Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2021] - Discussion and ToC Talk

[Rukasu]

Rip i tell c, kinda pathetic to think it's ending on this current case

 

[Rain Spectre]

Shockingly low rank for Roboco, being stuck in the middle of a cancellation and two axe fodder. The bottom rank is also pretty indicative Candy Flurry is a goner, and that's not a surprise in the slightest.

 

[KagamiKuroko]

Witch Watch in bottom half again

 

[Ottes]

Candy last already LOL, rip

 

[Cerclox]

Candy at the bottom with just 10 chapters yikes

 

[Thehoennhippo]

Wow, that's it for i tell c huh, a shame, I really liked it. Not a good look for Candy Flurry either, also a shame.

 

[Teennitro]

I'm not surprised with i tell c being axe and candy flurry placing at the very bottom. I think these two have a similar problem interesting idea but boring execution

 

[SharkBait]

Undead Unlock continues to be worrying. Hope it gets an anime announcement soon to save it.

Will not miss Candy Flurry leaving the magazine.

i Tell C is in a weird spot plotwise.

I guess the current antagonist must transition towards the major antagonist, I would have just done that in the mAR arc, brought him back then. Weird.

Guess we get some hastily written ending. Disappointing.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Wow this is a bad placement for Me & Roboco, i don't remember ever seeing the manga this low, not that something is going to happen now but still a bad ranking, UU als still with the low rankings too and no surprise at all that CF is dead last.

Well, i tell c ending makes total sense, i was really confused by the series continuing, but i was expecting Kowloon too, without JJK for a while it will be 19 series, if Kowloon ends next week, 18, so maybe is continuing for some more weeks until the next round or at least until Burn The Witch returns, btw, it did rise a bit this week too.

Ayakashi is rising more, going back to the full ecchi was the best decision Yabuki made.

 

[Teennitro]

Undead Unlock continues to be worrying. Hope it gets an anime announcement soon to save it.

I'm not worried anymore especially when it was on TV recently with mashle it have too much promotion for it to get axe. I do believe undead unluck is not going to be a long series either.

 

[SharkBait]

Wow this is a bad placement for Me & Roboco, i don't remember ever seeing the manga this low, not that something is going to happen now but still a bad ranking, UU als still with the low rankings too and no surprise at all that CF is dead last.

JUMP should just cut Roboco, and focus all energies on High School Family.

Roboco at this point has overstayed its welcome and theres no need to have it as free advertisement for other series anymore.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Forgot to mention, Kokosei Kazoku very high again, i said it before, is probably not in any danger for now, sales don't seem to have much impact for the series

 

[savethecat]

I'm not worried anymore especially when it was on TV recently with mashle it have too much promotion for it to get axe. I do believe undead unluck is not going to be a long series either.

Not saying that it’ll be axed. I’m leaning towards it not being in that much trouble. But I’m pretty sure Jump has axed series that’s had media attention before. iirc this happened with both Robot x Laserbeam and Straighten Up

 

[Ravellino]

Ayakashi is rising more, going back to the full ecchi was the best decision Yabuki made.

Now it's to see if he'll keep it that way

 

[Stivie]

I'm not worried anymore especially when it was on TV recently with mashle it have too much promotion for it to get axe. I do believe undead unluck is not going to be a long series either.

If an anime were a 100% guarantee of success, we wouldn't have anime that doesn't fully adapt a manga.

 

[SharkBait]

If an anime were a 100% guarantee of success, we wouldn't have anime that doesn't fully adapt a manga.

I cant remember any shonen jump series that got an early termination while the anime was airing. An anime announcement would force them to keep the manga around. Like wasn't that why Im From Japan got transferred when it got its anime announcement.

 

[KagamiKuroko]

I cant remember any shonen jump series that got an early termination while the anime was airing. An anime announcement would force them to keep the manga around. Like wasn't that why Im From Japan got transferred when it got its anime announcement.

I don't think Jump is gonna give an anime to UU if its TOC rankings stay low and sales drop again like they did from volume 5 to 6

 

[zjans]

Roboco's sales is much better than Magu and HSF.It's probably going to axe one of this gag mangas .

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

I cant remember any shonen jump series that got an early termination while the anime was airing. An anime announcement would force them to keep the manga around. Like wasn't that why Im From Japan got transferred when it got its anime announcement.

Closest thing i think is Hatsukoi Limited, got just 33 chapters and still had a anime adaptation 1 year after.

 

[PluemBNK48]

Candy flurry
Your next!!!!