haki you have....or a go around measure like Law’s & Killer, an attack that does internal damage.

I also mentioned Kaido’s surprise or unknown knowledge of Haki which seems weird asf to me. How does a Pirate that has lived so long not know everything there is about Haki???

Ryou in Wano overall means Haki. Similar to Amazon Lilly Amazon’s, Wano Samurai also use CoA to its fullest internal damage aside.

So Kaido was hurt by the barrier Haki of the scabbards, Luffy’s punches & Zoro’s Enma/
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
About the 3 swords technique that zoro used, does it ever shown that whenever he uses the technique the scar that resulted from that attack are always in 3 places?
Does killer have 3 big scar right now after he fought zorro??
I mean.. I can't really remember and never actually notice about it, but maybe zorro although using 3 swords but he only focusing his attack in one point so the end result are always only in one slash??
You can usually see the 3 slashed from Zoro's attack

Example:



It may not be that clear in some cases, but that's not the case when Kaido was attack, there's clearly only a single visible cut
 
Top