Theory The WG Was a Pirate Crew Originally

Australopithecus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2013
Messages
1,274
Reaction score
1,509
Gender
Male
Country
Akatsuki
There are so many mysteries revolving around the world government and their' past,' and it seems One Piece holds the answer to that. But what is that past whose knowledge alone suffices to cause the faith of people worldwide to crumble? One possibility is that the world government was originally a pirate crew in the past.

First off, the world government's flag resembles a pirate flag. The usual thing is to find a pirate flag with a skull and crossed bones. The WG's flag, however, strays from this in two ways.
First, there is no skull. Second, one of the crossed lines of the WG's flag is vertical, and the other is horizontal, whereas pirates' flags have diagonally crossed bones. It turned out, however, that it doesn't stray from this, given that Whitebeard's pirate flag is composed of crossed vertical and horizontal crossed bones.
As to the lack of the skull, it wouldn't be the first time we would see that. We have already seen the sun pirates having nothing but a sun symbol as their flag. Some pirate flags lacked both. To strengthen the similarity to a pirate flag, I tilted the WG's flag a little bit, and its novel appearance does look like a pirate flag.


Pirates have already tried to rule the world before, as evidenced by Rocks' past. Rocks was ambitious to become the king of the world. That is exactly what IMU is. If we entertain the possibility that a pirate crew succeeded in ruling over the world, we will get precisely where the WG is right now. We have already seen how pirates put kingdoms under their territories, as was shown when WB and, later on, BM had FI as their turf.

If the WG is indeed a pirate crew originally, then it would make sense that they will be afraid to have their past divulged to the world.

I have other things from the manga that would fit nicely with this possibility, but I am too lazy, so I'll stop here, lol. Lemme know what you think.
 

electricmastro

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 26, 2020
Messages
4,796
Reaction score
3,645
Age
30
Country
United States
I only recently had the thought as to why exactly I should feel obligated to deem pirates and the Marines as always having been completely different from each other, and not just because some characters say they’re always on different sides.

When I got to looking at the structure of Kaido’s crew, his structure actually seemed a little similar to the Marines, with the Flying Six being like Vice Admirals, the three All-Stars being like the three Admirals, the Kaido the Governor-General being like the Fleet Admiral. The Marines even conduct raids, genocides, and dealings with other pirates when they deem it necessary, using ships with their own symbols on them.

Really though, I think the biggest difference I could honestly find between the Marines and pirates is that the Marines have the support of the civilians and royalty of the world, while the pirates don’t. If the Marines didn’t have the support of the civilians and royalty, then they prob would function just like pirates after all.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
I only recently had the thought as to why exactly I should feel obligated to deem pirates and the Marines as always having been completely different from each other, and not just because some characters say they’re always on different sides.

When I got to looking at the structure of Kaido’s crew, his structure actually seemed a little similar to the Marines, with the Flying Six being like Vice Admirals, the three All-Stars being like the three Admirals, the Kaido the Governor-General being like the Fleet Admiral. The Marines even conduct raids, genocides, and dealings with other pirates when they deem it necessary, using ships with their own symbols on them.

Really though, I think the biggest difference I could honestly find between the Marines and pirates is that the Marines have the support of the civilians and royalty of the world, while the pirates don’t. If the Marines didn’t have the support of the civilians and royalty, then they prob would function just like pirates after all.
This is mostly because groups in OP tend to have similar structures. All yonko crews have, well, a yonko, 3 top commanders and then a group of 6-10 ish elite officers followed by affiliated folks and crews.
 

grey matter

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
6,582
Reaction score
10,159
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
India
This is mostly because groups in OP tend to have similar structures. All yonko crews have, well, a yonko, 3 top commanders and then a group of 6-10 ish elite officers followed by affiliated folks and crews.
I think this is generally true, but not always.

Whitebeard had:
- Marco
- Jozu
- Vista
- Ace
- Thatch

5 top commanders, who were distinct from the rest.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

I only recently had the thought as to why exactly I should feel obligated to deem pirates and the Marines as always having been completely different from each other, and not just because some characters say they’re always on different sides.

When I got to looking at the structure of Kaido’s crew, his structure actually seemed a little similar to the Marines, with the Flying Six being like Vice Admirals, the three All-Stars being like the three Admirals, the Kaido the Governor-General being like the Fleet Admiral. The Marines even conduct raids, genocides, and dealings with other pirates when they deem it necessary, using ships with their own symbols on them.

Really though, I think the biggest difference I could honestly find between the Marines and pirates is that the Marines have the support of the civilians and royalty of the world, while the pirates don’t. If the Marines didn’t have the support of the civilians and royalty, then they prob would function just like pirates after all.
The difference is that probably 95-99% of pirates are outright bad people.
While 95-99% of marines are people who truly want to make the world a more just place.

The Cipher Pol is a different entity all together, like the CIA, though there is certainly some relation for sure, since they answer to same top guys (Gorosei)

I mean, this is like saying army/police aren't really different from the criminals. Because there are some scumbags amongst the army/police, while there are some Robin Hoods amongst the criminals
 

wing_gundam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2007
Messages
1,298
Reaction score
892
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
There are so many mysteries revolving around the world government and their' past,' and it seems One Piece holds the answer to that. But what is that past whose knowledge alone suffices to cause the faith of people worldwide to crumble? One possibility is that the world government was originally a pirate crew in the past.

First off, the world government's flag resembles a pirate flag. The usual thing is to find a pirate flag with a skull and crossed bones. The WG's flag, however, strays from this in two ways.
First, there is no skull. Second, one of the crossed lines of the WG's flag is vertical, and the other is horizontal, whereas pirates' flags have diagonally crossed bones. It turned out, however, that it doesn't stray from this, given that Whitebeard's pirate flag is composed of crossed vertical and horizontal crossed bones.
As to the lack of the skull, it wouldn't be the first time we would see that. We have already seen the sun pirates having nothing but a sun symbol as their flag. Some pirate flags lacked both. To strengthen the similarity to a pirate flag, I tilted the WG's flag a little bit, and its novel appearance does look like a pirate flag.


Pirates have already tried to rule the world before, as evidenced by Rocks' past. Rocks was ambitious to become the king of the world. That is exactly what IMU is. If we entertain the possibility that a pirate crew succeeded in ruling over the world, we will get precisely where the WG is right now. We have already seen how pirates put kingdoms under their territories, as was shown when WB and, later on, BM had FI as their turf.

If the WG is indeed a pirate crew originally, then it would make sense that they will be afraid to have their past divulged to the world.

I have other things from the manga that would fit nicely with this possibility, but I am too lazy, so I'll stop here, lol. Lemme know what you think.
Not a bad theory. There could have been a crew that aligned with the CD of old and formed the first WG. But I'm not convinced yet. It's also really just a puppet state for the CDs.

Finally FYI WB's flag was originally designed as a swastika (Eastern) before Oda/Shounen changed it to a cross to sell to the Western audience.


 
Top