So these are my 2 cents until now~
Cinera:
Unfortunately Cinera might be the unluckiest player, but from what I have noticed besides the very low post count, most of the information he has given in day 1 was mostly irrelevant to the game and he gathered most of the post counts today when he was cornered about his Shad vote. At first he stated that his town reads are Uber and shad then he switched to Mary and Uber but said that he mostly doesn’t have any scum reads yet. Then he connected his reasoning with poms early comment saying that shad was throwing shade at early posters and implying that there are mafia among them. But that argument between pom and shad already ended by the time Cinera made those comments and still pushed his vote in the end on shad although his reasoning was that he didn’t want to lynch Seraph due to laziness ( even though earlier he said that he was busy at work and that he didn’t have time, not that he was lazy to go over the thread)
The thing that I found the most sus, was that first he said that he is going to sleep at around 4 pm his timezone and then at 7 pm he came back and said that he is actually at work. Which was very inconsistent for me.
Plus at 6 am his time today he informed us that he is sleeping at the moment and will only answer if he hears the push notifications and then around 10 pm his time he said that he is getting ready to go to work when the previous day he hinted at a late shift.
Then, most of his posts felt hollow and his reasoning for his vote switch goes wildly against what he firstly announced that he will do - that is following the voting train
Either bad play or scum
Brandish:
Has the smallest post count and she also went with the hint that she had the role before. Tut tut, most of her roles were mafia ahahahahah ( She was even Santa once) and that leaves us, if she is townie with 4 active roles: Bomb diffuser, Investigator, pirate, Bodyguard. If I got her hints right, she is on my trusted list for now, but I am waiting for a confirmation later in the game.
Mishoda:
Reminds me a lot of his last game when he was TP~
His contribution in day one scared me a bit as it reminded me of his SS play from last game. ( Trauma)
But today he is showing a bit more openness and trying to contribute a bit without going full trololo. For now I would add him to a neutral greenish zone as he might actually have a good role, but only his next actions will tell.
James:
James for me is playing on the low side. He reminds me of his last game when he was Santa and was lynched D1. His vote was random which also started a tatsumaki train when scav joined in. Although I can understand his reasoning for going after an inactive player, he was also in the same position as his target. Sussy sus James
Kira:
Kira seemed most sus to me when he asked about third party roles as if he was expecting something. Why would someone ask directly such a question in your first posts, seemed more like a slip up from my point of view.
Also today he played extremely on the low side and he has only one post, nothing more and nothing of substance where he tried to explain his vote switch from pom to mary, saying he didn”t want to be responsible for pompom lynch~
Margi:
I don’t really have a read on Margi, only that she sided with Shad a bit in the shad x pompom arc but she did mention that she wouldn’t focus on it to much as this type of argument ends up in townie x townie fights during her last games. I agree with her on the cinera not making sense part, other than that I have nothing to go on.
Scav:
Well, like I said yesterday, senpai mentioned that he rarely hints in the first days, I didn’t expect him to go for a full reveal. Still the sickly secondary role can be assigned to mafias as well so at the moment that does not confirm him in my eyes ( just like sakura wasn’t confirmed in the last game ) Until we don’t get his main role~
But I do appreciate the reveal.
Tatsu:
Very low in the first day which I didn’t like, also explains all the votes she gathered.
But I understand that she might have been busy as she mentioned, as I also have been pretty busy with work for the past 2 days ( January always sucks) so for now I am putting her in the grey area as there is not much to go on
Asako:
I appreciated the early active hint.
But, still a bit iffy about shads automatic trust in asako and uber when he faced a possible lynch, and what I didn’t like is the fact that she kept switching back and forth between players.
First she voted pom saying that she is sus for wasting her first vote on shad.
Then she mentions that she doesn’t understand why seraph is being voted instead of GB who reminded her of him when he was SS. Then why didn’t she switch to GB and kept her vote on pom at the time and this is also a reason why I mentioned her yesterday in the quatrinity ( shad trying to confirm her last minute saying if he dies she should be trusted along with uber and now her lack of understanding why seraph was being voted ) After that the next day seeing as seraph dies and flipping scum she automatically trusted pom, which she was pinpointing a day before and still throwing a bit of shade at her saying that her senpai might think that pom is a tp.
Today she also takes GB side by asking why scav voted so fast for him even though GB is sick and she was tunneling him a day before.
Mary:
I was a bit iffy due to her laying low and having Gry as her senpai, who is a very active player.
But I do trust what she said about shad changing his vote to pom although pom had already switched from him, because to me that still seemed like a revenge vote. I hope we can see more from her in the next days.
Sam:
I am sad that my revenge vote didn’t lynch him, would be funny though if he would be bomb this game kukukukuku
Leaving all the jokes aside, it feels odd to me that he dismissed the Santa theory so easily in the begining even though pretty much everyone agreed that there might be a tp in the game and that santa might be plausible.
Even though scavs reveal to be sickly also dismantles a possible santa at the moment.
So far, although I hate to admit it, he seems pretty town in my eyes for the moment, although I still don’t understand what type of passive he might be.
Pom:
Seemed very aggressive in her first day, but i can understand where she came from as there were little posts to grasp by and shad started early on pushing for information.
What was a bit sus to me how sure she was that seraph is the mafia when she vote locked him and said “not letting mafia have to many options here” Considering that it was a last minute vote change and seraph wasn’t defending himself. I can understand voting for him as he was laying low but the sureness she expressed was alarming for a D1 vote when most of the votes are pretty random and there were other pretty low posters who were good candidates who also grabbed a lot of votes for a first day lynch like tatsu.
She mostly agrees that the asako shad trust is a bit sus but at the same time she doesn’t seem to have an opinion on others. For now she is in the grey area
Shad:
Recap, still don’t like the trust bond. I don’t like the switch the next day saying that pom is now green because “it is unlikely to throw a strongman like that”. In my senpais opinion, strongman isn’t such an important role considering that it is only useful against bulletproof, so if yesterday there were 2 mafias on the chopping block and scum had to choose between strong man and a better role like detective than ofc strongman would fall and that would also explain why seraph chose to not try to save himself.
I disliked his approach towards Cinera when he said he doesn’t consider him a new player although cinera only has 1 game under the belt. I mean, Cinera is sussy sus, extra sussy sus, but he is still a new player, no reason to be that harsh. Give him a fair read but he also needs a chance to learn.
Shad the way you are hinting you might either be one shot action or traitor trying to get recruited. Which could be highly likely as there were no kills last night, so one way to prove is either by investigation or by your further actions. I stand to be corrected. So shad for me you are in a neutral zone at the moment.
Uber:
Uber for both me and senpai who have not played with him before screams Evil in a good way. Send our kind regards to your senpai~
He is mainly asking the right questions left and right he is also giving good explanations he is not beating around the bush and is pretty calculated. I really hope you are one of the good ones.
Hahaha, you thought this would be a short post
Edit: removed the wild hurr emoji that was inserted randomly and deleted 2 of my words
I won't say you're becoming the new Vandred because Vandred has the special rival place, but at least for this game, you're the vote of choice, Shad!