The most hilarious thing this week is reading Hakutaku and Shinobi Undercover back to back and seeing the bully character having the exact same character design. What if they're both in the same school and it's the exact same guy?
Hakutaku wasn't as strong for a first chapter as it needed to be. A lot of the focus was spent on the MC being bullied without realizing it, and it did not even payoff on that front. If they were going to spend so much time setting up that plot, they should pay it off on the opening chapter, it's the premise after all. I get that it's probably going to be paid off on the second chapter but for goodness sake, they spent two spreads on the MC's reaction to being noticed, I think that's four pages of content that would've made for a good old humiliation ritual for the bullies. Or at least, show us more of the game he made. A lot of the handling of its subject matter reminds me of Time Paradox Ghostwriter rather than Bakuman, where they don't show much of the product and just talk about it, which makes it hard to feel drawn in to their particular niche hobby. I really hope it picks up from here and expands on its ideas better. I also like the girl, she has punk energy.
Let's see here...
Ichi The Witch was retreading old ground and reiterating things that were already established before without much progression. Felt like a monster of the week sort of deal. Kinda reminds me of how Red Hood just didn't leave the village for a whole volume, but thank goodness they're heading for witch capital by the end of chapter 3. Still, it felt like a filler chapter, or like a gag of the day... hunt of the day? sort of chapter. Maybe it's to show that this is what the series is gonna be, taking down magical creatures with rudimentary hunting techniques. But at that point, what's the point of having magic in the series, y'know? I feel like a lot of the concepts Ichi The Witch is going for had been done by Dungeon Meshi
and done better at that, from the cast to the worldbuilding to the plot, comparatively at the third chapter. I want it to do well, but it's not exactly finding that proper footing yet. Do love the banter between the main trio at least.
Shinobi Undercover is still my pick for the one to make it past the axe. I still stand by my assessment that it has more pieces to make for a good hit, and the 2nd chapter's progressing and expanding on those ideas in a meaningful way. It's kinda cute, has a few action pieces, the jokes tickle me and the characters are alright. I really like the operator too, very funny quipman. I only hear Sugita's voice when I read his dialogue. Man's spitting facts over that radio.
Astro Royale is ugly as hell if they have an older woman with a cleavage window and my only thought is, "Meh." My standards are very low, y'know, it doesn't make me go awooga. I know you sold yourself on the fujoshi money, Ken Wakui, but it wouldn't hurt to get hornier.
I literally forgot that
Murakami exists that I didn't even consider it for axing.
Chojo used one png for a gorilla for almost all the pages and that is hilarious.
Kiyoshi and the glasses guy are pretty funny being good boys trying to be hard-boiled shonen edgy. There's a lot of Hunter Exams going with this forest arc, what with older contestants repeating and other contestants sabotaging.
@Newkerzy I'm not gonna smirk and say I told ya so, but I told ya so.
Hima-ten has opened up the harem saga. Where else was it gonna go?
Now I will proceed to dump an insane ramble about Hima-ten that no one should take seriously. Hima-ten is actually a psyop by the feminist illuminati to destroy the societal expectations of a family by placing the role of the breadwinner in the hands of the women and the role of the household caretaker in the hands of men. By framing it in the form of a harem manga, they aim to brainwash young men into domestication by telling them that they too can become appealing to gorgeous models and CEOs if they learn how to cook and clean like good wives. In turn, they frame the women as having the power to secure money at a young age, also being able to pay men, framing the concept that women are superior into the coding of the manga. In doing so, men become hopeless and will be manipulated into giving up their dreams in favor of becoming a househusband for their female superiors, thus shifting the typical household right up on its head, alongside the balance of power. Women will work and pay taxes, men will stay home and make sandwiches. This is the endgame. The death to familial society.