Top 3 most sus for you atm?
Lemme go through everyone, it'll help form my thoughts on my end as well:
Brandi - First to vote Kako, beyond that hasn't really pushed for anyone else. Seems to trust Nash and Erin above the town average (#348). Seems to be taking it chill thusfar, not sure if that's indicative of anything.
DD - Left their D1 vote on a meme vote, said something somewhat supportive of Nash, said something somewhat unsupportive of Gry, James and Erin, has voted Gry in line with the latter, but no posts indicate anything to actually back up these views, aside from Gry voting them up d1.
Eri - Pretty empty D1 but voting out the inactive makes sense when you got no reads yet. Poked Gry and Lawl a little, poked Sam a lot (understandable), but seems to mostly have limited her reads to "the people who wagoned me yesterday are sus". I do like how she is trying to gain more info from other townies by poking them to give reads, that's always a plus.
Gry - Opens with "my role will be ineffective" which irks me a bit. Seems to trust Brandish, myself, nash and somewhat teubs during d1, which is curious because Brandish' d1 until that point was 90% meme posts and otherwise voting Kako and some minor interactions with Nash. It seems surprisingly out-of-nowhere. On the other side, the vote on DD is reasonable in my eyes. Poking Erin, James and Teub (understandably on the last one) during D2. Greenchecks Holt and AP (what...). I would love to see a fleshed out viewlist from Gry at this point.
Holt - Not a lot to analyse so far, hints about their role, votes Nash, targets me with their ability, continues to tunnel Nash. Hoping to see more from Holt, since railing on the town abuse goblin could be a form of coasting.
James - Missed ya buddy, unfortunate you weren't here D1. Poked Gry a bit, pokes Nash a lot, but the sentiments mirror those I've shared here so I feel quite good on James right now. Plus, his reasoning for his ability use (Marm was nice to him) feels townie. I only know James for the duration of 1 game, but I got the impression that trying to corner the mechanics is one of his things, plus he only just arrived, so I'm unsure what people were expecting of him.
Lawl - Aside from their samurai convo, made a meme vote on d1 and kept it. Spent most of D2 wailing on the abuse goblin (Nash) and left a vote on James without explanation. Not inspiring a lot of confidence, plus seems strangely fixated on Samurai. Would love to hear the reasoning for the James vote, and if there are any other reads.
Marms - Shared my view on Nash, poked AP a little, voted Kako, greenchecked Sam, poked soon to die Kako for d1. Generally, pretty median behavior. I do like that she tried to prevent a thunderdome between Sam and Erin, having those this early in the game is unconductive, so I agree with that. Her reads during d2 are effectively "Nash, Gry, Teubs, Lawl and James are concerning, Sam is green", which continues her greenchecking of Sam from d1 so at least that's consistent.
Nash - Sigh. Claims hider d1. Consequently became the abuse goblin for the rest of town from that point onwards. Does an early greencheck on me, sam and teubs, which is interesting considering Sam costarred her Eri wagon later on. Interacted a lot with people's hints and the getting of more of them. Early vote on AP is curious considering AP wasn't the only one who had hinted solely being active. Shares sentiment against Kako and Erin and a tiny bit marms early on, so at least it stayed consistent. Said Teub is acting pretty townlike despite having only memeposted until then. Then says she would consider voting James if there's no better vote, then says she is still between Kako and AP and would vote James between Erin and James, then ultimately wagons Erin with Sam. Bit incoherent all in all for d1. Hides behind me (brave) during the night. D2 is mostly on the defense, understandably so, and redchecks mostly people who wailed on the abuse goblin, also understandable. Her reads list is pretty alright, even if I don't agree entirely. If Brandish ever flips evil she is defo evil as well. Beyond that, I do get the impression she is just overwhelmed and misplaying town at this point.
PIdge - Opening comments are surprisingly adversarial towards common tactics (dislikes early voters, dislikes people using votes as pressure, dislikes people giving early reads, dislikes big hints, what exactly are we supposed to do d1 then hahaha). After getting voted by Nash, tears into her and votes her later on. Also negatively associates DD with Nash. D2 has AP drop DD for Teub on the 'also bad alongside Nash' list, which is kinda wild. Stated not to have used their ability.
Sam - Mr Big Poster, let's go. Thankfully the first page is all memes. Page 2 is discussing hints or my claim. Did greencheck a bunch of people at differing degrees, which is interesting cause that early on a lot of the greenchecking had to come from people's memeposts considering most of d1 was memeposting. Top green were myself, Nash, Teubs and Gry, where Nash has myself, Teubs, Brandish, Gry and Sam and Gry has myself, Brandish, Nash and lesser Teubs. Feels a bit cabalish. Interaction with Erin start of d2 feels normal. Defends Nash quite thoroughly. Asks the 2 Gry voters for elaboration (would love to hear it as well). Appreciate the posts with hints and mechanics, feels like someone trying to make information more freely available, which is pretty towncore. His reads list has decent elaboration, and I agree with plenty of it, so really, Sam is either a phenomenal deepwolf trying to keep his team afloat or just town. If any of the cabal flips red, maybe consider him, otherwise, nah.
Teub - D1 is memes and an unexplained Gry vote. Started D2 claiming that he would have swapped to Erin if he was awake. Then votes Gry again, once again mostly unexplained (Wth is Mazino Freeman). Used his ability on Sam. Would love to hear reasoning for the Gry vote, or even just more interactions with others.
So, end results, my top 3 sus would be:
AP, Teub, DD, in that order. The next 3 would be Gry, Lawl, Brandish.
Analysis and formatting all this has taken 2h. Jesus why did I do this.
