Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump (2026) - News and Discussion!

Shinuki no Reborn

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
15,818
Reaction score
40,932
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Moderator Notice:

WEEKLY SHONEN JUMP THREAD RULES​

#1. No fights or personal insults.
#2. No bait or troll comments with the intention of being annoying or starting serious heated discussions, if i notice it's a continuous behavior, i will warn the user or delete the comment.
#3. No toxic attitude towards series, no one is obligated to enjoy any series and it's totally fine to criticize what you don't like, just avoid posting gratuitous hateful or toxic comments about X or Y series, if i notice this behavior, comments will be deleted.
#4. Don't bring politics or off-topic stuff to the thread, this is about Weekly Shonen Jump magazine and mangas, so keep any conversation about topics that aren't related about anime & manga outside the thread.
#5. Don't post news about series from other magazine or publishers in the WSJ thread, post in the series own thread, but it's fine if you're mentioning other series or magazine to express a opinion or reflection about Shonen Jump.
#6. Any tweet, specially japanese, about news, update or some interesting thing about the magazine or series has to come with a text of what that tweet means and also be on topic, if not it's going to be either deleted or i will edit the post.
#7. Refrain from self advertising or advertising Youtubers videos in the comments.
#8. Constant fanart posts just for the sake of praising a favorite series is prohibited, this rule doesn't apply for official art by Jump artists posted on social media, they're fine to post.
#9. Don't discuss or hype chapter spoilers before Sunday release, only comment if is related to a series surviving status and do it only inside the spoiler tag.
#10. Regarding rule #9, an exception will be made for when we have new series, in this case, spoilers will be allowed only for the first 3 chapters of a new series for the users who are interested in knowing informations and details about the new series, these spoilers will obviously be kept under tags to protect anyone that doesn't want to be spoiled, so don't worry about it.
~ Shinuki

I hope everyone reads the rules and use it as a guide to behave well in the thread, thanks! :kkthumbs
 
Last edited:

Shinuki no Reborn

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
15,818
Reaction score
40,932
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Weekly Shonen Jump Issue #51 (2026)
00. Jan is in Danger! (New Series by Nakama Ryo, Cover & Lead Color Pages)
01. Sakamoto Days
02. Ichi the Witch
03. Someone Hertz
00. Witch Watch (Color Page, End)
04. Akane-banashi
05. The Ura Files
00. Shinobi Undercover (Color Page)
06. Roku's House of Oddities
07. Animal Signal
08. Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi
00. Graykeith: Translator Daemonica (Color Page)
09. Me & Roboco
10. Nue's Exorcist
11. Under Doctor
12. Hal Formula
13. Class 2B Hero Destroyerz
14. Kagurabachi
15. Cannon Master
00. One Piece (Absent)

Weekly Shonen Jump Issue #52 (2026) - Information!
Mr. Hizuki of the Ginza Backstreet Police Box (New Series by Gondaira Hitsuji, Cover & Lead Color Pages)
Sakamoto Days (Color Page, End)
Jan is in Danger! (Color Page)
Nue's Exorcist (Color Page)
 

Kiaida

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2021
Messages
1,589
Reaction score
3,867
Country
United Nations
Even though it's full of jokes, Kimetsu's humor has never been the most prominent aspect of the series,
Zenitsu literally is a major character that has major battles all happening during his gag, his main ability is a gag. In fact, Inosuke, Zenitsu, Nezuko and Tanjiro is a very non serious main party. They all get their cool and serious moments, but they ALL have long running gags that never go away and show up during the fights as well.

 
Last edited:

ZodiacofDarkness

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2025
Messages
105
Reaction score
144
Age
26
Country
Australia
Zenitsu literally is a major character that has major battles all happening during his gag, his main ability is a gag. In fact, Inosuke, Zenitsu, Nezuko and Tanjiro is a very non serious main party. They all get their cool and serious moments, but they ALL have long running gags that never go away and show up during the fights as well.

I haven't read Death Note, so it's interesting that he (I should really get to know the death-like guy's name) is fond of Mario Golf.
 

Stivie

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Apr 23, 2019
Messages
3,274
Reaction score
2,359
Age
38
Country
Brazil
Zenitsu literally is a major character that has major battles all happening during his gag, his main ability is a gag. In fact, Inosuke, Zenitsu, Nezuko and Tanjiro is a very non serious main party. They all get their cool and serious moments, but they ALL have long running gags that never go away and show up during the fights as well.

Does that turn Kimetsu into a gag comedy now? Of course not.
I always participate in discussions about Kimetsu, and comedy is the least discussed topic.
Enviar
 

SharkBait

MH Senpai
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2013
Messages
14,186
Reaction score
6,985
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I haven't read Death Note, so it's interesting that he (I should really get to know the death-like guy's name) is fond of Mario Golf.
Omg please get into death note,
Live Action Japanese Movies from the 2000's/2010's: Best Death Note Adaptation (must watch)
Live Action Japanese Death Note TV Drama: 2nd best version, most iconic scenes
Original Anime: Must Watch
 

ItsSamu

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2020
Messages
666
Reaction score
2,997
Gender
Male
Country
Scotland
Even though it's full of jokes, Kimetsu's humor has never been the most prominent aspect of the series, and even the main group has two comic relief characters, Inosuke and Zenitsu. The dramatic part has always been the most prominent in Kimetsu; if you remember, the first chapter begins with the massacre of the protagonist's family. Kimetsu was never about elusive samurai; on the contrary, it was always more down-to-earth.

Even Kanroji, who is a comic relief character in the series, ended up dead in the last arc. Only you want to say that Kimetsu's humor has always been debated, but that's not true.
A series is not beholden to its first chapter in every regard. Authors find the identity of a long-running series through the week-to-week process and because they have to come up with it on the spot they're going to explore new story and comedic directions that make (a) for the better reading experience in their mind and (b) better for them to work on. You can tell when an author is just having a good time exploring something new of fresh and that is often in a series' humour. Demon Slayer has a very dark first chapter, but it's also a series that doesn't let itself be consumed in that darkness, and very quickly you get a good sense of Koyoharu Gotouge's sense of humour which carries out in pretty much every chapter in the series from that point onwards (which, for the record, I don't especially even like! But it doesn't disprove anything of what I'm saying because that's my taste and clearly it's different from the majority opinion).

People might not talk about the comedy of Demon Slayer, but that's because comedy isn't something that usually lends to in depth discussion in the same way that character development or plot analysis, especially online. All we can really say is: that was funny or it wasn't. We can break down the mechanics of a successful joke, but if you do that too often it kind of defeats the inherit fun-ness of it. Comedy isn't mean tot be discussed in the same way but that doesn't mean it isn't as appreciated or vital in enjoying a series.

One example recently you've clung onto is the idea that Roku was advertised as a "horror comedy", but you've used the fact that it leans into the comedy too much as a negative. I'm guessing you also didn't continue reading because you incorrectly said that it had abandoned its story that it set up, when its in fact delivered some truly horrific chapters as of late - not horrific in that its difficult to turn the page because of a jump scare or there are crazy monster designs, but in its exploring the deeply unsettling implications of someone being murdered and having to confront that about themself even when they can't remember it. And the one confronting it is the first boy her age she can call a friend.

But the series will return to telling jokes before long, and that's exactly what it should do, because that's what the author intended with the series and why he made it (and is making it well). The impact of the heavy, dramatic scenes pays off even more because of the light that comes in the humour and us feeling like these characters are family. If It was all grim then it would be harder to main a positive connection with them. Every joke about and featuring Sachiko only serves to elevate the horror of her current story. More comedy = a better story!
 
Last edited:

Stivie

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Apr 23, 2019
Messages
3,274
Reaction score
2,359
Age
38
Country
Brazil
A series is not beholden to its first chapter in every regard. Authors find the identity of a long-running series through the week-to-week process and because they have to come up with it on the spot they're going to explore new story and comedic directions that make (a) for the better reading experience in their mind and (b) better for them to work on. You can tell when an author is just having a good time exploring something new of fresh and that is often in a series' humour. Demon Slayer has a very dark first chapter, but it's also a series that doesn't let itself be consumed in that darkness, and very quickly you get a good sense of Koyoharu Gotouge's sense of humour which carries out in pretty much every chapter in the series from that point onwards (which, for the record, I don't especially even like! But it doesn't disprove anything of what I'm saying because that's my taste and clearly it's different from the majority opinion).

People might not talk about the comedy of Demon Slayer, but that's because comedy isn't something that usually lends to in depth discussion in the same way that character development or plot analysis, especially online. All we can really say is: that was funny or it wasn't. We can break down the mechanics of a successful joke, but if you do that too often it kind of defeats the inherit fun-ness of it. Comedy isn't mean tot be discussed in the same way but that doesn't mean it isn't as appreciated or vital in enjoying a series.

One examples recently you've clung onto is the idea that Roku was advertised as a "horror comedy", but you've used the fact that it leans into the comedy too much as a negative. I'm guessing you also didn't continue reading because you incorrectly said that it had abandoned its story that it set up, when its in fact delivered some truly horrific chapters as of late - not horrific in that its difficult to turn the page because of a jump scare or there are crazy monster designs, but in its exploring the deeply unsettling implications of someone being murdered and having to confront that about themself even when they can't remember it. And the one confronting it is the first boy her age she can call a friend.

But the series will return to telling jokes before long, and that's exactly what it should do, because that's example what the author intended with the series and why he made it (and is making it well). The impact of the heavy, dramatic scenes pays off even more because of the light that comes in the humour and us feeling like these characters are family. If It was all grim then it would be harder to main a positive connection with them. Every joke about and featuring Sachiko only serves to elevate the horror of her current story. More comedy = a better story!
You speak as if Kimetsu followed a path similar to Witch Watch and had chapters entirely dedicated to comedy, which is not true. Yes, we can see Gotouge's sense of humor, but that didn't erase the darkness of Kimetsu no Yaiba; otherwise, Rengoku wouldn't have died, as well as a good part of the main cast in the last arc.
What you said about, "people don't talk about Demon Slayer's humor, but that happens because humor generally doesn't lend itself to in-depth discussions," only reinforces the fact that comedy was never the main focus of Kimetsu; you're just trying to force disagreement just for the sake of it.
And changing the subject to Roku, what's the point of "having those horrible chapters"? That's not going to become a horror story; it's just a lie that everyone bought into simply because it's a comedy, just like Ura, which is a patchwork of several manga and a repetition of formula, but it's a comedy, so everyone accepts it.
Kimetsu no Yaiba isn't the comedy series you're trying to sell it as; even though it has comedy elements, that was never the main point of the series.
 

rg24

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2019
Messages
74
Reaction score
73
Age
33
Country
Argentina
Regarding "vague aspects". It's his job to translate those vague aspects right, isn't it? What's his job then, if not translating those? He is in the context of the story (he has to be), in the context of character's abilities, but he kept slipping. I understand it might be hard, but that's the job, so that's not really justifiable. I'm not trying to attack him as a person or anything, but if you're a transaltor and your translations are wrong on regular basis, you're just not a good enough transaltor. Maybe JJK was a hard series to translate, fine, then Werry's not at this level, and there is nothing wrong with that.

Regarding twitter and victimhood. I don't really follow twitter, neither did I compare him to ai nor worst transaltor of all time, all I did was point out that there is simply nothing to celebrate for Bachi fans. That was a wild claim to make.

Sure there are a lot of overreactions, however. Dunno if there is an english analogue, but we in Russia have a saying: first you work for your name, then your name works for you. Werry unfortunately built a himself quite a reputation, so any minor mistake will be spun out, but he didn't even bothered to confirm the most important part of the chapter, lol.
Looks like people are not aware that translators aren't the only one doing the input in the text that ends in the manga and in most cases they don't decide anything. After they do the translation it goes to the editorial team that not only check the quality of it but also decides a bunch of stuff of how the characters should sound and in cases like the names if they should be keep it or changed, translators can say if translate them could change or not in some the reading but they don't decide it.
In this case it looks like nor the translator had time to check the what the series was doing nor the editorial team to check and change the difference. I would bet that when the vol release the chapter will be redoit with the original translator and keep the continuity.
 

RealityChecker

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2025
Messages
861
Reaction score
388
Age
35
Country
Gotei 13
And changing the subject to Roku, what's the point of "having those horrible chapters"? That's not going to become a horror story; it's just a lie that everyone bought into simply because it's a comedy, just like Ura, which is a patchwork of several manga and a repetition of formula, but it's a comedy, so everyone accepts it.
Random Ura slander.
 

Magister Xehanort

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 29, 2019
Messages
344
Reaction score
1,374
Age
32
Country
Brazil
You speak as if Kimetsu followed a path similar to Witch Watch and had chapters entirely dedicated to comedy, which is not true.
That's not what he was talking about, he didn't even make that comparison. He didn't say Kimetsu was a comedy, but that it had a lot of humor and some jokes. I don't understand how many times you can't understand what people are saying.
 

Stivie

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Apr 23, 2019
Messages
3,274
Reaction score
2,359
Age
38
Country
Brazil
That's not what he was talking about, he didn't even make that comparison. He didn't say Kimetsu was a comedy, but that it had a lot of humor and some jokes. I don't understand how many times you can't understand what people are saying.
I understood what he said, but he didn't understand that even with a lot of humor and jokes, that's not what caught the audience's attention in Kimetsu no Yaiba.
 

RealityChecker

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2025
Messages
861
Reaction score
388
Age
35
Country
Gotei 13
I don't think there is a single aspect that caught anyone's attention to any series. For example, there are countless people who like the comedy arcs of Gintama, while there is a reasonable amount that likes the drama arcs. Others like the battle and stuff. You can even take HunterXHunter. There is drama, battle, game stylized chapters, and each person likes what they like.
 

Shockzz1234

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2025
Messages
223
Reaction score
417
Country
United Kingdom
Issue 51 rankings:

Tier 1 (Great):

1: Akanebanashi #230 –
Hahaha, I actually like the story told here, the old samurai just peacing out from the duel is pretty funny. The audience can’t help but react with a roar and the director of the tv show is well and truly humbled. Good! Mannnnn, she’s basically self declared herself as an Arakawa disciple now instead of a Shiguma one. I mean, they’re both “Arakawa” but once is very different from the other lol and it’s clear she doesn’t mean Shiguma’s ways. Guriko is here to rescue the day and bring her back from the wrong path, goooooo Guriko! Also random, but I really like Karashi realising that even though her and Hikari are Akene’s friends and rivals, they can’t be the ones to break her out of her current funk. It has to be someone else, someone even closer, someone from the same family – enter Guriko (and hopefully the rest of her Arakawa brothers).

2: Roku #30 – Altra has a nice goal, to learn to control her curse powers so she can go out more! Gevaudan has the right idea for the summer tbh. Senpai by 57 years must be a new record lol. Turns out Sachiko was sick when she was alive, interesting. Being stabbed to death on your first day back for ages is extra rough. So her murder turned into one of those incidents that people speculate on forever until even the most ridiculous of suggestions and theories become commonplace to talk about. I predict that the murderer is still probably alive as well, an old man by now of course, and that we’ll come across him in this arc. I also just realised while typing this that there’s a good chance Roku’s granny might also know some details right? It would have happened when she was young. I like this! Detective Roku is on the case!

3: Witch Watch #270 (FINAL) –
Welp, we’re finally here, the end. The final colour page is very nice, very bittersweet. Ohhh Moi got hit by the “bad haircut when you’re an adult” curse that shounen MCs tend to get (except Ichigo). He and Nico had a kid?!?! Fairs. Seven years is a big jump. Kanshi now has impressive standing! But we all know he’s still a goofball lmao. Keigo got the travelling ending, nice. And Miharu continued his studies. All good and appropriate endings for them honestly. Ahhh yep Kanshi is still a loser lmaoooo, yeah, that tracks. Stop being a bum! LMAO Keigo’s “journey” was just him visiting his mother and venting for a bit, and then he didn’t tell people he came back so that he could seem cool, yeah once again, that tracks. Nemu and him dated for a bit and then she dumped him lol, kinda annoyed about that after all the trouble we went to with their relationship, bleh. I’m just gonna imagine that they get back together eventually lol. And Miharu is uhhh…..involved in some vague ass company that may or may not get rich. Yeah that also tracks. Miko is just a normal child huh? You don’t wanna wait till she’s a bit older to make sure? Lol. Ewww Moi is a police officer. I mean, it fits but still. And yep, Miko does indeed have magic lol. A witch with presumably the power of an Oni…dangerous combo. Better hope she grows up to be nice, with all the people around her, I’m sure she will though. Theeeee end. I think overall it was a bit of a rushed ending, could have used some more SoL chapters to end it on and some more breathing room for everything, we didn’t even see Momochi for example in this chapter despite her being basically a part of the family and we could have done more with Nemu as well, but overall it wasn’t as bad as some others and the rest of the series held up pretty much all the way through. I really love the cast of characters Shinohara created here and the vibes were always immaculate. Gonna miss it, and I award it 8/10 in the end!

4: Greykeith #10 – The colour page is gorgeous. Victor casually going to sleep in the coffin is pretty funny. Wait he’s named Victor…and he’s Undead….and he has…..Unluck??? This has to be on purpose right? Like it’s absolutely a reference/homage…right? Anyway. Making the Undead human again is an interesting goal, and so far from what we’ve seen, most of them would be for it. I wonder if over the course of this arc, the undead become able to accept themselves as undead rather than wanting to be human. Oh the talisman turned the undead into basically zombies…funny. Greykeith being pissed that he keeps getting interrupted whilst trying to translate is very funny and relatable, like damn, lemme do my job. Honestly if that’s his reason for beating the shit out of the magician (who’s name is revealed to be Hu Niang), instead of just “saving everyone” that would be hilarious. The “saving everyone” part can come later from translating the book lol.

5: Under Doctor #40 – Aww, Shuli got a haircut. Looks good! It kinda looks like an early 2000s manga character type haircut lol. Like a Yugioh character, but not the main character, a Joey or a Kaiba type of haircut. Anyway. Lmao Shintaro’s face as he snitched on Shuli, little shit. Meanwhile Haiji and Chiwako are randomly in London. Nice. I get Shintaro honestly. Being misdiagnosed like that constantly must be annoying and since he’s a kid, he’ll obviously take everything to the extreme. Shuli and him are becoming good friends though, I like this for both of them! Good to hear he made it through the surgery and they became good friends! Wholesome chapter!

Tier 2 (Good):

Sakamoto Days #283 –
A year long timeskip. I like Shin’s look! He looks like Sakamoto lol. And Sakamoto’s store has become a whole chain of stores, nice. Nagumo is indeed alive. Also nice. Hana as the older sister figure is cute…..HOW DID SHE GET KIDANPPED SO EASILY?! Lmaooo. These poor stupid goons. Anyway, final chapter next, right? What a journey.

Kagurabachi #139 – Well a surprise attack that wasn’t prophesied. Not good. Even Akemura can’t stand up to Shurin. I mean, yeah he’s still a kid but goddamn, I expected a BIT more lol. Anyway, Giyu is lowkey a boss, missing an arm and still jumping into the fight anyway. This fight probably won’t end well for him, but I hope he shows off a bit. Also NOOO WHY IS JOHN WERRY TRANSLATING THE SERIES NOW NOOOOOOO

Someone Hertz #57 – Mimei is too worried about the Mon-Mid submissions to enjoy the trip nooooo, you’re only young once, enjoy it! The Mon-Mid stuff can be done at any age! Oooh, they’re sneaking out, how naughty. I used to do that on school trips as well lol. Also it’ll forever be funny to me how Japan counts time, fucking “26:50” for 2:50am lol.

Shinobi Undercover #105 –
Hibari’s team, yikes, good luck with that lmao. Meanwhile Umineko’s team is….even worse? Maybe? Hayabusa is good but this Kokko kid just gets injured by everything, she’s like that one fish in Spongebob who breaks every bone in his body just by living. Weirdly, Suzume’s team didn’t get a proper intro and one of her teammates is being held as a mystery, so we’ll see what’s up there in due time I suppose. Yodaka has Mugimaki! Kinda funny. And their last member is Kijibato’s grandson and he’s a freakin’ shut in and kind of a loser who doesn’t want to participate lmao. I like the dynamics! A nice way to freshen things up!

Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi #116 – Kiyoshi unlocks Black Precept Power! Kinda cool that taking in some Demon power basically made it mix in with him permanently. He instantly learned it, scuppering his granny’s plans lmao, unlucky. Dark Knights is a super badass name for people with this power. Even Kunikara hasn’t seen one before. As if Kiyoshi isn’t Ultimate enough. Little Pokemon reference! Actually the Pokemon ref helps me understand it, everything should be explained in Pokemon terms lol. Basically, he resists Demon attacks but when he attacks Demons, his attacks are super effective (like Dragon types in Pokemon). Of course, it has the drawback of draining stamina very quickly, a classic. I understand Kunikara and that losing Exorcists on mass to the war eventually takes a toll on you. Kiyoshi has a decent rebuttal imo about how they continue to live, in a way, and their wills are passed on to new Exorcists. Well anyway, Kunikara put his chips in with Rushihara to end the war, which I mean….putting your lot in with demons if you hate demons is probably not wise. The last page looks fucking sick.

HAL Formula #21 –
Hell yeah, Adler Lights have their own racing sim now! Nice! Wonder what Dan’s problem is? Maybe he just isn’t used to the new team setup yet, taking some time for him to adjust to the changes and the fact it’s not all down to him anymore. Miharu can still catch up and take first place overall from Kiryu. Kiryu is so strange hahah, she WANTS Miharu to become a demon racer and challenge her. Dan is worried that the new car will kill Miharu, a valid worry in this sport. But Miharu has no intention of stopping here, he wants to keep using the new car’s schematics, and he feels like he’s close! Can’t wait to see what kind of demon he emerges as…oh shit, I’m like Kiryu lol.

The Ura Files #11 –
I love the cover page for this chapter! Kibitsu is seen as even worse than the devil by his fellow students, that’s crazy. And they’re crazy! And very jealous! Oh new character! I actually fuck with his design lol. Ishimatsu also seems to know a bit about Kibitsu? Oh he sussed out that he’s actually strong as fuck and is hiding it. I guess a fighter’s instincts are never wrong, huh? Aww Kibitsu made a friend. A second friend I guess, after Takada? Does he count? Anyway, cool. Hope he actually goes to the boxing club every so often, would be fun to see him there. And Kibitsu is now feeling a bit more confident in himself, or rather in showing his true self. Nice.

Jan Is In Danger #1 (NEW) – Yup Tintin vibes are indeed strong lol. The gag of the doctor getting arrested immediately made me laugh tbh, so good start. These two goons are like Team Rocket ffs lol. Them becoming so frustrated that they just decide to try and kill him in broad daylight is a good bit. I have to say, I like the world’s design, it’s very whimsical lol. This feels like a very old school style gag series, Dr. Slump kinda thing, or maybe more so like an old western comic strip? Anyway, a decent start, I enjoyed it more than I thought I was gonna. But like most gag manga, I wonder how long this can go on before it becomes repetitive/tedious. But for now, good start imo!

Ichi the Witch #106 – Hmm seems this “form”, if you wanna call it that, damages Dess over time? Ichi and Hakari working together…or more accurately, using each other, is actually pretty interesting. I like Ichi’s no nonsense take on it. Lmao? Hakari’s having a whole fantasy play out in his head in windswept grass about working with Ichi. He removed Fujimine from within Hakari’s heart and replaced her. I don’t even know what to make of the whole scene tbh lol, I guess Ichi is just that nice? Or maybe Uroro’s power is at work here somehow? A king making others submit? Who knows lol.

Tier 3 (Ok):

Cannon Master #20 – Fucking brutal man, the art for the opening flurry of attacks this chapter was magnificent, I really felt each and every hit. I like Ur’s final attack here, it’s all concentrated into a much smaller beam than you’d expect, showing how good he is at controlling it. Finesse over raw power. Fun chapter. Definitely feels like we’re approaching the end now though, either that or it lives for a bit and we get an arc to repair and fix Ur, because man that kid took some crazy hits during the fight lol.

Class 2-B #28 – Ahh a system based on letters and ranks, classic. Although if Rank B’s can be taken care of by the group even without powers, then the majority of them are pretty useless anyway in the grand scheme of things lol. I like the new character, Tsunagu Kanbe. She looks cool and her powers are sick too. Lmao her designs suck, they all just look the same. Anyway, it’s a handy power as well, letting her create a kind of spy frame around the whole school using her threads. Narasaki probably had some problems back in the “real” world, so he wants to stay here where he’s strong. I mean, fair enough but also you’re power tripping man lol.

Animal Signal #22 – Roga kinda feels like the Kanshi of this manga, the joke is always on him lol. I think this rich guy just learned something new about himself by the end of the chapter lmfao, good for him!

Nue’s Exorcist #169 – LMAOO fight back Kasha, fight back! Bro got jumped. I do actually like everyone working together tbh, everyone got a moment to shine more or less. Now only Gashadokuro remains right? Assuming Kasha is done here. Unless Raisei has one last plan of his own as well.

Me and Roboco #305 – Ah a Witch Watch chapter for the finale of the series, Witch Watch I mean. Makes sense. I guess a Komodo Dragon is close enough to an actual dragon? Lol.
 

Broseph

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2023
Messages
970
Reaction score
1,571
Age
31
Country
United States
Demon Slayer is a terrible example to use for a series with a lack of comedy. I agree with stvie that the first chapter is fairly serious and dark (really the entire first volume) but that's only really the start. It doesn't take that long for things to really change. And the results are pretty clear. You can legit look at ToC rankings and volume sales for the series before and after Zenitsu and Inosuke were introduced. Two dudes with blatant gags and it shot the popularity of the series up
 

Stivie

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Apr 23, 2019
Messages
3,274
Reaction score
2,359
Age
38
Country
Brazil
Demon Slayer is a terrible example to use for a series with a lack of comedy. I agree with stvie that the first chapter is fairly serious and dark (really the entire first volume) but that's only really the start. It doesn't take that long for things to really change. And the results are pretty clear. You can legit look at ToC rankings and volume sales for the series before and after Zenitsu and Inosuke were introduced. Two dudes with blatant gags and it shot the popularity of the series up
Wait a minute, Kimetsu didn't change like you're saying after Zenitsu and Inosuke were introduced into the story; the manga didn't become that lighthearted. There were still dark moments that stood out MUCH MORE than the comedy. We had characters who died during the story, and they weren't just villains, and the story didn't turn into a Witch Watch-type story because of the comedy.
 

icrawfish

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2024
Messages
798
Reaction score
1,253
Age
25
Country
United States
Wait a minute, Kimetsu didn't change like you're saying after Zenitsu and Inosuke were introduced into the story; the manga didn't become that lighthearted. There were still dark moments that stood out MUCH MORE than the comedy. We had characters who died during the story, and they weren't just villains, and the story didn't turn into a Witch Watch-type story because of the comedy.
If I may; I don't believe any one is claiming that Demon Slayer "became a comedy". You use Witch Watch as an example, but Witch Watch is decisively a comedy series by genre, among other things. What they are saying is that series that are not "comedy" by genre, like Demon Slayer, are still capable of being filled with comedic moments, and that those comedic moments can be some of the more well recalled moments of these series, without detracting from the fact that it is still a serious story. The Elusive Samurai has a serious plotline with a lot of notable moments done fully earnestly but among the moments that remain in my mind the most are ones like Genba taking his mask off for the first time after falling into a pile of dung and spitting it out in the process.
 

Thehoennhippo

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2019
Messages
2,475
Reaction score
3,688
Age
26
Country
United States
Death doesn't mean a story can't have comedy. Roku has had multiple storylines about the death of children lol.
 
Top