Discussion Boycotting the Summer Olympics in China?

CrazyBoy

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
First off, the Chinese government is still occupying Tibet, whereas the South has almost universally accepted being a part of the US.(I bet there is some lunatic anarchist fringe who advocates succession consisting of a few hundred people) In fact, the South is possibly the most patriotic region in the US.
You are talking about now, but when the war just ended, it didn't settle down right away right? Look at Iraq now, after 1 year there are still bombers. Things don't settle down that fast, it takes nearly 2 generation for things to change, and it hasn't even been 1 generation yet in Tibet.

Yes Native Americans protest the government. What happened to them was indeed tragic, so why let it happen to the people of Tibet? Does saying "oh well you did it too" make what the Chinese doing any better? We have tried to make amends, but seeing as the occupation of Native American territory happened over a century ago, and to give them their land back would be impossible. If we started doing that, why shouldn't the Celts get their land back from the Anglo-Saxons? If you go back far enough, everyone has had land stolen from them. We can't change the past, but we can end the control of Tibet by an oppressive nation.
Unless you want China coming in and say "Give those land back to the Natives", then it's not that fair that the Americans come in and try to help out the Tibet when they are still having issues with the Natives. It is also too late for China to give back the land. They "modernized" it as the Tibet claimed. Unless they plan to take everything down, destroy all roads and transport, make their own food (since the monks won't make them, the serf system would most likely be back).

And what is the "North American gov"? There are people in Canada who would be pretty cheesed if you suggested there was a North American Union. The Facebook group "CANADIANS AGAINST THE NORTH AMERICAN UNION" has over 50,000 members, all of which I assume would not like the insinuation that there is one North American gov.
It should had been the North American Government’s", but I was lazy to type the entire thing out. (Which meant Mexico, US, Canada). Sorry for the mis understanding.

I consider any country that doesn't state they give their citizens freedom of demonstration and then quells "riots" of student demonstrators with armed troops "modern".
That's the Western thought of modernize. As I said, lots of short and long essays are talking about modernize, and is the world going at the right direction or not.

Yes, but would we give Iraq the Olympics? Do I think what we are doing in Iraq is wrong? Yes. But I think that "giving freedom to Iraqis" (which, to some extent, US forces have accomplished. There have been elections in Iraq, something they didn't truly have under Saddam) is a much better excuse as to why it is occupied than "because the Mongols took it over in 1290". Regardless of whether I think the war is legit, at least US Forces are doing it for the good of the Iraqi people and the rest of the Middle East, even if it is incredibly overbearing.
Olympics and politics should be separate matter since the reason for Olympics was to settle down these 5 nations. If my source is correct (just saw a bit of history about Olympics on TV), there were I think 5 nations who were constantly at war. And they all agree on having the Olympics and put political aside during that time. It was meant for peace and non-political reasons, thus I do believe that we should honour it. But of course, each have their opinions. And I am not sure if US is really doing it for the good or for the oil, lots of debate there, and I have no proof so I will not argue. And to me, democratic gov have their advantages, and non-democratic ones have theirs. Cannot just say because there is a lack of vote. Even when there is a voting system, it might fail like when it was Bush vs Al Gore after Bill Clinton. In the last stage, Al Gore would had won, but they had to "recount" the votes, and thus Bush won. No system is perfect IMO. As I said, China is changing, lots of places you can "vote" now. Don't judge someone from his past. It's changing give it more time. You can say these are fake votes or whatever, but you cannot say they cannot vote. And this "voting as freedom" is one of those Democratic vs Communism thingy I was talking about. There are a few essays that talked about how it is more political (make ppl vote more).

Who told you it was mainly monks fighting for Tibetan freedom? The PRC has denied Hong Kong and foreign news agencies from going into Tibet, so any news coming out of there would have to be from....the PRC? And don't you think they might be a little slanted in their reporting. (PRC media is terrible when it comes to fair news coverage.) The boys in the PRC's media make Fox News look down right honest.
I replied down there with a link that not only the news from PRC is not trustworthy. You might not believe any of PRC's news no matter what, but keep an open mind about it. Some might be true :) Especially a lot of tourist came back from Tibet who posted in their blogs that most of them were monks.

And the claim the PRC has to Tibet is flimsy at best. Sure, during imperial rule Tibet was part of China, but after China became a Republic and civil war broke out, China lost interest in Tibet. Sure it never formally renounced power, but in the same way the US hasn't officially ended the Korean War. I don't see how Tibet being controlled by the former emperor of China gives the PRC the right to claim Tibet as its own.
Fine, if you don't see that, then let me give you a more direct reason. Invasion. Winner takes all, that had been the rule. From North America, back to China or Roman's history, it is winner who takes the land. America tried to take Canada as theirs, but they failed (the Canadian, British were able to reach the White House and burned it down during the counter attack). If Americans succeed, would they take Canada? Yes they would, since they are the winner.

Time? In the 20+ since their new constitution, they have become more oppressive, and continually go back on the rights they "give" the people of China. Since when did the USA enact the Prime Directive? Why should we let other countries slog through the dark period of social injustice that we went through 200 years ago? We would be basically green lighting the deaths of millions while letting more lead sneak its way into our children's toys.
If the gov really learned from the past, then it wouldn't had taken Canada nearly 100 years to give back the money and apologized to the Chinese community the extra tax they put on them back then. They just apologized ... I think last year. Took them long enough to "learn" this social injustice. How have they become more oppressive? Just wondering, because they seemed to have open up more than oppress. You are allow to travel while back in the old days you are not. Free market, etc. So just wondering how they oppress ppl even more than back than.

And the lead toys issue. I really don’t like how the media downplayed the toy company’s responsibilities. First, it was a design problem from the start, and they admitted it. The Chinese followed the designed in the contract. Second, where are the quality control people who checks the toys? Were they on breaks or something? My cousin works as an engineer in a factory, he said that quality control should had found that problem ages ago. You don’t have to test it all, but the toy company should have tested at least some. The media, IMO downplayed those two facts and blame it on Chinese goods. Fair?

Why should the economy of China stand in the way of human rights? Their business sector may be doing well, but this success comes at the cost of the environment and social freedom. If you ask me,
Because the economy is part of politics. Changing the political system now would affect the economy a lot since the gov. would have less money to spend in the economy (takes a lot of money to change a system), thus the economy would slow down or might even down turn seeing how fast it is growing (Gov spending plays a large role in economy). If ppl start losing jobs (especially the poor), then even after you changed your political system, ppl would be even worst off, and would take much longer recover from it. Why not wait till it stabilize? So that most ppl would benefit from it. Money might not be everything, but without money, one cannot do anything. Human rights right now might affect a small portion of ppl who had been longing for voting, but changing it now will affect a big portion (especially the poor) to lose jobs, and etc. With inflation now, there is just no way for it to change. Give it 15 more years or so, so the the poor are not so poor, and maybe inflation will stop by then. You have to look at the overall affect when it changes, and not just now. And from my knowledge, it would affect majority ppl in a negative way more.

About the environmental issue (btw this got nothing to do with this topic, you can reply or not), I just don't like how many ppl are blaming the East Asia as the reason of Global Warming and want them to stop. I mean, East Asia started polluting around ... 20 years ago? While most of the Western countries started nearly 100 years already. They are the ones who really costed it, yet Bush reject signing the Kyoto, and I believe Canada used the excuse of "we will sign it when US signs it". That's not quite fair :/

Double standard? In your previous post you said

So China shouldn't be judged because it is a nation that actively lies about embracing human rights, yet the USA should be held accountable still for the Civil War, which happened 140 years ago?
You seemed to have mis understood my comparison with Civil War. I was pointing out the similar things between them and not making US accountable for something from 140 years ago. My point was, why did two countries took similar actions? There would most likely be a reason.

And how did I double standard. I said don't judge China, but judge their action now. If I am judging the Japanese about their actions during WWII and what they had done to China, South Korea, and etc. I wouldn't be reading manga lol. Nor do I judge the Germans because of WWII. The reason I pointed out other countries' actions from the past is because I wanted to point out the similarities. As I mentioned, they are similar for a reason, thus shouldn't judge someone due to one's past. Maybe you can clear it up, because I really don't see how I double standard.

Speaking about lies in the media, German media just apologized for using totally different images (Nepal - spelling? - police beating monks or even Indian police ... ) as Chinese and Tibet images. Or there are some media that used half of the full picture.

http://club.news.sohu.com/r-minjian-1674092-0-27-0.html

All of the human rights violations committed by Americans of yesteryear were indeed atrocious, but they did lead us to where we are today. Today, we know that every human deserves to have basic rights, and that governments should not put themselves over the people. Governments are meant to serve the people, not the other way around. If China wants to call itself "modern", it needs to give its citizens human rights. Period. I'm not singling out just China; any nation that grossly mistreats its citizens should be held accountable. We can't just sit by and let what happened to people in our nation centuries ago happen to other human beings. We can't just wait while countries like China play "catch up", treating them like any other country while turning a blind eye to their human rights violations.
Most of the points I already addressed in the upper paragraphs, about it needing time, and stuff. To me, the human right issue is there in China, I admit, but at the same time, it is more political than for the rights. The West made it sound big ever since the Democratic vs Communism. Each have their own goods and bad, for instance, with non-democratic, a country can aim for longer goals as political leaders don’t get strike down after 4 or 8 years. While Democratic leaders usually aim for small, short goals so that they can satisfy the people and get voted again, and if they are not lucky, and get voted off, then their long goals would fail since the next party would not carry that plan further. Each has their own good and bad points.

I don't really care whether or not Tibet is a free country or not. Or Quebec for that matter. Heck, I could live without the South (the North's economy didn't really depend on the South. In fact, The South's economy depended on the North more than North depended on it. The North had many industries, while the South pretty much just has crop farming such as cotton, which it exported to the North for processing. This is one of the many reasons the North won the Civil War - the South ran out of cash. It's funny, seldom are wars determined by which country has the better fighters or more troops, but rather who has more money.) Many historians speculate the South would have come back to the North within 30 years if their was no Civil War. It lacked the economic infrastructure to support a nation, seeking as the industrial revolution had pretty much passed them by. It's odd, parallels could be drawn to our current situation with oil. Oil may be the cheapest and most lucrative way of producing energy right now, but alternatives will outlast our oil reserves and prepare us better for crisis. We are acting like the South, sticking to the old ways which relied on tried-and-true plantation farming, which may be good for the owners right now, but it inevitably left them vulnerable. That was a weird tangent, huh?
Yep, quite interesting. The world just keep changing. I am kind of worry about the US’s economy since it will affect the Canadian one by a lot. Hope it hangs in there for long enough lol

Anyways, nice knowing you. Have a good day.
 
Last edited:

rabb

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
1,572
Reaction score
26
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
im tired, so im gunna make this quick: yes, america and other countries should. america, in particular, should leave for the simple reason that we make ourselves out to be the police of the world, yet we ally ourselves with regimes like china, and wherever immadinnerjacket is from. i think its iran, but im not sure, and there is no way in hell im gunna spell imadinnajon or w/e right. but i digress. we display ourselfs as the good guys and the upholders of human rights, and yet we stand by and watch as they get trampled.
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
That's the Western thought of modernize. As I said, lots of short and long essays are talking about modernize, and is the world going at the right direction or not.
China wants to be considered a Western nation, ergo it should live up to Western rules.


Olympics and politics should be separate
The Olympics and politics have never been separate. It's just another battleground for countries. For example, Hitler tried to use it to prove the Aryan race was superior. I'm not saying every country strives to prove they are superior, but countries have been going to extremes to get their competitors to win.

I replied down there with a link that not only the news from PRC is not trustworthy. You might not believe any of PRC's news no matter what, but keep an open mind about it. Some might be true :) Especially a lot of tourist came back from Tibet who posted in their blogs that most of them were monks.
I'd sooner believe Fixed News's report on "Barack Hussein Obama is a secret Muslim!" then the PRC's propaganda which it purports to be free press.

How would tourists know who started the riots? They were probably busy shopping or sightseeing when government reps told them to leave, saying some monks were causing trouble. I doubt many tourists were watching the riots start. Then again, I don't waste my time reading blogs, so their may be hundreds of blogging tourists who, in between writing about the "kewl shirt they bought is" and how the ice machine broke down, wrote a blog about who started the riots.

Fine, if you don't see that, then let me give you a more direct reason. Invasion. Winner takes all, that had been the rule. From North America, back to China or Roman's history, it is winner who takes the land. America tried to take Canada as theirs, but they failed (the Canadian, British were able to reach the White House and burned it down during the counter attack). If Americans succeed, would they take Canada? Yes they would, since they are the winner.
Way to sum up the War of 1812. Never mind that the British still maintained bases on US soil prior to the war, or that the British were trying to keep the US from trading with France during the Napoleonic Wars (which was the main cause of the war). The other main reason for the War was enslavement of overseas Americans into the British Navy to fight against Napoleon. If the US had taking over Canada as a final goal, it could have. Canada was thinly populated, and the British were preoccupied with taking down Napoleon, leaving the door wide open for the US. Taking over Canada was more of a strategy to win a war with Britain so the British would have to change their naval policies. Canada offered nothing that the US didn't have already, so why would they want to take it over? The only thing Canada had that the US didn't was glaciers, and who wants those?
If the gov really learned from the past, then it wouldn't had taken Canada nearly 100 years to give back the money and apologized to the Chinese community the extra tax they put on them back then. They just apologized ... I think last year. Took them long enough to "learn" this social injustice. How have they become more oppressive? Just wondering, because they seemed to have open up more than oppress. You are allow to travel while back in the old days you are not. Free market, etc. So just wondering how they oppress ppl even more than back than.
Exactly. Canada apologized for a head tax from 1885(Chinese had to pay $50 upon landing in Canada. The tax was made obsolete when the Canadians outright banned Chinese immigrants in 1923. This act was repealed in 1947). There are only a handful of people alive today who would remember that tax. Today, Chinese in Canada have the same rights as everyone else, enjoying all the freedoms every other Canadian does. This is in stark contrast to modern day China; where people are being forced to have abortions, killed for protesting the government, and going to jail for voicing opinions contrary to the Party's. Yeah, Canada is such a bad place. Canada gives all of its people equal rights, and China should as well.

And the lead toys issue. I really don’t like how the media downplayed the toy company’s responsibilities. First, it was a design problem from the start, and they admitted it. The Chinese followed the designed in the contract. Second, where are the quality control people who checks the toys? Were they on breaks or something? My cousin works as an engineer in a factory, he said that quality control should had found that problem ages ago. You don’t have to test it all, but the toy company should have tested at least some. The media, IMO downplayed those two facts and blame it on Chinese goods. Fair?
Yeah, the corporations suck. That doesn't change the fact Chinese factories are churning out deadly toys.

Because the economy is part of politics. Changing the political system now would affect the economy a lot since the gov. would have less money to spend in the economy (takes a lot of money to change a system), thus the economy would slow down or might even down turn seeing how fast it is growing (Gov spending plays a large role in economy). If ppl start losing jobs (especially the poor), then even after you changed your political system, ppl would be even worst off, and would take much longer recover from it. Why not wait till it stabilize? So that most ppl would benefit from it. Money might not be everything, but without money, one cannot do anything. Human rights right now might affect a small portion of ppl who had been longing for voting, but changing it now will affect a big portion (especially the poor) to lose jobs, and etc. With inflation now, there is just no way for it to change. Give it 15 more years or so, so the the poor are not so poor, and maybe inflation will stop by then. You have to look at the overall affect when it changes, and not just now. And from my knowledge, it would affect majority ppl in a negative way more.
How would giving the people of China freedom of speech effect the economy? "Oh no, now that I can say anything I want I don't feel like working. I'm going to leech off welfare and yell 'Mao sucks' at the top of the lungs." If anything, giving the people freedom of speech and press would increase business. Freedom of press would allow the Chinese people to start their own newspapers, tv shows, websites, etc... The only t

About the environmental issue (btw this got nothing to do with this topic, you can reply or not), I just don't like how many ppl are blaming the East Asia as the reason of Global Warming and want them to stop. I mean, East Asia started polluting around ... 20 years ago? While most of the Western countries started nearly 100 years already. They are the ones who really costed it, yet Bush reject signing the Kyoto, and I believe Canada used the excuse of "we will sign it when US signs it". That's not quite fair :/
I'm not blaming China for global warming. China just has terribly lax environmental laws, which has led to many of China's rivers and streams to become incredibly polluted. Most other "modern" nations have enacted laws that have cleaned up rivers and lakes along with reducing our carbon emissions, something China has yet to do.

You seemed to have mis understood my comparison with Civil War. I was pointing out the similar things between them and not making US accountable for something from 140 years ago. My point was, why did two countries took similar actions? There would most likely be a reason.
There's a big difference: the South actively succeeded from the Union, which they had been members of. Tibet, which had a degree of autonomy during the Chinese Civil War, was taken over by an invading force which had only recently came to power in China.

And how did I double standard. I said don't judge China, but judge their action now. If I am judging the Japanese about their actions during WWII and what they had done to China, South Korea, and etc. I wouldn't be reading manga lol. Nor do I judge the Germans because of WWII. The reason I pointed out other countries' actions from the past is because I wanted to point out the similarities. As I mentioned, they are similar for a reason, thus shouldn't judge someone due to one's past. Maybe you can clear it up, because I really don't see how I double standard.
Fine, I will judge China by it's actions now. They are lying about freedom of speech, freedom of press, freedom of press right now. They are forcing women to have abortions right now. Are the United States doing this right now? No. Germany? No. Japan? No. What the Germans and Japanese did during WWII, Canada and US did during the Industrial Revolution, and what China is doing right now is wrong. The difference is, while Japan, Germany, the US and Canada have changed their ways, China has not.
Speaking about lies in the media, German media just apologized for using totally different images (Nepal - spelling? - police beating monks or even Indian police ... ) as Chinese and Tibet images. Or there are some media that used half of the full picture.

http://club.news.sohu.com/r-minjian-1674092-0-27-0.html
OMG stop what you are doing! Germany used a picture of Nepal instead of using a picture from China! We must stop this cruel indecency! We could lose millions of lives if Germany doesn't start using pictures of police beatings from the right nation!
[/sarcasm]

So Germany used a picture from Nepal to represent a police beating in China. Does that change the fact that the Chinese PD is beating demonstrators?
Most of the points I already addressed in the upper paragraphs, about it needing time, and stuff. To me, the human right issue is there in China, I admit, but at the same time, it is more political than for the rights. The West made it sound big ever since the Democratic vs Communism. Each have their own goods and bad, for instance, with non-democratic, a country can aim for longer goals as political leaders don’t get strike down after 4 or 8 years. While Democratic leaders usually aim for small, short goals so that they can satisfy the people and get voted again, and if they are not lucky, and get voted off, then their long goals would fail since the next party would not carry that plan further. Each has their own good and bad points.
Yes, but if a leader sucks in a democracy it's easier to oust them, whereas in a dictatorship you are stuck with the leader you've got, seeing as he has all the guns.
Anyways, nice knowing you. Have a good day.
This discussion is far from over.
 

CrazyBoy

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
China wants to be considered a Western nation, ergo it should live up to Western rules.
So it is between no Westernize or totally Westernize? Can't it be in between (I think this is where China is heading to) where they use the advantages of Western society, but uses some Eastern one too.

The Olympics and politics have never been separate. It's just another battleground for countries. For example, Hitler tried to use it to prove the Aryan race was superior. I'm not saying every country strives to prove they are superior, but countries have been going to extremes to get their competitors to win.
And that's why you boycott China's Olympics for "non" political reason? Human rights is political more than about sports ... at least that's my concept, maybe you have a differnt one?


I'd sooner believe Fixed News's report on "Barack Hussein Obama is a secret Muslim!" then the PRC's propaganda which it purports to be free press.
You are already bias. You already think "all" news from PRC are propaganda and fake. No point in argueing with someone like this. Keep an open mind.

How would tourists know who started the riots? They were probably busy shopping or sightseeing when government reps told them to leave, saying some monks were causing trouble. I doubt many tourists were watching the riots start. Then again, I don't waste my time reading blogs, so their may be hundreds of blogging tourists who, in between writing about the "kewl shirt they bought is" and how the ice machine broke down, wrote a blog about who started the riots.
Actually, they said they saw the monks act violently, riot on the street, and started burning buildings. Key word "saw". Just because you are lazy, doesn't mean these blogs doesn't exist. And they said it was mainly monks who were casuing the troubles. And they had to watch it. The Chinese send police to protect them from leaving the hotel for a day or two. They saw the riot from their windows, not from the news. Some even video typed it, but the Chinese gov prevented them from posting by deleting them (which I think is stupid. If you think you are right, why not let them post? This move make themselves more doubtful ... actually they are always like this no matter what the issue is ... the political ppl there are stupid)

Way to sum up the War of 1812. Never mind that the British still maintained bases on US soil prior to the war, or that the British were trying to keep the US from trading with France during the Napoleonic Wars (which was the main cause of the war). The other main reason for the War was enslavement of overseas Americans into the British Navy to fight against Napoleon. If the US had taking over Canada as a final goal, it could have. Canada was thinly populated, and the British were preoccupied with taking down Napoleon, leaving the door wide open for the US. Taking over Canada was more of a strategy to win a war with Britain so the British would have to change their naval policies. Canada offered nothing that the US didn't have already, so why would they want to take it over? The only thing Canada had that the US didn't was glaciers, and who wants those?
So this is political while China trying to keep Tibet together is all about Human right. Why not look at the political aspect too? And I wasn't summing it up. As I said, I was making connection with past events. Simular things happen for a reason, like invasion - winner takes all. Doesn't matter if it's political or not. Simple enough IMO. Even if you say all these, in the end, if US won, there would be no Canada even though the Canadian doesn't like being part of the States to fight against it (Human rights?). And trust me, there is nothing called "too much". That's glustony. They would take what ever they have or don't have and keep extra. Don't live in a fantasy where ppl would take what they need (look at how much food we waste here each day). If land isn't so important, there won't be any wars about land. To a country, resource and its size is very important, a way to show its power.

Exactly. Canada apologized for a head tax from 1885(Chinese had to pay $50 upon landing in Canada. The tax was made obsolete when the Canadians outright banned Chinese immigrants in 1923. This act was repealed in 1947). There are only a handful of people alive today who would remember that tax. Today, Chinese in Canada have the same rights as everyone else, enjoying all the freedoms every other Canadian does. This is in stark contrast to modern day China; where people are being forced to have abortions, killed for protesting the government, and going to jail for voicing opinions contrary to the Party's. Yeah, Canada is such a bad place. Canada gives all of its people equal rights, and China should as well.
So Canada can takes up to 100 of years after being forced by the Chinese for 30 years before they can claim this tax back and an apology, but on the other hand, China have to learn right away, no time given? That's double standard. Do you know why they waited so long? It's like Japan. Ppl don't know why Chinese and South Koreans hate Japanese Gov so much. Let me tell you, the Japanese citizens are mostly very good ppl, but the gov is not so well off. They DID NOT even apologized to ANYONE for WWII. Let's not even ask about paying those countries (at least Germans apologized). What are they waiting for? A lot of historians said that they are waiting for WWII generation to die off to pay less, like the Canadian gov waiting to pay less. That's just how the world is. The Canadian gov knew it was wrong, but they did not apologized themselves, they were forced to do so. If they weren't forced, they would rather not apologize at all. Not even closed to being better.

You know what minority race political ppl say? This is fake democracy. Yes, ppl get to vote for them, but since in most places, it's mainly White majority parties, the other races have no chance of getting elected by their own party members to become a representative to "be voted for". Not because they are not capable, or because they won't have a chance of winning, but because they are just not the majority. They will never become the representative to be voted even though they can be voted for. The gov makes you think you are free, but in realitiy, if you are not the majority, there is no hope. Only recently are there any changes(as if these 2 to 3 years), but still not even close to enough. That's not freedom, more like oppression. And I think your vision of China is still quite ... old. Maybe you go visit China when you have some time to change it up a bit. Every teacher I had who went to China said, their image changed once the were there.

"where people are being forced to have abortions". No offense, you are looking at now, not the future where ppl have to fight for resources. The only way to fight for it is war. Which one do you perfer? War or adortion? I rather have abortions to keep it 1 family 1 child. Resource is running low, and China knows it. It's doing this for the better of man kind. Look at 100 years from now if this rule didn't exist - Inflation everywhere (and ppl are complaing about gas now, if China does not have that policy, even food would be 3 or 5 times its price), no jobs for a lot of ppl, and etc. So before you complain, look at the overall picture, not 1 year, 10 years, but 100 years. Predict what would happen. Everything in the world is connected now, what happens there would affect you and your future life as well.

Yeah, the corporations suck. That doesn't change the fact Chinese factories are churning out deadly toys.
To me, you are just totally bias, I rather you not type this. You seem so sarcastic saying the corporation sucks, and just wanting to say Chinese factories suck more. If it's so deadly, you would had die from something made from China already. The chances of it happening is so low (as if any injury caused by Chinese products). You used/touched like maybe 50 China made product a day, times that by 365, times that for around 10 years. You seem to be fine after touching 182500 products from China. And IF one product does injure you (not because you misued it, but manufacturing problem where you can sue them), that's 1/182500 chances, that 5.4 x 10^-4 %. That's some deadly stuff there! This is basic math, unless you want me to get into those statistic math and stuff (but then I need actual data of how many China made products on average one touches a day). By the time you get injuried like that, you might have won 3rd price in a lotery lol

How would giving the people of China freedom of speech effect the economy? "Oh no, now that I can say anything I want I don't feel like working. I'm going to leech off welfare and yell 'Mao sucks' at the top of the lungs." If anything, giving the people freedom of speech and press would increase business. Freedom of press would allow the Chinese people to start their own newspapers, tv shows, websites, etc... The only t
If you read some essays, they say freedom of speech only slows down society's growth. You give them a free voice, they start rebelling, and the society might end up in chaos (that's the theory at least, that's why some Sci-fi novels mentioned no freedom of choice). Of course, freedom of speech also have it's good side. Freedom of speech might be taken away to protect the citizens. It would work in a perfect society where everyone is happy and won't complain. If freedom of speech is legal, there might be riots, chaos, rebellions, distorted thoughts and rummors, some might abuse it, and etc. It's a very debatable thing actually since it have both pros and cons. And if I remembered correctly, there was this reporter for CNN like 4 years ago who disagreed with Bush's action was fired teh next day, but lucky, was rehired by BBC. There is also isn't much freedom of speech in America. Lot's of propaganda going on here and there. The Dixie Chicks country artist group was banned from reward shows after disagreeing with Bush as well, for a year or two. Lots of cases like these happened within these few years just in America. Even the American gov knows they need to limit the freedom of speech. That's also reality. Or else why would they arrest ppl for illegal meeting (forgot the actual term ... was it illegal gathering?) even if the riotors were peaceful (like the ones in recent news 5 days ago. The university students were just sitting on the grass and yelling then the police came in and took them away - kind of violently too, the students claim so - it was somewhere in Europe - totally forgot where). The concept of freedom of speech is actually not as free as you think, and it might case economical and physical damage if there is too much, and your gov understands this perfectly.

I'm not blaming China for global warming. China just has terribly lax environmental laws, which has led to many of China's rivers and streams to become incredibly polluted. Most other "modern" nations have enacted laws that have cleaned up rivers and lakes along with reducing our carbon emissions, something China has yet to do.
You should look at ... I think it was Denmark or was it Norway. Most of the rivers are acidic lol. At least China is putting billions of dollars to change the enviornment now since they earn enough money. Go visit it sometime, the technology there that changes the dirty water is unbelievable. Anyways, this topic is really out of place, so I won't respond to it anymore.

There's a big difference: the South actively succeeded from the Union, which they had been members of. Tibet, which had a degree of autonomy during the Chinese Civil War, was taken over by an invading force which had only recently came to power in China.
As I said, invasion is winner takes all. Matters not if they agree or not. Let's ask if the Natives agree to give the land to the Americans shall we? You just can't say not to that fact about invasion. To me, you are just bias about China's action

Fine, I will judge China by it's actions now. They are lying about freedom of speech, freedom of press, freedom of press right now. They are forcing women to have abortions right now. Are the United States doing this right now? No. Germany? No. Japan? No. What the Germans and Japanese did during WWII, Canada and US did during the Industrial Revolution, and what China is doing right now is wrong. The difference is, while Japan, Germany, the US and Canada have changed their ways, China has not.
And US invading Iraq as a "police" is right? Well, if I do remembered correctly, the UN said no, don't attack it, but the US ignored them (changed French Fries to Freedom Fries lol), is that right? You talked about Chinese killing anyone against them (haven't happened for more than 10 years now), how about the US's army torturing the Iraqis's prisonors right now? Changing someone else's gov system right now. Did the Iraqis ask for help? As if a majority of them. Since I don't have double standard, I won't be answering these questions :) I will let the States do what ever they want, if they invaded it, they really have the right to claim it IMO, this is why I am not complaining about living in Canada since it is a product of invasion.

OMG stop what you are doing! Germany used a picture of Nepal instead of using a picture from China! We must stop this cruel indecency! We could lose millions of lives if Germany doesn't start using pictures of police beatings from the right nation!
[/sarcasm]

So Germany used a picture from Nepal to represent a police beating in China. Does that change the fact that the Chinese PD is beating demonstrators?
As I said, you seemed so bias already. And you do know what an image is right? Is like a logo, or trademark. If you stink up the name of a trademark, then it's over. Same for China, if you stink up it's image, there would be economcial damages, which might lead to others (and in your mind, China's image seem to stink already thanks to media like those, which proves my point). You don't trust the Chinese news, and I can't change your way.

Yes, but if a leader sucks in a democracy it's easier to oust them, whereas in a dictatorship you are stuck with the leader you've got, seeing as he has all the guns.
That's only an advantage of democracy, but as I said, it is actually very debatable since both side have pros and cons. The world is still coming up with the best gov method.


This discussion is far from over.
Okai ... I was just being nice and say nice to meet you and have a nice day. Guess you don't like that O_o
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
So it is between no Westernize or totally Westernize? Can't it be in between (I think this is where China is heading to) where they use the advantages of Western society, but uses some Eastern one too.
Sure, it can be in between. But then it would wouldn't be a western nation - it would be a westernizing nation. If China wants to be called a modern nation, it has to due away with the oppressive totalitarian system they have. This system has nothing to do with Eastern tradition. For starters, communism was invented by a German. The PRC actively destroyed anything that rooted them to their traditional past in the first years of the regime. The current state of China has nothing to do with their "traditional" way of life - it is just a way for party bosses to exploit the working poor of the nation.
And that's why you boycott China's Olympics for "non" political reason? Human rights is political more than about sports ... at least that's my concept, maybe you have a differnt one?
I never said I was boycotting for non-political reasons. I said that the Olympics have always been about politics. And you're right- human rights are more political than sports. That's why I refuse to watch sporting events in a country that is actively violating them.

You are already bias. You already think "all" news from PRC are propaganda and fake. No point in argueing with someone like this. Keep an open mind.
I am sure some of the news from PRC media is true - there is always the occasional "soft news" piece about a cat that called the police or of the new baby panda. But I doubt it would report on anything that would make the government look bad.
Actually, they said they saw the monks act violently, riot on the street, and started burning buildings. Key word "saw". Just because you are lazy, doesn't mean these blogs doesn't exist. And they said it was mainly monks who were casuing the troubles. And they had to watch it. The Chinese send police to protect them from leaving the hotel for a day or two. They saw the riot from their windows, not from the news. Some even video typed it, but the Chinese gov prevented them from posting by deleting them (which I think is stupid. If you think you are right, why not let them post? This move make themselves more doubtful ... actually they are always like this no matter what the issue is ... the political ppl there are stupid)
Here's the video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rA2U8cIjNws&NR=1

So, yes the monks started it. But I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that the PRC didn't want people to see this video because then people would see they called in over a hundred troops before the protest even began. Why did they need that many troops? I'm not saying the monks were doing the right thing by throwing rocks, but did they really need that many riot police for a protest by a bunch of guys wearing robes? You're just begging for hostility if you do that.
So this is political while China trying to keep Tibet together is all about Human right. Why not look at the political aspect too? And I wasn't summing it up. As I said, I was making connection with past events. Simular things happen for a reason, like invasion - winner takes all. Doesn't matter if it's political or not. Simple enough IMO. Even if you say all these, in the end, if US won, there would be no Canada even though the Canadian doesn't like being part of the States to fight against it (Human rights?). And trust me, there is nothing called "too much". That's glustony. They would take what ever they have or don't have and keep extra. Don't live in a fantasy where ppl would take what they need (look at how much food we waste here each day). If land isn't so important, there won't be any wars about land. To a country, resource and its size is very important, a way to show its power.
I don't live in a fantasy world. I'm stating the facts: Canada didn't have anything the US didn't have already. Why would the US go to all the trouble of invading Canada (which it never did) only a few years after the Louisiana Purchase? Historians generally agree that invading Canada would only be as part of the war effort against Britain. Wars aren't simply about "land", it's about what the land has. And resource-wise, Canada didn't have anything the US didn't. And it wouldn't be "gluttony"; it would be "avarice". Gluttony is habitual eating to excess; avarice is insatiable greed. Get you sins right.
So Canada can takes up to 100 of years after being forced by the Chinese for 30 years before they can claim this tax back and an apology, but on the other hand, China have to learn right away, no time given? That's double standard. Do you know why they waited so long? It's like Japan. Ppl don't know why Chinese and South Koreans hate Japanese Gov so much. Let me tell you, the Japanese citizens are mostly very good ppl, but the gov is not so well off. They DID NOT even apologized to ANYONE for WWII. Let's not even ask about paying those countries (at least Germans apologized). What are they waiting for? A lot of historians said that they are waiting for WWII generation to die off to pay less, like the Canadian gov waiting to pay less. That's just how the world is. The Canadian gov knew it was wrong, but they did not apologized themselves, they were forced to do so. If they weren't forced, they would rather not apologize at all. Not even closed to being better.
So you are saying that because the Japanese don't want to apologize for crimes their grandparents committed, there as bad as people who are making a mockery of human rights right now? I'm not saying it isn't right
that the Japanese haven't apoligized, but c'mon. Those apologies are only token gestures anyway. I'm not going to wait around for the Anglo Saxons to apologize for killing my Celtic great-great-great-great-great-
great-great-great-.......great- grandfathers. Leave the past in the past and focus on the problems today. Japan gives its people human rights, Germany does, and Italy does. And it didn't take a decade to get there. If you want to drum up every terrible thing that dead Germans and Japanese people did, that's fine. But I'm going to worry about today.
You know what minority race political ppl say? This is fake democracy. Yes, ppl get to vote for them, but since in most places, it's mainly White majority parties, the other races have no chance of getting elected by their own party members to become a representative to "be voted for". Not because they are not capable, or because they won't have a chance of winning, but because they are just not the majority. They will never become the representative to be voted even though they can be voted for. The gov makes you think you are free, but in realitiy, if you are not the majority, there is no hope. Only recently are there any changes(as if these 2 to 3 years), but still not even close to enough. That's not freedom, more like oppression. And I think your vision of China is still quite ... old. Maybe you go visit China when you have some time to change it up a bit. Every teacher I had who went to China said, their image changed once the were there.
We have had plenty of minority candidates, and a black man is more than likely going to be the candidate for the Dems. Things are changing in the US.

What? I only think I'm free? Listen, I can do pretty much whatever I want, regardless of who's in office. I can say what I want, drive where I want, shop where I want, and eat where I want. I have freedom, and plenty of it. Just because my candidate may not always win, it doesn't mean I don't have freedom. My vote was cast, there were just more people for the opposition. That's a democracy. I still have my freedom, even if I don't like who's in charge. How can you say people are oppressed in America? Sure, poor people do have it tough, but like you said, we don't live in a "fantasy world". At least the minority in America have the right to voice their opinion and to work towards change.

How is my vision of China old? Are they not forcing people to have abortions? Are they not denying people freedom of speech?
"where people are being forced to have abortions". No offense, you are looking at now, not the future where ppl have to fight for resources. The only way to fight for it is war. Which one do you perfer? War or adortion? I rather have abortions to keep it 1 family 1 child. Resource is running low, and China knows it. It's doing this for the better of man kind. Look at 100 years from now if this rule didn't exist - Inflation everywhere (and ppl are complaing about gas now, if China does not have that policy, even food would be 3 or 5 times its price), no jobs for a lot of ppl, and etc. So before you complain, look at the overall picture, not 1 year, 10 years, but 100 years. Predict what would happen. Everything in the world is connected now, what happens there would affect you and your future life as well.
Oh, so it's for the people's good? The standard defense of the fascist. No matter how many babies they kill, the population is just going to keep getting larger. Modern medicine has seen to that. The PRC can't hope to make the 1 Child law a reality - they barely try to enforce it in rural areas. The trend for all of human history is an increase in the population (save in situations such as the Plague or a world war), and to try and change that is crazy. The only real solution to the problem is to start colonizing space. It may sound far-fetched now, but Lunar/Martian colonization isn't as crazy as it seems. If the boys in NASA stop dicking around with mattresses and get back to work on spaceships, we could be on Mars in 50 years or less.

To me, you are just totally bias, I rather you not type this. You seem so sarcastic saying the corporation sucks, and just wanting to say Chinese factories suck more. If it's so deadly, you would had die ....
I can type whatever I want. It's called freedom of speech. And I am against corporate greed, but that isn't the topic here - China is. The US needs to do a better job regulating what comes into America, but China should hold up it's end of the bargain.

If you read some essays, they say freedom of speech only slows down society's growth. You give them a free voice, they start rebelling, and the society might end up in chaos (that's the theory at least, that's why some Sci-fi novels mentioned no freedom of choice). Of course, freedom of speech also have it's good side. Freedom of speech might be taken away to protect the citizens. It would work in a perfect society where everyone is happy and won't complain. If freedom of speech is legal, there might be riots, chaos, rebellions, distorted thoughts and rummors, some might abuse it, and etc. It's a very debatable thing actually since it have both pros and cons. And if I remembered correctly, there was this reporter for CNN like 4 years ago who disagreed with Bush's action was fired teh next day, but lucky, was rehired by BBC. There is also isn't much freedom of speech in America. Lot's of propaganda going on here and there. The Dixie Chicks country artist group was banned from reward shows after disagreeing with Bush as well, for a year or two. Lots of cases like these happened within these few years just in America. Even the American gov knows they need to limit the freedom of speech. That's also reality. Or else why would they arrest ppl for illegal meeting (forgot the actual term ... was it illegal gathering?) even if the riotors were peaceful (like the ones in recent news 5 days ago. The university students were just sitting on the grass and yelling then the police came in and took them away - kind of violently too, the students claim so - it was somewhere in Europe - totally forgot where). The concept of freedom of speech is actually not as free as you think, and it might case economical and physical damage if there is too much, and your gov understands this perfectly.
Sure you can find people who think freedom of speech is bad. You can also find websites dedicated to the outlawing of water due to the fact it is dangerous. What good is having a "good economy" if the people do not have the freedom to voice their opinion?
You should look at ... I think it was Denmark or was it Norway. Most of the rivers are acidic lol. At least China is putting billions of dollars to change the enviornment now since they earn enough money. Go visit it sometime, the technology there that changes the dirty water is unbelievable. Anyways, this topic is really out of place, so I won't respond to it anymore.
And Denmark and Norway aren't?
As I said, invasion is winner takes all. Matters not if they agree or not. Let's ask if the Natives agree to give the land to the Americans shall we? You just can't say not to that fact about invasion. To me, you are just bias about China's action
What land would the Natives give to the Americans?
And US invading Iraq as a "police" is right? Well, if I do remembered correctly, the UN said no, don't attack it, but the US ignored them (changed French Fries to Freedom Fries lol), is that right? You talked about Chinese killing anyone against them (haven't happened for more than 10 years now), how about the US's army torturing the Iraqis's prisonors right now? Changing someone else's gov system right now. Did the Iraqis ask for help? As if a majority of them. Since I don't have double standard, I won't be answering these questions :) I will let the States do what ever they want, if they invaded it, they really have the right to claim it IMO, this is why I am not complaining about living in Canada since it is a product of invasion.
I am against the War in Iraq. But those torture situations, while cruel and disgusting, were isolated incidents. The Iraqi people don't care about freedom. All they want to do is blow each other up. That's why there are over 400,000 civilian casualties in Iraq. This debate is going on in another thread, so please keep it there.
As I said, you seemed so bias already. And you do know what an image is right? Is like a logo, or trademark. If you stink up the name of a trademark, then it's over. Same for China, if you stink up it's image, there would be economcial damages, which might lead to others (and in your mind, China's image seem to stink already thanks to media like those, which proves my point). You don't trust the Chinese news, and I can't change your way.
Yes I'm biased. I'm biased against any country that forces people to kill babies and denies people human rights their constitution supposedly grants them. So China shouldn't live up to it's word because it would "stink up it's image"? China doesn't have the greatest image right now anyway. There's a better term for that : pride.
That's only an advantage of democracy, but as I said, it is actually very debatable since both side have pros and cons. The world is still coming up with the best gov method.
So let's see my options: Democracy, where I can say anything I want, vote for whomever I'd like, and have the opportunity to start my own business; or "communism" ala China, where I don't have freedom of speech, the government controls how I reproduce, and the government allows multinational corporations to use my labor to increase their profit margins, while I starve? Democracy please.
 

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
well, it looks like the olympics are happening...no matter what tibet or the rest of the world says or does...no amount of protesting can stop this, and thats the way it should be....
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The Olympics will go on, but I will not watch it. I'm also boycotting Chinese products - it's difficult, and most of my alternatives are Indonesia, Mexico, Taiwan, etc... Not great options, but it's a start.
 

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
And about the issue at Khartoum. I do not think it got anything to do with China really. They are trading weapons for goods (it is in a contract). It's like me trading a knife for your food, but you you used the knife to steal, is it really my problem? In a way, China could had helped the situation, but they are only trading partners after all. Again just my view on this topic. No bashing of flaming. I admit, I am not very familar with this topic (since I was business during that time and didn't have time to read the news). So correct me if I am wrong that China is just a trading partner.
China knowingly trades weapons that are being used for ethnic cleansing, whether or not it is in a business contract does not take away from the fact that what they are continuing to do is morally reprehensible. They are complicit in the murders taking place, and what's worse, they choose to do very little about the situation.



I found this article, and it's a good background information of the history between Sino-Tibetan relations in the past century:

http://www.foreignaffairs.org/19980...vyn-c-goldstein/the-dalai-lama-s-dilemma.html
 

Koen

Celestial Belgian
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2006
Messages
13,821
Reaction score
3,547
Gender
Male
Country
Belgium
I don't care about the olympics so for me a boycot or not doesn't matter at all. There are some reasons for doing it but there are some reasons for not doing it too. Imo it isn't coincidence the riots started just before the flame travel, etc etc So I think tibetans aren't so innocent as they claim to be. On the other hand I have never liked the chinese and their censoring policy

Imo governements shouldn't take action against by a sports boycot. Incorrect Politics should be opposed by political/economical actions. The sportsmen have to decide for themself
 

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
we should just leave China alone, and worry about ourselves...
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
oh gosh, there is so much reading in this thread and i am not in the mood..

but here is my take on this, if you look at history atlas map (which i have many ) you could see that both vietnam and tibet had been part of china like (mongol, manchu, and even korea) so the their relationship is kinda closely tie .. But Ho Chi Minh had once said “Better to eat the French dung for 100 years than the Chinese dung for 1,000.” (and PS during 3rd Indochina war, they did invade vietnam). show the resentment against chinese rule (in other country as well including tibet) ..

As for the news and stuff that happen in Tibet, I could never trust everything I read.. Some sources seem very bias...

Well as for media and stuff, and someone here had said that the media in china is very bias (which is true) but look back in the USA history .. during the beginning of the Spanish American was all the newspaper said negative things about spain (for which maybe truth or untruth) and even blame them for the USS Maine explosion.. and this probably happen in other nation as well... so it is very hypocrite to blame china over this since their motive is the same as USA during the Spanish American war or etc...

The Dali Lama once said "We are willing to be part of the People's Republic of China, to have it govern and guarantee to preserve our Tibetan culture, spirituality and our environment." As everyone know that communism is strict on the freedom of religion and such but during this modern era these things have improving.. It not whether or not Tibet should be an independent state, but compromising between China and Tibet..

About the Olympic, how many of you going? in this thread, probably none so even if you guys decided to boycott it would not even do a thing..

Well, I think boycott the Olympic is an insult to China.. and for the Chinese.. the Tibet situation (whether whose false) have nothing to do with the Olympic... and this could farther creating distrust.. (oh the media already done that XD )
 

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I don't have any qualms with China per se, just their government. I think that China should do more to improve their human rights record, and being that they will host the Olympics this summer, they should use this opportunity to prove to the world that their rule is legit. Instead, we're seeing the opposite trend, and it's disappointing.

By comparison, America today gives way more freedom to the individual than China. I just heard on the radio the other day, where a man who's serving time in jail for murder, have apparently underwent a sex-change operation. The procedure was incomplete, and he demanded that it be completed, and the judge granted in his favor.

This is not to say anything bad about people who undergo sex-change operations. The larger point is that this man (or woman?) is a criminal, and he is nonetheless being granted full human rights. The operation, no doubt, will cost a lot of money, and the doctors involved in the procedure will be spending their effort on a guy, who committed murder. Why should he be given rights at all?

In America, it has come to a point where the individual is so important, that the government must bend down to its knees to service the individual, not the other way around.

The opposite is still true in China, where the State is what matters, and the individual second.

Under Communism, it puts the government in a better position, relative to other capitalist systems such as United States, to abuse State power. Individual rights is less important in China, than say, in the USA.

Wasn't it Confucious who came up with the notion that when the government does not serve the will of the people, that they have the right to oppose their rule? Why, then, is Communism stifling dissent with force? The Tibetans just want autonomy, and I understand that there is another side to this issue (you can argue that the Tibetans are using violence via riots to get what they want...but is there another alternative? Should they sit and do nothing?)

Saying that the US should not criticize because it's being hypocritical, is the easy way out. Of course, if you go back far enough, we can all spend an eternity criticizing each other's past governments for it's past human rights abuse. The issue isn't about the past, it's about now.

If you want to argue about USA abusing their powers, oppressing, for example, the racial minority, then why is there hardly an incident concerning a nationalistic revolt?

China should use this opportunity to make a statement. Human rights issues will not go unscrutinized. China's press is directly run by the government, and they choose which gets published, and which is silenced. They punish journalists for publishing any criticism of the Chinese state. Obviously this is biased...probably as biased as you can possibly get. Can we make the same claims in the American media? perhaps in the past, yes. Today? no.

On another note, I've been thinking this over. I agree, boycotting the Olympics is pointless.

Being a sports junkie, I sympathize for the athletes, and I think it is fundamentally unfair if we boycott something which they've worked so hard to get to. Not just unfair for US athletes, but Chinese athletes, as well, and in fact all athletes. So on second thought, no I'm not boycotting the olympics. Even though I had no intention of attending any of the Beijing games, by "boycott", I think what everyone meant was the gesture of boycotting. And yes, simply boycotting the games by not watching it on TV does have a significant effect.....losing a big chunk of a TV audience translates into losing revenue from the ads, etc.
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
well, the things with China is that it have been this way for thousand of years.. the state come before the individuals... and the Chinese's mindset is that "way too much freedom can be dangerous" if changes must happen, then i guess should be smooth and will not happen overnight... And China did change and improve in this topic... And please keep in mind that their traditional values are different than here..

PS. the sex-change example is kinda, i dunno not a very good example ( i am sure that there are many better example out there ) so i am not arguing your point..

Confucius teaching can see in changes in the dynasty, when Confucius began this teaching, he probably meant that the government is responsible that its citizens are well fed and clothed.. If not then there are revolts large enough to overthrow the dynasty.. So this point only valid, if the republic of china falter and someone or some different group in power..

I am not using "hypocritical" thing as a way out, rather that we should look at ourself too, and how long it is that we need in order to change or improve, before we start criticizing, at least giving them the same amount of time.. I'm no expert in the history of the press so i will not further argue..

During both the Yuan and recent Qing dynasty Tibet was part of China.. so asking the Chinese to forfeit Tibet is kinda like asking USA to forfeit Texas over to Mehico ...

The tibet people may deserve their freedom.. and i am not argue that they shouldn't receive this freedom.. rather i argue that people need to see the China's side of viewpoint.. after a long consideration of both side without any bias then decide which side they should take but still understand why there are people on the opposite side and their reasonings..
 
Last edited:

BoXs

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Dec 31, 2007
Messages
19
Reaction score
1
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
People in this thread kept on saying China is communism ... but it isn't ... it's more of a mix ... just want to tell you guys :)
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
People in this thread kept on saying China is communism ... but it isn't ... it's more of a mix ... just want to tell you guys :)
Absolutely agree, there is no such thing as truth communism or capitalism now back on topic
 

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
its communist like kurdistan, or cuba.......need new communist countries though.....maybe like brazil or somethin
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
People in this thread kept on saying China is communism ... but it isn't ... it's more of a mix ... just want to tell you guys :)
Of course they are not true communists... there has never been a true communist state, perhaps with the exception of hunter gathers, but even that is up to debate.

its communist like kurdistan, or cuba.......need new communist countries though.....maybe like brazil or somethin
Why would Brazil go commie?
 

natli

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2006
Messages
847
Reaction score
290
Gender
Female
Country
Poland
Dalai Lama doesn't support independence for Tibet but an authonomy (I think). As far as this I support Tibetan demands. And that's why I'm very glad that China got the Olympics. If it weren't for that there wouldn't be as much controversy and media coverage on the issue.

I agree it's unfair that the group which is being pressured the most by the boycott campaign are the sportsmen. Olympics is their Holy Grail, they were preparing themselves for years for this one occasion. The people who can do something are politicians and businessmen. But is it fair to demand that someone should endanger their company in the name of ideals? People have to earn a living, even if it means doing business with a country which doesn't respect human rights (it is different case with Google, since they were actively helping with violating those rights). That's why we're left with politicians. Let's see what happens.
 

BoXs

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Dec 31, 2007
Messages
19
Reaction score
1
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
no no ... I mear that it is far from Communism ... no one shares anything anymore, there are votings for like provincial leaders ... what are they called again? ... and many cities have voting for mayors now ... it is FAR FAR away from communism for sure ... they are changing but slow ... better than India ... talk about human rights there ... women who lost their husbands are said to be cursed and seen as 3rd class ... and it is much harder for Indian women to find jobs ... at least the riches person in china is a woman
 

walkie

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2005
Messages
844
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
Turkey
its communist like kurdistan, or cuba.......need new communist countries though.....maybe like brazil or somethin
for kurdistan to be communist, first there must be a country named as kurdistan, you cannot decide government type of a non-existing country/province :)
 
Top