- Joined
- Oct 2, 2016
- Messages
- 2,373
- Reaction score
- 12,959
- Gender
- Female
- Country
-
Ugh so I typed a whole thing in word to not accidentally send this message before I'm done, but somehow the site refuses to copy it properly.
Alright so I'm back to haunt you guys just for a little bit.
First things first, I'm noticing a spooky theme in the game (if other claims are truthful of course). Restless spirit + Spirit Medium + Necro. Very spooky very well done. Also very useful in this setting DO USE IT WISELY OR I WILL THROW ACTUAL HOT POTATOES AT YOU GUYS IRL.
I will say, seems like a fun comp if most of you are not lying.
The two prostitutes I'm not so sure about, seems like a lot for a smaller game like this. Panda + Farm do like to balance in pairs, and if this is true I wonder what they paired it against to make it more balanced. I have no idea. Escort + Prosti pair seems more likely for me, but let's not 100% rule it out.
Also stop being weird everyone, why is everyone playing so weirdly lol.
Please do consider the fact that the janitor is likely stealing Gryff's role to claim.
So about the living players:
- Brandish: Seems calmer D2 than D1. I still stand by what I said, the Kami defense was a bit odd feeling. Among the me-voters from yesterday, he’s more sus than Sam and maybe Erin, less sus than Nash. Brandish at least had a good reason (saving himself, which is fair I suppose). Very lucky bomb-disabling. I was considering the scenario Hardy and Brandish would be together, but honestly is there a need for a play like this as a mafia duo? I don't know, let's not throw away this thought.
- Hardy – Speaking of Hardy: On D1, I wasn’t alarmed by Hardy. I did feel that town Hardy tends to be a bit more mean. Perhaps agressive is the right word for it. Being a busy father probably does get in the way of that. The Doc claim is a bit hmm, but I suppose it would work for a bait if you want to murder a mafia perhaps. Very on the nose for him though, it's kinda pulling my good feelings about him away by a lot. Is he mafia bomb or town bomb? That's the question here... Please remember that if Hardy is mafia that does not confirm Brandish.
- DD – Kind of missing him in the discussions today, please do go bother him. It's very easy to go under the radar like this.
- Demon – Very laidback and relaxed for now, I’m not sure if I like that. For me, that’s often a mafia tell for him. Overly mafia alarms? Not this time. Small mafia alarms? Yes. The fact that it's only small alarms is concerning. What is also concerning is that we seem to agree on Nash. Hmmm not sure how to feel about that. I hope you do feel better soo Demon
- Erin – I disliked her D1, did not give good vibes, but not bad enough to really sus honestly. Seems more active but confused today, which happens sometimes, but don't let that slide. it's giving flying under the radar, and that's a dangerous thing. Makes me more suspicious of her. A green hot potato doesn't exist, if I give it to someone I find sus it might very well be a red hot potato the next day. I do hope days get less busy for you and you get to relax a bit Erin
- Gary - Had good vibes so far, I don't think I'm seeing anything wrong with his playing so far. Claims that his role has already been claimed.... Not sure how to feel about that though. Why aren't you exposing them. Necromancer it seems....
- Holt – Feels pretty open with his role, posts are easy to follow and steady. I think he's likely town. Felt that way D1, posts so far on this day point to the same thing.
- James – I don’t think the “afk james is mafia” theory is correct anymore, considering he hasn’t been posting walls like he used to back in the days for a few years now. What we do know is that mafia-James will say anything survive, and quite frankly, does get away with it. The walling now, after getting called out for it, feels very mafia-esque. The question is here, do we want to risk it or investigate that first? Don't wait too long. It's pulling away the focus that could be spent on other players. Not to mention his current defense somehow feels very meh.
A townie blocking James imo makes no sense, but I wonder if he's really lying about what happened last night. No counter claim? Is it the different kind of investigative roles (like SM) or something else?
- Nash – Looking back at D1, I honestly didn’t mind Nash’ gameplay mostly. I thought she was okay, obviously that doesn’t always say that much on D1. What I want to focus on here is the sequence of events in the last hour or so of D1. She was online, but looking back – her presence and way of replying was calculated. Very passive in a way, waiting till other players make a move. And surely, we were all looking at each other to see what was going to happen. Her actions made me feel like she was waiting for something. Perhaps trying to save a mafia-chan? Where was the pressure she likes to put on players? It wasn’t there. Naming a few players, to see how people react to it. Also notice how she did have at least some reasoning for a couple of players but jumped on me with ‘gut feelings’ only. Make it make sense.
I disliked the baiting with different hints. I'm not even surprised anymore it turned out to be something else. Wonder why you didn't go for Kami more yesterday? That’s strange. It felt more like a defense of his statement than anything else.
James and Nash together doesn't really make sense to me, DO NOT completely rule that out though. Could be a mafia ploy, but I'm really wondering if it's one that's worth it at this stage of the game. That's the main thing that's throwing me off of Nash right now.
- Kami - I don't know anymore, PLEASE INVESTIGATE HIM. It feels like the D1 claimers are already getting off easy and that bothers me. Also start making sense, I see you are dropping cryptic things. SHARE IT ALL you are not doing town a favor imo by keeping things in the dark. "reasons" What are those reasons? Do you have a result? Or is it different reasoning? If so than share it, you are not being helpful.
- Sam – I think he’s town. Sam stop following your feelings when you are stressed, that does not work for you. You tend to often murder me in those cases, it’s a pattern. Does confirm the townie-ness for me, but please destress first before you come to the thread. You do seem more chill now.
I did make an image for you yesterday at the time of the cold blooded murder.
- Teub – The random reveal does bother me. There was hardly any pressure, I literally had to go back and try to find it when Erin mentioned that. It almost felt like, oh looks like Kami is getting away with claiming, might as well claim as well because early claiming = town. Also why are we still voting for people with no reasoning? Explain your thought processes, hiding that will do nothing for town.
That said, I'm not sure if that's a stressed-mafia move or an stress-town move. Leaning towards town for now, but it feels somewhat meh.
- Wojak - doesn't really stand out to me, but feels like town so far. I can absolutely be wrong here, I think he managed to follow me before. There are no signs really that indicate being red to me. Wojak DID point out that it's interesting there is no counter claim to James. Hmm.
In conclusion: Actually thinking about it..... Double necro might be used as an investigative role INSTEAD of detective - it kind of adds up with Janitor. If there is also a detective... isn't that too much? Esp considering the other claims. I don't necessarily read both necro-claimers as red. In the case it's true, you guys must reconsider the prosit-situation. SO PLEASE GO INVESTIGATE AND DO NOT LET ME DOWN BC I ACTUALLY WILL THROW POTATOES.
That said I'm happy I'm free now good luck, use your heads please.
Votekill James.
Also one thing, @Teubier please refrain from posting like this. It's not the style of the post, but let's not use slurs and keep this game fun for everyone. It's also not okay to say in rhyming form imo. I don't think this really needs more explanation but I'll be more than happy to discuss it in DM's.
Alright so I'm back to haunt you guys just for a little bit.
First things first, I'm noticing a spooky theme in the game (if other claims are truthful of course). Restless spirit
+ Spirit Medium + Necro. Very spooky very well done. Also very useful in this setting DO USE IT WISELY OR I WILL THROW ACTUAL HOT POTATOES AT YOU GUYS IRL.I will say, seems like a fun comp if most of you are not lying.
The two prostitutes I'm not so sure about, seems like a lot for a smaller game like this. Panda + Farm do like to balance in pairs, and if this is true I wonder what they paired it against to make it more balanced. I have no idea. Escort + Prosti pair seems more likely for me, but let's not 100% rule it out.
Also stop being weird everyone, why is everyone playing so weirdly lol.
Please do consider the fact that the janitor is likely stealing Gryff's role to claim.
So about the living players:
- Brandish: Seems calmer D2 than D1. I still stand by what I said, the Kami defense was a bit odd feeling. Among the me-voters from yesterday, he’s more sus than Sam and maybe Erin, less sus than Nash. Brandish at least had a good reason (saving himself, which is fair I suppose). Very lucky bomb-disabling. I was considering the scenario Hardy and Brandish would be together, but honestly is there a need for a play like this as a mafia duo? I don't know, let's not throw away this thought.
- Hardy – Speaking of Hardy: On D1, I wasn’t alarmed by Hardy. I did feel that town Hardy tends to be a bit more mean. Perhaps agressive is the right word for it. Being a busy father probably does get in the way of that. The Doc claim is a bit hmm, but I suppose it would work for a bait if you want to murder a mafia perhaps. Very on the nose for him though, it's kinda pulling my good feelings about him away by a lot. Is he mafia bomb or town bomb? That's the question here... Please remember that if Hardy is mafia that does not confirm Brandish.
- DD – Kind of missing him in the discussions today, please do go bother him. It's very easy to go under the radar like this.
- Demon – Very laidback and relaxed for now, I’m not sure if I like that. For me, that’s often a mafia tell for him. Overly mafia alarms? Not this time. Small mafia alarms? Yes. The fact that it's only small alarms is concerning. What is also concerning is that we seem to agree on Nash. Hmmm not sure how to feel about that. I hope you do feel better soo Demon
- Erin – I disliked her D1, did not give good vibes, but not bad enough to really sus honestly. Seems more active but confused today, which happens sometimes, but don't let that slide. it's giving flying under the radar, and that's a dangerous thing. Makes me more suspicious of her. A green hot potato doesn't exist, if I give it to someone I find sus it might very well be a red hot potato the next day. I do hope days get less busy for you and you get to relax a bit Erin
- Gary - Had good vibes so far, I don't think I'm seeing anything wrong with his playing so far. Claims that his role has already been claimed.... Not sure how to feel about that though. Why aren't you exposing them. Necromancer it seems....
- Holt – Feels pretty open with his role, posts are easy to follow and steady. I think he's likely town. Felt that way D1, posts so far on this day point to the same thing.
- James – I don’t think the “afk james is mafia” theory is correct anymore, considering he hasn’t been posting walls like he used to back in the days for a few years now. What we do know is that mafia-James will say anything survive, and quite frankly, does get away with it. The walling now, after getting called out for it, feels very mafia-esque. The question is here, do we want to risk it or investigate that first? Don't wait too long. It's pulling away the focus that could be spent on other players. Not to mention his current defense somehow feels very meh.
A townie blocking James imo makes no sense, but I wonder if he's really lying about what happened last night. No counter claim? Is it the different kind of investigative roles (like SM) or something else?
- Nash – Looking back at D1, I honestly didn’t mind Nash’ gameplay mostly. I thought she was okay, obviously that doesn’t always say that much on D1. What I want to focus on here is the sequence of events in the last hour or so of D1. She was online, but looking back – her presence and way of replying was calculated. Very passive in a way, waiting till other players make a move. And surely, we were all looking at each other to see what was going to happen. Her actions made me feel like she was waiting for something. Perhaps trying to save a mafia-chan? Where was the pressure she likes to put on players? It wasn’t there. Naming a few players, to see how people react to it. Also notice how she did have at least some reasoning for a couple of players but jumped on me with ‘gut feelings’ only. Make it make sense.
I disliked the baiting with different hints. I'm not even surprised anymore it turned out to be something else. Wonder why you didn't go for Kami more yesterday? That’s strange. It felt more like a defense of his statement than anything else.
James and Nash together doesn't really make sense to me, DO NOT completely rule that out though. Could be a mafia ploy, but I'm really wondering if it's one that's worth it at this stage of the game. That's the main thing that's throwing me off of Nash right now.
- Kami - I don't know anymore, PLEASE INVESTIGATE HIM. It feels like the D1 claimers are already getting off easy and that bothers me. Also start making sense, I see you are dropping cryptic things. SHARE IT ALL you are not doing town a favor imo by keeping things in the dark. "reasons" What are those reasons? Do you have a result? Or is it different reasoning? If so than share it, you are not being helpful.
- Sam – I think he’s town. Sam stop following your feelings when you are stressed, that does not work for you. You tend to often murder me in those cases, it’s a pattern. Does confirm the townie-ness for me, but please destress first before you come to the thread. You do seem more chill now.
I did make an image for you yesterday at the time of the cold blooded murder.
- Teub – The random reveal does bother me. There was hardly any pressure, I literally had to go back and try to find it when Erin mentioned that. It almost felt like, oh looks like Kami is getting away with claiming, might as well claim as well because early claiming = town. Also why are we still voting for people with no reasoning? Explain your thought processes, hiding that will do nothing for town.
That said, I'm not sure if that's a stressed-mafia move or an stress-town move. Leaning towards town for now, but it feels somewhat meh.
- Wojak - doesn't really stand out to me, but feels like town so far. I can absolutely be wrong here, I think he managed to follow me before. There are no signs really that indicate being red to me. Wojak DID point out that it's interesting there is no counter claim to James. Hmm.
In conclusion: Actually thinking about it..... Double necro might be used as an investigative role INSTEAD of detective - it kind of adds up with Janitor. If there is also a detective... isn't that too much? Esp considering the other claims. I don't necessarily read both necro-claimers as red. In the case it's true, you guys must reconsider the prosit-situation. SO PLEASE GO INVESTIGATE AND DO NOT LET ME DOWN BC I ACTUALLY WILL THROW POTATOES.
That said I'm happy I'm free now good luck, use your heads please.
Votekill James.
Also one thing, @Teubier please refrain from posting like this. It's not the style of the post, but let's not use slurs and keep this game fun for everyone. It's also not okay to say in rhyming form imo. I don't think this really needs more explanation but I'll be more than happy to discuss it in DM's.
