Crazy Theories and Predictions

[M3J]

Spoiler

I personally don't see much of a difference in their ages there, and since Roger died over 20 years ago, I doubt he'd look as young as Dragon does now and probably more like Garp. Rayleigh looked really young back when Roger was alive too but has a head full of grey hairs just like Garp does now.

Garp seems to have half-white hair while Roger's hair was still black. Seems to be enough of an age difference that they aren't likely brothers or full brothers.

Dragon has to be more than 34 though, assuming the youngest age he had Luffy was 16.

 

[Freid]

Garp seems to have half-white hair while Roger's hair was still black. Seems to be enough of an age difference that they aren't likely brothers or full brothers.

Dragon has to be more than 34 though, assuming the youngest age he had Luffy was 16.

Some people age faster than others. Sengoku didn't have any white hairs 20 years ago and he still doesn't have any now.

 

[Kaishaku]

Some people age faster than others. Sengoku didn't have any white hairs 20 years ago and he still doesn't have any now.

Spoiler

I beg your pardon?

 

[Mohsen]

I seriously doubt there's any direct relationship between Garp and Roger other than being both D. by coincidence.
Garp is psychologically simillar to Luffy, he wouldn't fight a "brother" even if he didn't knew him, unless they were really atrocious folks, which wasn't the case here. Garp wasn't also seeking any kind of reputation by trying to catch roger, he probably initially didn't even knew Roger was a D. too, until probably after several confrontations, they were led to empathize with each others.
I think Garp and Roger relationship is very probably the same kind of relationship that smoker and luffy have, which is roger probably "fled" from a Garp's controlled place at some point and Garp went after Roger through all grand line to see if he could finally catch him.

The way I see it Garp and Roger could have been brothers and still clash with each other. If Ace would still be alive then eventually he and Luffy would have to clash seeing that both initially wanted to become the PK. Garp and Roger followed two different ideologies by searching for freedom. If they wanted to prove to each other whose way was better than there would be no toher way as clashin against each other and see who still reaches his goal.


But isn't it confirmed that Roger was born in the city were Luffy nearly got his head chopped off before the lightening rescued him? And Garp like Luffy grw up in Luffy's home town seeing that Oda drew him as a child in the grey terminal with the tiger Luffy,Ace and Sabo fought against too. And seeing that Garp seems a bit older than Roger then there is no way that he doesn't know that Roger is his brother besides Garp's mother left Garp and his father before she realized she is pregnant with Roger.

The only thing i can think of is that Garp and Roger are like Ace and Luffy but there didn't seem to be any kind of brotherly love between them but what is strange is that Roger seemed to trust Garp more than anyone of his crew by giving his son to garp.

About why Garp already had white hair at the time of Rogers excecution and Roger didn't. Well imagine you being a marine and your son is the worst criminal in history. I think everyone would age a lot faster by having a son like Dragon who according to Ivan is as reckless as Luffy.

 

[Freid]

Spoiler

I beg your pardon?

Kay.

Sengoku didn't have any white hairs 20 years ago and he still didn't two years ago.

 

[M3J]

Some people age faster than others. Sengoku didn't have any white hairs 20 years ago and he still doesn't have any now.

However, we know Sengoku is old. Given that Roger's kid was seven years (give or take) older than Luffy, he'd likely be closer to Dragon's age as I'm sure Dragon was at least a teen. Though, I won't deny that there are various factors to take under consideration, like the fact that men can be old and still be able to reproduce.

Though, I think it's just more of the matter that Garp and Roger are good people, and that played a part in respecting each other, and Roger trusting Garp. Garp likely did something that showed Roger that he was an honest Marine who cared about others and did not believe in "absolute justice."

 

[Freid]

However, we know Sengoku is old.

And now we know that Roger could have been as old as Garp too, give or take some years.

Given that Roger's kid was seven years (give or take) older than Luffy, he'd likely be closer to Dragon's age as I'm sure Dragon was at least a teen. Though, I won't deny that there are various factors to take under consideration, like the fact that men can be old and still be able to reproduce.

Something tells me Garp and Roger didn't meet up and plan to have their children at the same time.

Though, I think it's just more of the matter that Garp and Roger are good people, and that played a part in respecting each other, and Roger trusting Garp. Garp likely did something that showed Roger that he was an honest Marine who cared about others and did not believe in "absolute justice."

That's possible. And so is them being brothers.

 

[M3J]

How do we know Roger could have been as old as Garp or so if his hair was black while Garp's was half-gray?

 

[Freid]

Because Sengoku's hair was also black at the time and remained black up until just two years ago. Neither Rayleigh or Crocus had white hair at the time either. Hell, even Whitebeard had a lovely set of flowing blonde locks still in his fifties.

 

[diavolo]

Guys i would like to post o question/theory.
is there any possibility the tontatta princess has a reason to be captured unrelated to the artidicial DF busines?
i think maybe she has some abilty(DF) that gives Mingo some kind of edge in battle or something...
maybe he has a string attached to her and she channels that ability.
i think that because he survived Aokiji with no apparent damage he took Luffy's attack like nothing and an attack by Law which attack was avoided like it would be fatal by the Trebol(with the help of Mingo to boot!!! so it should be deadly...)
please don't shoot me

 

[M3J]

I think Ace has an offspring.

 

[Sharikaaria]

I think Ace has an offspring.

I bet most pirates have offspring they don't know about. :P So it's a possibility. It just depends on what Oda wants to highlight in this big world he's created.

 

[M3J]

Dunno, the ones we've seen have known about their offspring. Ace likely knows but hasn't told anyone out of fear, given how Roger's lover and unborn child were hunted and marked for death. Though, he actually might not given he seems to be on the seas all the time.

 

[seimei]

Who is the baby Makino is holding?
.... It is shank's.

He will be the future Luffy!

 

[Notice me Escanor senpai]

Who is the baby Makino is holding?
.... It is shank's.

He will be the future Luffy!

...or Woopslap's I'd like it if it was Ace the father

 

[seimei]

...or Woopslap's I'd like it if it was Ace the father

I'd be really jealous if it was Ace's... Noooo my love~~~~

Oh, and next, i think Sanji's team will be nearly died and Nami will negotiate to meet or having a conversation with Big Mam in a certain island. And Sanji will entertain the binge eating to the point of him being kidnapped as a worthy chef

 

[Notice me Escanor senpai]

I'd be really jealous if it was Ace's... Noooo my love~~~~

Oh, and next, i think Sanji's team will be nearly died and Nami will negotiate to meet or having a conversation with Big Mam in a certain island. And Sanji will entertain the binge eating to the point of him being kidnapped as a worthy chef

Well then you understand how I feel, except for me it's Shanks
You know this is not that crazy of a theory. I'm pretty sure BM will want to keep Sanji because he's a good chef, and I can also see her fall in love with him, for his looks or his abilities(or both).
Poor Sanji the only time he would manage to get a girl fall for him it turns out she's far too ugly

 

[seimei]

Well then you understand how I feel, except for me it's Shanks
You know this is not that crazy of a theory. I'm pretty sure BM will want to keep Sanji because he's a good chef, and I can also see her fall in love with him, for his looks or his abilities(or both).
Poor Sanji the only time he would manage to get a girl fall for him it turns out she's far too ugly

Oh, so that's how it is.. xD
Yea i know how it feels... Lol

Yea Sanji's luck is always if it comes to women... He almost always meet girl he cannot have..

Be it a royal family,
A mermaid,
Even an island full of women-hearted fighters cannot satisfy him.

But well, i guess it will be doom in One Piece if Sanji does found one.

 

[I Am Atomic]

Oh, so that's how it is.. xD
Yea i know how it feels... Lol

Yea Sanji's luck is always if it comes to women... He almost always meet girl he cannot have..

Be it a royal family,
A mermaid,
Even an island full of women-hearted fighters cannot satisfy him.

But well, i guess it will be doom in One Piece if Sanji does found one.

It nearly happened with violet

 

[Notice me Escanor senpai]

It nearly happened with violet

Yeah but not quite. Maybe she was just grateful for him helping her out.Plus she's a princess/queen...she can't go with him, can she? Unless she pulls something like what Scarlet did when she married Kyros.
Overall Sanji is very unlucky with women, the only chance he would have had was with Baby 5, but she's with Sai now