- Joined
- Jul 4, 2024
- Messages
- 1,564
- Reaction score
- 1,493
- Country
-
isnt screenrant a random blog pretending to be a tabloid
Last edited:
I have more faith in Terasaka coming back, but if he does, he has to do something different than sports. If he is a fan of One Piece and Katakuri Circus (if I am saying it right), do that. And with some of the positive western fan base it gained from GGG, I think he can return.Do you think Fusai Naba can return to the magazine?
Because , I can't find any mangaka who had 2 instant axes and came back for a 3rd serialization.
Horikoshi had oumagadoki zou which lasted 37 chapters before mha.
Ikezawa had kurogane which lasted 70 chapters before noah's notes.
Hasegawa had spring weapon n1 which lasted 70 chapters before moriking.
Shuichi Aso had Boku no Watashi no Yusha which lasted 66 chapters before saiki k.
Iwashiro had psyren which lasted 145 chapters before kagamigami.
It is just a bit sad knowing that we will probably never see fusai naba, kento terasaka , jun kirarazawa , yusaku shibata and kazusa inaoka again in this magazine .
Do you think Fusai Naba can return to the magazine?
>Cut to the EiC & editors in the serialization meeting approving the most generic, forgettable or unfunny shounen series they can.

Look I get it. We can talk about past editors and their blunders. But we also have to remember Jumps structure in how they have to have 20 series at a time. Also I know I asked this before, but if you had to say how their job performance was to WSJ, which EiC and which editor was the weakest, and which was the strongest?>Cut to the EiC & editors in the serialization meeting approving the most generic, forgettable or unfunny shounen series they can.
Truly inspirational words!![]()
I don't think it counts since it wasn't jump but well, Ken WakuiBecause , I can't find any mangaka who had 2 instant axes and came back for a 3rd serialization.
That's the thing, Jump has this "Manga only needs to be good/interesting to get serialized" motto but truth is that they don't have any "high standards", they just throw stuff at the wall since they're locked into this eternal cycle of having to axe and start stuff in short periods of time which causes a lot of bland/forgettable stuff and few truly atrocious stuff here and there, i'm not seriously criticizing, just joking about, it is what it isLook I get it. We can talk about past editors and their blunders. But we also have to remember Jumps structure in how they have to have 20 series at a time. Also I know I asked this before, but if you had to say how their job performance was to WSJ, which EiC and which editor was the weakest, and which was the strongest?

--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
If those manga are the best 3 in all submissions they got ft. the EiC's taste then it can't be helpedThat's the thing, Jump has this "Manga only needs to be good/interesting to get serialized" motto but truth is that they don't have any "high standards", they just throw stuff at the wall since they're locked into this eternal cycle of having to axe and start stuff in short periods of time which causes a lot of bland/forgettable stuff and few truly atrocious stuff here and there, i'm not seriously criticizing, just joking about, it is what it is![]()
I don't think most of the time it's "the best" they have at the moment but they simply decide to what serialize based in what kind of series they want for that moment unless they get something that they really think is going to do well.If those manga are the best 3 in all submissions they got ft. the EiC's taste then it can't be helped
Gonna be honest it didn't grab me at all. Definitely on the lower end of this years one shots for me. That being said I agree with you that Machida will probably be serialized sooner rather than later.So is it a bad time to say that Memento in Kowloon was by far the most interesting one shot this year for now?
I think Reiya Machida might be closer to making a series than I realise.
Summer and Insects in the Fire's Flight was far more interesting personally.So is it a bad time to say that Memento in Kowloon was by far the most interesting one shot this year for now?
I think Reiya Machida might be closer to making a series than I realise.
That is exactly how I feel when I read most of them. In all honesty I felt that a lot of the 2020 series at that point were really underdeveloped (story based not gag as that is a different standard), even for 2019 when I went to look at those titles, I can understand the disappointment. And I can imagine how hard it was to make sure that the series lived up to the one-shots. But when looking at this line up, here was what was a one-shot and is still running now.I get the impression at least part of it is WSJ serialises what's available to start, they have to fill a certain amount of slots each round after all and if there's only 3 authors ready to go, those three are going to get the chance even if they're not especially promising.
There's clearly big series they're really eager to run and prepared well for like most veterans returning and incredibly popular oneshots like Blue Box, but there's also series that feel like they were pushed out too early without being fully planned, and other series that are difficult to imagine Jump having any real expectations for succeeding like the incredibly bland Shadow Eliminators, or Necromance repeating a similar set up and dynamics to the author's previous U19 series.
Like I'm sure there's always some hope for success, but some of them are "I guess this might gather a niche fanbase?" serialisations which are there as backup to fill a batch when nobody else is ready to go while others are "We have to run this now!" which are serialised as soon as possible even if they maybe needed more time in the oven.