Theory Joy Boy is Momonosuke and Momonosuke is Uranus.

Prxnce

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2020
Messages
265
Reaction score
405
Country
United Kingdom
Understand there is a dedicated Joy Boy thread however the premise of that centers around a different topic. Now my inference is not based so much on hypotheticals but what we learned in segments of the story. I'll add pictures later. I don't usually do theory's but I had time today...

1. Joy Boy left a message to Poseidon on a poneglyph some 900 years ago, apologising for a broken promise to the Merfolk which left them at a detriment. This surrounded the purpose of Noah and the raising of the sunken Fishman Island.

2. The only people with the skill and means to leave that message where members of the Kozuki clan but this would have to at most been about 800 years ago as the method had yet to be invented. Just as we found out Oden inscribed Roger's message on the Bell Tower on Skypia. This suggests Joy Boy lived a long life, that akin to giants.

3. During the Fishman Island arc we learned the nature of Poseidon and its identity. The first mention of 1 of the ancient weapons being a living being contrary to the existence of Pluton which we learned during Water 7 arc was man-made. This was not divested during the Alabasta arc when Crocodile was looking for it.

4. During the Shaboady arc, before we learned Oden sailed with Roger on the final journey, we first learned from Rayleigh that the Roger Pirates could not transcribe the Poneglyphs with him vaguely stating they simply had the 'Voice of all things".

5. Putting the above into context with information recently learned during the Wano arc, Rayleigh was either referring to the addition of Oden to their crew during that journey, the strange power alluded to by the Sea Kings and exhibited by Roger, Luffy and Momosuke or both. I want to stress this has not been clarified despite what a majority of readers have decided.

6. What we can confirm is Joy Boy was either a Kozuki or, travelling with a member(s) of the Kozuki clan or both when he was on Fishman Island. We learned during the Wano arc that the Kozuki clan spread the poneglyphs across the world to retain the integrity its historical record. As for the time the message and poneglyph was left in the Sea Forest the above would fit in context.

7. "When the "appointed time" comes, Joy Boy is expected to appear again" - this is the exert from the manga. Pay attention to the adjective and noun. "Appointed time". Toki facilitated what would be in ordinance, a series of events relevant to the present time line in the One Piece world, coming from a time (806-830 years ago) which is not recorded in the present history "The Void Century".

8. Whatever information Toki possessed, what or whom she was seeking has not been divested. But 'where' was revealed - Wano, her homeland from at least 804 - 830 years ago. 15 years after Shimotsuki Kozabura fled Wano illegally. The reasons why both Toki and Kozabura left Wano remain a mystery.

8. I want to note why the above is important and relevant. When Hiyori first met Zoro, the first thing she noticed was "Wado Ichimonji" which as we recently learned was crafted by Kozabura, the man Zoro learned the expression "Sunacci" from.

9. It was Hiyori who was left behind with Toki after she sent the vanguard forward 20 years in time. Remember we do not know whom nor what Toki was seeking as she kept jumping forward in time, only where. But at least for now we can assume she told someone as it must be explained why Hiyori seemed to recognized Wado Ichimonji.

Do I still have your attention?

10. Appreciate that Zoro was in fact born 20/21 years ago. Let me explain - we do not have a reference as to exactly when time the time skip continued following the 2 year break from sailing, Zoro may not have turned 21 yet as they are still in their first year of commencement following a 2 year hiatus, we only know his birthday is in Novemeber however Oda has not indicated what month we are in in the story. Simply stating - in the story this is still the year all characters would age 2 years from when the story began.

11. We know that Joy Boy is a central figure of the Void Century as declared numerous times throughout the story yet remains shrouded in mystery however what has been uncovered are the prophecies of the Sea Kings.

12. During Roger's final journey with Oden we learned the sea Kings told him the 2 kings would meet again at an appointed time. Rayleigh also told the Strawhats that at the time which they reached Laugh Tale, they where simply too early and Oden detailed an appointed time in the letter left to Toki.

13. Whitebeard also stated that Roger was waiting for someone and assumed Ace was the one to inherit Roger's will. We came to find in the story that this was not the case as alluded to numerous times, Luffy embodies the will of Roger. I think readers need to decide whether Luffy carries Roger's will or Joy Boy's, he cannot be both as they are not.

14. We know from the story that although the Roger Pirates and Oden made it to Laugh Tale, they were not the ones Joy Boy was waiting for as that journey was made 26 years too early, fate had ordained it that Roger would die before the appointed time.

15. We also know that in context to Joy Boy, 26 years ago Poseidon (Shirashoshi) had yet to be (re)born and Joy Boy had not (re)appeared. 6 years after the journey when Kaido and Orochi killed Oden, he revealed to Toki an appointed time of 20 years into the future in his letter, where surely those strong enough to bring down Kaido would be alive.

16. It would coincide with the fact that out materially for the sole reason of wanting at least one heir to survive, it could have been either Hiyori or Momonosuke that was sent forward in time however it ended up being Momonosuke. This wasn't coincidental it was ordained by fate, because Uranus (Momonosuke) and Poseidon (Shirahoshi) are co-exisiting.

17. Wano with its closed borders and Fishman Island sunken to the sea bed has prevented the two kings from meeting again earlier than intended by Joy Boy (who broke his promise to raise Fishman Island with Poseidon).

18. This is because prior to Luffy reaching this point of his journey, those strong enough to oppose the powers that be did not exist as pointed out by Oden. Roger (Luffy), was the man ordained to facilitate this meeting but he was too early 26 years ago so fate prevented him doing so by casting an incurable illness on him.

20. How is it Momonosuke is Joy Boy? Easy, throughout the story it has been alluded that Joy Boy had some form of clairvoyance, this is signaled by the truth of which was discovered by Oden and the Roger Pirates where by reaching Laugh Tale did not only learn the true history of the world, but the future also. Momonosuke has already displayed the same power of clairvoyance on 2 separate occasions.

21. How is it Momonosuke is Uranus? Again, just as Poseidon dominates the wills of the Sea Kings, Momonosuke has shown a dominance over the Land Pullers or whatever noun these Zunesha type creatures were referred with.

22. What's been confirmed is that although the Void Century remains a mystery, the future is(was)/became known to several characters - Joy Boy, Oden, The Roger Pirates and the Sea Kings.

By now you're probably wondering why I just cut-off from the Zoro thing... Is it irrelevant that Kozaburo fled Wano 15 years before Toki jumped into the future?

23. Yes and no. Toki was born born into the Amatsuki dynasty of Wano. A daimyo clan like the Shimotsuki which served the Kozuki clan. At some point she became geographically displaced and could not recognize nor navigate back to her homeland. This is how she was introduced into the story.

24. The only other person(s) known to have left Wano but not yet introduced in the story was the person who fled with Kozaburo. Kozaburo was already implied to in the story by Zoro when he answered Momosuke about the word "Sunnacci". However, in SBS Oda expanded revealing that Kozaburo fled with another person before the events leading to him founding Shimotsuki village.

25. Oda stopped there and said he had not considered those details to be a major plot point for the Wano arc, however he didn't say anything about a leading plot point ot following arc.

26. Seeing as we do not know when Toki left Wano to be unable to navigate back, I have deduced that Kazaburo for one reason or another fled Wano with Toki before she jumped forward in time and ran into Oden 30 years ago. At some point they separated and Toki tried to return home for one reason or another.

27. As well as noticing Wado Ichimonji, Hiyori at a time also took notice of the fact Zoro wielded 3 blades. Her motivation in giving Zoro Enma did not seem to be solely based on the condition of him returning Shisui. Hitetsu later commented on this when he revealed that both Wado Ichimonji and Enma were crafted by the same person and that fact could contribute to why Zoro was able to grasp Enma so quickly.

28. I believe Toki left details to Hiyori surrounding her prophecy which has been improperly interpreted by the people of Wano:

"Like the Moon, you are ignorant of the Dawn. If there is one ardent wish that must be fufilled, it will be when nine shadows are cast woven together through twenty years of moonlit nights. Only then shall you understand the radiance of Dawn"

29. This would explain the presence of a Hiyori/Toki like figure on Onigashima who has healed the "8" scabbards. We know the 9 shadows cannot refer to the 9RS due to how the story has unfolded. Hiyori must understand the true meaning of the prophesy and I believe it pertains to Zoro having both Enma and Wado Ichimonji. Again, this was a plot point hinted to by Oda in SBS, that a new dragon slaying legend would be born in Wano so I am not grasping at straws here.

30. In addition think the words of the Sea Kings are a double entendre. "Two kings will meet again", they foretold multiple meetings. [Dark King Silvers Rayleigh, Pirate King Gol D. Roger], [Ancient Weapon Poseidon, Ancient Weapon Uranus], [Shogun Momonosuke, Mermaid Princess Shirahoshi] and after Chapter 1010 - [Monkey D. Luffy, Roronoa Zoro] - 8 shadows woven together through 20 years of moon lit nights. The 9th being Toki/Hoyori w/Toki's will who has always been present at all points in time up to now.

The appointed time when all the connected pieces are together is now.

 

Hannibal Psyche

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
8,180
Reaction score
9,256
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
JoyBoy can't be Momonosuke.



Oden said he's waiting for JoyBoy to come to Wano... when he was inside Wano with Momonosuke.

Luffy is JoyBoy.

JoyBoy is a title for whomever carries the Will of D which is the person who is destined to defeat the WG and bring about Freedom.

Momonsuke is probably Uranus, he's got similar features to Poseidon which makes it likely.
 

jaymizzo

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Aug 1, 2008
Messages
3,785
Reaction score
2,411
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
JoyBoy can't be Momonosuke.



Oden said he's waiting for JoyBoy to come to Wano... when he was inside Wano with Momonosuke.

Luffy is JoyBoy.

JoyBoy is a title for whomever carries the Will of D which is the person who is destined to defeat the WG and bring about Freedom.

Momonsuke is probably Uranus, he's got similar features to Poseidon which makes it likely.
Damn, Hannibal killing theories before they even mature.

You're right though, everything has pointed to Luffy being Joyboy with Momo facilitating his arrival to Wano and maybe later opening its borders for the final war.

Was it ever stated if Joyboy could control the ancient weapons?
 

McNuss

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 5, 2012
Messages
2,995
Reaction score
2,436
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
No. Forget about it, it is the wrong direction.
 

Hannibal Psyche

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
8,180
Reaction score
9,256
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
Was it ever stated if Joyboy could control the ancient weapons?
Not as far as I'm aware.

What I know for almost certain is that 800 years ago, he had a message written to Fishman Island meaning he was a D and from the Ancient Kingdom.

He tried to bring about peace, but the WG fought against him, and probably killed him.

He was friends with Poseidon, hid Pluton and involved with Uranus.

I don't think he could control Ancient Weapons, but if he had VOAT like Luffy... he could control them with permission from the Ancient Weapons themselves. So, if Shirahoshi told the Sea Kings to listen to Luffy, they would since they can both understand and communicate to the other.
 

Prxnce

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2020
Messages
265
Reaction score
405
Country
United Kingdom
JoyBoy can't be Momonosuke.



Oden said he's waiting for JoyBoy to come to Wano... when he was inside Wano with Momonosuke.

Luffy is JoyBoy.

JoyBoy is a title for whomever carries the Will of D which is the person who is destined to defeat the WG and bring about Freedom.

Momonsuke is probably Uranus, he's got similar features to Poseidon which makes it likely.
This is assuming Oden knew Momonosuke wasn’t Joy Boy or even knows who Joy Boy would be. I didn’t make rebuttal arguments in the OP so here is why I dismissed that panel;

Oden says they must open Wano’s borders before Joy Boy appears again, yet Luffy arrived on Wano long before that has happened. If we are to apply Oden’s statement with impartiality Luffy cannot be Joy Boy as that criteria hasn’t been met yet he is on Wano.

That statement does not rule out Oden’s potential ignorance of Joy Boy’s identity it only confirms his expectations for Wano to receive him. Another reason I believe its Momonosuke is the Chinese story Journey to the West of which Momonosuke’s story takes influence.
 

Rmstorm

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2019
Messages
376
Reaction score
279
Age
30
Country
Phantom Lord
This is assuming Oden knew Momonosuke wasn’t Joy Boy or even knows who Joy Boy would be. I didn’t make rebuttal arguments in the OP so here is why I dismissed that panel;

Oden says they must open Wano’s borders before Joy Boy appears again, yet Luffy arrived on Wano long before that has happened. If we are to apply Oden’s statement with impartiality Luffy cannot be Joy Boy as that criteria hasn’t been met yet he is on Wano.

That statement does not rule out Oden’s potential ignorance of Joy Boy’s identity it only confirms his expectations for Wano to receive him. Another reason I believe its Momonosuke is the Chinese story Journey to the West of which Momonosuke’s story takes influence.
Luffy is 100% Joyboy

Luffy is joyboy, and Wano needs to be opened for when Luffy returns from Laughtale.


Chapter 626, 647, 649, 968 & 972 confirm that.

Oda has also pointed to Luffy being Joyboy


 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It's heavily implied that Luffy is Joyboy.



The Sea Kings indicate that their two "Kings" have not been born yet. One will "be born in a far away sea." (Luffy)

Momonosuke was already born at this time. I think Momonosuke's role is similar to Oden's role; Help prepare the world for whatever Luffy is going to do by opening Wano. The Kozuki Family are certainly tied to the void century and heavily involved in the history of OP, but I think more as heralds than anything.

I imagine void-era Joyboy was likely a ruffian / similar to Roger and Luffy. He probably met with that Mermaid Princess. The world probably wasn't ready for what they wanted to do, and they realized that, so they had a Kozuki Clan member encrypt some information (poneglyphs) to guide the next eras towards their goals.

Other things to consider are Shirley's predictions. We have Noah which the Sea Kings wanted to protect, and the image of the man in the Straw Hat destroying Fishman Island. Shirley basically alluded to the fact that her predictions always come true and that it's not an if, but a when. It's heavily implied something crazy is going to happen on Fishman Island, and that Shirahoshi will end up instructing the Sea Kings to pull Noah to the surface with Luffy.
 

Hannibal Psyche

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
8,180
Reaction score
9,256
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
Oden says they must open Wano’s borders before Joy Boy appears again, yet Luffy arrived on Wano long before that has happened.
Well, it can't be Momonosuke for sure. He was already alive and in Wano.

We know the first JoyBoy was from the Ancient Kingdom, so it follows that the next would also be from the same place.

D is a name given to people from the Ancient Kingdom which is why the prophecy is linked to those with the D name.

Luffy is a far much more sensible candidate with that context in hand

Also, it seems the wording suggests Wano's border must be opened before JoyBoy arrives. Oden's assuming that they need to willingly as a country let people in for that to happen. Logically, that would be the circumstances to let people in.
Luffy's more or less come there through force/luck, but he's been he was called to come. He's in Wano. The reason for going to Wano was for the Poneglyph. The reason for the Poneglyphs is to inform the next JoyBoy on what took place and then he'll decide on how to play things out. Luffy's that person, once he learns he history, he'll take action.

He is the main character afterall.
 

Prxnce

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2020
Messages
265
Reaction score
405
Country
United Kingdom
Ahha 1041 Spoilers got me feeling groovy and this thread and my theory!

We have..

Shirahoshi who can control the Sea Kings
Momonosuke who can control the Land King(s) or whatever name they were given.

Pluton which is man-made supposedly a Warship and A Devil Fruit whose true name was hidden by the World Government and its location and current whereabouts are unknown yet blueprints existed all this time...

Hmm I have a feeling there is a twist about Pluton and what it is, where it was found and who ate-- I mean who has it :3c
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ShadowHeart

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 11, 2010
Messages
6,235
Reaction score
3,062
Age
34
Country
England
Looks like you're wrong.
 

goldb

Strongest Under the Sun
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
27,709
Reaction score
27,506
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Other things to consider are Shirley's predictions. We have Noah which the Sea Kings wanted to protect, and the image of the man in the Straw Hat destroying Fishman Island. Shirley basically alluded to the fact that her predictions always come true and that it's not an if, but a when. It's heavily implied something crazy is going to happen on Fishman Island, and that Shirahoshi will end up instructing the Sea Kings to pull Noah to the surface with Luffy.
I thought about this after the revelations of the most recent chapter and the implications of Joy Boy awakening within Luffy.
Besides the island being redundant after the citizens of Fishman Island have relocated, us not being shown the face of the man in strawhat could indicate that the sinking/burning of the island is Joy Boy's doing and not explicitly Luffy.
 
Top