- Joined
- Jul 25, 2007
- Messages
- 1,216
- Reaction score
- 7
- Age
- 35
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
Well this week our teacher has been showing us the 3-part movie by Jared Diamond. Im not gonna lie even though I have an A in world History I'd rather mess with girls them pay attention but this documentary has caught my attention. Ill admit it's very interesting how Diamond explains why some civilzations have flourished while others are struggling to catch up. He says geograpic luck is the main reason why some people rose while others are still trying to advance. In the movie his example is the people of Papua New Guinea who are among the most adaptable in the world but are still nothing like other countries today. He also talks about how the conquistatdors were able to conquer the Inca.
What do ya'll think about all this? Are you familiar with Jared Diamond?
What do ya'll think about all this? Are you familiar with Jared Diamond?
I heard Jared Diamond has a book about the collapse of civilizations fittingly titled Collapse (which I'm planning on getting to...eventually.
) I highly recommend this book to anyone, as it's very thought provoking and provides alot of very well thought out and researched ideas on the origins of civilizations, and tries to answer the question "Why did the Spanish come to conquer the Inca instead of the other way around?" As you said the basis of his theory is that the geography of different areas dictated how fast civilizations would spring up. One very small example of his reasoning is that from the beginning Europe had an advantage over America because of it's location, as it allowed for good cultural diffusion and had the benifit of large animals able to be domesticated ("beasts of burden", if you will). On the other side, America didn't have as much cultural diffusion due to it's relative isolation compared to Europe (which sat nicely by Africa and the Middle East, and in a less direct sense Asia) and this lack of contact with other regions didn't allow the passage of diseases and the buildup of immunities. Furthermore, as America evolved without the human species present, the large animals (i.e. Mammoths that could be domesticated were rapidly exterminated with the entrance of Humans. This is because, since they had never seen a human before, they were unprepared to flee or fight, and generally just stood there until they were killed. There's a whole lot more to it then that, that's just a brief little example, and hope that everyone even slightly interested at least tries this book.