- Joined
- Mar 26, 2008
- Messages
- 4
- Reaction score
- 0
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
You are talking about now, but when the war just ended, it didn't settle down right away right? Look at Iraq now, after 1 year there are still bombers. Things don't settle down that fast, it takes nearly 2 generation for things to change, and it hasn't even been 1 generation yet in Tibet.First off, the Chinese government is still occupying Tibet, whereas the South has almost universally accepted being a part of the US.(I bet there is some lunatic anarchist fringe who advocates succession consisting of a few hundred people) In fact, the South is possibly the most patriotic region in the US.
Unless you want China coming in and say "Give those land back to the Natives", then it's not that fair that the Americans come in and try to help out the Tibet when they are still having issues with the Natives. It is also too late for China to give back the land. They "modernized" it as the Tibet claimed. Unless they plan to take everything down, destroy all roads and transport, make their own food (since the monks won't make them, the serf system would most likely be back).Yes Native Americans protest the government. What happened to them was indeed tragic, so why let it happen to the people of Tibet? Does saying "oh well you did it too" make what the Chinese doing any better? We have tried to make amends, but seeing as the occupation of Native American territory happened over a century ago, and to give them their land back would be impossible. If we started doing that, why shouldn't the Celts get their land back from the Anglo-Saxons? If you go back far enough, everyone has had land stolen from them. We can't change the past, but we can end the control of Tibet by an oppressive nation.
It should had been the North American Government’s", but I was lazy to type the entire thing out. (Which meant Mexico, US, Canada). Sorry for the mis understanding.And what is the "North American gov"? There are people in Canada who would be pretty cheesed if you suggested there was a North American Union. The Facebook group "CANADIANS AGAINST THE NORTH AMERICAN UNION" has over 50,000 members, all of which I assume would not like the insinuation that there is one North American gov.
That's the Western thought of modernize. As I said, lots of short and long essays are talking about modernize, and is the world going at the right direction or not.I consider any country that doesn't state they give their citizens freedom of demonstration and then quells "riots" of student demonstrators with armed troops "modern".
Olympics and politics should be separate matter since the reason for Olympics was to settle down these 5 nations. If my source is correct (just saw a bit of history about Olympics on TV), there were I think 5 nations who were constantly at war. And they all agree on having the Olympics and put political aside during that time. It was meant for peace and non-political reasons, thus I do believe that we should honour it. But of course, each have their opinions. And I am not sure if US is really doing it for the good or for the oil, lots of debate there, and I have no proof so I will not argue. And to me, democratic gov have their advantages, and non-democratic ones have theirs. Cannot just say because there is a lack of vote. Even when there is a voting system, it might fail like when it was Bush vs Al Gore after Bill Clinton. In the last stage, Al Gore would had won, but they had to "recount" the votes, and thus Bush won. No system is perfect IMO. As I said, China is changing, lots of places you can "vote" now. Don't judge someone from his past. It's changing give it more time. You can say these are fake votes or whatever, but you cannot say they cannot vote. And this "voting as freedom" is one of those Democratic vs Communism thingy I was talking about. There are a few essays that talked about how it is more political (make ppl vote more).Yes, but would we give Iraq the Olympics? Do I think what we are doing in Iraq is wrong? Yes. But I think that "giving freedom to Iraqis" (which, to some extent, US forces have accomplished. There have been elections in Iraq, something they didn't truly have under Saddam) is a much better excuse as to why it is occupied than "because the Mongols took it over in 1290". Regardless of whether I think the war is legit, at least US Forces are doing it for the good of the Iraqi people and the rest of the Middle East, even if it is incredibly overbearing.
I replied down there with a link that not only the news from PRC is not trustworthy. You might not believe any of PRC's news no matter what, but keep an open mind about it. Some might be trueWho told you it was mainly monks fighting for Tibetan freedom? The PRC has denied Hong Kong and foreign news agencies from going into Tibet, so any news coming out of there would have to be from....the PRC? And don't you think they might be a little slanted in their reporting. (PRC media is terrible when it comes to fair news coverage.) The boys in the PRC's media make Fox News look down right honest.
Especially a lot of tourist came back from Tibet who posted in their blogs that most of them were monks.Fine, if you don't see that, then let me give you a more direct reason. Invasion. Winner takes all, that had been the rule. From North America, back to China or Roman's history, it is winner who takes the land. America tried to take Canada as theirs, but they failed (the Canadian, British were able to reach the White House and burned it down during the counter attack). If Americans succeed, would they take Canada? Yes they would, since they are the winner.And the claim the PRC has to Tibet is flimsy at best. Sure, during imperial rule Tibet was part of China, but after China became a Republic and civil war broke out, China lost interest in Tibet. Sure it never formally renounced power, but in the same way the US hasn't officially ended the Korean War. I don't see how Tibet being controlled by the former emperor of China gives the PRC the right to claim Tibet as its own.
If the gov really learned from the past, then it wouldn't had taken Canada nearly 100 years to give back the money and apologized to the Chinese community the extra tax they put on them back then. They just apologized ... I think last year. Took them long enough to "learn" this social injustice. How have they become more oppressive? Just wondering, because they seemed to have open up more than oppress. You are allow to travel while back in the old days you are not. Free market, etc. So just wondering how they oppress ppl even more than back than.Time? In the 20+ since their new constitution, they have become more oppressive, and continually go back on the rights they "give" the people of China. Since when did the USA enact the Prime Directive? Why should we let other countries slog through the dark period of social injustice that we went through 200 years ago? We would be basically green lighting the deaths of millions while letting more lead sneak its way into our children's toys.
And the lead toys issue. I really don’t like how the media downplayed the toy company’s responsibilities. First, it was a design problem from the start, and they admitted it. The Chinese followed the designed in the contract. Second, where are the quality control people who checks the toys? Were they on breaks or something? My cousin works as an engineer in a factory, he said that quality control should had found that problem ages ago. You don’t have to test it all, but the toy company should have tested at least some. The media, IMO downplayed those two facts and blame it on Chinese goods. Fair?
Because the economy is part of politics. Changing the political system now would affect the economy a lot since the gov. would have less money to spend in the economy (takes a lot of money to change a system), thus the economy would slow down or might even down turn seeing how fast it is growing (Gov spending plays a large role in economy). If ppl start losing jobs (especially the poor), then even after you changed your political system, ppl would be even worst off, and would take much longer recover from it. Why not wait till it stabilize? So that most ppl would benefit from it. Money might not be everything, but without money, one cannot do anything. Human rights right now might affect a small portion of ppl who had been longing for voting, but changing it now will affect a big portion (especially the poor) to lose jobs, and etc. With inflation now, there is just no way for it to change. Give it 15 more years or so, so the the poor are not so poor, and maybe inflation will stop by then. You have to look at the overall affect when it changes, and not just now. And from my knowledge, it would affect majority ppl in a negative way more.Why should the economy of China stand in the way of human rights? Their business sector may be doing well, but this success comes at the cost of the environment and social freedom. If you ask me,
About the environmental issue (btw this got nothing to do with this topic, you can reply or not), I just don't like how many ppl are blaming the East Asia as the reason of Global Warming and want them to stop. I mean, East Asia started polluting around ... 20 years ago? While most of the Western countries started nearly 100 years already. They are the ones who really costed it, yet Bush reject signing the Kyoto, and I believe Canada used the excuse of "we will sign it when US signs it". That's not quite fair :/
You seemed to have mis understood my comparison with Civil War. I was pointing out the similar things between them and not making US accountable for something from 140 years ago. My point was, why did two countries took similar actions? There would most likely be a reason.Double standard? In your previous post you said
So China shouldn't be judged because it is a nation that actively lies about embracing human rights, yet the USA should be held accountable still for the Civil War, which happened 140 years ago?
And how did I double standard. I said don't judge China, but judge their action now. If I am judging the Japanese about their actions during WWII and what they had done to China, South Korea, and etc. I wouldn't be reading manga lol. Nor do I judge the Germans because of WWII. The reason I pointed out other countries' actions from the past is because I wanted to point out the similarities. As I mentioned, they are similar for a reason, thus shouldn't judge someone due to one's past. Maybe you can clear it up, because I really don't see how I double standard.
Speaking about lies in the media, German media just apologized for using totally different images (Nepal - spelling? - police beating monks or even Indian police ... ) as Chinese and Tibet images. Or there are some media that used half of the full picture.
http://club.news.sohu.com/r-minjian-1674092-0-27-0.html
Most of the points I already addressed in the upper paragraphs, about it needing time, and stuff. To me, the human right issue is there in China, I admit, but at the same time, it is more political than for the rights. The West made it sound big ever since the Democratic vs Communism. Each have their own goods and bad, for instance, with non-democratic, a country can aim for longer goals as political leaders don’t get strike down after 4 or 8 years. While Democratic leaders usually aim for small, short goals so that they can satisfy the people and get voted again, and if they are not lucky, and get voted off, then their long goals would fail since the next party would not carry that plan further. Each has their own good and bad points.All of the human rights violations committed by Americans of yesteryear were indeed atrocious, but they did lead us to where we are today. Today, we know that every human deserves to have basic rights, and that governments should not put themselves over the people. Governments are meant to serve the people, not the other way around. If China wants to call itself "modern", it needs to give its citizens human rights. Period. I'm not singling out just China; any nation that grossly mistreats its citizens should be held accountable. We can't just sit by and let what happened to people in our nation centuries ago happen to other human beings. We can't just wait while countries like China play "catch up", treating them like any other country while turning a blind eye to their human rights violations.
Yep, quite interesting. The world just keep changing. I am kind of worry about the US’s economy since it will affect the Canadian one by a lot. Hope it hangs in there for long enough lolI don't really care whether or not Tibet is a free country or not. Or Quebec for that matter. Heck, I could live without the South (the North's economy didn't really depend on the South. In fact, The South's economy depended on the North more than North depended on it. The North had many industries, while the South pretty much just has crop farming such as cotton, which it exported to the North for processing. This is one of the many reasons the North won the Civil War - the South ran out of cash. It's funny, seldom are wars determined by which country has the better fighters or more troops, but rather who has more money.) Many historians speculate the South would have come back to the North within 30 years if their was no Civil War. It lacked the economic infrastructure to support a nation, seeking as the industrial revolution had pretty much passed them by. It's odd, parallels could be drawn to our current situation with oil. Oil may be the cheapest and most lucrative way of producing energy right now, but alternatives will outlast our oil reserves and prepare us better for crisis. We are acting like the South, sticking to the old ways which relied on tried-and-true plantation farming, which may be good for the owners right now, but it inevitably left them vulnerable. That was a weird tangent, huh?
Anyways, nice knowing you. Have a good day.
Last edited: