Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Leoat12]

Shoseki Manga Rankings (7/8-13/8)
2. One Piece #86
5. Haikyu!! #27
11. Black Clover #12
24. Kimetsu no Yaiba #7
38. We Never Learn #2
93. Samon the Summoner #10
415. Demon Prince Poro's Diaries #2

Looks good for We Never Learn, it will make into the top 50 in its second week, it is great for a second volume.

 

[Tamil]

You need to compare with the estimates.

This week ranked at 24:

30位29700/50位16900/100位9730/200位5850/300位3950/400位2850/500位2200​

Volume 6's second week ranked at 21:

30位16000/50位10700/100位7050/200位4150/300位2900/400位2350/500位2000​

It's growing.

I see, thank you. KnY Vol. 6's sales covered 13 days at that point and Vol. 7 covered 10 days. Never considered that lol.

 

[Shinji Hirako]

Reborn continuation would be amazing and I feel like Shueisha may have missed out on a big opportunity to revive the series. Instead of capitalising on the re-emergence of merchandise to celebrate the anime's 10th anniversary all we got were the Blu-ray sets and some figurines(at least its Megahouse).

 

[TyVip]

give me a continuation of Eyeshield21!!!

 

[Leoat12]

People are already forgetting that Reborn was dead last almost in a weekly basis until they forced it out of the magazine? Continuations? *laughs*

 

[RubyR91]

People are already forgetting that Reborn was dead last almost in a weekly basis until they forced it out of the magazine? Continuations? *laughs*

What are you talking about? In its final year Reborn mainly ranked in the middle.

 

[ChocoBar9]

Spoiler

Shaman King has 53 million copies in circulation now.

 

[Heiji]

Spoiler

Shaman King has 53 million copies in circulation now.

Its for all series means : Normal edition (32 volumes), deluxe edition (27 volumes), flowers (6 volumes) & zero (2 volumes). Perhaps they are also remix edition (16 volumes).

 

[shoyoboyo]

Ehh, I wouldn't really want a Reborn continuation or reboot. It's not that old nor is it that great. The only good things about it were the unique premise, the art, and some good characters (Yamamoto, Hibari, and Mukuro). It peaked too soon at the Kokuyo arc, then later the Varia arc, and then afterward it just fell into mediocrity. Don't even get me started on the long drawn out mess that was the Future arc, or the horrible protag Tsuna.

Haikyuu, World Trigger, and Bleach are definitely continuations I can get behind though. A Toriko reboot is merely a dream though.

 

[Nakura]

It's all a matter of subjectivity I suppose, but I would agree that the Varia arc is the peak of the whole series... and that's not even to say it was amazing or anything. It's just that everything afterwards was so dragged out and repetitive. I definitely couldn't care less about a possible KHR remake.

 

[WesKR]

Still waiting on that Yu Yu Hakusho remake...

 

[Avok]

I think the YYH anime is perfectly fine.

 

[Ecchi Boy]

Really about opinions but I think Reborn is great, I don't about stupid crap and besides it gets alot more retweets than Eldlive which is sad Because I love Eldlive too. I am going to guess Fujos don't want to read Eldlive which explains Eldlive low popularity. even though Eldlive had hot sexy guys (No Homo) but I hope Amano recaptures more male readers I must stay positive.

 

[Heiji]

 

[shoyoboyo]

Nah, Eldlive has no chance of becoming popular. The anime was a flop and it brought little to no boosts to the manga sales.

 

[Doughboy]

What do you guys feel is better: Shaman King or Reborn? If I never came across this thread I would of legit never heard of either.

 

[Leoat12]

For a moment I thought it was a Kimetsu no Yaiba spin-off because the character looks like KY main character although cartoon-ish. XD

 

[razerxs]

What do you guys feel is better: Shaman King or Reborn? If I never came across this thread I would of legit never heard of either.

I'd vote for Shaman King but that might just be nostalgia.

Spoiler: Nostalgia

It was all the cool parts of Bleach before it was even a thing.

 

[Tamil]

What do you guys feel is better: Shaman King or Reborn? If I never came across this thread I would of legit never heard of either.

Shaman King and yeah mainly because of nostalgia. It would be greatly condensed. Ushio To Tora was 39 episodes and was condensed a lot and skipped some stuff but under the mangaka's approval. I wouldn't know what to expect from MAPPA.

 

[shoyoboyo]

Definitely Shaman King. It had its problems that arose at the final arc, but everything before that was great. I also find the art style and characters more charming than Reborn's.