Yup. I don’t really understand how the term ”safe choice” came about.
Afaik there is no safe choice here. Either we flip a red through the lynch, or we mislynch, a kill in the night, and D4 doesn’t come to be. There is no winning without getting a red today. So nothing safe in any choice, that’s what makes it hard and why a lot of thought should be given. Patience is necessary here. Mafia will be patient, they got the best scenario.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I’m sorry @wojak. I don’t know what your alignment is. But if you are town you really did us a disservice. And the reasoning that you gave for sicklying me was, imho, feeble at best.
Now, that’s done and we work with what we have, no choice.
I’ll try to take another look at Nash’s posts to see if I can gather something.
I wouldn't want to play against a mafia Nash. No wonder she got killed last night.
A shame that I had already used Gryffindor’s Doctor...
Damn. Re-reading Nash’s posts, her pool of suspects, her interactions with you Hardy, your own posts. Factoring in the way the votes went yesterday. Including what I think about what James’ role could really be instead of his dubious claim... it’s hard to make a case for you. I wouldn't be surprised if you were the one who sicklied Demonspeed. And I wouldn't be surprised by two mafia with sickly.
Damn. Re-reading Nash’s posts, her pool of suspects, her interactions with you Hardy, your own posts. Factoring in the way the votes went yesterday. Including what I think about what James’ role could really be instead of his dubious claim... it’s hard to make a case for you. I wouldn't be surprised if you were the one who sicklied Demonspeed. And I wouldn't be surprised by two mafia with sickly.
Yes. James or Holt wad losing a Janitor whichever way. Losing James was less consequential as it wouldn’t have revealed Gryffindor’s and Gary’s role.
And she didn’t stop you voting Holt. Never. She told you to dedicate. You chose James on your own accord.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
If I’m right, mafia is indeed patient and none have voted so far. So Sam and Sifu will have to lock Hardy to force a cointoss.
To make things clear, here is my take on the situation :
_ James = 2nd Janitor.
_ Hardy = mafia bomb + sickly.
_ Wojak = mafia ??? + sickly.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Yes. James or Holt wad losing a Janitor whichever way. Losing James was less consequential as it wouldn’t have revealed Gryffindor’s and Gary’s role.
And she didn’t stop you voting Holt. Never. She told you to dedicate. You chose James on your own accord.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
If I’m right, mafia is indeed patient and none have voted so far. So Sam and Sifu will have to lock Hardy to force a cointoss.
She did. When you popped in the thread I agreed with you but she told you to stop until DD and me locked AKA "dont go there". I asked her specifically what she wanted me to do and what was the issue and she said this:
Her fear was mafia voting for James then voting away if they had an opportunity. To show I wasn't doing that I locked on James the moment she made it clear she wanted me to do that. If she said Holt I'd had voted Holt because I didn't trust him either, but she didn't. From my point of view she was seeing it as "an out" and I just followed her.
Like I said a lot of times now, odds are that if she told me to vote Holt and I voted Holt then James would had been lynched and I'd be in the same spot now.
What does role revealing change at this point of the game anyway? If James was lynched over Holt then the latter would still not be trusted at all as he was yesterday, revealed roles or not. What do the Gryf and Gary role change in the world view?
I actually suspect Nash blocked me last night but I have nothing other than a hunch.
Yeah. I’ll be frank with you Hardy. At this point it’s a done deal for me.
I am convinced about my take on things. I trust DD and Sam are town.
The timing of the votes, both yesterday and today, make sense for a mafteam of you/james/wojak/holt.
Mafia were forced to lose someone yesterday because of those early votes from town.
Mafia were forced to create a situation where it would be a 3v3 voters today, to ensure a cointoss in the worst case for them. Hence the second sickly who acted.
This is it. I’m hoping that Sam and Sifu will lock you so that we at least have a 50/50.
Good luck mafia. I want to win this game, fingers crossed the cointoss goes our way.
Yeah. I’ll be frank with you Hardy. At this point it’s a done deal for me.
I am convinced about my take on things. I trust DD and Sam are town.
The timing of the votes, both yesterday and today, make sense for a mafteam of you/james/wojak/holt.
Mafia were forced to lose someone yesterday because of those early votes from town.
Mafia were forced to create a situation where it would be a 3v3 voters today, to ensure a cointoss in the worst case for them. Hence the second sickly who acted.
This is it. I’m hoping that Sam and Sifu will lock you so that we at least have a 50/50.
Good luck mafia. I want to win this game, fingers crossed the cointoss goes our way.
I've been wanting James dead since day 2 when I locked super early how can I be in the same team as him? Even today I was campaigning to lynch him which Demon didn't like. Woj I also disliked several times this game and even voted me like two days I think? Based on Demon's summary. He's only looking better for me today because a second sickly popped.
I agree with the second part but it has nothing to do with me at all.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I've been stuck in this cursed if you do cursed if you don't situation the whole game starting with Brandish defusing me. Bait bomb or not. Come clean or not. Vote James or not. Lock or not. Vote Holt or not. Felt like just giving up several times and will take a break after this one for sure, very annoying.
Bro you are not an anime protagonist what are you doing
I literally just complained about Erin's lock. If Sam or one of DD/woj don't follow we are fucked, I need to know if they'll go there or maybe are more comfortable switching to Erin. Idgaf, both are scum (though James surviving any longer would be stupid).
Wdym you and me? Where are you even getting these?
I'll hit the bed but won't miss EoD, put an alarm and everything.
It was very bad We're all emphasising the need to thoroughly discuss what we know before deciding to lock and then the very next minute she locks following a joke from Demon; unsure if thats a town playing poorly or a mafia trying to capitalise on what they thought was a growing mislynch possibility
Sam is focused on James and Erin, trying to make the latter look scummy especially. Nothing about Hardy, DD etc. He already voted James without saying anything substantial about it.
Sam is focused on James and Erin, trying to make the latter look scummy especially. Nothing about Hardy, DD etc. He already voted James without saying anything substantial about it.
What do you want me to say? I'm trying to figure out why Erin is so shonky, surely you see how I see her coming across as less trustworthy? Its like she's in another dimension at times with how disconnected she is
What do you want from me? I don't have the time to invest heavily in the game currently as I have extremely pressing deadlines to meet
If I see something I think is shit, like the act of rushing to lock like Erin did, then regardless of target I think that deserves criticism. This is do or die, if we mislynch then the scums win yet caution got thrown out the window. Yes Hardy can be scum and quite possibly is, but are you telling me you seriously believe James at this point?
What I need to be sure of is that Hardy through process of elimination is the best lynch to keep town in it. From my perspective, I'm a Psychiatrist so I know that I have to be finding something- be it the hidden sickly or something else. What baffles me though is the doubt some have about me which feels very odd. James flipped from trusting me for most of the game to suddenly distrusting me after I locked on Holt yesterday. It's such a significant shift, and then you've got others bouncing on that argument too in fashions that sound so genuinely inauthentic.
I'm fucking lost in this game and two Janitors is the biggest fucking bit of bullshit I've seen since the Clown role, but at least try and understand my concerns instead of getting swept up by bad actors and town dickheads wanting me gone.