Short player evaluation mid D2:
not that sus
Faust - first day was fairly suspicious by being the first to stack a vote on somebody. Lucky for him the player flipped mafia. Althought his vote was not decisive in the end he benefitted from the host miscount in the end and today was a bit weird by saying false stuff like it being a hostkill I am willing to turn a blind eye here for now.
James Rye - first to fully reveal the domain yesterday made an impression to me, don't see how that would benefit a mafia other than gaining creditability but risking to jeopardize some strategies later (I mean not impossible) but it worked on me so far, so am happily giving a pass here as well for now.
Asako - fairly busy yesterday so wasn't that much input but I felt like the posts were provising enough information about oneself to contribute, made some comments on the domain and claimed active D1, also fairly creditabile.
neutral sus
MarmaladeSky - I don't really know about her playstyle, it's very much different than how I usually play, being not that offensive and for what it seems to me often being neutral, so I have a hard time to trust her. But have to evalute the hard facts here, she gave a role hint day 1 about being active, so enough to also put in fairly creditabile rating for now. Her only flaw was to vote James yesterday, which I don't really get (because as aforementioned he's an angel in my eyes), so neutral here, dunno am I too harsh?
Gajeel - He was almost killed yesterday, but then was saved by a vote change from Brando. I kind of have hard time believing that mafia would let two of their guys being in top three voted for most of the day. That's the only reason I would not rank him more suspicious but rather neutral, as I didn't feel there was some genuine intend to contribute and discuss anything other than domains.
Crescent Jinx - I don't really play often with Jinx so it's hard to tell or my memory is not so well to see some nuances in how she plays in different alignments. I feel like she is being her usual fun/entertain
neutral bit sus
Belserion - she said she wouldn't be sharing a lot in the beginning and that felt like a reasonable thing to me because I wanted to change it up a little myself, but then I felt like that's how she usually plays anyways, so not sure what that broadcasting it was about. Saw she was more active in todays discussion so might again be a late bloomer, but I will have my eyes on her a little.
GrySun - perhaps game bias that I can never fully trust him from some past experiences or just that I hate losing to him, but this game I feel like he's more passive and not as discussion driven. People do change play styles, I know, but he didn't anything to not be suspicious either, so stays here for now.
gnut - pretty much same as above.
bit sus
Brandish μ - the two Aussies were the decision driving forces yesterday and we all saw the results. I'm also a little bit extra careful with cute guys that give me compliments for seemingly no reason (I don't know who hurt me :xP) so bit sus.
SirSamuel016 - Sam is the person I would probably vote for today based on what has happened so far. If someone doesn't make a case for someone else in favour of him, I will read that out but from what I read so far I don't mind lynching Sam at all. The reasons been said before, day 1 voting seemed like he was protecting GB - the voting post wasn't really making it clear why other than a gut feeling he would want to kill Gajeel instead of the two other. Today's exchange with farfalla was something I want to reread as well. It seemed she was going to comment on something she picked up on him just before dying, and inconsitancy in the claims, will have to do some backreading here as I didn't get to it yet.
Might be tunnel visioning, so won't vote right away and read some more input from everyone before making a final decision.
