We should be 8 towns and 4 mafia according to the opening post. Coming out as town to say they have 2 votes is kind of dangerous, this is a super good role late game.
Misha had no robot at the end of N2, and if that's when it went out the auction then it's not her. It must be Jinx then. The was no one sick on D3 and she was upset you claimed to have blocked her and she sicklied you. I asked her today and she dodged the question saying "didn't you read I said I am mason" - which has nothing to do with each other, as one is primary other is secondary role.
I don't know about Marmalade, dont ask me about Marmalade. I dont believe Marmalade and Pigeon are in one team, or that mecha trade wouldn't make any sense. Or could this be a backing each other up mafia game? It would explain how Pigeon didn't try to steal from someone without anything at all.
Damn. So I missed some variables. I stopped Cres‘ sicklying which is why it didn‘t happen that night. I thought it had to be that they were the killer of their team, and the other mechs had higher priority to be used.
So this whole Sickly hunt was a waste of time. At least we don‘t need to worry that it‘s in mafia hands, since she got recruited. I can‘t believe she‘d bid on it after failing on Recruiter. And I can believe even less how heavily she is tunneling and even anon voted Sam in secret.
Awful townplay.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Well this is why dialogue is important, I missed that angle on my own.
Fell asleep and have to work for a few a bit now, I don’t know exactly how long this will take but I should be back before the day ends at least (taking some hours so a coworker can go to a docs appoinntment)
Gry, if you are Mafia you are doing a really good job. I can't read you as one gameplay-wise. But Eva 01 being left alone bothers me more than anything.
What happens if you trade with a mechless person? You get nothing and they get Thief mech, or does nothing happen because there‘s no 2 mechs? Probably the former.
If Marm had a more interesting mafia benefit mech, the team argument angle looks better because Pidgeon is rich on points. But it‘s just Spy. Good for fake claim in a final day to win and mislynch but otherwise not very relevant. I‘d have traded my Prostitute mech for sure, the blocking probably is still very relevant. Marm cannot do that with her low mind.
So I rate it, they are not in a team. Pidgeon had dumb luck with his guess..?
Gry, if you are Mafia you are doing a really good job. I can't read you as one gameplay-wise. But Eva 01 being left alone bothers me more than anything.
Did you read the post I wrote to Bran? How would mafia have touched me this game? If Sam is town, impossible. And even if Sam is scum, they would think I am baiting them. Why else would I claim Prostitute out in the open? Even Evil accused me of baiting.
I claimed early so it appears like I‘m baiting, while I was in truth still having another Prostitute night. So either that worked or Sam was the main deterrent. That‘s my perspective as a town, and if you can‘t read me as mafia then it should be your perspective too.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Why am I spelling pigeon as pidgeon? I need a break.
What happens if you trade with a mechless person? You get nothing and they get Thief mech, or does nothing happen because there‘s no 2 mechs? Probably the former.
If Marm had a more interesting mafia benefit mech, the team argument angle looks better because Pidgeon is rich on points. But it‘s just Spy. Good for fake claim in a final day to win and mislynch but otherwise not very relevant. I‘d have traded my Prostitute mech for sure, the blocking probably is still very relevant. Marm cannot do that with her low mind.
So I rate it, they are not in a team. Pidgeon had dumb luck with his guess..?
Her reveal with the Spy/Medium, was that even a reveal? There was zero new info. We knew that Holt did nothing on N1 - he flipped townie D2, we knew Van didn't recruit because why would someone not just claim it, and what was the other thing? For me the reveal / non-reveal was pretty meh and the timing of it even more so eyebrow-raising, because she did it when her thing was stolen. Would we have even gotten it if there was no certainty that someone is gonna come out and call her out on her results? Perhaps not.
When they are not in a team and she is actually a Mafia, it probably caught her off-guard. But the results mustn't even be completely incorrect. And while I'm not sure of usefulness as for Mafia for Medium, to use spy makes sense to see who is not a vanilla. But just having the robot also denies it to town, so this game anything is better than nothing.
Do we have a list which evas where available per day?
Somehow in the back of my mind i thought there should be a history of it posted by hosts somewhere
For me it is pretty clear that who is using the sickly might be mafia, just because of the sam early train
Available: Inquiry eva 1
Marm - Voodoo mech 2 ( i know it has another name)
Gry - Hider 3
Sam - Doc 4
Evil - scout 5
Pigeon - theft 6
Me - none
Jinx ?
Demon -?
Erin - says she is low on mht because she bid high on banshee
Bran - ?
James - ?
Tatsu - says she was leeched and possible low mht
Missing 7 MR, 8 democratic ,9 revenge
I am still waking up, unsure if I missed some claims
So Erin is mentioning that she lost the mech because she bid high on banshee and quickly ejected. My memory is fuzzy but i do remember a short discussion on the revenge mech being up
James is usually not around, the anon vote appeared when me, sam, bran, jinx and pigeon were online, erin and marm were also briefly in the discussions
Sam is doc, I do not have a mech yet, jinx said she is mason now has not claimed a mech, erin mentioned the high bet on banshee, pigeon informed he was leaching on tatsu and i have not seen any claims from bran
Marm claims the voodoo mech and her findings seem to align to what has happened until now. Also from what i understood from pigeons post the swap has not happened yet and is planning on the swap tonight, hence the theft eva is still not up there
Is there a mech list so at least we can cross check erin claim? Because if erin tells the truth is leaves bran as a possible sickly
The entire pigeon tatsu dynamic also does not sit well with me. It might just be mafia lie to cover another mafia mech actions tbh, so i am not taking what pigeon says 100% as truth
Her reveal with the Spy/Medium, was that even a reveal? There was zero new info. We knew that Holt did nothing on N1 - he flipped townie D2, we knew Van didn't recruit because why would someone not just claim it, and what was the other thing? For me the reveal / non-reveal was pretty meh and the timing of it even more so eyebrow-raising, because she did it when her thing was stolen. Would we have even gotten it if there was no certainty that someone is gonna come out and call her out on her results? Perhaps not.
When they are not in a team and she is actually a Mafia, it probably caught her off-guard. But the results mustn't even be completely incorrect. And while I'm not sure of usefulness as for Mafia for Medium, to use spy makes sense to see who is not a vanilla. But just having the robot also denies it to town, so this game anything is better than nothing.
My line of thinking is that if marm was truly scum, she could have easily lied and told that a recruitment took place, pointing that Vans recruit could have been on a mafia member. This could have lead us easily on some weird conspiracies and double check everyone that was interacting directly with Van. It would even had helped mafia build a case against Gry tbh, going off their recruitment banter.
My line of thinking is that if marm was truly scum, she could have easily lied and told that a recruitment took place, pointing that Vans recruit could have been on a mafia member. This could have lead us easily on some weird conspiracies and double check everyone that was interacting directly with Van. It would even had helped mafia build a case against Gry tbh, going off their recruitment banter.
But we also don't know how much HP she really has. Maybe she was in spy range the whole time and they didn't know. Or did someone else say how much they bet on the spy and didn't get it?
Even if nothing happened, she still went for James D2
James is also not in the clear for me, but because of his inactivity due to his sickness i tend not to truly take him into my calculations
Here are the targets. So basically she just clears James from killing Lawlet, the Holt and Van info is predictable.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
But we also don't know how much HP she really has. Maybe she was in spy range the whole time and they didn't know. Or did someone else say how much they bet on the spy and didn't get it?
Do we have a list which evas where available per day?
Somehow in the back of my mind i thought there should be a history of it posted by hosts somewhere
For me it is pretty clear that who is using the sickly might be mafia, just because of the sam early train
Available: Inquiry eva 1
Marm - Voodoo mech 2 ( i know it has another name)
Gry - Hider 3
Sam - Doc 4
Evil - scout 5
Pigeon - theft 6
Me - none
Jinx ?
Demon -?
Erin - says she is low on mht because she bid high on banshee
Bran - ?
James - ?
Tatsu - says she was leeched and possible low mht
Missing 7 MR, 8 democratic ,9 revenge
I am still waking up, unsure if I missed some claims
So Erin is mentioning that she lost the mech because she bid high on banshee and quickly ejected. My memory is fuzzy but i do remember a short discussion on the revenge mech being up
James is usually not around, the anon vote appeared when me, sam, bran, jinx and pigeon were online, erin and marm were also briefly in the discussions
Sam is doc, I do not have a mech yet, jinx said she is mason now has not claimed a mech, erin mentioned the high bet on banshee, pigeon informed he was leaching on tatsu and i have not seen any claims from bran
Marm claims the voodoo mech and her findings seem to align to what has happened until now. Also from what i understood from pigeons post the swap has not happened yet and is planning on the swap tonight, hence the theft eva is still not up there
Is there a mech list so at least we can cross check erin claim? Because if erin tells the truth is leaves bran as a possible sickly
The entire pigeon tatsu dynamic also does not sit well with me. It might just be mafia lie to cover another mafia mech actions tbh, so i am not taking what pigeon says 100% as truth
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
As much as
My line of thinking is that if marm was truly scum, she could have easily lied and told that a recruitment took place, pointing that Vans recruit could have been on a mafia member. This could have lead us easily on some weird conspiracies and double check everyone that was interacting directly with Van. It would even had helped mafia build a case against Gry tbh, going off their recruitment banter.
Even if nothing happened, she still went for James D2
James is also not in the clear for me, but because of his inactivity due to his sickness i tend not to truly take him into my calculations
Well, sorry my dear, you should. The hosts don't decide on who is mafia and who isn't based on their health level.
But that's interesting, isn't it. Marmalade spies on James N1 and finds no action and still adamantly votes James D2. Sure, he is not cleared after doing nothing, but is he more suspicious because of it? Very strange.
i wanted scout D1, which demon took from me
After i bet on banshee and my bid failed
I haven’t bid on anything last night because i didn’t found the Mechs interesting enough so i was waiting on the next rotations to check what availible mechs will come out
OF COURSE!!! WTFFF she went there yesterday and was like "oh by the way desin, you totally contradict yourself, that's so sus" then votes me!! I can only explain that because I had priorly admitted to be sitting on a robot and desin was all empty, so between two towns I might have been a more evaluable kill on that quick assessment.
Anyways, VOTEKILL MARMALADE
I mean, tbh, idk, but there's still time to change.
I didn’t want the sickly because it never appealed to me, because of my level of paranoia i didn’t want to misslynch a town and also didn’t want to take a mech and jus not use it, in hindsight seeing that the game is smaller maybe it would have been better to have went for it
I didn’t want the sickly because it never appealed to me, because of my level of paranoia i didn’t want to misslynch a town and also didn’t want to take a mech and jus not use it, in hindsight seeing that the game is smaller maybe it would have been better to have went for it
