Crazy Theories and Predictions

[VioletVector]

Wait, didn't Ace vs Blackbeard happened at the end of the Ennies Lobby arc, after the CP9 were already defeated?

Then let me adjust that. Somehow practically nobody noticed that Laffite had speed lines + the "Hyu" the same way as the Geppou users in the previous arc. It should have been a clear representation of it, but I guess most people didn't see that. I had to think about it afterward and I remembered that he seemed to have speed lines at one point back then. Anyway, it's a good thing to remember now because it helps us figure out who Laffite can be matched with when fighting the Straw Hats.

 

[Lord Rayleigh]

BB wanted Catarina Devon to copy a Gorusei member so that he could use Pudding’s DF on Catarina Devon and read the memories of Gorusei.

 

[traf]

BB wanted Catarina Devon to copy a Gorusei member so that he could use Pudding’s DF on Catarina Devon and read the memories of Gorusei.

If Catarina's DF copies memories, why do they need Pudding to read them? Can't Catarina just tell them those?

 

[electricmastro]

I get the feeling Kaido will be formally revealed to be part of the Oni race, which is connected to Ancient Giant heritage like with Oars, and this be connected to Elbaf. Could be a similar case with Kuma dn Buccaneers.

 

[WILDCARD 1 7]

Shot in the dark here but I believe if WG pop up in Elbapha Oda will bring Spandine ( Spandams dad) back since he's the reason for Ohara getting wiped off the map and would be a full circle moment for Robin and Saul.

 

[WILDCARD 1 7]

A little theory that popped into my head.
With the recent Revelation about Joy boy being a pirate I'm guess that Noah was actually his ship. Since we don't know much about it only that it was part of a promise that Joy Boy made to the fisherman.
So I would say fishermen built it for him and then eventually he gave it back to them after he failed at what he was trying to do.

 

[VegetarianWolf]

Blackbeard will take away Yamato's devil fruit and will be replaced by Kuma's devil fruit with the help of Vegapunk's technology.

 

[FetherMan]

How could the world be affected by Wano, if their borders are opened and Pluton is released?.

Could this become more disastrous for the world…

 

[WILDCARD 1 7]

The "Shanks" we saw meet with the Gorosei was Shamrock and "that certain pirate" was Loki.

 

[Gryphon]

The "Shanks" we saw meet with the Gorosei was Shamrock and "that certain pirate" was Loki.

Not Shamrock or Shanks... but there is a third brother. And he was the one talking to the Gorosei.

 

[Riku]

Not Shamrock or Shanks... but there is a third brother. And he was the one talking to the Gorosei.

Now this crazy theory content!

I'll add - Franky invents time travelling. That's why in the big mural scene his silhouette is so prominent in the same way as the big elements of the mural. Franky is the 4th Ancient Weapon.

Emeth is a Battle Franky. I haven't sketched it out, but his name is derived from smudged remains of worn text on his body, that originally read Battle Franky.

 

[Gryphon]

I have a theory... It might be possible only in a fan story, but I'll share it with you. I still think that Shanks and his twin brother aren't Garling's sons.


I'm not quite sure, but I remember Garp saying something along these lines: "The World Government took something from the Rocks, and it's only natural for him to come to God Valley," back in Kuma's flashback.


I think the World Government found out that the Rocks had a family and were able to locate them. They didn't kill the babies but offered them as prizes for the tournament. After the battle they were Separated. One was taken by WG and the other by Roger’s crew.

Also am not sure of what did garp said i don't read the official translate very often.

I don't know if someone said that before me.. But if there is one... Am Sorry.

Don't judge me; take it or leave it.

 

[Riku]

I like it picasso!

No judgements in this thread imho. I think this thread is for letting loose and go wild. Nobody expects very serious theories.

 

[WILDCARD 1 7]

Not Shamrock or Shanks... but there is a third brother. And he was the one talking to the Gorosei.

But a little warm up here and since you want me going all in he's got more than that and two of them are Kidd and Coby. Garling abandoned because they seemed useless.

Also the Adam tree originally human named Adam that just got Greenbulls df and turned into a tree to help the Giants and was one of Joy Boys crew members.. And that's why it's called the Adam tree.
And at some point we'll see Luffy talk to the Adam tree the same way Momo did to Zunisha.

 

[costicla]

Also the Adam tree originally human named Adam that just got Greenbulls df and turned into a tree to help the Giants and was one of Joy Boys crew members.. And that's why it's called the Adam tree.
And at some point we'll see Luffy talk to the Adam tree the same way Momo did to Zunisha.

But then, what about the Treasure Tree Eve? And the other Adam trees that we found out exist in other parts of the world ?

 

[SanaNeOlm]

I just had a thought; probably this isn’t new at all. The mural refers to the “People of the Half-Moon,” and we’ve already assumed that means the people of the D. But when you think about a half-moon, it logically has two halves: one in permanent light and one permanent in the dark.

So what if there are actually two opposing D. clans? One side includes Luffy, Roger, and Ace. those who follow their dreams with a sense of freedom and adventure. The other side, including Teach and Xebec, also pursues their ambitions but in a far more ruthless, self-centgered way. We already know Blackbeard is the clear opposite of Luffy.

Both sides reject the order and break the rules, but one does so in a way we can agree on, while the other does it in a more ruthless way. From an outsider’s perspective though, both are dangerous forces of chaos.

Are the WG actually the "good" guys in the grand scheme of things (I know currently they're tyrants who are drunk on control and power, but their early motivation might've been justified)? If all D. ever brought was war/great change to the order, it would make sense.

 

[Bradhimself]

BB wanted Catarina Devon to copy a Gorusei member so that he could use Pudding’s DF on Catarina Devon and read the memories of Gorusei.

I think that was opportunistic given nobody knew Saturn was there, or on the way.

But regardless, Blackbeard will definitely take advantage of those memories.

 

[slomaZbuta]

I was just rereading the manga from the Egghead events. While reading chapter 1121, one detail caught my attention—specifically, the part where Vegapunk mentions the ancient weapons.

A panel appears with Shirahoshi and Vivi. It makes sense for Shirahoshi to be there since she wields the power of Poseidon, but why Vivi?

What if Lili, the Queen of Alabasta, never returned to her kingdom because:
A. She is still alive.
B. Her dead body, or at least what remains of it, is needed to activate Uranus?

This would mean that Vivi is an even more crucial character than we ever thought!

To summarize:

1. Pluton → Kozuki clan, Momo
2. Poseidon → Neptune family
3. Uranus → Nefertari family

 

[WILDCARD 1 7]

Based on the name I had the far fetched idea that Mosa is a female fuzzy giant, from the same tribe as the Yeti Cool brothers. After all we‘ve learned so far about Elbaf and different giant tribes I figured that they actually do live on a different island as well. Hoping for Mosa if she is indeed a woman of said tribe to end up as Loki‘s wife / Elbaf‘s next queen.

You know the more I think about it the more I think Moza might be the Judas of the arc, cause every single arc since punk hazard someone turning on someone. Law turning on Caesar, Viola turning against Doflamingo, Pudding turning on the SH then her and Capone turning on big mom, everything to do is Kanjuro, Denjuro turning on Orochi, and of course York. There's always someone betraying someone else at least once in every ark and I think Mosa is going to do that to Loki.

Basically I can see Mosa of using Loki as a red herring. It could be the Konjuro / York of the ark.

Shoot maybe she's a CP this entire time. Secretly been manipulating or at least fueling the antagonism between Loki and his father this entire time.

 

[Boagrious]

I have a theory about this Mosa character, and it might as well be the "god of the forest"

1. Possible Connection to Old Norse Language:

"Mosa" resembles the Old Norse word "mósi", which can mean "mossy" or relate to nature and earth.

In Norse mythology, nature is deeply symbolic, with sacred trees like Yggdrasil representing life, fate, and the connection between realms.


2. Connection to Giants or Mythological Beings:

If Mosa is intended as a giant's name, it could align with Norse figures like Surtr (fire giant) or Ymir (primordial giant). I don't think this is the case.

Giants (Jötnar) were often associated with natural elements—earth, fire, water, and ice—so if Mosa has a meaning linked to moss, earth, or forests, it could signify a giant connected to nature, or Loki has the VOAT—giving him a connection to nature around him on a level we haven't seen before.


3. Hypothetical Role in Norse-Inspired Stories:

If Mosa is being introduced in an Elbaf-related One Piece storyline, it might be a name for a giant with ancient knowledge or ties to the Adam Tree.

Given the Elbaf arc’s focus on Norse mythology, Mosa could be a guardian figure, an elder, or even a being with connections to the past (Void Century).

I'm thinking that the Adam Tree houses the god of the forest.