My thoughts so far
sakura-aneki - Was one of my early suspects, because I missed the first hint. had to revaluate the situation after as it's quite specific for such early hint
Evil3ye - obviously i know my role
Farfalla - neutral. first very vague hint, then bit more concrete. just trying not to fall immediately into my tunnel here again
James Rye - seemed helpful in the beginning, on second thought he just repeated the same things I said just couple posts before about early strategy. hint seemed specific enough fot early hint, so a pass for now
Demonspeed - neutral, vague early hint, but something one can easily be held accountable and lynched for in later phases if he reveals a role that doesn't fit it anymore, so pass
desin24 - his first hint was no real hint, i was on high alert here. the late hint is on same quality as some other people's early hints, could be due to the delay of aligning in mafia pad. very sus for now
Lady pompom - neutral, rather concrete hint as it can be easily looked up but came but later after some talk, not right away.
digitaldude - neutral to bit sus for now, mid-game hint, vague, and passive is more save to claim
Goodboy - said active and excluded some roles with this personal preference thing, but very small post count, bit sus
Gajeel - passive claim is saver but he then later continued discussing coin earning methods and aligning makes me think he's a townie
MarmaladeSky - bit sus, not much to say about her, although the post count is not so low. might be just talking for the sake of talking
Copy Panda - bit sus, low quality late game hint, didn't read the rules properly in the beginning, which seemed ingenuine to me
Holt - didn't really post anthing to discuss, came in late to the discussion, remained at low post count
Tatsumaki - didn't post anything really, like we all have upgrades.... you know
SonOfDaws - didn't post many posts, but what he posted had much more content than the previous two, so neutral for now