Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2021] - Discussion and ToC Talk

[Rain Spectre]

Spoiler: 14 TOC & 15 Preview

ONE PIECE
Jujutsu Kaisen
My Hero Academia
Dr. STONE
Black Clover
Magu
i tell c
Yozakura
Nige Jouzu
Me and Roboco
Undead Unluck
Witch Watch
MASHLE
Kowloon
SAKAMOTO DAYS
Ayakashi Triangle
High School Family
Niraikanai
Maid no Rin-san
BUILD KING
Phantom Seer

15
Cover & LCP: Dr. STONE
CP: SAKAMOTO DAYS Yozakura
Jump Short Frontier: buster sweet

Phantom Seer: Gets reprints for both volumes.

Phantom Seer: Literal bottom of the TOC.

Also, damn, Sakamoto got a new CP already! Good going, Sakamoto-san!

 

[Neala897]

Spoiler: 14 TOC & 15 Preview

ONE PIECE
Jujutsu Kaisen
My Hero Academia
Dr. STONE
Black Clover
Magu
i tell c
Yozakura
Nige Jouzu
Me and Roboco
Undead Unluck
Witch Watch
MASHLE
Kowloon
SAKAMOTO DAYS
Ayakashi Triangle
High School Family
Niraikanai
Maid no Rin-san
BUILD KING
Phantom Seer

15
Cover & LCP: Dr. STONE
CP: SAKAMOTO DAYS Yozakura
Jump Short Frontier: buster sweet

Is this the first raiting for Elusive Samurai?

 

[Jovan]

Is this the first raiting for Elusive Samurai?

Next issue.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

I knew Nak would push Dr.Stone over JJK. Anyways that's 3 Dr.Stone covers already in 2021. I hope Dr.Stone doesn't get new covers until 40s after this

 

[ginsenjou]

Another week with Phantom Seer at the bottom, find it bizarre and unfair that it's still being treated like this.

 

[redon]

Luffy (center), Law (left) and Kid (right) in Jump cover

 

[4Eyes]

Someone needs to pay the therapist for our boy Fukuda. Weird concept but he always delivers well the weird stuff.

Also... Ouch for Phantom Seer. I'm confused with this series placement.

 

[Jorden Rivera]

Wow Sakamoto Days got another color page. I love that series so I’m glad it’s getting a push. Phantom Seer and Build King seem like they’re dead in the water. I won’t count out PS cause its volume sales are decent, but I feel like Build King is on the chopping block.

 

[KiMiTo]

Phantom Seer: Sells out and gets reprints
Nak: Let's put you in the back of the magazine

I'm wondering what is the chance of BK actually doing well in the surveys, but gets PS treatment? We'll have to wait for the sells of V1.

Another CP for Sakamoto Days - Let's gooooo!

 

[Archaon]

Could it be that PS is a case of while people do like it, it not their top choice in weekly survey? Like most people probably" I like this but isn't as much as this other series."

 

[Stivie]

Could it be that PS is a case of while people do like it, it not their top choice in weekly survey? Like most people probably" I like this but isn't as much as this other series."

Even so, the manga is bringing profit to Jump, at least it deserved a CP.

 

[Rheine]

This is a question: is it possible that Phantom Seer is at the bottom because the series above it are by veterans? Does it come into play?

 

[Archaon]

This is a question: is it possible that Phantom Seer is at the bottom because the series above it are by veterans? Does it come into play?

Unlikely, among the series at the top, beside the established series (MHA, OP, JJK, BC) the rest are a mix of newbie and veteran. BK is from a veteran and it dead last.

 

[yadayada]

Not to add insult to injury with how much better treated roboco gets compared to PS relative to its performance, but there was a spam flyer in the KnY artbook (I'd wager fanbook could have it as well but don't have any proof of it) with these in it for WSJ. Nothing about PS.

Spoiler

Not sure what to say about that ToC either, I guess the reward for back-to-back immediate reprints and visible growth is sinking to bottom 1 now.

 

[Neala897]

One wild thing about Ps that maybe its going to be moved somewhere latter and thats a real reason for its place in toc

 

[Ike79]

New vomic today is for Tatsuki Fujimoto's Nayuta of the Prophecy (Yugen no Nayuta), a Jump SQ one-shot from 2015.
Main characters are voiced by Mikako Komatsu (Tsugumi in Nisekoi, Maki in Jujutsu) and Yuma Uchida (Megumi in Jujutsu Kaisen, Kawaki in Boruto). This is the first vomic with popular VAs in it.

 

[Neala897]

New vomic today is for Tatsuki Fujimoto's Nayuta of the Prophecy (Yugen no Nayuta), a Jump SQ one-shot from 2015.
Main characters are voiced by Mikako Komatsu (Tsugumi in Nisekoi) and Yuma Uchida (Megumi in Jujutsu Kaisen). This is the first vomic with popular VAs in it.

Mashie had Natsuki Hanae right?

 

[lgrmjauffre]

Just throwing in my thoughts about the Phantom Seer debacle: low rankings aside, has anyone considered the possibility for no CPs being that the artist himself doesn't have time/doesn't want to do them because of the extra effort?

 

[Rukasu]

Mashie had Natsuki Hanae right?

Mashle didn't get a vomic, just a PV for the new volume

 

[RafGL]

Just throwing in my thoughts about the Phantom Seer debacle: low rankings aside, has anyone considered the possibility for no CPs being that the artist himself doesn't have time/doesn't want to do them because of the extra effort?

Phantom Seer received extra pages not that long ago and Matsura is even publishing illustrations sometimes on his Twitter account. I highly doubt that.