Fantasy Mirajane vs Gildarts

[Garmadooon]

Mira Macro him and stomps

 

[AmitDS]

Gildarts high-extreme diff

 

[FireIce]

^You're trolling right

 

[Garmadooon]

^You're trolling right

?

 

[FireIce]

?

I was talking to AmitDS

 

[Shoutmon]

Yeah I'm voting Gildarts. He's the strongest S class, while Mira's possibly the weakest portrayal wise

Edit:even limiting them to feats only he's more impressive

 

[Axiomus]

Gildarts, and it's not close.

Laxus without red lightning is already above Mira.

Macro is a meme.

 

[AmitDS]

I was talking to AmitDS

No I'm not. Mashima isn't writing Gildarts low diffing Mirajane especially since S class wank is alive and well and he's comparable to Erza and Laxus in MP even if he's a bit above.

 

[Darklord#10]

Mira Macro him and stomps

I swear I almost thought this wasn't a troll

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 3, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 3, 2023 ---

No I'm not. Mashima isn't writing Gildarts low diffing Mirajane especially since S class wank is alive and well and he's comparable to Erza and Laxus in MP even if he's a bit above.

This is the same gildarts that fought August and held his own? While Mira was struggling with swords and Jacob.
Same gildarts that was said to be on another level from everyone on tenrou? Be realistic here

 

[AmitDS]

I swear I almost thought this wasn't a troll

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 3, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 3, 2023 ---

This is the same gildarts that fought August and held his own? While Mira was struggling with swords and Jacob.
Same gildarts that was said to be on another level from everyone on tenrou? Be realistic here

Lol holding his own? August was playing with him and he couldn't do anything to August.

Lol the same Gildarts whose magical power is comparable to Laxus and Erza who I don't see low diffing Mirajane either. Also my point is that Mashima isn't letting any S class mage low diff another.

 

[Garmadooon]

Lol holding how own? August was playing with him and he couldn't do anything to August.

Lol the same Gildarts whose magical power is comparable to Laxus and Erza who I don't see low diffing Mirajane either. Also my point is that Mashima isn't letting any S class mage low diff another.

Gildarts is described in another tier compared to S-rank mages. How does Mira give him a match? She is Skullion level which is fodder for Laxus, who himself is weaker than Gildarts.

Being stomped by August is not an anti-feat, he could give him a low-mid diff and blitzed him 2 times while Mira burned all his MP on 2 fodder from Irene.


Gildarts just needs to blitz Mira and divide her into cubes, she is not at Erza/Laxus level.

 

[Ratrace]

Also my point is that Mashima isn't letting any S class mage low diff another.

feat wise Gildarts should easily beat Mira but Hiro doesn’t care about those things so it might be closer than it should be

 

[Darklord#10]

feat wise Gildarts should easily beat Mira but Hiro doesn’t care about those things so it might be closer than it should be

My friend it's not even close feat wise or portrayal wise. Mira is nowhere near laxus/Erza level this guys are beasts and they'll destroy Mira not to talk of gildarts. It's not close at all, hell even natsu is more closer to laxus and erza than Mira is

 

[Ratrace]

My friend it's not even close feat wise or portrayal wise. Mira is nowhere near laxus/Erza level this guys are beasts and they'll destroy Mira not to talk of gildarts. It's not close at all, hell even natsu is more closer to laxus and erza than Mira is

Read my comment again never said it was close

 

[Darklord#10]

Mira is not even a threat to natsu not to talk of gildarts. Mira gets low diff'd anything else is pure wank and mental problem

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 11, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 11, 2023 ---

Read my comment again never said it was close

I saw it. But you said I might be closer than we make it out to be and I'm saying it's not going beyond low diff, anything above low diff is crazy talk

 

[Ratrace]

Mira is not even a threat to natsu not to talk of gildarts. Mira gets low diff'd anything else is pure wank and mental problem

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 11, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 11, 2023 ---

I saw it. But you said I might be closer than we make it out to be and I'm saying it's not going beyond low diff, anything above low diff is crazy talk

No I said Hiro might make it closer (if he wrote it) than it should be

 

[Darklord#10]

No I said Hiro might make it closer (if he wrote it) than it should be

And I'm saying no

 

[Ratrace]

And I'm saying no

No to what? Do you think Hiro cares about feats

 

[Darklord#10]

No what? Do you control what Hiro puts in his manga not

Not even hiro can write Mira giving gildarts some issues. He was the one that wrote Mira vs skullion and Mira vs Jacob

 

[Ratrace]

Not even hiro can write Mira giving gildarts some issues. He was the one that wrote Mira vs skullion and Mira vs Jacob

What’s stopping him from increasing her power level. I will ask again do you think Hiro cares about feats