Theory Why Vegapunk couldn't duplicate the ability of a Logia

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
So I was thinking why Vegapunk couldn't duplicate the ability of a Logia, and the reason is very simple


Vegapunk can only create Artificial Fruits of the Zoan type



The reason is simple because only Zoans transform into something that exists. However, an "earthquake Human" or "fire Human" do not, therefore their lineage factor cannot be extracted


Vegapunk also create an Artificial Mythical Zoan, which are not real beings



But there's a key difference: Vegapunk made these creatures real

Vegapunk created the "Pink Dragon" from stratch, by meddling with the lineage factor, just like the real dragons he kept on Punk Hazard




But apparently, it's impossible to make an "earthquake Human" or "magma Human", and the Seraphim require a constant supply of Green Blood with the lineage factor of the Paramecia user




Vegapunk said that it takes a lot of time and money to duplicate a Mythical Zoan

But why Vegapunk didn't used Green Blood to duplicate Kaido's ability?

The answer is that it's not possible to fully duplicate a Zoan with Green Blood, for the same reason it's not possible to duplicate a Logia with Green Blood


Zoans and Logias can transform and each form has a different lineage factor





This means that in order for Green Blood to duplicate these abilities, Vegapunk has to extract the lineage factor when the user is transformed

But it's impossible to extract the lineage factor of a "fire Human" when they are transformed in fire

For a Zoan, Green Blood would cause the user to be stuck into one form
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,470
Reaction score
25,031
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
I think you missread a bit there. Vegapiunk says regarding zoans "virtually all fruits of that type, even the special ones... Can probably be recreated...". The special ones I would argue refer to both ancient zoans AND mythical zoans. And we see this in practice via momo's fruit.

Then we get to paramecia types. Which he couldn't replicate as fruits but he can replicate via green blood by extracting an user's lineage factor.

And the logia couldn't be replicated at all.

So zoans can be fully replicated with awakenings being unconfirmed. Green blood is a reliable way to successfully replicate paramecia abilities but the usage of this rather than a fruit IMO evidences that even with available lineage factors vegapunk cannot replicate a fruit. As in, the process for replicating a zoan fruit does not work for paramecia at all. And then we get to logias, which vegapunk could not replicate to any capacity. Which suggests an added layer of difficulty.

In that sense, the issue is likely not that vegapunk cannot extract a lineage factor from logia users. We know they can bleed, pretty sure the greatest mind in OP would be able to crack extracting a sample.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
We know they can bleed, pretty sure the greatest mind in OP would be able to crack extracting a sample.
My point is that different forms have a different lineage factor

Chopper's rumble ball works based on that

But a Logia while turned into their element has no blood to be extracted, once they bleed they have reverted
 

DeadlyBeast

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
3,093
Reaction score
3,978
Gender
Male
Country
United States
That's an interesting hypothesis. The extracting of the blood could be one of the underlying factors that make replicating the DFs difficult but that also opens up its own can of worms. In the case of artificial zoan, how is he replicating them?

For example Momo has an artificial zoan fruit. How did Vegapunk get the lineage factor of all possible forms a zoan can take into the fruit? Did he first have to extract the multiple possible lineage factors and put them together into a fruit? Or did he just need Kaido full form lineage factor. If he can put zoan lineage factos into a fruit why couldn't he take the single lineage factor from a Paramecia and put it into a fruit too instead of green blood?

Honestly I was hoping we'd get an actual explanation for Devil Fruits this arc but we haven't gotten much of an answer. If Oda was not going to give a logical in universe answer I'd have preferred he just let magic exist in the world and that DFs are just magic and nothing more. At this point the whole someone wished for it thing makes no sense. It also introduced a concept of a sentient/conscious sea/ocean so now we have some kind of potential Sea God that exists independently of all this that likely will never get explained.

We also don't know much about the artificial zoan fruits either. Can they accomplish what I say is the most important aspect of a DF - the infinite reincarnation e.g. will there always be a Pink Dragon fruit from now on? Do they have minds of their own like actual zoan fruits?

Personally been disappointed with DF lore this arc. Hope we get a better explanation once we learn about the Ancient Kingdom.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
For example Momo has an artificial zoan fruit. How did Vegapunk get the lineage factor of all possible forms a zoan can take into the fruit? Did he first have to extract the multiple possible lineage factors and put them together into a fruit? Or did he just need Kaido full form lineage factor.
As I pointed out, Vegapunk may not have used Kaido's lineage factor at all, and simply created his own dragons, trying his best to make them look like Kaido's fruit.

Interesting enough, we haven't seen Momonosuke taking another form.

If he can put zoan lineage factos into a fruit why couldn't he take the single lineage factor from a Paramecia and put it into a fruit too instead of green blood?
I don't know exactly, but I think this ties back to Zoans having a conscious of their own

There's a full creature inside a Zoan, while a Paramecia or Logia only half of the information that gives the ability.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,470
Reaction score
25,031
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
My point is that different forms have a different lineage factor

Chopper's rumble ball works based on that

But a Logia while turned into their element has no blood to be extracted, once they bleed they have reverted
As in, walk point, brain point and monster point having different lineage factors? hmmm, I don't buy that.
 

DeadlyBeast

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
3,093
Reaction score
3,978
Gender
Male
Country
United States
As I pointed out, Vegapunk may not have used Kaido's lineage factor at all, and simply created his own dragons, trying his best to make them look like Kaido's fruit.

Interesting enough, we haven't seen Momonosuke taking another form.
Well we'll have to wait and see but I'm sure Momo will have a hybrid form at some point. If he never develops one or is incapable of it then what you said may be true that Vegapunk created his own eastern dragon to base the fruit off of.


I don't know exactly, but I think this ties back to Zoans having a conscious of their own

There's a full creature inside a Zoan, while a Paramecia or Logia only half of the information that gives the ability.
That's a fair guess. Hopefully this gets elaborated on more in the future but currently not holding up my hopes.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,470
Reaction score
25,031
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
IIRC it was pretty much said the pink dragon devil fruit did come from kaido's lineage factor to which vegapunk definitely had access to. Let alone that recreating kaido's devil fruit from his lineage factor is literally what vegapunk said was within his capabilities.
 

HereNThere

Alive Ain't Always Livin'
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
8,395
Reaction score
12,211
Gender
Male
Country
United States
While I'm not sure about the accuracy, I think you are on the right path.

Lineage Factors only exist in living things, so, yeah, it makes sense he can easily recreate them as he can just pull the Lineage Factor from an existing animal and recreate a DF from scratch. It's highly likely that Fruits can only be replicated with a "pure" strain of Lineage Factor, thus the success of Artificial Zoans. I imagine that Vegapunk, through a lot of time and effort, managed to almost perfectly distill the Dragon aspect of Kaido's Lineage Factor to a pure enough strain for replication. I'd say those Dragons on Punk Hazard were actually the results of this tinkering, rather than him creating a Dragon to pull the lineage factor from. After all, he would have had to test to see if the Lineage Factor would actually result in a dragon at some point rather than just making the fruit and handing it off to someone. So he grew dragons from that Lineage Factor.

However, the "natural" states of the Paramecia and Logia just don't have a Lineage Factor because, well, they aren't alive, so getting the "pure" Lineage Factor to create a fruit from scratch is impossible. And that's where the Green Blood comes into play.

Now, why can't Vegapunk use Green Blood for Logia? I don't think it's because he can't extract the Lineage Factor from those elements. Again, the abilities that Paramecia possess don't have Lineage Factors to pull from either, but Green Blood works with them. I think it's more likely that Logia are just too, let's say, substantial to reproduce in full. We know he managed to make some headway given that the Pacifista lasers were based on Kizaru's ability, but that's as far as he's been confirmed to have gotten. I think the lineage factors of Logia users are just too volatile due to the amount of power.
 
Top