This sounds too insane and tinfoily right now, and I'm aware of that.
I think the betrayal stuff is worth contemplating, because it's a recurrent theme in One Piece, but I could see it happening on too many fronts, so we'll see how it goes. Perhaps the Straw Hats are meant to break that cycle, or having one of them is too irrealistic, but let me remind people that this doesn't mean it's a definitive change. We've had Nami "betray" the crew very early on, but we later found out her circunstances and she was saved. We had Usopp abandon the crew and fighting Luffy, but he came back.
Betrayal doesn't mean there's no chance for redemption.
One thing I'd like to mention when it comes to this hunch, is how little we know about most of the SHs past. We've had some of their stories told, but an important thing to notice is how most of them were orphans who got taken in by foster parents. Zoro should be a good example of this, considering we've only recently been given hints about his lineage, and that turned out relevant.