Politics Are the New Security Procedures too Invasive

lordHokage

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
4,697
Reaction score
421
Gender
Female
Country
Bahamas

Whether you like it or not, a revealing full-body scans or a genital touching patdowns or both, these new security procedures are too invasive and without probable cause violate basic human rights. Governments do not have the right to conduct routine and mandatory screening strip searches to remove clothes at airports and regardless of their methods of moral reasoning, people are so angry over these screening measures. And if there is another terrorist attack, passengers will be subjected to a whole new type of enhanced invasiveness patdowns and a new and improved high-quality image full-body x-ray scanners machines at all ports of entry. :comfort



In a post-9/11 world, are these high-image full-body x-ray scanners machines really safe, efficient, and protect passengers privacy or do they store, export, print, transmit images or create long-term health problems due to unknown radiation risks. There are those who claim that this new security procedure is ineffective, very expensive and totally useless against detecting bomb parts or explosives hidden within a person's body and passenger profiling should replace high-image full body x-ray scanners and enhanced patdowns. :crying



In the United States of America, public opinion approved of the high-image full-body x-ray scanners but disapproved of the enhanced patdowns. Do you approve or disapprove of the new security procedures and why? Besides visiting Grandma's, will you continue to travel by some other means or just stay put and explore the global internet market from home? :(



If Roman Catholic nuns can be groped not Muslim women, something is seriously wrong with that President Obama. Since these high-images full-body scans violate Islamic law they also violate Christian beliefs too. On that note, best wishes to everyone and to each it's own path. PEACE. :)


Thank you for your posts. :wtf
 

Roflkopt3r

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2010
Messages
2,476
Reaction score
1,663
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
I'm definitly gonna write a lot about this the next days, since I got few time right now I'll keep it short:

-Death due to terrorism is really really rare... there hasn't been many victims since 9/11 on the mentioned countries home grounds (West and Central Europe and USA)
-The much bigger thread currently is probably rather that some states rather constrict their citizen's rights out of fear
-Terrorists are nothing but murderers, they just are threated so differently only because they're organised - though way less successful than the group of unorganised miscelangelous random murderers who kill people every day in any country. Thus they just shouldn't be feared so much
-The existence of Terrorism should be treated as a symptom for a certain injustice in the world which drives people into becoming fanatics. Rather than spending money, time and energy on trying to find these peoples, the reasons and how to fix the injustice should be discussed and found.

Right now politicians and public are rather busy with discussing how to treat the symptoms (means: The terrorists) but not the underlying causes (deficits in many countries such as for example: Poorness, Starvation, Injustice, Bad Education)
However, the treatment of symptoms not only doesn't work very well, but also has severe side effects (surveillance, it's expansive, it takes time of people who could do more important things) plus the illness will not disappear on it's own obviously. Thus, the current attempts are bad - and the new security procedures belong to that.

By the way the conservatives managed to enforce a new ID card in Germany which has both a computer chip for digital and biometric data as well as a fingerprint.
The authors of German constitution said "The Germans are not a nation of criminals, thus we do not need a fingerprint on ID cards". Seemingly our conservatives know better... Actually they appointed to Spain - where it ackwardedly was introduced by General Franco, not the guy you want to appoint to as a politician - and could've appointed to Hitler as well...

(Ok, now I didn't keep it short, lol :D)
 

lordHokage

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
4,697
Reaction score
421
Gender
Female
Country
Bahamas
By the way the conservatives managed to enforce a new ID card in Germany which has both a computer chip for digital and biometric data as well as a fingerprint.
Even though you didn't answer the questions, very well said. :)

This new ID card in Germany which has both a computer chip for digital and biometric data as well as a fingerprint sparks my curiosity. Is it a biometric passport aka ePassport and if not, could you please elaborate on your country latest national security procedures, enquiring minds want to know? :D
 

AnkorSVK

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2009
Messages
105
Reaction score
20
Gender
Male
Country
Slovakia
Some interesting thoughts.

Roflkopt3r some realy good opinnions.

Ilikethe idea of lowering symptoms instead of destroying the root of the problem.
The ppl who try to cure are those who poison-you coulod say that the doctor is the one spreading it (doesnt matter if the original source of infected). The symptoms are in some way also side effects from cures like by medicaments used.
The best (depends on the point of view)is to cure the doctor and stop spreading even more before starting healing.
However the doctor doesnt want to be cured cos it would mean to change his lifestyle from the scratch and from his point of view not to a better one.

To the bio cards its garbage. if i remember correctly CCC (Chaos Computer Club ) proved their inefficiency. So another ineffective and overpriced drug.
Its all silly when i think about how the documents IDs and similar get more complicated and more expensive and have no effect, only reason to pull money from the wallets of the working class so that someone has profit.

All democracy....or more fitting capitalism bad/mounths komunism despite the fact they became more insane and incompetent.
 

Roflkopt3r

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2010
Messages
2,476
Reaction score
1,663
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Even though you didn't answer the questions, very well said. :)
Oops sorry, as I wrote in the beginning I was short and time and didn't really read it :amuse
Seems I rather wrote about how useful the new security procedures are than wether they're inappropriate or not.

Full body X-Ray scanners? That's even worse than in Germany and other European countries. Here some idiots want to introduce body scanners as well, but at least not with X-Rays because that's too risky for health. The German ones are somewhere between "not as risky" and "not risky at all", but nobody knows how risky they exactly are.
However, X-Rays and other scanners have a statistical risk of causing health problems up to cancer.

Thus, at the current rate of terrorists killing air passangers by bringing weapons into airplanes - which is next to NONE - it won't take the scanners a long time to have killed more people than airplane terrorists. Or actually it will, as even cancer takes some time to develop and kill, however, you get my point - the risks are higher. Certainly, it won't kill a whole bunch of people at once, but there will be some "individual cases" which will sum up to some people in the end.

Ok, that's still not about the question.
Well, if something is too invasive or not always depends on the situation of course. If someone enters a nuclear weapon base, it's nothing wrong with having rigid security procedures; even more it's necessary to protect society.
But these decisions about body scanners were just made out of fear, or possibly only the urge of politicians to pretend that they were doing something useful (not too unlikely imo :notrust), and I can't see much use in it.
Al Quaida and other terrorist organisations exist for years and decades now, and yet the number of people killed by terrorist hijacked airplanes is low apart from the 9/11 attack. The statistical improvement to security is next to none, while the violation of privacy is huge.

-> A typical example of a bad reaction. Yes, the new procedures are too invasive measured to the benefit to security they bring.
 

lordHokage

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
4,697
Reaction score
421
Gender
Female
Country
Bahamas
-Death due to terrorism is really really rare... there hasn't been many victims since 9/11 on the mentioned countries home grounds (West and Central Europe and USA)
-Terrorists are nothing but murderers, they just are threated so differently only because they're organised - though way less successful than the group of unorganised miscelangelous random murderers who kill people every day in any country. Thus they just shouldn't be feared so much
-The existence of Terrorism should be treated as a symptom for a certain injustice in the world which drives people into becoming fanatics. Rather than spending money, time and energy on trying to find these peoples, the reasons and how to fix the injustice should be discussed and found.

Right now politicians and public are rather busy with discussing how to treat the symptoms (means: The terrorists) but not the underlying causes (deficits in many countries such as for example: Poorness, Starvation, Injustice, Bad Education)

However, the treatment of symptoms not only doesn't work very well, but also has severe side effects (surveillance, it's expansive, it takes time of people who could do more important things) plus the illness will not disappear on it's own obviously. Thus, the current attempts are bad - and the new security procedures belong to that.
If you are hoping that Governments rolled up their sleeves to treat the symptoms meaning terrorists is wishful thinking. The former Homeland Security secretary Michael Chertoff with Government connections promoted terrorists out of fear while lobbying for companies that makes the unsafe full-body scanners machines for profit. :mad

It is not in elected officials best interest to determine the root cause of terrorists and why terrorists are viewed as modern day Robin Hood by impoverished, educated people. Both Politicians and the general public are only interested in a band-aid solution and scoring brownie points rather than treating the symptoms the right way putting an end to invasive security procedures. No one wants to be killed by terrorist's hands while on a airplane, train or cruise ship, or at a sporting arenas or the malls, but there are those who strongly believe that the new screening measures are not too invasive. :s
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,453
Reaction score
25,023
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Well, treating the underlying causes of something is important indeed (its even a logical move, basically prevent things from happening) however treating the symptom so to speak is just as important. Both should be given equal importance IMO. That said, it is not like individual countries don't try to prevent the symptoms at all. For a country to finally find a way to reduce poverty and increase its wealth in itself is extremely a long road of trial and error and even if a path is found it will still take half a century to finally turn things around. In that sense, the symptoms that are currently being dealt with are gonna be around for a while and its gonna be a LONG while until whatever solution applied now kicks in and makes a difference.

As for the actual topic, I guess it depends on the actual threat level. I mean, certainly terrorist attacks are rare in itself to a great degree however just one can be very severe. So far I am very much under the impression that a lot of this measures are simply made to create the idea that terrorist attacks are in a way imminent though, basically a form of marketing so to speak so in that sense the measures currently taken are far from necessary. On the other hand, if the real risk was actually high enough then such measures would seem reasonable. Seriously, if danger was actually high there shouldn't be room for error(I still do think most of these things are actually a marketing scheme though). I guess the other question would be whether there are alternative systems which would be just as effective(or at least close enough) without being this invasive(and for the love of god FASTER, I hate being in line just to have some random douche go through my stuff).
 

lordHokage

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
4,697
Reaction score
421
Gender
Female
Country
Bahamas
Oops sorry, as I wrote in the beginning I was short and time and didn't really read it :amuse
Seems I rather wrote about how useful the new security procedures are than wether they're inappropriate or not.

Full body X-Ray scanners? That's even worse than in Germany and other European countries. Here some idiots want to introduce body scanners as well, but at least not with X-Rays because that's too risky for health. The German ones are somewhere between "not as risky" and "not risky at all", but nobody knows how risky they exactly are.
However, X-Rays and other scanners have a statistical risk of causing health problems up to cancer.

Thus, at the current rate of terrorists killing air passangers by bringing weapons into airplanes - which is next to NONE - it won't take the scanners a long time to have killed more people than airplane terrorists. Or actually it will, as even cancer takes some time to develop and kill, however, you get my point - the risks are higher. Certainly, it won't kill a whole bunch of people at once, but there will be some "individual cases" which will sum up to some people in the end.

Ok, that's still not about the question.
Well, if something is too invasive or not always depends on the situation of course. If someone enters a nuclear weapon base, it's nothing wrong with having rigid security procedures; even more it's necessary to protect society.
But these decisions about body scanners were just made out of fear, or possibly only the urge of politicians to pretend that they were doing something useful (not too unlikely imo :notrust), and I can't see much use in it.
Al Quaida and other terrorist organisations exist for years and decades now, and yet the number of people killed by terrorist hijacked airplanes is low apart from the 9/11 attack. The statistical improvement to security is next to none, while the violation of privacy is huge.

-> A typical example of a bad reaction. Yes, the new procedures are too invasive measured to the benefit to security they bring.

Well, treating the underlying causes of something is important indeed (its even a logical move, basically prevent things from happening) however treating the symptom so to speak is just as important. Both should be given equal importance IMO. That said, it is not like individual countries don't try to prevent the symptoms at all. For a country to finally find a way to reduce poverty and increase its wealth in itself is extremely a long road of trial and error and even if a path is found it will still take half a century to finally turn things around. In that sense, the symptoms that are currently being dealt with are gonna be around for a while and its gonna be a LONG while until whatever solution applied now kicks in and makes a difference.

As for the actual topic, I guess it depends on the actual threat level. I mean, certainly terrorist attacks are rare in itself to a great degree however just one can be very severe. So far I am very much under the impression that a lot of this measures are simply made to create the idea that terrorist attacks are in a way imminent though, basically a form of marketing so to speak so in that sense the measures currently taken are far from necessary. On the other hand, if the real risk was actually high enough then such measures would seem reasonable. Seriously, if danger was actually high there shouldn't be room for error(I still do think most of these things are actually a marketing scheme though). I guess the other question would be whether there are alternative systems which would be just as effective(or at least close enough) without being this invasive(and for the love of god FASTER, I hate being in line just to have some random douche go through my stuff).
Thanks for answering the question. I really appreciate it alot :)

Al Qaeda and other terrorist organizations do not have to kill a whole bunch of people at once to strike fear into peoples hearts, just knowing that thousand upon thousands would die from radiation cancer within ten to fifteen years is a victory. :faint :sad :crying

If there are alternative, effective and less expensive methods for full-body x-ray scans machines and patdowns procedures without being too invasion, why not implement them unless those methods are not profitable. Ex-Homeland Security boss Michael Chertoff is very happy after making ton of money. Since Governments are known to use the fear of fear to passed anti-terrorism legislation, the government just wants to uncovered your nakedness or feel you up. That is the reality until the situation is change for the better. :( :comfort
 

HegemonKhan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2010
Messages
2,367
Reaction score
1,229
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I'm all for the situation in the first comic, if I'm the screener, hehe :D

nah, it directly violates our constutional amendment rights.

(where's our lawyers, this is such an easy case to win, and end this idiocy)

---------

someone I know came up with THEE solution to airport security:

have people go through a blast chamber which will detonate the explosizes, and which has a method of "removing the mess quickly" for the next person in line :D

if you don't have explosives on you, you're fine. if you do, boom! :D

no violation of any rights, its the perfect solution! :D

---------

or, people should organize, the most ugly gross looking people possible, and flood all the airports in the nude until this 100% unlawful security measure is removed :D

--------

and there's always dogs, which are a lot cheaper than these body scanners... though I hate animals/dogs being used in human affairs where they can be hurt/killed :(
 
Last edited:
Top