Games Mafia Game 127 - Neon Genesis Omongelion - End Game

[AwkwardMisha]

As much as my spidey senses are tingling, the one who’s done the most tunneling has been Evil. Gry, for me, is still unfamiliar, but Evil, most of your posts have been laser focused on Gry, with not much probing elsewhere

I’m unsure if this heated argument is between two towns or one town and one mafia, but at least Gry has multiple suspects and hasn’t been applying pressure to just one player

On another note, James has been unusually quiet this round. It’s odd considering how aggressive he was yesterday, especially when he was actively trying to strategize.
That energy fizzled out really fast on Day 2


As for Gry, I’m leaning toward his side, given his claim about blocking Holt and the lack of other parry/eva claims
If Gry is truthful and Holt is town, then the mafia still managing a kill suggests one of two things: either Holt isn’t mafia, or there’s a second mafia team, and they didn’t secure a kill

I really hope this game isn’t cruel enough to have two distinct mafia teams

 

[Baka Taichou]

If she lives to D3, she will deny that she stormed off and will claim she was just fine. This behavior is very similar to yesterday and how she retconned today so I don’t think you need to bother

hello, i'm still here?

But since players like Gry say to ignore me, and i've been ignored in over 20 posts since end of D1, and I already stated my thoughts, what else do you want me to do? should I keep being top poster till I die? I think baka tunneling was enough for now, time to look at other players. I made enough noise. Or is it that you like the distraction I create with my big mouth?

 

[AwkwardMisha]

As much as my spidey senses are tingling, the one who’s done the most tunneling has been Evil. Gry, for me, is still unfamiliar, but Evil, most of your posts have been laser focused on Gry, with not much probing elsewhere

I’m unsure if this heated argument is between two towns or one town and one mafia, but at least Gry has multiple suspects and hasn’t been applying pressure to just one player

On another note, James has been unusually quiet this round. It’s odd considering how aggressive he was yesterday, especially when he was actively trying to strategize.
That energy fizzled out really fast on Day 2


As for Gry, I’m leaning toward his side, given his claim about blocking Holt and the lack of other parry/eva claims
If Gry is truthful and Holt is town, then the mafia still managing a kill suggests one of two things: either Holt isn’t mafia, or there’s a second mafia team, and they didn’t secure a kill

I really hope this game isn’t cruel enough to have two distinct mafia teams

edit: wanted to say “If Gry is truthful and blocked Holt “

sorry i qm still at my first coffee trying to wake up

 

[Baka Taichou]

As much as my spidey senses are tingling, the one who’s done the most tunneling has been Evil. Gry, for me, is still unfamiliar, but Evil, most of your posts have been laser focused on Gry, with not much probing elsewhere

I’m unsure if this heated argument is between two towns or one town and one mafia, but at least Gry has multiple suspects and hasn’t been applying pressure to just one player

On another note, James has been unusually quiet this round. It’s odd considering how aggressive he was yesterday, especially when he was actively trying to strategize.
That energy fizzled out really fast on Day 2


As for Gry, I’m leaning toward his side, given his claim about blocking Holt and the lack of other parry/eva claims
If Gry is truthful and Holt is town, then the mafia still managing a kill suggests one of two things: either Holt isn’t mafia, or there’s a second mafia team, and they didn’t secure a kill

I really hope this game isn’t cruel enough to have two distinct mafia teams

why does blocking holt mean if he's mafia that mafia wouldn't be able to claim a kill? It's not like it's a one man army. Someone else could have done the kill from the team.
Having Eva in mafia team doesn't mean if one uses eva another can't do kill, no?

 

[AwkwardMisha]

why does blocking holt mean if he's mafia that mafia wouldn't be able to claim a kill? It's not like it's a one man army. Someone else could have done the kill from the team.
Having Eva in mafia team doesn't mean if one uses eva another can't do kill, no?

i remember that the rules stated that mafia can either use eva or do a kill, either one or the other

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 16, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 16, 2024 ---

If i am wrong i stand to be corrected

 

[GrySun]

Low odds that a block on N1 hits the mark, but it tells us at least he wasn‘t the killer(maybe, unless two teams/tp), and that he wasn‘t the mech stealing mind from Tatsu I guess.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 16, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 16, 2024 ---

i remember that the rules stated that mafia can either use eva or do a kill, either one or the other

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 16, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 16, 2024 ---

If i am wrong i stand to be corrected

I believe this refers to the individual mafia player, not the team as a whole. Can‘t kill and use mech at same time, but your friend can do the kill while you mech.

 

[AwkwardMisha]

Or wait, can mafia also use eva+kill depending on who is doing the actions?

 

[SirSamuel016]

As for Gry, I’m leaning toward his side, given his claim about blocking Holt and the lack of other parry/eva claims
If Gry is truthful and Holt is town, then the mafia still managing a kill suggests one of two things: either Holt isn’t mafia, or there’s a second mafia team, and they didn’t secure a kill

No? You've missed out a plausible scenario where Holt is mafia but his teammate did the kill. That's if Holt is scum though.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Feel free to be the change you want to see in the world. Go spend energy on specific people. You yourself were all over the place with your thoughts today.

exasperated

I was hunting who took Eva 09. Because if DD is truthful and he lost bid too then someone went for Jesus and I’m still mad. The only forgiveness if it is evil or Van. Brandish made me think James might have it. Eva 9 isn’t like doctor or Detectice that people need to keep silent. People like Tatsu who came out wanting the thief kind and you doing Perry fit with your personalities. Plus I don’t feel like Desin Lynch. Feels like low handing fruit like the demon lynch from D1.

Can you tell a bit more on why you suspect these players ? Except for Sam maybe that one is obvious.

Holt and James changed their playstyle from D1 to D2. I don’t see how Misha gets more traction because Marm is playing similar to me. DD cuz he went for MR. Van because he showed up so automatically he’s town?? Like…. No ppl.

 

[James Rye]

Hi. Am sick. Will try to do minimum. Haven't read anything of day 2.
I sus Demon, Van and Gry. Since only Gry got a vote, I vote on him.
Votekill GrySun.

 

[SirSamuel016]

Hi. Am sick. Will try to do minimum. Haven't read anything of day 2.
I sus Demon, Van and Gry. Since only Gry got a vote, I vote on him.
Votekill GrySun.

What's your reasoning for this?

 

[AwkwardMisha]

Low odds that a block on N1 hits the mark, but it tells us at least he wasn‘t the killer(maybe, unless two teams/tp), and that he wasn‘t the mech stealing mind from Tatsu I guess.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 16, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 16, 2024 ---

I believe this refers to the individual mafia player, not the team as a whole. Can‘t kill and use mech at same time, but your friend can do the kill while you mech.

so mafia can use the mechs and the kills simultaneously

I’ve read the rules as either or

Hmmmmm

 

[GrySun]

Sam, thoughts on Brandy? Usually I fairly early feel he‘s town. No such luck this game.

 

[Holt]

So you voting Pom and leaving, does that also seem intentional?

Elaborate more on why at the time it was not justified. You mean the time she voted, or the person she voted? If the former, is it better to vote with 20 seconds to go like Demon? If the latter, were the only legal people to vote for, according to you, Demon and James? Or people with 0 votes? What happened to being able to vote for a person you want lynched?

Just trying to follow your thoughts to the roots.

I didn’t intend to vote and leave actually, I did lose track of time but I likely would’ve changed if I was around at the time Desin and Demon voted as that would’ve raised alarms for me. Probably would’ve locked on Demon. Not seeing a follow-through with Baka votes after Pom locked would’ve also made me re-evaluate my vote on her.

There isn’t much else I can explain besides this. Of course everyone can vote, and choice wasn’t limited to Demon/James but unless you don’t intend for the vote to matter, then you’ll either go for one of them, or bump someone up. Yes, I understand me voting Pom also bumped her up, however the stakes are different. That was my first vote, and I had an obligation to do so. It was also not locked. Pom locking Baka to lynchable territory with a locked vote is very clear intent (which is fine), it just rang alarm bells for me. Voting for the person you want lynched is fine of course, but it applies to me as well as anyone else.

The justification is a bit of both, because Baka was fueling the situation and it did look like things were on the verge of swinging that way. Pom putting a locked vote on her at that time felt like the start, and it rubbed me off wrong.

 

[AwkwardMisha]

No? You've missed out a plausible scenario where Holt is mafia but his teammate did the kill. That's if Holt is scum though.

i digress, as stated somehow i read the rules as either or, now i know

 

[Holt]

hello, i'm still here?

But since players like Gry say to ignore me, and i've been ignored in over 20 posts since end of D1, and I already stated my thoughts, what else do you want me to do? should I keep being top poster till I die? I think baka tunneling was enough for now, time to look at other players. I made enough noise. Or is it that you like the distraction I create with my big mouth?

I didn’t even tag or respond to you, I’m responding to what Sam said lol

 

[GrySun]

exasperated

I was hunting who took Eva 09. Because if DD is truthful and he lost bid too then someone went for Jesus and I’m still mad. The only forgiveness if it is evil or Van. Brandish made me think James might have it. Eva 9 isn’t like doctor or Detectice that people need to keep silent. People like Tatsu who came out wanting the thief kind and you doing Perry fit with your personalities. Plus I don’t feel like Desin Lynch. Feels like low handing fruit like the demon lynch from D1.

I assume it‘s in mafia hands. I dont see why a town would rush Jesus, because by doing this they take away town‘s chance to recruit Masons and get confirmable towns. Since everyone is vanilla, anyone recruited is town beyond a doubt.

 

[SirSamuel016]

Sam, thoughts on Brandy? Usually I fairly early feel he‘s town. No such luck this game.

He's very inactive which is surprising to me as I'd of expected him around a bit more even though christmas time can be hectic. He's middle ground for me, could be holding onto something and not wanting to pull me revealing a mech

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 16, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 16, 2024 ---

* PULL A ME, NOT PULL ME

 

[GrySun]

Hi. Am sick. Will try to do minimum. Haven't read anything of day 2.
I sus Demon, Van and Gry. Since only Gry got a vote, I vote on him.
Votekill GrySun.

Get better soon

 

[Marmalade]

Hi. Am sick. Will try to do minimum. Haven't read anything of day 2.
I sus Demon, Van and Gry. Since only Gry got a vote, I vote on him.
Votekill GrySun.

(Hope u feel better soon! )