(2years skip) Shiliew vs Zoro

[aceking888]

Who will win?
Location:Marine headquarters, Marines all passed out, only 'em
Zoro trained under mihawk
Shilew rivals magellan remember?

 

[Schabrak]

Re: (2years skip) shilew vs Zoro

Why would two pirates fight in the Marine HQ and even more idiotic, why would everyone be asleep on the dusty ground? There is no basis to compare them to each other, since we've seen nearly nothing from Zorro and still nothing from Shilew. There's just one thing to say, both are strong, but that's it.

 

[Anduren]

It's true that after the 2 years we have no idea how strong Zoro has gotten. On top of that we have no idea how strong Shiryu has gotten after the 2 years either. Add to this that we have seen next to nothing on the ability of Shiryu BEFORE the 2 year time skip except for being told that he was equal in power to Warden Magellan (Eventhough he lost to Magellan when he was put into Level 6 in Impel Down). If such a battle did take place in Marineford, I would say it could go either way but highly doubt at this point in time that Zoro could beat Shiryu just because I think Zoro will not be fighting him for a while and when he does, it will be further down the grand line after he has improved more, and when the battle between Zoro and Shiryu eventually DOES take place, they will be evenly matched.

By the way Schabrak please be nice and don't insult people that just want to discuss things for fun as fans of One Piece. Chances are most of the things people on the forums talk about will never happen but that doesn't mean its idiotic or that no one is allowed to talk about it. All you're doing is attacking a person's self esteem and discouraging more people who might want to join in the discussions from wanting to ever get involved.

 

[Katz]

It's true that after the 2 years we have no idea how strong Zoro has gotten. On top of that we have no idea how strong Shiryu has gotten after the 2 years either. Add to this that we have seen next to nothing on the ability of Shiryu BEFORE the 2 year time skip except for being told that he was equal in power to Warden Magellan (Eventhough he lost to Magellan when he was put into Level 6 in Impel Down). If such a battle did take place in Marineford, I would say it could go either way but highly doubt at this point in time that Zoro could beat Shiryu just because I think Zoro will not be fighting him for a while and when he does, it will be further down the grand line after he has improved more, and when the battle between Zoro and Shiryu eventually DOES take place, they will be evenly matched.

By the way Schabrak please be nice and don't insult people that just want to discuss things for fun as fans of One Piece. Chances are most of the things people on the forums talk about will never happen but that doesn't mean its idiotic or that no one is allowed to talk about it. All you're doing is attacking a person's self esteem and discouraging more people who might want to join in the discussions from wanting to ever get involved.

Gotta agree here, they'll fight eventually (the fight between the straw hat crew and the blackbeard pirates is 100% gonna happen but not for awhile) but like Anduren stats we know NOTHING of what Current Zoro or Shiryu of now or two years ago could or can do now.....this is one of those threads that we should just set in our back pocket for when this clash actually happens.

 

[jorped]

we dont have any info to make a good answer. we still dont know how strong got zoro after the 2 years skip and we know less about shiliew if you make ask to me i think he might be as strong as Mangella but this is just a thought.


Straw hat crew vs blackbear crew will happen , that i have 100% sure but i think is not going to be so soon so zoro still will have lots of times to get stronger and also the same for the rest of the crew eventually the day will come that they will beat the blacbeard pirates and luffy is going to get his revenge , blackbeard is a dead man

 

[frontaLobotomy]

It depends when they fight, the location will have little to do with it. For all we know, they might end up fighting the Blackbeard Pirates more than once, Roger and Whitebeard apparently did.
At the current time, Shiryu is probably still stronger than Zoro. Surviving 2 years of training with Mihawk, which probably involved having to fight every swordsman that came to challenge him, has no doubt made him a great deal more skilled. Shiryu is already mad strong, though we've yet to see battle where the odds were not stacked in his favour; cutting down unprepared guards, suckerpunching Magellan and ganging up on an almost dead Whitebeard don't count for much.

 

[Realtwisted]

Shilew was magellan rival, and it was said that they were equally strong. Knowing how strong Magellan is, Shilew should be a beast.

 

[beastboy]

Well, Zoro would make Sashime out of a Krakken, but we don't know a thing about Shillew so we should just wait.

 

[Realtwisted]

You know what would be great if their is like another Pirate Crew that is the Dark side of SH, but i guess their is already is one Kid Pirate.

 

[Franckie]

Shiliew is still feat-less but should win via powerscaling. Because Shiliew is Zoro's last major opponent and close to Magellan's level before the timeskip, that makes him top-tier. Thus, we can hold Shiliew to the same expectations people have for Mihawk. Zoro as he is right now is still not strong enough to defeat Mihawk (otherwise he would have taken Mihawk's title already), which means he is weaker than Shiliew as well.

 

[BlackHair]

I still hope Mihawk is Zoro's last enemy. If Shiliew happens to be the last one, it would technically mean that he is stronger than Mwk or at some point he will be stronger than Mwk. I just don't want that to happen. Mwk should stay as the strongest swordsman, until Zoro defeats him.

Anyway, on topic Shiliew wins this.