Question Heat Fruit > Magma Fruit?

baditz

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2015
Messages
2,440
Reaction score
1,352
Gender
Male
Country
Indonesia
Its does't matter if it stronger fruit or not, all back to user, Oda most of time wasted a good df to suck user, just like Foxy, Orochi, n goes on,,
 

wing_gundam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2007
Messages
1,298
Reaction score
892
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Maybe good is the wrong word. I suspect Ace probably hadn't drawn out the full potential of the ability since he was only 20, and had barely had time to master that ability. He got his ability at age 17, and died at 20. So compared to characters like Luffy, Law, Kaido, etc... he had much less time to "master" his fruit beyond utilizing it in combat (awakening), where Luffy had his ability since before he even met Ace and Sabo, IIRC, and Law got his as a child as well. Same with Doflamingo (I believe he was given it as a child by Trebol?).

So I suspect he probably is an adept user, but whatever Kaido mentioned about the mind and body catching up with the ability probably was something that hadn't happened for Ace specifically. I'm mostly basing this off the fact that fire's temperature range is about 600C - 1700C, whereas magma ranges from 700C-1400C. So I think if he'd unlocked his ability fully he'd likely not have been "burned" by Akainu. I still think it's weird that Ace was able to get burned in general, but I don't make the rules.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Luffy was basically 7 when he ate the fruit and left on his adventure at 17 and mastered what? gomu gomu no pistol? However in the 2 years (say 2.5) since this all began he's gone from that to awakening. So mastering your fruit really only takes 2-3 years (or maybe a bit longer if you're lazy - Luffy obviously being the biggest exception and really the only character ever to actually 'train'/grow his DF powers).

We all know that Ace died not because of his fruit being 'weaker' but for plot reasons only. All DFs and haki are complete ass-pulls anyway. Oda can clearly make up whatever he wants to tell his story.
--- Double Post Merged, ---

Dont just get yourself worked up on heat. Magma is a mixture of fire and earth in most rpgs, or even mangas. So that means Akainu is superior to mera mera and a possibke earth earth fruit.

Same with Aokiji And Snow+Water/Wind probably.

Enel with Fire/Wind.

But thats just my grandiabrain talking.
I didn't initially think of it that way but that's true - magma is often a second tier power when you combine fire + earth / deviant power in TBATE too. If you go by that powerscaling it should be more powerful.

Then again I've seen manga where fire is the single greatest power of all (demon slayer), and I've seen one where wind was unstoppable (tokyo underground).

In the end the author can still come up with whatever they want to advance the plot. (Moria could have been just as powerful if not more than Big Mom for example as they have very similar powers).
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Luffy was basically 7 when he ate the fruit and left on his adventure at 17 and mastered what? gomu gomu no pistol? However in the 2 years (say 2.5) since this all began he's gone from that to awakening. So mastering your fruit really only takes 2-3 years (or maybe a bit longer if you're lazy - Luffy obviously being the biggest exception and really the only character ever to actually 'train'/grow his DF powers).
He had a wide range of attacks he used in East Blue. Obviously he's going to advance faster when he starts getting stacked against more challenging opponents, but my point is that if you recall his past, he did fail at "Gomu Gomu no Pistol" for quite a while. He went from not even being able to throw one, to being able to battle his way through all East Blue without finding much challenge. It took finding Crocodile to really push him from there.
 

wing_gundam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2007
Messages
1,298
Reaction score
892
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
He had a wide range of attacks he used in East Blue. Obviously he's going to advance faster when he starts getting stacked against more challenging opponents, but my point is that if you recall his past, he did fail at "Gomu Gomu no Pistol" for quite a while. He went from not even being able to throw one, to being able to battle his way through all East Blue without finding much challenge. It took finding Crocodile to really push him from there.
Yes and I think you've proved my point. It took him years to master his most basic attack but once the manga started he learned fairly quickly getting through the "flexibility" of his fruit.

I think it's an age/maturity thing rather than time of exposure. Think about Momo too. He's had his fruit for 6 months? and he had zero control over it as an 8 year old but when he was 'matured' to 28 he figured out how to fly, fly with someone on his back, and "sort of figure out how to use flame clouds".

Doffy and Law were far more 'mature' kids than Luffy though. I think if Sabo or Ace at the gomu hito /nika fruit they would have probably developed faster than Luffy.

However once Luffy left, he certainly mastered it quickly.

I think Ace basically mastered his fruit by his death.
 
Top