Discussion Boycotting the Summer Olympics in China?

Gold Knight

MH Senpai
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2005
Messages
19,231
Reaction score
1,275
Gender
Hidden
Country
Abu Dhabi

D3M1URG3

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2007
Messages
179
Reaction score
19
Age
40
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I wouldn't necessarily endorse any kind of of boycotting, nor do I believe any of the Nations belonging to the U.N would either. There being many issues with holding it there notwithstanding, China is simply just too important to be put down in any way. These nations might deter their citizens from attending in some unofficial way, but I just don't see them trying to boycott. Simply don't.
 

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Bah, Tibet is just a rogue territory like Taiwan, they are still part of China, if Alaska rebeled against the gov't, dont you think we would use similar tactics, and they brought it down upon themselves for not listening to the Chinese gov't. If we boycott the games, we might as well boycott it in the U.S. for its suppression of Iraqi and Afghani peoples, and Russia for Chechnya.....if anything, China needs our support to help crush these uprisings that threaten the stability of the far east.
 

Gold Knight

MH Senpai
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2005
Messages
19,231
Reaction score
1,275
Gender
Hidden
Country
Abu Dhabi
Well, it's not just Tibet that's the issue.
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
There's a big difference between Alaska and Tibet: we didn't take Alaska by force. Russians did, and we bought it from them :p.

I'll support a boycott of the Chinese Olympics. There censoring of numerous websites and laws that limit freedom of speech piss me off. Also, I don't like any country that forces women to have abortions. That's just wrong.
 

Gold Knight

MH Senpai
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2005
Messages
19,231
Reaction score
1,275
Gender
Hidden
Country
Abu Dhabi
I'll support a boycott of the Chinese Olympics. There censoring of numerous websites and laws that limit freedom of speech piss me off. Also, I don't like any country that forces women to have abortions. That's just wrong.
Well, population control is something China likely doesn't enjoy advocating, but there's already a billion of them, as they would say on SNL. :p
 

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
yeah, except they have problems with food as it is, over 1/3 of the entire populace of the earth is crowded into that tiny country....there is kinda a need for pop. control, everywhere in fact because there are alrdy millions of homeless children.....and what, you think America doesn't censor? ever heard of the house of unamerican activities committee? they censored darn near every aspect of life in America, and tarnished the names of thousands of people, just because they were called communists, when in fact most of them weren't...
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
yeah, except they have problems with food as it is, over 1/3 of the entire populace of the earth is crowded into that tiny country....there is kinda a need for pop. control, everywhere in fact because there are alrdy millions of homeless children.....and what, you think America doesn't censor? ever heard of the house of unamerican activities committee? they censored darn near every aspect of life in America, and tarnished the names of thousands of people, just because they were called communists, when in fact most of them weren't...
Yes, but that was the 1950s, things have changed since then. I can walk up to the gates of the White House and yell "Bush Sucks" and nothing will happen. I can voice any political opinion I want. Heck, your sig has commies in it - you are voicing an opinion contrary to the president's. In China, you can't do that. You say anything against the government, you'll either end up in jail or dead. And the government doesn't censor the internet half as much as China does. A google search of "fuck bush" shows over half a million hits. In China, you couldn't look up "fuck mao" or see anything that the Party opposes. You say anything contrary to the Party's belief you'll end up with jail time, if not worse.

I know plenty about the House Un-American. Yes, they did injure many people, ruin lives and many others. I also know that the House Un-American closed in 1975 and had been in decline since 1959 when Truman called it "the most Un-American thing in the country today". We are not even close to being as censored as the Chinese are.
People may have been censored in the past, but today Americans can say just about anything they want. (Save anything libelous).
 
Last edited:

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I really really really want to talk about the Tibet crisis, but unfortunately I'm on vacation so I only can talk briefly on it..

It is sad. The Tibetan people want democracy and freedom, and they are fed up with the Chinese government, but sadly I don't think they even have a shot against the government. It is futile what they are doing, and they'll only end up dead. Perhaps hundreds have died, but who knows...I don't think foreign journalists are even allowed in China so we rely on what the government-run China media says...but I've heard videos of what actually happened are all over youtube, but I haven't gotten a chance to see it yet though.

Ever heard of the Tienenman Square massacre of 1989? Students protested and they wanted democracy and freedom, they even set up a statue that represented liberty, and what happened? the Chinese government put down the protest (they called it rebellion), and they sent tanks to run over the people, and some people estimate thousands have died, but nobody knows for sure. Up to this day, people our age in China (teens to early 20's) probably have never heard of the incident. Why? because it's illegal to mention it, not in the media, not in textbooks, not anywhere. The penalties are harsh at the slight mention of it. You probably cannot even google the words "Tienenman", because it's filtered.

In contrast, the US have had embarrassing moments as well...perhaps the biggest breach to civil liberties that I can recall is the Mccarthy Communist-witch-hunt, or the Japanese internment camps....but this pales in comparison with what the Chinese government are doing. The US government has not committed any atrocity, or killed protesters and then made it illegal to mention it.....Even today, you can argue that the American media has a certain political party bias, but that's about it....it is by far the most "uncensored" media in the world, in my opinion. In China, the state runs the whole show, the media is state controlled, and they stifle dissent with force. Sadly, we cannot do anything about it, other than to reprimand, perhaps boycott the Olympics, but at the end of the day, it's probably not going to change anything.


Will I boycott the Olympics? Yes. Although it's unfair to the athletes because they're stuck in this whole political aspect of it, and boycotting probably won't force China to change their policies. Steven Spielberg a month ago, who is a sponsor of the Olympics, stepped down because he did not agree with China's foreign policy in its support for the Khartoum (Sudan) government. As you all know, the Khartoum government is suspected of supporting the Janjaweed anti-rebel militias, who is believed to have been responsible with ethnic-cleansing in Darfur..........and the Chinese government has major investments in Sudan, and so as expected, they are silent about the Darfur genocide, and has done little to oppose the Khartoum government's policies.

So China is in a lot of mess right now, and it will hurt the Olympic games, no doubt about it.
 

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
yes ive heard about tinnamen square, and the govt hav evry right to do what they did, the people were told to leave, but they refused, so action had to be taken...same thing at Kent State during nam.
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
yes ive heard about tinnamen square, and the govt hav evry right to do what they did, the people were told to leave, but they refused, so action had to be taken...same thing at Kent State during nam.
So your saying that the government did the right thing by killing students just because they voiced their opinion? You're kidding me, right? Only someone under the complete control of the fascist Chinese government would say that.

Yeah, I'm calling China a fascist state. They have all the hallmarks of a fascist country - worship of the State. Most definitions of fascism revolve around worshipping the State, the Party.

Whoever gave Beijing the Olympics was either drunk or dropped on their head. Hong Kong maybe, but Beijing? It's never a good idea to give the Olympics to a country that is currently embroiled in border disputes. Do we really need a repeat of Berlin?
 

CrazyBoy

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
http://www.michaelparenti.org/Tibet.html

I do encourage that everyone read this article about Tibet's past with slavery, Monks being kings (that's why they want their land back), and how things were back then before really talking about it. They had no human right to start with, yet they used that excuse to break away from China. They talked about modernizing when sooner or later they will modernize with the world. I mean, please don't live in a fantasy that 1000 years from now Tibet will use hands to build temples, use horse as transport, have no modern toilets, etc. All their excuses to break away from China are all BS to me.

And try not to listen to the media, a lot of them tend to be wrong, or distorted the facts:
http://club.news.sohu.com/r-minjian-1674092-0-27-0.html

The Germans just apologized yesterday for using Napol's images as China. Some of these media even used Indian army and say they are Chinese @@, or used only half of the entire image (the first one. They only showed the Chinese military truck and dead bodies, but cut out the riotors)

China is not 100% correct that's for sure, but Tibet is not all right or holy (considering their history). Dalai Lama was one of those rich Grand monks that was forced to leave when they lost to China when China stop slavery (since Communism doesn't believe in slavery - read the first link I post, please~). To me, Dalai Lama is totally two faced, and a very good polical figure. Also, in my eyes, why British is helping Dalai Lama is because Tibet used to be theirs, so they don't want China to have it (British have a very good history of spliting countries up when they cannot have something, India is a great example. After Gandhi worked so hard for independence, the British in a way, tricked him and seperated India and Pakistan)

Well that's just my opinion. I think China is doing fine right now for this issue. The west should really mind their own business (I mean Canada won't want China to start making a big fuss about this northern town in Ontario where the Native Americans are blocking all traffics - cars, trains - and claiming that land as their for nearly 2 years now. The towns ppl are really distrubed by this, and cannot live peacefully. Since it isn't China's business, so China shouldn't interfer right? Just like how the West shouldn't intefer. Or China helping Quebec province splite away from Canada)

Again, just an opinion, please no bashing. But I do hope most of you would read a bit of history abut Tibet (the link I posted or you can find your own about Tibet, monks and the serfs). I do not think any country should boycott Chinese Olympics for this.

And about the issue at Khartoum. I do not think it got anything to do with China really. They are trading weapons for goods (it is in a contract). It's like me trading a knife for your food, but you you used the knife to steal, is it really my problem? In a way, China could had helped the situation, but they are only trading partners after all. Again just my view on this topic. No bashing of flaming. I admit, I am not very familar with this topic (since I was business during that time and didn't have time to read the news). So correct me if I am wrong that China is just a trading partner.
 
Last edited:

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
China isnt a facist state, that would be more along the lines of Myanmar, or perhaps Mexico, maybe even Columbia, but not China, we have a lot to learn from the chinese.....and america treats them like crap, we force them to work for long hours with no pay....a prime example of capitalist greed i might add
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Every country's history has slavery in the past. Slavery is the legacy of every culture. Religious figures in most every country have wielded enormous amounts of political power.(ever heard of Cardinal Richelieu, or the Pope?) I'm not against China's takeover of Tibet because I think Tibet is such a great country. I'm against any country that exercises blatant imperialism. Sure, the West is guilty of imperialism, but the West ceased their grabs for lands after WWI and much of the land they stole has been given back. The Tibetan people don't want to be under Chinese rule, and that's why I support Tibetan freedom. Not because I hold any hippy-dippy "All the Lama wants is peace" fantasies. Tibet's hands are covered with blood, just like every other country. That doesn't mean they deserve to be under the control of any other country.

And there's a difference between the Native Americans blocking roads and the protests in Tibet - the Canadian government isn't mowing down the Natives.

I am going to boycott the Beijing Olympics, not because of China's treatment of protesters. I am going to boycott because China almost parallels INGSOC. There is worship of the Party and the Party's founder. There are also constant examples of doublespeak. According to China's 1982 constitution, every citizen is allowed freedom of demonstation, yet 2000 protesters were killed at Tiananmen Square. It claims to be a "communist" country, yet the 2004 amendments to their constitution protects private property. Don't get me wrong, I think private property is awesome. But in a communist society, there is no private property. There are examples of "Big Brother"-esque policies in much of the West, but they are nowhere near as glaring or obvious as PRC.

I don't think any country should "mind there own business" when human rights are being violated. I will not turn a blind eye when people are being forced to have abortions (a policy that has not been effective) or where a country that claims to have "freedom of press" goes to extremes to keep its citizens from viewing websites critical of the Party.

China isnt a facist state, that would be more along the lines of Myanmar, or perhaps Mexico, maybe even Columbia, but not China, we have a lot to learn from the chinese.....and america treats them like crap, we force them to work for long hours with no pay....a prime example of capitalist greed i might add
Yes, it's our fault that Chinese people toil for hours. It has nothing to do with China not enforcing their human rights laws. Fascism in its most basic definition is "a system in which the Party comes before the individual." China has repeatedly done things that deteriorate the individual for the sake of the State. The most obvious example is the One Child Policy. What do we have to learn from the Chinese? Doublespeak? How to institute Apartheid against a country we take over?
 
Last edited:

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
That's one isolated incident, as opposed to troops being called in. And to be honest, I think both are open to inquiry by other countries.
EDIT:

First off, yes Canadians, Americans, Australians, etc... Just about every British settled colony (or any colonizing country) is guilty of oppressing the native people. But you know what? That's the past. We have for the most part learned from our mistakes and are trying to make amends. China is oppressing the Tibetans today. I can't be positive that the Tibetan people won't return to serfdom, but I know that they are right now being oppressed. If China wants to considered a modern country, it has to respect modern standards of human rights. They can't claim "it's their culture". They can't have it both ways. No one can change the past, but you can learn from it. People in the US have learned the treatment of the Native peoples was wrong and have tried to fix the mistakes of their forefathers, but I am not guilty of my forefather's crimes. The PRC is committing these atrocities in the here and now. To continue the "thief" metaphor, they are not thieves because they stole something years ago; they are thieves because they are stealing as we speak.

There's a big difference between the South leaving the Union and Tibet wanting independence. First off, the States in the South all applied for admittance into the Union, whereas Tibet was taken over in an invasion, once in 1290 and again in 1950. Another difference: the Civil War happened over 120 years ago! And the South didn't want independence because they were being considered "second class citizens", they wanted independence because they wanted to continue harboring slaves. And the Confederacy wasn't just going to succeed and stay to themselves; sooner or later it was going to try and claim more of the Union's territory. One final difference between the Civil War and Tibet: Tibet doesn't make up over half of the PRC!


I don't "hate" China because they are commies. This has nothing to do with the US Government creating a "common enemy" in the Chinese. This has to do with the Chinese government actively disregarding human rights. Sure, the US may be guilty of some human rights violations, but they are nowhere near as extensive as the Chinese governments and I am opposed to those violations committed as well. If China wants to say its citizens have "freedom of speech, freedom of press, freedom of association, freedom of demonstration", then they should give their citizens these rights. Currently, they don't have them. Apartheid was wrong, segregation was wrong, and the treatment of Native Americans was wrong. The key word there is "was". We have learned from our mistakes and have learned that every human deserves to be treated with respect. It's time China learned that as well.
 
Last edited:

Franckie

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 16, 2007
Messages
2,902
Reaction score
1,381
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
Approximately half of USA's debt is held by foreign governments, primarily by China, Japan, and Southeast Asian nations. USA is pretty unlikely to boycott the Olympics, especially with how China considers the Olympics to be very important.

It's true that something may very well happen down the road which causes countries such as the USA to boycott the Olympics, but it won't occur under current circumstances.
 

Vampire_Fanatic

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2007
Messages
51
Reaction score
2
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
United States
if we boycott the olympics in china, the next time they are to arrive in the U.S.A., China will surely due the same to us, and they hav just as much power, if not more, in the political sphere of influence.....we just need to drop it...
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I'm okay with the Chinese boycotting the Olympics. We may have a chance in the gymnastics competition finally.
 

CrazyBoy

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
This is what I meant by double standard. It meant somone DID something and won't allow others to do it and also, having another persepecitive on it and judge it completely different. Chinese invaded Tibet over ... over 50 or so years ago, that was the past too. There are a lot of Natives striking against the North American gov as we speak. They don't just want reserves, but a piece of thier own land that doesn't belong to any gov on any map.

For me, I always ask, how do one define moderinize? Some might argue having a necleus family, or putting more discipline in school (like in Asian school) is more modernize. In the novel, Brave New World, the lower grade of ppl were in a way, being treated unfairly, that's how that guy thought modernize would mean (even though he disagree). In the novel Giver, the world is pure, happy, jobs were given to citizens like Communist countries, that might mean modernize too. To me, modernize does not mean going towards what the West thinks is right (Karl Marx thought that Communism is a modernize system, which was different from the West). So the statement that China wants to become more modernize, in my opinion, should change to, China wants to become more like the West, which doesn't mean it's the best. (There are a lot of articles, novels, short essays about what modernize mean or is about, which is different from West's image of modernize)

And as we speak "today" the States are trying to Westernize Iraq, and introduce ppl with their system even though majority are against it, since "recently" the States, in a way, invaded Iraq (in my opinion, it was an invassion, but they didn't ruled over like normal invassion). They are stealing, what I called, Iraqis' choices.

My opinion on how Tibet and the Civil War is alike still stands. If you look around, it is mosly monks who are doing the riots. They wear red robes and stuff. Why? Many say it is because China took slavery away from them, that's why Delia Lama fought against the Chinese, lost, flee to India, and asked West for help. It started out as slavery more that "second class citizens". And they were lucky, and a bit special, since in Karl Marx's Communism (you can refer to John Lennon's Imagine song), there should be NO relgion, but Chinese let them keep their beliefs instead of totally destroying their temples, killing those monks. If that's still being treated as "second" class, then I guess a lot of Chinese are treated as "third", "fourth" or even "fifth". And being second class citizens, China dumps billions of dollars to Tibet, to keep it alive. Lucky them I guess.

The point of me making the connection to Civil War is because the South also wanted to leave (and had all the rights), but yet the North still claim it back (doesn't matter if it is about slavery or not). The real polical reason why they want it back is because once they let them splite, even if the other side will not attack them or claim more terriotory, other parts might want independence too once an disagreement started between them and another state (they will say, you let A splite away from you, why can't I?). The country will grow smaller and smaller into parts. This is why Canada do not allow Quebec to fall apart because BC might want to leave too, the the entire country wil be totally apart (I believe last time there was a vote in Quebec regarding independence, it was 48% or so. It was estimated that next vote would be over 50% "for sure" since each time there was a vote, it increased dramatically and so, the gov doesn't allow another vote anytime soon, to keep it as theirs - heard that from my history teacher, so I might need more reference on this one). This is also why China does not want Tibet to leave China, it would affect the other parts too. And to me, and some ppl, the North is still wrong since they invaded and claimed the South even against the South's wishes. It is like Tibet, who belonged to China since 1290 AD (of course, during some time, it was taken over by others such as British due to invassion), and was last invaded by China (in short, it belonged to China - like South part of the States, and left - like the South left, then China took over again - like North took over the South, stop slavery, the monks rebelled and etc.). In my opinion, its more polical reason than just being free and etc.

As I said, give China time. It took a while for the Blacks in America to get what they deserved. Give China some time. Nothing is going to happen right away. If China have a big change right now, it is bad for the economy. With the economy being bad, ppl will lose jobs and rather have the old system back. I mean, China had changed a lot already in the last 10 years. They vote for their mayors, and their Premiers. Things are changing, but it takes time.

Again, this is my opinion on the topic. I like to use the past as reference so that there would be no double standard.

Oh well, whatever. Have a good day and thank you for reading :)
 

mrcongojack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
651
Reaction score
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
This is what I meant by double standard. It meant somone DID something and won't allow others to do it and also, having another persepecitive on it and judge it completely different. Chinese invaded Tibet over ... over 50 or so years ago, that was the past too. There are a lot of Natives striking against the North American gov as we speak. They don't just want reserves, but a piece of thier own land that doesn't belong to any gov on any map.
First off, the Chinese government is still occupying Tibet, whereas the South has almost universally accepted being a part of the US.(I bet there is some lunatic anarchist fringe who advocates succession consisting of a few hundred people) In fact, the South is possibly the most patriotic region in the US.

Yes Native Americans protest the government. What happened to them was indeed tragic, so why let it happen to the people of Tibet? Does saying "oh well you did it too" make what the Chinese doing any better? We have tried to make amends, but seeing as the occupation of Native American territory happened over a century ago, and to give them their land back would be impossible. If we started doing that, why shouldn't the Celts get their land back from the Anglo-Saxons? If you go back far enough, everyone has had land stolen from them. We can't change the past, but we can end the control of Tibet by an oppressive nation.

And what is the "North American gov"? There are people in Canada who would be pretty cheesed if you suggested there was a North American Union. The Facebook group "CANADIANS AGAINST THE NORTH AMERICAN UNION" has over 50,000 members, all of which I assume would not like the insinuation that there is one North American gov.
For me, I always ask, how do one define moderinize?
I consider any country that doesn't state they give their citizens freedom of demonstration and then quells "riots" of student demonstrators with armed troops "modern".
And as we speak "today" the States are trying to Westernize Iraq, and introduce ppl with their system even though majority are against it, since "recently" the States, in a way, invaded Iraq (in my opinion, it was an invassion, but they didn't ruled over like normal invassion). They are stealing, what I called, Iraqis' choices.
Yes, but would we give Iraq the Olympics? Do I think what we are doing in Iraq is wrong? Yes. But I think that "giving freedom to Iraqis" (which, to some extent, US forces have accomplished. There have been elections in Iraq, something they didn't truly have under Saddam) is a much better excuse as to why it is occupied than "because the Mongols took it over in 1290". Regardless of whether I think the war is legit, at least US Forces are doing it for the good of the Iraqi people and the rest of the Middle East, even if it is incredibly overbearing.
My opinion on how Tibet and the Civil War is alike still stands. If you look around, it is mosly monks who are doing the riots. They wear red robes and stuff. Why? Many say it is because China took slavery away from them, that's why Delia Lama fought against the Chinese, lost, flee to India, and asked West for help. It started out as slavery more that "second class citizens". And they were lucky, and a bit special, since in Karl Marx's Communism (you can refer to John Lennon's Imagine song), there should be NO relgion, but Chinese let them keep their beliefs instead of totally destroying their temples, killing those monks. If that's still being treated as "second" class, then I guess a lot of Chinese are treated as "third", "fourth" or even "fifth". And being second class citizens, China dumps billions of dollars to Tibet, to keep it alive. Lucky them I guess.
The point of me making the connection to Civil War is because the South also wanted to leave (and had all the rights), but yet the North still claim it back (doesn't matter if it is about slavery or not). The real polical reason why they want it back is because once they let them splite, even if the other side will not attack them or claim more terriotory, other parts might want independence too once an disagreement started between them and another state (they will say, you let A splite away from you, why can't I?). The country will grow smaller and smaller into parts. This is why Canada do not allow Quebec to fall apart because BC might want to leave too, the the entire country wil be totally apart (I believe last time there was a vote in Quebec regarding independence, it was 48% or so. It was estimated that next vote would be over 50% "for sure" since each time there was a vote, it increased dramatically and so, the gov doesn't allow another vote anytime soon, to keep it as theirs - heard that from my history teacher, so I might need more reference on this one). This is also why China does not want Tibet to leave China, it would affect the other parts too. And to me, and some ppl, the North is still wrong since they invaded and claimed the South even against the South's wishes. It is like Tibet, who belonged to China since 1290 AD (of course, during some time, it was taken over by others such as British due to invassion), and was last invaded by China (in short, it belonged to China - like South part of the States, and left - like the South left, then China took over again - like North took over the South, stop slavery, the monks rebelled and etc.). In my opinion, its more polical reason than just being free and etc.
Who told you it was mainly monks fighting for Tibetan freedom? The PRC has denied Hong Kong and foreign news agencies from going into Tibet, so any news coming out of there would have to be from....the PRC? And don't you think they might be a little slanted in their reporting. (PRC media is terrible when it comes to fair news coverage.) The boys in the PRC's media make Fox News look down right honest.

And the claim the PRC has to Tibet is flimsy at best. Sure, during imperial rule Tibet was part of China, but after China became a Republic and civil war broke out, China lost interest in Tibet. Sure it never formally renounced power, but in the same way the US hasn't officially ended the Korean War. I don't see how Tibet being controlled by the former emperor of China gives the PRC the right to claim Tibet as its own.
As I said, give China time. It took a while for the Blacks in America to get what they deserved. Give China some time. Nothing is going to happen right away. If China have a big change right now, it is bad for the economy. With the economy being bad, ppl will lose jobs and rather have the old system back. I mean, China had changed a lot already in the last 10 years. They vote for their mayors, and their Premiers. Things are changing, but it takes time.
Time? In the 20+ since their new constitution, they have become more oppressive, and continually go back on the rights they "give" the people of China. Since when did the USA enact the Prime Directive? Why should we let other countries slog through the dark period of social injustice that we went through 200 years ago? We would be basically green lighting the deaths of millions while letting more lead sneak its way into our children's toys.

Why should the economy of China stand in the way of human rights? Their business sector may be doing well, but this success comes at the cost of the environment and social freedom. If you ask me,
Again, this is my opinion on the topic. I like to use the past as reference so that there would be no double standard.

O well, whatever. Have a good day and thank you for reading :)
Double standard? In your previous post you said
One shouldn't judge a person's action because of who is he (example: a thief will always be a thief, but this might not be true all the time)
So China shouldn't be judged because it is a nation that actively lies about embracing human rights, yet the USA should be held accountable still for the Civil War, which happened 140 years ago?

All of the human rights violations committed by Americans of yesteryear were indeed atrocious, but they did lead us to where we are today. Today, we know that every human deserves to have basic rights, and that governments should not put themselves over the people. Governments are meant to serve the people, not the other way around. If China wants to call itself "modern", it needs to give its citizens human rights. Period. I'm not singling out just China; any nation that grossly mistreats its citizens should be held accountable. We can't just sit by and let what happened to people in our nation centuries ago happen to other human beings. We can't just wait while countries like China play "catch up", treating them like any other country while turning a blind eye to their human rights violations.

I don't really care whether or not Tibet is a free country or not. Or Quebec for that matter. Heck, I could live without the South (the North's economy didn't really depend on the South. In fact, The South's economy depended on the North more than North depended on it. The North had many industries, while the South pretty much just has crop farming such as cotton, which it exported to the North for processing. This is one of the many reasons the North won the Civil War - the South ran out of cash. It's funny, seldom are wars determined by which country has the better fighters or more troops, but rather who has more money.) Many historians speculate the South would have come back to the North within 30 years if their was no Civil War. It lacked the economic infrastructure to support a nation, seeking as the industrial revolution had pretty much passed them by. It's odd, parallels could be drawn to our current situation with oil. Oil may be the cheapest and most lucrative way of producing energy right now, but alternatives will outlast our oil reserves and prepare us better for crisis. We are acting like the South, sticking to the old ways which relied on tried-and-true plantation farming, which may be good for the owners right now, but it inevitably left them vulnerable. That was a weird tangent, huh?
 
Top