Question Heat Fruit > Magma Fruit?

Phaizzy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
764
Reaction score
553
Age
33
Country
United States
Wouldn’t Ovens heat fruit technically have stronger and better potential than magma? Like in theory oven can produce enough heat to knock people around him unconscious. I feel as if Oda gave the big mom pirates some crazy Good dfs and just missed the ball. Genie fruit is another one. Like would the awakening give him 3 wishes? Fun fact.. The Genie Df is the only df who basically is another entity.
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Hard to say. I feel like a good Mera Mera no Mi user could be stronger than a Magu Magu no Mi user, since fire has the potential to burn hotter than magma.

The heat fruit is interesting in that we don't know much about it, but similar to Aokiji, he can activate it while partially submerged. Hard to say without the limitations clearly defined. For instance, Machvise's fruit is superior to Miss Valentine's.
 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
Hard to say. I feel like a good Mera Mera no Mi user could be stronger than a Magu Magu no Mi user, since fire has the potential to burn hotter than magma.

The heat fruit is interesting in that we don't know much about it, but similar to Aokiji, he can activate it while partially submerged. Hard to say without the limitations clearly defined. For instance, Machvise's fruit is superior to Miss Valentine's.
Ace was a very good DF user, though.

Agreed on the second paragraph.
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Ace was a very good DF user, though.

Agreed on the second paragraph.
Maybe good is the wrong word. I suspect Ace probably hadn't drawn out the full potential of the ability since he was only 20, and had barely had time to master that ability. He got his ability at age 17, and died at 20. So compared to characters like Luffy, Law, Kaido, etc... he had much less time to "master" his fruit beyond utilizing it in combat (awakening), where Luffy had his ability since before he even met Ace and Sabo, IIRC, and Law got his as a child as well. Same with Doflamingo (I believe he was given it as a child by Trebol?).

So I suspect he probably is an adept user, but whatever Kaido mentioned about the mind and body catching up with the ability probably was something that hadn't happened for Ace specifically. I'm mostly basing this off the fact that fire's temperature range is about 600C - 1700C, whereas magma ranges from 700C-1400C. So I think if he'd unlocked his ability fully he'd likely not have been "burned" by Akainu. I still think it's weird that Ace was able to get burned in general, but I don't make the rules.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
Maybe good is the wrong word. I suspect Ace probably hadn't drawn out the full potential of the ability since he was only 20, and had barely had time to master that ability. He got his ability at age 17, and died at 20. So compared to characters like Luffy, Law, Kaido, etc... he had much less time to "master" his fruit beyond utilizing it in combat (awakening), where Luffy had his ability since before he even met Ace and Sabo, IIRC, and Law got his as a child as well. Same with Doflamingo (I believe he was given it as a child by Trebol?).

So I suspect he probably is an adept user, but whatever Kaido mentioned about the mind and body catching up with the ability probably was something that hadn't happened for Ace specifically. I'm mostly basing this off the fact that fire's temperature range is about 600C - 1700C, whereas magma ranges from 700C-1400C. So I think if he'd unlocked his ability fully he'd likely not have been "burned" by Akainu. I still think it's weird that Ace was able to get burned in general, but I don't make the rules.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
At the time they didn't mention it like this, but I'm pretty sure Ace was burned simple because Akainu was a better haki user. Since that's what it takes to damage a fellow logia.

Regarding the temperatures, we don't know if the mera mera could possibly reach the maximum temperature of fire in real life. Just like the two "weight" fruits have totally random limitations that make both fruits different despite revolving around the exact same ability, the mera mera may have a temperature limit.

Wasn't the talk about the mind and body catching up regarding how to reach awakening? We don't know much about awakened logias.
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
At the time they didn't mention it like this, but I'm pretty sure Ace was burned simple because Akainu was a better haki user. Since that's what it takes to damage a fellow logia.

Regarding the temperatures, we don't know if the mera mera could possibly reach the maximum temperature of fire in real life. Just like the two "weight" fruits have totally random limitations that make both fruits different despite revolving around the exact same ability, the mera mera may have a temperature limit.

Wasn't the talk about the mind and body catching up regarding how to reach awakening? We don't know much about awakened logias.
Akainu was pretty specific in using the hierarchy of Magma vs Fire. Could be haki related, but it's hard to say back then. These were the days not too far off from when Smoker somehow stalemated Ace.

With those weight fruits I think their names actually make sense in them having caps. One is the Kiro Kiro, and the other is the Ton Ton. No telling if the mera mera user can get up to those temperatures, but in this case fire is a thing, whereas weight is a property. I'd assume becoming the thing, in this case, fire, would give you most of fire's properties. Kinda like we're all humans, and humans can technically lift 1000 lbs via a dead lift, but it's an ability only a few humans can do. So maybe the right user can unlock extreme temperatures in the Mera Mera no Mi? Two ways the ability could increase in potential and that's area covered or heat generated.

On your third point yes it was. I'm mostly saying there, anecdotally, that I'd be surprised if Ace could use his ability to the extent that existing awakened users do. He's a good mix of fighting and mixing his fire abilities in, but then we have people like Kaido who was literally able to replicate Luffy's snake-man attacks to an extend using his head as a projectile, and Doflamingo who can create an entire marionette and sew his insides back together to prevent life-threatening damage.

I kind of assume that Aokiji / Akainu are an example of awakened logia, since they changed the entire climate of Punk Hazard. Could just be that the extreme differences brought in some weird ice ages / heat age but influencing a whole climate is a pretty big deal.
 

Nie Li

Marine Hunter
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jul 24, 2016
Messages
6,207
Reaction score
8,760
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
Akainu was pretty specific in using the hierarchy of Magma vs Fire. Could be haki related, but it's hard to say back then. These were the days not too far off from when Smoker somehow stalemated Ace.

With those weight fruits I think their names actually make sense in them having caps. One is the Kiro Kiro, and the other is the Ton Ton. No telling if the mera mera user can get up to those temperatures, but in this case fire is a thing, whereas weight is a property. I'd assume becoming the thing, in this case, fire, would give you most of fire's properties. Kinda like we're all humans, and humans can technically lift 1000 lbs via a dead lift, but it's an ability only a few humans can do. So maybe the right user can unlock extreme temperatures in the Mera Mera no Mi? Two ways the ability could increase in potential and that's area covered or heat generated.

On your third point yes it was. I'm mostly saying there, anecdotally, that I'd be surprised if Ace could use his ability to the extent that existing awakened users do. He's a good mix of fighting and mixing his fire abilities in, but then we have people like Kaido who was literally able to replicate Luffy's snake-man attacks to an extend using his head as a projectile, and Doflamingo who can create an entire marionette and sew his insides back together to prevent life-threatening damage.

I kind of assume that Aokiji / Akainu are an example of awakened logia, since they changed the entire climate of Punk Hazard. Could just be that the extreme differences brought in some weird ice ages / heat age but influencing a whole climate is a pretty big deal.
You can indeed argue that the name of ton ton implies it gets heavier than the kiro kiro no mi, and that it's a property instead of a thing, but the names are just tags people attribute to the power, not the other way around. They're both fruits that allow the user to freely alter his own weight, but they're limited differently: the ton ton can get the user to become heavier than the kiro kiro can, but the ton ton didn't show the ability to make the user lighter (unlike the kiro kiro). Same power, but very different upper and lower limits to it. Transforming into fire may also have well-defined limits that make it so only normal yellowish fire can be generated.

I'm not saying it must have such a limitation, but I believe it's equally likely that it does. Ace had the fruit for little time but he was some kind of super genius. Luffy has evolved the gomu gomu much farther in much less time as a pirate (he had the fruit for years but he didn't start thinking on how to evolve his abilities until he had his ass handed to him on the adventure).

Regarding Aokiji and Akainu... Most logia users have shown the ability to affect the climate passively, right? Even Ace. Punk Hazard's transformation is impressive but it's also the only example we have of two strong haki-logia users duking it out for three days straight. Even Crocodile, with no haki, using his powers in an intense fight for three days would turn an island into a desert (through drying the floor). I'd say Aokiji's half of the island is the most impressive since Akainu may just created natural volcanoes on the floor that simply remained there, but there's no natural way to explain Aokiji's part remaining ice-cold close to a volcano area for years.



Regarding the original topic, the Heat Heat fruit probably has the same kind of limitations as the kilo kilo and such paramecias. He can't just reach supernova temperature and destroy the Earth.
 

Core D. Roy

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
7,363
Reaction score
9,272
Age
37
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
The heat fruit is interesting in that we don't know much about it, but similar to Aokiji, he can activate it while partially submerged. Hard to say without the limitations clearly defined. For instance, Machvise's fruit is superior to Miss Valentine's.
Unless the water itself is a weakness, like with Crocodile, there's nothing stopping any DF user from using their ability with their hands submerged. Luffy did the same thing underwater while in a bubble during Fishman Island.
 

Phaizzy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
764
Reaction score
553
Age
33
Country
United States
Unless the water itself is a weakness, like with Crocodile, there's nothing stopping any DF user from using their ability with their hands submerged. Luffy did the same thing underwater while in a bubble during Fishman Island.
If I’m correct. Luffy got weak the initial time he did redhawk. But Oven is different as his heat is so hot that he melts the ground. This already puts his fruit hotter than Ace as Ace using his fruit was never shown melting things. Akainu IS magma so he isn’t producing heat but making it. Oven is producing heat and can actually materialize his heat. He can heat up a big portion of the water around whole cake island. By this logic his heat is already hot as magma. I’d argue that aside from haki. Fruit for Fruit Oven has more potential. How old is oven even? Is he the same age as the admirals?

I said this once and I’ll say it again. none of the sweet commanders deserve their spot except katakuri and oven needs to be promoted.
Oven imo is what saved the villain side because if you get rid of oven, big mom pirates wouldn’t have even been close to getting rid of the straw hats. Oven was always that strong thorn in ya side.
 

Core D. Roy

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
7,363
Reaction score
9,272
Age
37
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
There's different advantages/disadvantages when comparing how Fire/Magma/Heat all interact with water, we actually have no idea how hot they are relative to each other, though. Only that Magma is nebulously "stronger" than Fire. Heat boils water, Fire creates a steam/smokescreen, and Magma can straight up create new land.

Oven's fruit is crazy powerful, and he's one of the many Big Mom Pirates that proved her crew is vastly more competent than the Beasts Pirates. Shame he couldn't even kill Pound tho. Oh and he's the same age as Katakuri- they're triplets with Daifuku.

Akainu IS magma so he isn’t producing heat but making it. Oven is producing heat and can actually materialize his heat.
I kinda get what you're trying to say but that's a terrible way of wording it lol. A more clear description would be that heat is a byproduct of Akainu's DF, when it's the central aspect of Oven's DF. I'm not sure what's the point of that distinction though, it's not like we know whether or not the Heat fruit can get hotter than the Magma fruit.
 

Phaizzy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
764
Reaction score
553
Age
33
Country
United States
There's different advantages/disadvantages when comparing how Fire/Magma/Heat all interact with water, we actually have no idea how hot they are relative to each other, though. Only that Magma is nebulously "stronger" than Fire. Heat boils water, Fire creates a steam/smokescreen, and Magma can straight up create new land.

Oven's fruit is crazy powerful, and he's one of the many Big Mom Pirates that proved her crew is vastly more competent than the Beasts Pirates. Shame he couldn't even kill Pound tho. Oh and he's the same age as Katakuri- they're triplets with Daifuku.



I kinda get what you're trying to say but that's a terrible way of wording it lol. A more clear description would be that heat is a byproduct of Akainu's DF, when it's the central aspect of Oven's DF. I'm not sure what's the point of that distinction though, it's not like we know whether or not the Heat fruit can get hotter than the Magma fruit.
By what we seen his fruit is as hot as magma if not hotter. We seen Akainu magma hit the water and not really boil it. We seen oven walk and melts the ground producing molten rock. That’s the same templates volcanoes are at to heat up the earth. We also seen him BOIL the ocean with just his hand. They had to swim real deep to get out of the heat.
 

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,800
Reaction score
61,534
Gender
Male
Country
France
They have similar abilities and Logia > Paramecia in general so I doubt the Heat fruit is better. The Magma fruit was even portrayed as superior to the Mera Mera and both are Logias.
 

Phaizzy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
764
Reaction score
553
Age
33
Country
United States
They have similar abilities and Logia > Paramecia in general so I doubt the Heat fruit is better. The Magma fruit was even portrayed as superior to the Mera Mera and both are Logias.
So let me ask you.. just for fun sakes of course lol. If you had the chance to have any of those fruits. Meta, Magma, or Fire? What would you choose? And for argument sake let’s say oven can phase into heat. (Making all the fruit the same type) would you take magma over heat or fire? I always felt that Magma wasn’t more so a unique fruit or take much imagination to use. It’s simply a deadly df. I think my imagation would allow me to do way more things with Heat than Magma
 

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,800
Reaction score
61,534
Gender
Male
Country
France
So let me ask you.. just for fun sakes of course lol. If you had the chance to have any of those fruits. Meta, Magma, or Fire? What would you choose? And for argument sake let’s say oven can phase into heat. (Making all the fruit the same type) would you take magma over heat or fire? I always felt that Magma wasn’t more so a unique fruit or take much imagination to use. It’s simply a deadly df. I think my imagation would allow me to do way more things with Heat than Magma
Mera Mera because it's cooler.
 

Phaizzy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
764
Reaction score
553
Age
33
Country
United States
Mera Mera because it's cooler.
That’s fair. I find it hard to like fire style magics/abilities to be likable because they are all so generic. Then again Mereoleona is my favorite. But fair enough.
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Unless the water itself is a weakness, like with Crocodile, there's nothing stopping any DF user from using their ability with their hands submerged. Luffy did the same thing underwater while in a bubble during Fishman Island.
Yeah, I guess the difference is they affect the temperature of water which is one of the more obvious ways to show off. Luffy can stretch and sure he's moving water around when he does it, but Aokiji changing the physical state of an entire sea or Oven launching those heat waves in the water were pretty insane. Makes me wonder if Whitebeard would of been able to create earthquakes while submerged, or why can't Big Mom create a Homie to rescue herself when she's submerged?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

They have similar abilities and Logia > Paramecia in general so I doubt the Heat fruit is better. The Magma fruit was even portrayed as superior to the Mera Mera and both are Logias.
Dunno man. Most of the super BS abilities we see are paramecia.

Paw Paw (Kuma)
Hobi Hobi (sugar)
Gura Gura (Whitebeard/Blackbeard)
Doku Doku (Magellan)
Bari Bari (Bartomoleo)
Soru Soru (Big Mom)
Mochi Mochi (Katakuri)
Buku Buku (Mont D'or)
Zushi Zushi (Fujitora)

I think a few Logia are really powerful, but I think for the most part the versatility of Paramecia seem superior once you take haki and Logia losing their tangibility away into account.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,439
Reaction score
25,013
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Within the internal logic of OP magma is in fact hotter than fire. In real life this is quite wrong of course but given how oda has handled the abilities in question I think any argument in regards to this should be based on the fact that magma in OP is hotter than fire.

The vivre card stuff also makes the point that the magma fruit has the highest offensive power among devil fruits.

Based on the capabilities we have seen from each fruit:

- Oven made a boiling ocean.
- Akainu farted away an iceberg in a second.
- Akainu burned ace, who was made out of fire.
- Oven was able to make an enemy's blade so hot he had to drop it.

So to me that looks like in terms of sheer heat akainu is unmatched. And it's not even close. In terms of practical combat I think it'd be safe to say that ace or oven would fare better resisting akainu's attacks than people without heat related abilities at least. Which speaks volumes of what akainu did to ace. Maybe a heat man is entirely immune to heat based attacks? Though even in this insanely convenient scenario oven would still be quite vulnerable to the sheer force behind akainu's attacks. Though it'd be like he is fighting a mud mountain...
 

Phaizzy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2020
Messages
764
Reaction score
553
Age
33
Country
United States
Within the internal logic of OP magma is in fact hotter than fire. In real life this is quite wrong of course but given how oda has handled the abilities in question I think any argument in regards to this should be based on the fact that magma in OP is hotter than fire.

The vivre card stuff also makes the point that the magma fruit has the highest offensive power among devil fruits.

Based on the capabilities we have seen from each fruit:

- Oven made a boiling ocean.
- Akainu farted away an iceberg in a second.
- Akainu burned ace, who was made out of fire.
- Oven was able to make an enemy's blade so hot he had to drop it.

So to me that looks like in terms of sheer heat akainu is unmatched. And it's not even close. In terms of practical combat I think it'd be safe to say that ace or oven would fare better resisting akainu's attacks than people without heat related abilities at least. Which speaks volumes of what akainu did to ace. Maybe a heat man is entirely immune to heat based attacks? Though even in this insanely convenient scenario oven would still be quite vulnerable to the sheer force behind akainu's attacks. Though it'd be like he is fighting a mud mountain...
Hmm I see I see. Well that makes sense. I think it’s time they give logias some love.
 

Sachsenhesse

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
May 28, 2008
Messages
2,843
Reaction score
3,669
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Dont just get yourself worked up on heat. Magma is a mixture of fire and earth in most rpgs, or even mangas. So that means Akainu is superior to mera mera and a possibke earth earth fruit.

Same with Aokiji And Snow+Water/Wind probably.

Enel with Fire/Wind.

But thats just my grandiabrain talking.
 
Top