Okay quick reviews, let's yap.
Embers had its first chapter and I'd say the best character is the teacher. Which is something that's completely normal for me to say, but not when the teacher's a half balding old man. Look, he's just a really good teacher who put it in a lot of effort to reform the school punk, aight? It's too respectable. While the setting has shifted away from where the teach could be a recurring character, I feel like he'll come around time to time whenever Haitani needs a push forward.
Now let's talk about everything else. A defender MC is a choice, but Inazuma Eleven had a goalkeeper MC, so nothing odd. That said, I can't 100% say this first chapter is amazing, and that's specifically because the characterizations are missing some sauce. I think Haitani's okay, but he's really bland. As in, he lacks a certain haughtiness, charm or comedian chops to take that delinquent MC role. Obviously, I'm comparing him to Hanamichi from Slam Dunk who was the butt of a lot of jokes and always let his ego get ahead of him. Haitani lacks those noticeable character flaws, which on paper should be a good thing, but in execution, takes away a lot of what could've been endearing. And the result is an MC that looks kinda cool, but not easily relatable or easy to empathize with. It would've been really good if they handed over pompadour's gags with the bat and his hair over to him. Pompadour had that dog in him, which Haitani does not. I also feel like they speedran his love for football in the opening chapter, since he went from learning to play to crying about it very fast. At the very least, I don't think he should've reached a point where he can cry about losing this soon. Slam Dunk had it that Hanamichi was really just in it to impress a girl, something easily relatable, and it became a very powerful thing when much later on, he would genuinely say he loved basketball. You can't speedrun someone's love, is what I'm saying. That said, art is good... But horribly claustraphobic. Like, there's a little too much going on every page and it just feels cramped. I feel like there's a weakness in the paneling composition, but it's really hard to put it into words. Not my most pleasurable reading experience.
It was, overall okay. Just enough ingredients to be a mainstay, but it's hard for me to say it'd be a success. I think it's a bit staler than it could've been, but it represented football well enough and you can sort of get a good read for the characters involved, even if they come off a tad too bland at the moment. It's a decent football manga beginning, only lacking in charm. The character designs are great, except for the rival guy. Those eyelashes look like his eyewhites are leaking out in spikes. It'll take a while to get used to. I think the comedy chops are a bit dialed back because Haitani's very straight-laced for a punk, and he'll be dealing with an equally straight laced rival striker dude, which makes for some difficulty in inserting levity and humor into their interactions..
By the way, Haitani's actually gotta be pretty smart, right? Considering how strict education is in Japan, for anyone to get into a university-affiliated school, they've gotta have some good grades. It's damn clear Haitani's too green to get in via his sports accomplishments so the only plausibility is that he was accepted there because of his grades. Interesting thing to infer, huh?
Akanebanashi is already returning to Japan as soon as she went to Paris. I was kinda stoked for a Paris arc, but that kinda blew out my fire. But that's on me, what was I expecting? An entire arc in Paris about rakugo which is already pretty damn niche in Japan as it is? I'm fine with the development, but I gotta say that it's hard not to feel blue-balled about it.
Super Psychic Policeman Chojo had its first decent chapter about the perv brat. It was funny, and the best part is that the final cure is being insulted by the police chick. Not gonna lie, I too would awaken from a straight-laced stupor under the same conditions... It's a dish not many get to indulge in...
Astro Royale is interesting to read when literally anyone except the MC takes the stage. Tsurugi finally lives up to his name by pulling out a sword. I think everyone has decently interesting abilities except the MC. How many versions of punch harder can you reasonably do? Even Deku had to switch tactics and so on when it came to destroying his body punching hard.
Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi is just doing a big cast showoff, which usually happens when the end is approaching, but I'm not sure. The spread with the demons is cool, but Kiyoshi already went around making 'em look like chumps, so I dunno how much hype they have showing up with all that drip.
Ichi The Witch has me noticing a trend in suicidal protagonists. Oh you know, Deku, just destroying his body to use his Quirk. There's Yuji, who just said sure when they told him they were gonna kill him after he's done being useful. Here's Ichi, who says okay when told the prophecy where he dies to save the world. I'm okay with the whole big messiah development, and it gives the story a very good endgame to look forward to. I'm just thinking that it's about time we had Jump protagonists who actually value their life and wellbeing? Y'know, maybe teach some dumb kids that dying isn't okay? That maybe uh, treasure being alive or something? Haha...
Shinobi Undercover... Wonder if SharkBait reads my crap. Well, if he does, I'm sorry friend, it looks like the BL has turned hetero. Turns out Makoto Yuki was a girl, which I was 40% suspicious of, but since I was so used to pretty boys, I didn't voice out my suspicions. I mean Makoto and Yuki are androgynous names and also the name of the main character of Persona 3. Shinobi Undercover is just a harem manga in disguise, innit? Sort of a harem undercover, haha. It's good that the fight was over quick and now we're going back to romcom shenanigans. Can't wait to see how this fails spectacularly. Anyway, the introduction of Kekkai reminds me of Baki where they do weird techniques with their bodies to get a superhuman effect. Like that one guy that just imagined his arm had 20 hinges and just cracked it as if it did and it worked. I like Baki, so I hope we get to see much more of it cause the fights need to change up a bit to keep it fresh. It also introduces some ninja family lore too... Oh god, someone's gonna be out here with a Sharingan, aren't they?
Hakutaku ends with a patter. It's okay, nothing special. And being nothing special is exactly why it just didn't take off. I think a lot of it was just too bland and lacking in personality to really capture a readerbase. Noto's cool, but the MC, not so much. That said, Noto's big plan of making it to Comiket has me wondering that it'd be funny if some madman made a doujin of her to publish there so they can really say she made it to Comiket. Hahaha... The last gag about making a cute girl had me wondering if it was a throwaway gag or if there's some inside joke with the author who was being told off by the editor that his heroine isn't cute. Usually when I ponder on this, it's hearsay. I have no way of proving it. But when something so throwaway is just dumped on the second last page with so little context, it really makes me think...
Kanna-Ten is still on Kanna's ride... Man... It's so rare for a subheroine to have her route an arc so soon, and especially running for five chapters straight... I get it... Kanna's a great girl... Please... Introduce someone else already... I'm getting too much Kanna...
Syd Craft has me thinking about one thing and one thing only. Lulu's ass. And what a fine ass it was. Damn, that shadowed triangle in the spread really tells you what a dumptruck that thing is. What an ass. 22i wants his hot spring episode and British be damned, he will get his hot spring episode. I do think the blurbs like "Elio is pretending to be a boy!" gets repetitive, but on a weekly reading, it actually makes it easy for anyone to flick open the mag and read Syd Craft from any chapter without losing context or humor. It's great. Now do a five chapter mystery whodunnit arc. Please. I've tasted your women plenty. I'm sold, 22i. So just please do a real whodunnit already. It's great that he's bringing sexy back into the mag after a dry spell of truly sensational content, but I want mysteries. But yeah, maybe he can relax and do a fullblown one now that he's safe. Maybe he just writes these stupid fanservice gag chapters to ease up before he writes some mysteries.
Kill Blue's fights are pretty cool whenever they happen and it's part 2 of the showdown against that dude. It's pretty kick ass. There's just a very strong feeling of ending with how that monologue in the beginning went. I think there's a lot more to do, but there's so much vibes of this being the final battle I don't know how to feel.