Discussion Cross Guild vs Blackbeard Pirates

[WILDCARD 1 7]

Saw this topic come up a couple of times and thought it deserved its own thread.

Well I think BBP would win in a head on fight.
But if they were forced to fight each other I don't think it'd be a straight-up fight.
Crocodile is pretty smart and Buggy can be sneak at times. So they're at least know that they lose in a straight up fight.

Now even if say there is an Impel down 2.0 arc and they got Doflamingo, I don't think they'd be able to win in a straight-up fight.

 

[Fox666]

Cross Guild doesn't has that many top fighters

Mihawk would get busy with Blackbeard, I don't think Crocodile can handle Kuzan yet, and there's nobody to fight the remaining captains...

 

[WILDCARD 1 7]

Cross Guild doesn't has that many top fighters

Mihawk would get busy with Blackbeard, I don't think Crocodile can handle Kuzan yet, and there's nobody to fight the remaining captains...

I think Crocodile can handle anyone not name Kuzan or Teach ( and possibly Shiryu).
And maybe Mr.1 if he got his awakening like Kaku could handle 1 of them. But yeah their not winning in a head to head.

 

[kkck]

Hard to say how strong crocodile even is... I suppose daz bones has grown strong enough to be a yonko executive at least. No idea if strong enough for a YC1 spot though. The most likely scenario is that more people will end up joining the cross guild than what we have seen as a result of kaido and big mom falling. They could also potentially see reinforces from other underworld organizations interested in safeguarding their investments.

 

[Darklord#10]

Mihawk one shots

 

[CharlosTenryuubito]

Moria and Weevil also most likely join Cross Guild, even then Buggy realize that race to Laugh tale isnt all about fight.

 

[afromarco005]

Mihawk high diffs BB while the rest stall kuzan and co then Mihawk soloes.

If Law's crew could push BB this much there is no reason why a man stronger than shanks would lose here.

 

[john ellis]

Mihawk high diffs BB while the rest stall kuzan and co then Mihawk soloes.

If Law's crew could push BB this much there is no reason why a man stronger than shanks would lose here.

Look I’ll buy arguement a Mihawk high-extreme diffs Blackbeard, however kuzan stomps cross guild, let alone any of the other titanic captains, best case bb loses then kuzan stomps a weakened Mihawk, worst case Mihawk gets piled by kuzan and Blackbeard very quickly and he’s going to get low diffed

 

[afromarco005]

Look I’ll buy arguement a Mihawk high-extreme diffs Blackbeard, however kuzan stomps cross guild, let alone any of the other titanic captains, best case bb loses then kuzan stomps a weakened Mihawk, worst case Mihawk gets piled by kuzan and Blackbeard very quickly and he’s going to get low diffed

Let's be honest replace Mihawk with Shanks in your equation does it still hold true or do you have Shanks winning?

 

[john ellis]

Let's be honest replace Mihawk with Shanks in your equation does it still hold true or do you have Shanks winning?

Shanks is not defeating a yonko, especially black beard and an admiral, frankly I wouldn’t be surprised if Blackbeard kills shanks

 

[afromarco005]

That's fair enough. I hope Buggy recruits all remaining former shishibukai