Those images are making it hard to copy text from the mechanic
First impression of the Civic Tree is multiple mafia or mafia + third party
I agree with DDs point as well.
I don't think hosts will put roles in the civic tree that are unusable by mafia, so roles like Hider... what would they hide from, probably another night killing party.
Roles like badass coboy or vigilante, will be hard to use for mafia, but balanced if more teams are in the game. But again they are not forced to use them... so maybe it is balanced another way.
Restless Spirit is just weird in mafia's hand.
[PERMANENT] Necromancer - Cultural leadership
The breaker: Random
We may want to send a lot of townies here, since it is random.
Just the threat of sending a lot of people will discourage mafia from trying their luck.
So I claim that I will go here, for now.
(But will do whatever I decide, day just started.)
[PERMANENT] Jesus - Religious leadership
The breaker: Deadpad vote.
This one is easy, which ever team is losing will get a chance to comeback, like in the previous game mechanic with the sign.
@Evil3ye @Hardy @MArGi is this majority vote or similar to how it worked in the Saint Seiya game?
This one can be very strong or very weak, depends on a lot of random factors like: which teams get is, how fast it activates and so on. I didn't do the math but you only became Jesus starting N4 (needs host confirmation). If you get lucky and die with it, you will only comeback 3 days later, only 19 players this game, some killing abilities in the civic, gotta do the math but it doesn't look good.
If you don't die N4, then it probably useless... very confusing for now.
[PERMANENT] Noble - Diplomatic leadership
The breaker : Least amount of votes against them.
This one I will keep my thoughts for myself for now.
[TEMPORARY] Mafia Detective - Science leadership
The breaker: Highest amount of total posts
This one also should probably not discuss in public for now.
Leaving this here just for the format (in case you wanna reuse it for later posts).
[PERMANENT] Vigilante - Military leadership
The breaker: Person who lynched the most.
This is also a comeback mechanic but at the scale of 1 player, if you screw up a lot in your votes and are still alive by D4 go for it, true for mafia more than town, either way nothing we can about it past D4 lynch.